10 Real Reasons Why Man Of Steel Was A Failure

This ever-increasing animosity toward Man of Steel reveals some underlying things that we would all do well to think about when it comes to our blockbusters.

By Ian Boucher /

In the months since the release of Man of Steel, the reviews have somehow seemed to be getting worse and worse. Initially, there were indeed many reviews that were generally mixed, citing faults such as joylessness, never-ending fight sequences, and, of course, the neck-breaking. But each new day in the world of superhero movie fandom seems to bring reviews more relishing in their castigations than the previous ones, and these castigations are generally not due to discoveries of new flaws€”they are generally the same points being rehashed over and over and over again with greater intensity. Man of Steel is not a perfect film but whether or not you dig what it's trying to do, it certainly doesn't deserve the matter-of-fact derision it is increasingly receiving, and I've come to the conclusion that this ever-increasing animosity toward Man of Steel reveals some underlying things that we would all do well to think about when it comes to our blockbusters. Besides web hits of course. Spoilers ahead...

10. A Director With A Signature

Let's face it. If we really think about it, outside of casting and maybe dialogue, many of us don't like to see the signature touches of a director in our blockbusters. When taste becomes too specialized, it at least initially can take a lot of us out of what we're watching, and some of us can't get past that. At the end of the day, we just want to see our beloved characters standing next to each other without camera, color, or editing styles getting in the way. Filmmakers can really be interchangeable so long as a movie is entertaining. In the case of Man of Steel, even if you're not familiar with Zack Snyder's stylistic predilections, such as shaky cameras, quick zooms, cool colors, and grand-scale reverence, it's easy to notice that Man of Steel is highly stylized (although not nearly as prominent as some of Zack Snyder's other films). From start to finish, from the cinematography to the music, you can tell a filmmaker is exerting his influence on it. The culmination of every single element is meant to create a very distinct motion picture experience€”it's not just a story on paper, but a signature statement through film. We want quality superhero movies, right? Movies that can be recognized for the art they are? Man of Steel is not the epitome of that, but it is a step in the right direction. If a director clearly respects the source material but we don't click with his or her style, we need to fight any initial revulsion we may naturally feel, even if the style in question wasn't conveyed well in the trailers. That's what being a film fan is all about. Taking in different styles can be very rewarding.

9. It's More Than A Superhero Movie

At its core, Man of Steel isn't a standard superhero movie about a good guy versus a bad guy. It goes further in scope as a true science fiction film revolving around so much more than that. It's about a person from another planet trying to identify with this one€”not just among the beings ruling Earth but with every facet of the planet itself, from animals to the Sun. It's about humans coming to terms with an extraterrestrial individual possessing extraordinary abilities. It's about a dying race unable to face reality. Man of Steel is about good on a much greater scale. This isn't the kind of focus many viewers were expecting, and very likely was a turn-off for many people. If we really look at ourselves in our respective mirrors, we know that we want our superhero movies to be more centralized around a smaller premise, and the more a movie deviates from that, the harder it is for us to accept it right away. What can a superhero movie be? As fans, we know many answers to that question.

8. It's Both Hyperbolic And Subtle

The tone of Man of Steel is as much a mainstream experiment as the rest of it. The visuals, dialogue, and music all go back and forth between the two extremes, even within the same scenes€”not necessarily enough to break the reality of the movie's universe, but enough for an audience to notice. Some people have called this uneven, but rather than careless filmmaking, it actually demonstrates a very deliberate artistic interpretation of the spirit of Superman. The action is thunderous but the emotions are multidimensional and understated. The movie is about true feelings with implications epic in their aspirations. For instance, Superman may reach for the Sun dramatically, but his face is quietly and realistically weary. Zod may give grandiose speeches, but his eyes flicker ever so slightly. The editing may jump around, but most scenes are given the time they need to develop. Although this kind of back-and-forth has gone over well for audiences with more respected movies, especially in the realm of science fiction (Blade Runner comes to mind€”which isn't my cup of tea, but I don't consider it a bad movie by any means), it is something to be testy about in mainstream blockbusters. We can only experiment with tone so much. Or can we?

7. Superman Isn't An Expert Right Away

A major complaint with Man of Steel is that Superman isn't good at fighting, planning, or protecting. Whether we like Superman or not, we put a lot of expectation into that "S" and cape. We like to think that Superman needs to be an expert in what he does right away, that he be as perennially calm and omnipotent in his actions as he is in his senses (yet dismiss him as being uninteresting because of those traits). But Man of Steel is not the Christopher Reeve interpretation (which isn't perennially calm and omnipotent either). The filmmakers behind Man of Steel wanted to explore a Superman beginning his journey without the training Christopher Reeve's Superman had, and in many of the comics Superman is not what you would always call a tactical genius anyway. Do we really need our superheroes to be so far along their journey at the very beginning, even further than they are within the comics they are being adapted from? Which brings me to my next point. Well, all of the points are like that. But you know what I mean.

