10 Ridiculously Over-The-Top Acting Performances

By WhatCulture /

Whether for better or worse, nothing makes you sit up quite like a scenery chewing, over-the-top performance. It's something you will always remember and actors such as Sean Penn, Al Pacino, Nicolas Cage and Jack Nicholson have made careers out of dialing it up and overwhelming the screen. It's certainly one way to make an impression, although, more often than not, an over-the-top performance will be hideously grating and remind you of that horrible B-movie you accidentally stumbled across on late night TV once. You will often find ludicrously over-the-top performances in comedy, and sometimes it works, like in the case of Charlie Day and Jeremy Piven, but often it wears thin very quickly like the films of Jim Carrey and Will Ferrell. No matter how good or bad the performance is, a true over-the-top performance will have you talking, and if cinema has taught us anything, nothing gets people excited quite like an eccentric maniac who shouts a lot. I decided to have a single rule for this list: one performance per actor as the list could be entirely Nicolas Cage based otherwise.

10. Matthew McConaughey - Magic Mike

Steven Soderbergh's stripper movie, Magic Mike, was one of the best and most underrated movies of 2012, and key to the film's success was Matthew McConaughey's Oscar worthy performance as strip club owner Dallas. McConaughey has come a long way from leaning against inanimate objects on posters for awful rom-coms and has established himself as one of the most daring actors currently working. McConaughey throws himself head first into the material, and clearly isn't afraid of anything. He lets go completely, most notably in two scenes. The first one, he is teaching Alex Pettyfer how to dance whilst dressed in nothing but a tight yellow top and the smallest pair of shorts you will ever see. He plays it admirably straight and it's the funniest scene in the film. The second is his outrageous stripping sequence, where we see more of McConaughey than we ever dreamed of. McConaughey plays Dallas with a frantic energy, and he toes the line between eccentric and sleazy perfectly. The role called for an energetic, grandstanding performance and McConaughey more than delivered.

9. Arnold Schwarzenegger - Batman & Robin

Arnold Schwarzenegger has never been able to act, but that never stopped him being a great movie star, and he has in fact been in many good movies such as The Terminator and Total Recall, but his performance in Joel Schumacher's beyond disastrous Batman & Robin is one of the worst screen performances of all time. Granted, the script doesn't help the big man's cause but his hammy delivery of the horrible puns just descended us all into despair. The thing is, Arnie actually looks proud of himself as he's delivering the 'jokes', completely unaware of the disaster he's participating in. Arnie has always overacted in everything he's been in and his almost self-parodic performance in Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines was a contender for this list, but ultimately, this is a performance the former Governor of California should be ashamed of. It's actually one of the most depressing performances on this list, as the former bodybuilder and action hero was resorted to camping it up for cheap laughs in one of the most strange and abhorrent movies ever created.

8. John Malkovich - Con Air

Simon West's Con Air was hardly a masterclass in subtlety. The climax of the film entails an airplane landing on and destroying the Las Vegas strip, Nicolas Cage does a ludicrous Southern accent in one of his craziest performances and Steve Buscemi has a tea party with a little girl. And that's without mentioning John Malkovich's sociopath villain, Cyrus the Virus. Malkovich is a fine actor, everybody knows that, which makes his appearance and performance in Con Air all the more strange. Malkovich manages to outdo Cage in the intense weirdo stakes, which if you've seen the film is truly something to be hold. Seeing Malkovich be this much of a maniac in such a bad film is something of a guilty pleasure, because it's so bad you can't help but stare and look mystified. Malkovich wouldn't let his over-the-top alter ego out of the bag again until 2007's Burn After Reading to similarly hilarious results, only this time they were intentional.

7. Jim Carrey - Batman Forever

An article looking at over-the-top performances would never be complete without mentioning Jim Carrey. More specifically, an article looking at over-the-top performances would never be complete without mentioning Jim Carrey's performance in Batman Forever as The Riddler. Dressed in what appears to be an early incarnation of the onesie, Carrey is all camp, cackling mischief without the slightest resemblance of threat. Carrey's brand of comedy has always been wide eyes and goofy smiles, and many people, judging by the box-office his movies used to do, liked his shtick, but Batman Forever was most definitely not the place for that. Carrey plays most things on a level of hysteria, but in Batman Forever, the over-the-top goofiness tires quicker than ever before.

