10 Radical Ideas To Save The DC Extended Universe

Increasingly left-field notions on how to fix the issues in DC’s troubled superhero franchise.

By Jack Morrell /

The DC Extended Universe needs saving. People have argued that the poor critical reception for the films to date is because they’re made for the fans, not reviewers. They’ve pointed out that Batman Vs. Superman made nearly $875 million at box offices worldwide, while Suicide Squad is coming up on $600 million only weeks after release, despite the worst reviews to date.

Advertisement

Firstly, to correct some misapprehensions: it’s estimated that marketing for a Hollywood blockbuster hits $200million per movie, over and above the production budget. A good, approximate rule of thumb is that the studio will see roughly half the money a film drags in worldwide.

That means that Batman Vs. Superman probably needed to make around $900million worldwide to break even, and Suicide Squad, about $750million worldwide.

But even if these films are loss leaders, intended to introduce a colossal, multi-billion dollar franchise, it’s the overarching narrative that’s killing the DCEU. Marvel’s story, loudly trumpeted anywhere and everywhere, is one of massive creative and financial success, despite the glaring issues raised with many of the movies released under the MCU banner.

The DCEU, on the other hand, is being characterised as a hamfisted series of dismal, dreary financial flops. That’s a problem, for a franchise intended to run and run.

Last week, Jack gave us his fifteen-step plausible, constructive plan to rehabilitate of the DCEU. Here’s the flipside: ten increasingly radical and outlandish ideas to do likewise. Keep an open mind...

10. A New Man Of Steel

If your only significant experiences of an alien god-creature were constant destruction and loss of life on a scale equivalent to massive earthquake damage or nuclear attack, all while he clumsily fends off creatures from his own planet that have come specifically to attack him… well, you wouldn’t be erecting statues to him, let’s put it that way.

Advertisement

The world’s reaction to Superman’s demise in Batman Vs. Superman is completely disproportionate. They shouldn’t be honouring this strange visitor from another planet who brings catastrophe and murder wherever he goes, they should be thanking whatever gods they believe in that the terrifying b*stard is dead.

Because he is a terrifying b*stard. He's not a good guy to be around. This is a Superman who'd be your last call, when things were at their worst, because you really wouldn't want to bother him. That's not a Superman that anyone who knows the character even a little would recognise.

All of which means that, far more urgently than a Justice League movie, the DCEU needs a new Man Of Steel movie to make up for some of the damage that Zack Snyder’s done so far... and given that Henry Cavill is the only person as closely associated as Snyder with the failure to represent Superman in these films, Cavill should probably be recast.

Ideally, we’d have a new Superman when he inevitably comes back to life in the Justice League movie, but that ship has sailed. However, it’s not too late to give a new face to the next Superman film proper. If Warners et al don’t have the guts to sack Zack The Hack himself, then Cavill should be the next logical place to look.

What would a new Superman look like? He'd be more relaxed, less moody and brooding. After all, what does Superman really have to be tense, irritable or depressed about? The key thing that makes people love Superman isn't his phenomenal power and strength, it's that he's one of us... only better. People trust him to do what's right, not because he's powerful, but because they believe he's a truly good man who'll always put other people first. There are villains that wouldn't kill Superman, even if they had the chance... because he's Superman.

Zack Snyder's Man Of Steel isn't that guy. Perhaps the next one can be.

9. Smaller And Smarter Alongside Bigger And Badder

Forget the massive, unwieldy tentpole flicks: the DCEU should be managing the damage already inflicted to its reputations by presenting audiences with shorter, lower budget, smaller scale movies set in this shared world they’re trying to set up.

Advertisement

Look at Deadpool: an R-rated, profane and ultraviolent movie produced on a comparatively tiny budget, based upon a character unknown to casual audiences and with a star with unproven leading man credentials, it’s currently the biggest movie in the X-Men franchise to date, outperforming the franchise team’s own biggest hit, X-Men: Days Of Future Past.

