I don't know if it was the low expectations or the fact that Logan got to snikt! some ninjas, but I was pleasantly surprised with The Wolverine. You could argue that the latest entry in the X-Men franchise isn't terribly original or daring... and well, you'd be right. It's interested only in giving Logan a classic hero's journey, which it does pretty darn well. Director James Mangold brings a good bit of intelligence and restraint back to the summer blockbuster - and superhero films, in particular. If it wasn't for a healthy amount of CGI and incoherent action scenes (more on that later), The Wolverine would almost feel like a movie out of time, and it's to the movie's credit that it plays more like a Western or Samurai film than a comic book movie. Before we go any further, lets start with the facts of the case. Im a thirty-four year-old male and an all around smart-ass. While I'd argue that the X-Men franchise, with its exploration of bigotry and tolerance, is probably the most thematically important comic book series going, I've never cared for it personally. It's usually far too silly and soap opera-y for my tastes. And then came Bryan Singer's X-Men in 2000, which finally made the series work for me. I've never read the source material that The Wolverine is based on, and have little interest in doing so. Frankly, my interest in Wolverine begins and ends with Hugh Jackman, who has created one of the greatest screen characters of all time with his portrayal of Logan. So let's get those SPOILERS going with another ten probablyfailed attempts at balancing fanboy enthusiasm with a little objectivity. If you can, enjoy.
10. The Bombing Of Nagasaki Is Taken Seriously
I was prepared to give up on The Wolverine if it turned the nuclear bombing of Nagasaki into a tasteless action scene. Fortunately, Mangold delivers a thrilling sequence that respects the power and horror of that day. When viewed in retrospect, Mangold introduces most of the movie's major themes and character arcs in this one scene... and does so with skill and subtlety. There's little doubt that Logan could survive a nuclear blast - but without Yashida's help, he would have remained trapped in his cage for God knows how long, which would have become a personal hell for Logan. The potential awfulness of Logan's immortality is established from the first scene. It's also interesting how this scene deals with two very different cultures. To modern sensibilities, Yashida and Logan both make honorable, compassionate choices. Logan saves Yashida from death, and Yashida saves Logan from a fate possibly worse than death. Despite being a few generations removed from this time period, I wonder how Yashida's choice to not commit seppuku will play to modern Japanese audiences. (I'm going to plead complete ignorance on this and would love some feedback.) At first glance, we're supposed to believe that Yashida makes a sane, rational decision. Instead, Yashida betrays his personal code of honor to stay alive, which foreshadows his plan to go all super-villain in his old age and steal Logan's powers. Of course, I could be reading this all wrong - but that's a testament to the movie's complexity in its best moments.
9. That Canadian Hunter Pushes "It's Miller Time!" Into Faux Pas Territory
OK, am I the only one who couldn't follow the first ten minutes of this movie? Logan, now a recluse living in the Yukon wild, moseys into town one day for the two essential "b's", booze and batteries. He bumps into a bunch of Canadian hunters, who Logan will no doubt have words with very soon. Later that night, he hears screaming. He comes across a campsite that's been torn apart. Nearby, he finds a bear that one of the hunters shot with a poison-tipped arrow, a poison that enrages the bear than leaves it in agony. Logan puts the bear out of its misery and heads into town to have those words with the hunters. That's where I get lost. Did some of the hunting party get mauled or killed by the bear? And if so, what the hell is the hunter who shot the bear doing in a bar a few hours later, boasting about what happened to his injured/dead friends? True, I might have missed something. Even with the confusion, the scene still plays well enough, as if it came directly out of a Western. But like the rest of these opening scenes, it all seems a bit perfunctory. If there's one thing missing from this section of the movie, it's the full weight and despair of Logan's immortality. On the other hand, I love Jackman's reading of "Sorry, Jean..." as he pops his claws in the bar - which shows just how complex this character is under his watch. Logan truly is sorry to break his vow of non-violence... just not that sorry.