6. Superman Explores More Character Territory

In Man of Steel, Superman is all-out emotional and has flaws. He may downplay many of these with that quiet nobility initially, but he proves in this movie time and time again that he's rough around the edges, and lets out a wide range of character traits. For starters, he ironically doesn't always look far enough ahead. He gets angry and isn't perfect in his reactions. His heat vision doesn't feel pleasant. He sweats, even without Kryptonite around. And by throwing in the Zod stuff (does anyone care that Superman also approved that Phantom Zone plan dooming the other Kryptonians to a vacuum?), the filmmakers force Superman to not just overcome the conflict he faces in the movie, but to one day have to come to grips with it€”not just within himself, but with the U.S. military following his every move. This goes for the other characters in the movie as well, right down to Richard Schiff's Dr. Emil Hamilton. A great amount of Man of Steel is dedicated to the feelings of its characters, across a variety of points of view. The film gives all that they do weight€”not the bad kind€”and makes the movie more intense emotionally than we're used to seeing in a superhero film, even more than (dare I say it?) the Iron Man and Dark Knight films. The atmosphere is dense with emotion. In its own way, this gives all of the characters exciting room to grow. But unfortunately, it also falls outside of the conventions of our general moviegoing routines. Do we want Superman to explore emotional territory not seen as much in his previous films (but frequently in the comics)€”without coming off as emo no less? More than that, can we ever take in our characters this way? What's wrong with an effort like this every once in a while?

5. Man Of Steel Puts Us Face-To-Face With The Destruction We Love To Cheer

We love explosions and the destruction that follows them. There are books about that. However, as with any kind of recreation, movies can only go so far, and superhero movies are no exception. There are books about that too. We like to think that destruction between two super-powered beings would only go so far before one of them relents, but in Man of Steel, we are not given such relief, and this hit many people very hard. It has remained one of the most common complaints about the movie. Many viewers felt Man of Steel's third act took superhero cinema to its breaking point. Why can't a superhero movie make us uncomfortable every now and then? After all, superhero movies are best when they get us thinking, and Man of Steel certainly does that, both through the film and our expectations of it. The destruction was not gratuitous. It has meaning.

4. Man Of Steel Sets Up Fresh Dynamics For The Sequel

We're human. We like what we know, and uncertainty always means effort. That's why we tell each other the same handful of stories over and over again, and that's why franchises are so popular. In superhero movies, we love the identity of the hero to remain a secret until the dramatic irony can be pushed no further. As much as we like to make fun of Clark Kent's glasses, it's an expectation we have. Many of us might initially say we're relieved that Man of Steel gets that stuff out of the way by the film's conclusion, with Lois Lane and possibly also Perry White knowing who Clark really is, but again, this brings us into unfamiliar territory with Superman, and this makes some people apprehensive. I have no doubt this has been a factor in many reviewers' feelings about the relationship between Lois and Clark. The relationships in Man of Steel are already pushed to a much greater level even without a sequel. We applaud "normal" dramas that push the boundaries of character relationships, so why get upset when Man of Steel just switches around the toys in the sandbox a little bit? If we feel that apprehension, we should take some deep breaths and see where the movie goes.

3. It Achieves Most Of Its Joy And Inspiration Through Drama

Contrary to what the Christopher Reeve movies may convey€”and incidentally, what many people also deplore about the character in question here today€”Superman, as we've accepted with most other fictional narratives across genres, does not have to be tongue-in-cheek and happy-go-lucky to be a positive, beautiful story. There are lines in between, and Man of Steel is just that. It's nuanced. Man of Steel does have many great outright humorous moments, but like any "normal" movie€”you know, those ones that non-geeks go to€”we feel happy and inspired through the drama of good characters, from the scenes between Clark and Jor-El, to the first reunion of Clark with Martha Kent, to the final moments between Clark and the World Engine. Man of Steel doesn't take itself too seriously as a blockbuster movie. It's just a movie, with care given to dialogue and direction that we would have been able to respect just fine in other genres. We're supposed to be the experts on this stuff, aren't we? Why is only Superman forbidden from the gray areas of emotion?

2. It's About Superman, Who We All Clearly Know Everything About Already

There are many people who truly know the ins and outs of Superman. And there are many more who think that they do. But Superman, like most comic book characters, is always more than what any of us know. Despite all the time he's been around, and maybe because of that, Superman has been sentenced more than any other hero to preconceived notions and stereotype. On one hand, there are the people who of course don't want to like him "because he can do everything and has no emotions," but on the other you have those who do like him but haven't read enough about him to know how much ground Superman has truly covered in the comics, or in other media for that matter. Liking or not liking Superman for certain reasons is of course perfectly fine. But should we ruin what could be an enlightening experience for ourselves and others because of our preconceptions? Now more than ever, we are open to heroes and interpretations of them€”why can't we be that way with Superman? Click "Next" for the underlying truth behind all the other points on this list.

1. Mostly, Man Of Steel Is Just Too Outside The Box

For most people, superhero movies can go outside the box to a certain extent. The best superhero movies usually do. But through all of the points I've addressed and then some, Man of Steel forces us to go a little further outside the box than we might usually feel comfortable with. Instead of running from something like this, we should welcome it as a healthy exercise in storytelling. There were things that bothered me the first time I saw Man of Steel, mostly on the technical side, but those things didn't cause me to viciously shoot down the movie every chance I got, because Man of Steel is skilled filmmaking overall. We can talk about neck-breaking all we want, but the fact is that Man of Steel has exposed more people saying what Superman "needs" to be than most other superhero movies in recent memory. Man of Steel really dug into the core of Superman and many of the themes associated with him and delivered the most human superhero movie of 2013 (and there were some good ones this year). It went in directions that were harder to swallow because they were different, but the genre is better for it. The movie certainly is not perfect, but it opens up a great many possibilities that we can only hope will eventually pay off. Watch it again. It's a creative, skillful, incredibly caring take on Superman and, more than that, a good film. We don't just want references to what we already know, do we? What do we really expect here? Are we fans of movies as they are or fans of expectations? Think about it. Hating on this movie doesn't help anyone. I for one think that time will ultimately be kind to Man of Steel, but let's be better than that. Instead of merely getting used to a movie, let's be better movie fans. What are your thoughts on this stuff? Let me know in the comments below.