Why did Deadpool work so well? There are a ton of theories, but the best explanation is that word of mouth said that this little movie - that Fox hadn’t even wanted to make - delivered like gangbusters. The DCEU needs some of that kind of word of mouth, and it needs it soon. For the money it cost to make Batman Vs. Superman, DC could have made four slimline ninety minute movies. A Nightwing film, a Green Arrow movie. Suicide Squad could have been a much smaller film if they'd hired lesser known actors.

These ridiculous city-destroying set-pieces need to go. They're expensive, and a lazy substitute for quality writing. Few superheroes in movies fight villains with logical motivations, and few superhero movies have coherent, sensible plots. Superhero films need an antagonist with a plan that makes sense, and a solid three act structure to hang the silliness on.

In Deadpool, it wasn't even the villain's plan that needed foiling. The plot revolved around the protagonist getting revenge against the antagonist. You wanted Wade Wilson to win, because Ajax was an a-hole. It's not rocket surgery.

As far as smaller goes - there’s no need to cast established, expensive stars. Shazam would have been an excellent start as it’s got the potential to be kid friendly: it’s about a young teen who utters a magic word to transform into a Superman-style powerhouse, so it’s practically a cartoon already. But they couldn't help themselves. They hired the world's biggest action star, Dwayne Johnson, to play antagonist Black Adam. There's no way you cast The Rock in your superhero movie and give it a medium-sized budget.

If you want good word of mouth, write smart, funny films that make sense. If you want to be sure of making a profit, keeping the cost down has to be your first consideration. Keeping the running time around ninety minutes allows cinemas to add an extra showing a day, maybe more. Again, none of this is rocket surgery.

8. Stop Fast Forwarding Through Everything

Man Of Steel gave us yet another crack at the Superman origin story - however, that film also introduced General Zod, only to kill him immediately and definitively in what’s commonly referred to as the ‘Tim Burton Joker Error’.

Advertisement

We didn’t need a retread of Superman’s beginnings in Man Of Steel. Superman’s origin story is entrenched in popular culture. Conversely, that pitfall may have been avoided with the new Batman... but then Snyder went too far the other way, fast forwarding right over Batman's history and presenting us with a Dark Knight two decades into his career as a crimefighter. He's lost Robin to his war and already had the best battles of his career against the Joker - none of which the cinema-going audience has been privy to.

In that same film, we were also treated to both a contrived Batman versus Superman dust-up and a version of the the Death Of Superman storyline, as well as the introduction of Superman’s nemesis Lex Luthor (who might as well have been the Riddler for all the impact or gravitas he presented) and top DC hero Wonder Woman.

Justice League will be responsible for formally introducing audiences to Aquaman and the reality of the undersea empire of Atlantis, the Flash and Cyborg, and presumably bringing Superman back to life. Alongside that, rumour has it that the film will feature Darkseid’s lieutenant Steppenwolf and a few hordes of Parademons, as well as more of this ersatz version of Lex Luthor.

We don’t need all of this to happen all at once. The Death Of Superman arc was a step too far for Batman Vs. Superman, and the threat of Doomsday could have been saved for a future film: the Man Of Steel sequel, for example. Had he not been a prancing, megalomaniacal and clearly psychotic goon, Lex Luthor could have remained a clear and present threat outside of jail.

Why fast forward all of these stories? Why present a whole load of narrative and exposition all at once, and hamfistedly at that? The DCEU needs to slow down and stop shooting its bolt early. At this rate, Superman’s going to come back to life and deck Darkseid before the opening credits of Justice League have finished rolling.

7. Get Comics Writers To Write Comics Characters

You know when you're desperate for a job, and you exaggerate some of your previous experience to get your foot in the door? As long as the person interviewing you knows just a little less about the subject than you, it's perfectly possible to bluff your way in with minimal real knowledge of the subject at hand.

Advertisement

Well, that's exactly how Warner Bros. have been landed with their major creative personnel for the DCEU: they’ve handpicked people already in the film industry who claim to have a working knowledge of comics and superheroes, and given them carte blanche to do whatever the hell they like, because they know even less about comics and superheroes than the muppets they’ve hired. Fox made the same schoolboy error with the people they picked to run the X-Men franchise.

Marvel, on the other hand, set up a creative inner circle with specific interest in and background in the comics and the characters being adapted, and then had them heavily involved in the strategising and planning of the MCU from the word go. The DCEU needs to gravitate more towards the Marvel model than the Fox model.