8. Yukio Keeps Picking Up Interference From A Psychic Weather Balloon
Well-written and smartly cast, Yukio is an excellent counterpart to Logan. She largely serves the same purpose as Rogue did in the first X-Men movie - to show that Logan's just a big softie. The only difference is Yukio can hold her own and rocks a cool sword. So what's not to like? Well... maybe her mutant ability, which is to foresee someone's death when it's close to their time. Not a bad power as they go... though not a terribly good one to add to a story that largely revolves around someone faking their death. The movie largely plays fair with the audience regarding her powers, but it's still a problematic idea. True, as a writer I may be thinking of plot construction too much: once Yukio fails to sense Yashida's death, we know that either the story isn't playing fair or Yashida is faking his own death, making him the bad guy. Also, her vision of Logan holding his heart in his hand is only mostly right, like she's only getting one bar of reception to the afterlife or something. Like the rest of movie, it works well enough to get by. And Yukio's character arc is my personal favorite in the film. As an orphan and a mutant, she serves a family which she never really feels completely part of. The closure she gets from Mariko at the end is quite sweet, and nicely ties into X-Men's themes of finding a place where you belong while still being yourself.
7. So... Has Wolverine Flipped His Lid With The Whole Jean Grey Thing?
Speaking of crappy connections with the afterlife, what is going on with Jean Grey? Is Logan so obsessed with her death that he's starting to lose it? Or is she somehow able to speak to Logan in his dreams? I'm not asking because I'm upset with the intentional ambiguity. I just really, really want to know, that's all. A lot of fans weren't overly enthused with these scenes - probably because it forced them to acknowledge the existence of X-Men 3. I never thought Logan loved Jean Grey as much as previous movies said he did, but I can see how killing her would mess him up. (Also, did they ever explain in X-Men 3 why they didn't just use the mutant cure on her? I'd watch that movie again, but that would mean I'd have to watch that movie again.) Personally, I think Logan's moments with Jean are among the best in the movie. It keeps the film moving forward in a way the actual story fails to do. His final words to her, "You were hurting people, Jean," are simple but surprisingly powerful. Then, their final scene ups the ante by strongly suggesting that Logan hasn't been wearing his crazy pants through the whole movie, that Jean Grey's spirit does live on in some kind of limbo, with Logan being her last connection to the world. If Logan lets go of that connection - which he does - he could doom her spirit to an eternity alone. I hope they don't try to bring her back, because the idea that these characters may have to suffer alone in their own ways - possibly forever - is pretty damned haunting.
6. The Superman II Plot Never Gets Old
I never get tired of this particular song and dance. Let's face it, being a superhero would kinda suck - bad hours, worse pay, super-villains, and lots and lots of death. My favorite comic book stories are the ones that treat a hero's powers - or for the Batmans of the world, the mask and cape - as both a blessing and a curse. It's easy to imagine any hero wanting to give it all up at some point... even Logan. And when Logan is presented with the chance at a normal life, the movie goes in both familiar and new directions. I like the choice given to Logan: he can give up his powers by passing them on to someone else and accepting that person's mortality. Logan doesn't take Yashida's deal because he wouldn't pass on his existence to his worst enemy... which he would actually be doing, in fact. A lot of interesting things happen once Logan gets a taste of mortality. Even though his healing powers become repressed, he can still take more punishment than the average joe. But if he keeps being the best at what he does, it's going to kill him. And it all works because Logan never changes or comprises who he is - he's as determined and angry and claw-happy as ever. In the end, it leaves Logan with an appreciation for what he has and the good he can do with his powers. I rather like that. What can I say, I'm a "with great power comes great responsibility" kind of guy.
5. You know, There's A Thing Called A Steadicam, Bub...
The Wolverine has the most cohesive story of the summer so far. Unfortunately, it also has the most incoherent fight scenes of the summer - and that's saying something. This was a huge surprise to me, since James Mangold delivered some truly amazing, old-school action scenes in 3:10 To Yuma. I'm sure no one in Hollywood would ever actually read my sad, depraved ramblings on this site - but if someone in the filmmaking business is reading this, can I ask you a favor? I'm sure you're making a big action/sci-fi movie right now. Who isn't, really? I don't have to tell you that movies are made of thousands of individual camera setups. I want you to try something during one of the action scenes, just for one setup. First, decide where you're going to place the camera. Done? Good. Now move it back five feet. This will ensure that all the characters are properly in the frame, and that we have a clear understanding of where they are to each other and their environment. Your next instinct will probably be to go with a handheld aesthetic, which makes everything look exciting and kinetic and all that. That's fine, you can do that later. For the time being, I want you to look around you. There's probably a steadicam rig, crane, or even a good, old-fashioned tripod lying around somewhere. Use one of these handy devices - they're there to keep the camera still, so we can see what's going on. You may ask, how's the scene supposed to be exciting now? Well, by filming something that it is exciting, which requires some combination of good planning, impressive stunts, or just solid fight choreography. The rest will take care of itself. Finally, film at least a few seconds of footage. The more seconds the better, actually. If you're filming something real and exciting, then audiences will believe they're watching something real and exciting. That's it. Enough soap-boxing.
4. Logan And Mariko Are Given Time To Build A Relationship
I wouldn't call The Wolverine a love story, because Logan and Mariko never fall in love. For a superhero movie - where characters usually have to swoon over someone to ridiculous Tobey-Maguire-wide-eyed-dopey-grin levels - The Wolverine features a surprisingly mature romance between two characters who find comfort in each other for awhile. It's not incredibly deep, but both Mariko and Logan find something they lost - or really never had - from their time together. And it's nice that Mariko gets the last word in now and again, like with the chopsticks scene. And boy howdy, do I appreciate how The Wolverine never plays the "Hey, your country sure is funny" card that so many American films do when dealing with foreign cultures. There's at least a modicum of respect for the setting, even though the movie hits most of the usual clichés about Japan.
3. I Don't Even Want To Imagine What It Smells Like Inside That Silver Samurai Outfit
The Wolverine conveniently forgets about Logan's heightened sense of smell. If it hadn't, Logan would've been able to get a whiff of Ben-Gay, talcum powder, and adamantium off the Silver Samurai from fifty yards away, allowing him to instantly know who's inside the giant robot: his old friend, Yashida. Sure, it's a twist we all saw coming - but it works because none of the characters saw it coming. There's two problems with it, though. First, we don't know Yashida well enough to care that he's become a crazy-ass Bond villain in his old age. During my first viewing of the film, it was hard to reconcile this character with the man Logan saves at Nagasaki. Also, I know a lot of time has passed and it's not like many of us want to grow old and die and all that, but a few more minutes to define Yashida would have paid off considerably. As it is, there's no real drama in the climatic fight scene outside of a big scary robot fighting a big scary man. Logan fighting a CGI baddie feels totally out of place in the world Mangold has created for The Wolverine. Until he shows up, The Wolverine feels grounded in something relatively close to reality. And it's a shame the movie leaves this heightened reality and real world locations for an obvious - but well-constructed - movie set, with Hugh Jackman fighting the latest CGI baddie that leaves little impression on the audience.
2. Days Of Future Movies That Aren't Out Already, Dammit!
I'm really on the fence with the mid-credits scene. I usually enjoy these scenes, but they work better as a neat little bonus for moviegoers whose bladders haven't reached critical mass - like the Shawarma scene in Avengers or Ron Perlman looking for his god**n shoe in Pacific Rim. I'm less of a fan when they're just a movie trailer for the next film in a franchise. It deflates the movie you just watched - especially when it's a good but not great movie like The Wolverine. The actual scene is pretty good - and I'm excited to see Bryan Singer back at the helm of the X-Men franchise. Seeing Ian McKellan and Patrick Stewart sharing the screen with Hugh Jackman again has a definite "getting the band back to together" vibe. Exciting stuff. It's a shame I walked out of the theater thinking, "Boy, I wish I just watched that movie."
1. Hugh Jackman Is The Wolverine. 'Nuff Said.
Let's all take a moment and give it up for Hugh Jackman. The guy knocks it out of the park again. Does Jackman still love playing Logan, or is he just a classy entertainer who respects the fans enough to put on a good show? I lean towards the former idea. He's at the point in his career where he didn't have to commit to the physical torture he endured for this movie to look like Plato's ideal form of a brick s**t-house. He's still giving it all - and it shows on the screen. Like Robert Downey Jr.'s Tony Stark and Ron Perlman's Hellboy, it's impossible to imagine anyone else in the role. There's a lot of good work going on both behind and in front of the camera with this one... but it's Hugh Jackman that's making the whole thing work. The Wolverine doesn't fully live up to what he can do with the part, but it's another solid step in getting this franchise back on track. Agree? Disagree? Feel like the movie could do with a few more ninjas? Let us know below. Either Way, Jeremy Wickett will return in 10 (Probably Failed) Attempts At A Measured Response To Elysium.