Now, DC comics guru Geoff Johns is currently overseeing parts of the DCEU, which is an excellent step in the right direction. But instead of hiring screenwriters and directors who may or may not know about the characters they’re writing about, or about anything to do with comics, why not hire the people writing and drawing the comics as consultants on a movie by movie basis?

I’m not suggesting that comics writers can miraculously write perfect screenplays - it’s a different discipline. But is there any reason why you couldn’t pair an accomplished comics writer with an accomplished screenwriter? Can Mark Waid, Gail Simone, James Robinson, Chris Terrio and Ben Affleck not hole themselves up in a Hollywood hotel suite for a fortnight and put together the bare bones of the next few films in this franchise?

As it stands, the initial plan for the Aquaman movie was to have Gangster Squad’s Will Beale and 300’s Kurt Johnstad write two completely separate screenplays for the film and to pick the best one. That’s ludicrous… but it’s par for the course for the DCEU.

6. Not Everything Needs To Be The End Of The World

The major criticism of the MCU’s superhero movies has been a singular lack of decent antagonists and high stakes shenanigans. The DCEU movies, on the other hand, seem to have a kitchen sink approach to plot and drama - throw everything in and hope that something sticks.

Advertisement

There has to be a middle ground. Why shouldn’t DC try the low key, non-powered crimefighting approach for a change? It’s something that DC comics arguably do better than Marvel comics: but how many live action superhero stories do you know of where the superheroes actually fight crime?

In between foiling the batsh*t schemes of a host of disfigured maniacs, Batman still breaks heads for a living, as do most of the heroes in the Batman family of characters (Nightwing, Batwoman, Robin, Red Hood, Huntress, etc). Green Arrow, the Black Canary, Checkmate, the Question… the list goes on and on.

On the MCU side, there’s Daredevil, but that pretty much seems to be it. That’s Marvel all over, though. Spider-Man seems too busy; Captain America has more important things to do. Even in the comics, the X-Men only ever seem to fight people when the scrap is politically motivated: it’s either pro-mutant terrorists or anti-mutant terrorists, with the occasional departure to put down mutants who’ve gone mad with power (but only because they’ll give mutants a bad name).

You shouldn’t have to be a street level ninja-style hero to fight street level crime. After all, there’s supposed to be a reason why these people put on silly suits and give themselves dumbass names in the first place, and it’s not to take down Captain Cold or Deathstroke, or to foil weird CGI energy mcguffins (aka the plot of Captain America: The First Avenger, Thor: The Dark World, Guardians Of The Galaxy and Suicide Squad).

5. Go Big Or Go Home

And then of course, you could always go the other direction, and hit the cosmic stuff hard. After all, it’s the other thing that DC probably does better than the competition. While Marvel is stuck repeating the same superheroes-punching-supervillains-and-sometimes-each-other schtick they’ve been doing for decades, DC has the market cornered on gritty street crime and extra-dimensional, extraterrestrial awe-fests.

Advertisement

Look at it this way: the Green Lantern Corps aren’t just alien superheroes, they’re an intergalactic paramilitary police force, space cops. Superman can shunt moons out of orbit, and has a rogue’s gallery of comparable power. Wonder Woman gets her power from the classical Greco-Roman pantheon, as does Shazam for the most part.

The Martian Manhunter is one of a whole race of creatures only one planet over in our solar system, each one of whom is a shapechanging warrior on a par with Wonder Woman and the Man Of Steel. Darkseid and the whole New Gods, Apokolips vs. New Genesis thing is a whole primary-coloured madcap, overpowered and enjoyably ludicrous space opera waiting to happen.

If you’re looking for something to differentiate the DCEU from the MCU, then cosmic may well be the way to go. After all, Marvel’s own cosmic stories have been underwhelming on the big screen so far. The Kree have been depicted as big, blue lunkhead warriors. Guardians Of The Galaxy introduced a Drax The Destroyer who was no match whatsoever for a pre-Infinity Stone Ronan The Accuser, let alone his supposed nemesis Thanos.

Thanos himself is Marvel’s own, rip-off version of Darkseid and has still barely been introduced. The Collector, another powerful cosmic alien in the comics, has been set up in the MCU as a weird-haired, virtually powerless eccentric. The Asgardians are just aliens. All cosmic power seems to come in the form of those CGI mcguffins I’ve mentioned.

Perhaps it’s best to let the DCEU do what DC often does best: massive, operatic stories involving ridiculous, high-falutin’ powers smiting one another. Foiling alien invasions! Busting through the walls of parallel universes! Just, maybe quit it with the urban devastation. Do it on the moon, or another planet.

4. Lean Into It

Okay, so Warner have committed to this bleak, barren wasteland of a DCEU: a land where a sudden break in the clouds in the form of a couple of half-decent gags in a Justice League trailer feels like a fortnight in Hawaii.

Advertisement

Fine. If that’s the case, let’s lean into it. Let Snyder indulge his grim, nineties-style brooding anti-hero fetish. If this is the approach they’re going for, let them go nuts.

But rather than take a primary coloured symbol of hope and optimism like Clark Kent and turning him into a brooding, angst-ridden Catholic Messiah figure - rather than have Snyder re-enact The Passion Of The Christ with the Man Of Tomorrow - let’s find the actual brooding, angst-ridden anti-heroes in the DCEU and make movies out of their lives.

Being a Gail Simone fanboy, I’d suggest the Secret Six… except they’ve already pretty much made a Secret Six movie with this abortion of a Suicide Squad flick, so that’s off the table.

Doug Liman's literally just been announced as the director for Dark Universe, an adaptation of DC's murky supernatural book Justice League Dark. That's likely to feature series regulars John Constantine, Zatanna, Etrigan The Demon, Deadman, Madame Zanadu and Shade The Changing Man, all of whom are weird and wonderful oddballs and freaks. And 'dark' doesn't begin to cover it.

Then there’s Lobo, the intergalactic DC equivalent of Deadpool - kind of like a scary space biker who tears people’s arms off. In the language of his people, his name means “one who devours your entrails and thoroughly enjoys it”, and the reason he’s the last of his kind is because he killed all of the others.

How about Catwoman? She’s a burglar who neatly straddles the DC underworld, the rogues galleries of half a dozen heroes and the superhero community, having plenty of friends and enemies in all three. We could do with erasing all memory of Halle Berry with cat ears, and realised properly, the character is a star-making turn for the right actress.

Huntress is the Batgirl who kills criminals. Green Arrow often gets his hands dirty. And what about Garth Ennis’ Hitman, the telepathic assassin with x-ray eyes who kills metahumans? Cast the right Tommy Monaghan, keep the budget the low side of sixty million, advertise it as being from the twisted brain behind Preacher, and you could easily have a Deadpool style hit on your hands.

3. Change Whatever You Like… Within Reason

Marvel do a lot wrong, but this they do perfectly. When it comes to a comic book character, you can mess with a whole hell of a lot provided you keep the elements that made them iconic and/or popular to begin with. There’s a reason some stuff works and some stuff doesn’t, after all.

Advertisement

But let’s be serious, here: in most cases, there’s no such thing as ‘true to the comics’. Snyder’s right when he says that Superman’s killed before. So has Batman: in fact, he started out carrying a gun before editorial mandate came down that he wouldn’t use them, and several stories since then have seen him use a gun as a special occasion.

The fact is that there are many, many different iterations of these iconic heroes and villains in the comics, almost as many as the writers and artists that have worked on them, and many fans have their own preferred version. DC and Marvel don’t treat their characters like sacred texts, or indeed with a whole lot of respect most of the time. That’s something that literally only exists in the minds of the fans. But, for as many versions as there have been, there are hard and fast things that most fans agree on.

That’s the consensus that people have come to concerning the most important aspects of these characters, their essence. Some things are more important than others: for example, Green Arrow dresses in green and carries a bow and anything else just isn’t him... but of slightly lesser importance is the character’s iron principles, his relationship with Black Canary, his philanthropy and activism.

Now, Superman may not be human, but he still represents the best of humanity. He does what he does because it’s the right thing to do, because he was raised that way. He’d try to always do what’s right and treat people with respect and kindness even if he had no powers at all. And everyone knows this, even casual fans. It’s a part of popular culture. The DCEU needs to reflect that Superman pretty quickly, or it’s not going to have the success it deserves.

There are other problems ongoing: for example, Will Smith is grossly miscast as Deadshot, and it’s nothing to do with race (Jamie Foxx would have made an amazing Floyd Lawton, and Smith himself could have made a good Rick Flag or Bronze Tiger). Whatever Jason Momoa is playing, it’s not Aquaman, and casting the Joker and Harley Quinn as True Romance style lovers is offensive in every conceivable sense. Harley’s an empowered (if loopy) survivor of a horribly abusive relationship, not the Bonnie in Bonnie & Clyde.

2. Amp Up The Multiverse

It’s one of the major things the DC Universe has going for it: the concept of the multiverse, the theory of parallel worlds, as one of the core precepts of their shared continuity.

Advertisement

Geoff Johns has already indicated that they’re using a version of the multiverse with the live action DC adaptations: the television universe represented by the CW shows Arrow, Legends Of Tomorrow and The Flash is supposed to be a separate parallel universe to the DC characters represented in the movies, and it seems that the parallel world represented in the Supergirl TV series will be joining the Arrowverse continuity now that the show has moved to the CW.

There’s a school of thought that says that the ‘Knightmare’ sequence in Batman Vs. Superman is a vision, not of the future, but of a parallel world in which Superman and Darkseid rule Earth together with an iron fist. Snyder has already fuelled speculation that the Flash who comes to Bruce Wayne in that dream sequence is the Flash of another world.

That’s all fine and dandy, but I want to see my multiversal weirdness amped up to eleven. Let’s see the Knightmare Batman come to this universe for help, following in the footsteps of their Flash. Let’s see other versions of legendary DC superheroes and villains come out from other worlds: in the comics, for example, we’ve seen heroic versions of the Joker and Lex Luthor.

Let’s see that Superman versus this Superman, with our version in his Clark Kent persona. If it takes place in a junkyard, it can pay tribute to the single greatest scene in cinema history: the set-piece from Superman III where an evil Superman fights a heroic Clark Kent for the soul of Kal-El.

1. The Crisis On Infinite Earths

I’m not the only one who’s speculated that the DCEU is gently rolling towards a version of the most seminal, epic crossover event in the history of superhero comics. That’s right: it’s Maximum Carnage.

Advertisement

No, only joking. That was sh*tbox. Crisis On Infinite Earths was the first ever major comics crossover, celebrating fifty years of DC Comics (dating back to the February 1935 first issue of New Fun: The Big Comic Magazine, when the company was called National Allied Publications, for those of you obsessed with trivia).

The idea was that the continuity of so many titles and characters with a shared history, written by so many people over so many years, styles and eras of comic books had created this massive, unwieldy mess that needed restructuring, pruning and culling. In the story, DC’s multiverse was being erased by a sinister cosmic entity, and only the combined forces of… well, everyone, could stop it. Yes, it’s far more complicated than that, and no, you don’t need to know.

It was seminal stuff, and changed the face of DC and comics in general forever. It’s not dated very well as a piece of comics literature, and editorial confusion kind of messed up what they were trying to execute - but the principles are still sound, and still being used today.

If this was planned from the start - and there are enough parallels between Crisis and the current DCEU to make you wonder - then it’s a brilliant, if convoluted answer to all the DCEU’s critics. If not… well, it’s an excellent ‘new broom’ style twist to remove all of the godawful elements of current DCEU continuity, when they ultimately realise that Zack Snyder is a gormless turd of a man with a skull full of curdled milk.

Either way, the effect would be the same. It would allow for a fix of the current, enormously unpopular version of Superman. It would allow for a revision of the current, middle-aged Batman to a younger iteration, preferably with an entirely different Joker that didn’t look like a try-hard Juggalo.

It might also allow for a reboot of the Suicide Squad to a form that makes sense and a version of Deadshot that doesn’t make me want to eat my own face, but that’s not quite as urgent a revision as the rest...

How would you go about saving the DCEU, or do you think it's fine as it is? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.

Advertisement