6. Peter Finch - Network

Perhaps the most famous part of Sidney Lumet's 70's masterpiece, Network, is Peter Finch's performance as raving TV anchor, Howard Beale. His superbly ranting performance earned him an Oscar, though he sadly died shortly after filming on the picture was completed. Even those that haven't seen Network would probably recognise Beale's iconic rant and his roaring of "I'm as mad as Hell and I'm not going to take it anymore!" as it is one of the finest scenes in cinema and long ago entered the pop culture pantheon. Finch's performance is pure fire and genuinely worthy of the word 'powerhouse'. It's not just a wonderfully over-the-top performance, it's a great acting performance and tonally perfect for Lumet's masterpiece. Nobody quite rants and raves quite like Peter Finch.

5. Gary Oldman - Leon: The Professional

To Hollywood, Gary Oldman has been the go-to-guy for gloriously eccentric villains for multiple decades and the best example of this is his portrayal of corrupt cop Norman Stansfield in Leon: The Professional. Oldman takes the standard bent cop cliche and runs as far as possible with it. He turns him into a Beethoven loving, cocaine snorting psychopath of the highest order, and with that, one of the most purely entertaining villains from the past two decades. Whilst Oldman's very best performances are the one's where he is completely restrained (Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy), nobody does ludicrously over-the-top quite like him. He always manages to come up with unique little things that make his characters stand out. The energy he emits in Leon is unrivalled and is by far the craziest performance he has ever done, even topping his slightly surreal small performance in True Romance.

4. Dennis Hopper - Blue Velvet

Dennis Hopper's portrayal of Frank Booth is simply one of the finest screen performances of all time. Even in the nightmarish world of David Lynch, Frank Booth is the scariest, leeriest and most venomous creation from his entire catalogue. Hopper got the role of Booth by convincing Lynch that he was Booth and his performance gives the unsettling insight that he wasn't exaggerating. Hopper's performance is full on odd-ball. In one scene, he is sexually humiliating Isabella Rossellini's Dorothy and in another, he breaks down after hearing Roy Orbison's In Dreams. Hopper does not hold back a single bit. He snarls with venom, his profanity laced rants are relentless and he spits with such hate it leaves you feeling deeply unsettled. He's an outrageous character and Hopper's lurid eccentricity made him one of the finest screen villains in American film history.

3. Al Pacino - The Devil's Advocate

In the later part of his career, Al Pacino has developed a reputation as 'the shouty guy', and sadly, this is mostly true. In between good performances in Insomnia, Any Given Sunday and Donnie Brasco, ever since the late 90's, he's dialed it up to 11 and turned into a roaring monster that is a million miles away from his masterful portrayal of Michael Corleone. In The Devil's Advocate, he plays Satan (who else?) and the script gives him full support to explode with camp pomp, giving us a depiction of the Devil that has been often mocked for its outrageousness. Somehow, it kind of works. Opposite Pacino is Keanu Reaves, so he looks even more manic and intense than he usually would. The performance cautiously toes the line between awful and genius, in the way that it's a lot of fun, but you're also laughing at it, not with it. Pacino's tone throughout the movie is hysterical, and its so over-the-top it's overwhelming and his End of Days rant is the thing of legend.

2. Jack Nicholson - The Shining

Jack Nicholson has always had a reputation over his lengthy and storied career as being able to play manic intensity with ease and often needs reigning in by directors when he steps a little too far. Here, his unpredictability and insanity works massively to his favour in his iconic role of Jack Torrance in Stanley Kubrick's The Shining. When Torrance finally descends into madness, Nicholson is the perfect choice to display over-the-top madness, whilst also maintaining the ability to make the audience sympathise with the tortured man. What's so great about Nicholson's performance is that he pushes himself so much further and experiments with things no other actor would, and adding that to Stanley Kubrick's quest for perfection through hundreds of takes and you have one of the most gloriously unstable performances ever captured by film. The infamous "Here's Johnny!" moment was also improvised by Nicholson, and despite it being one of the most well-known scenes in film, it is still an intense and sinister moment in Kubrick's horror masterpiece. Nicholson has never been more bonkers and brilliant than he is here, and his performance is the perfect example of over-the-top acting done well.

1. Nicolas Cage - The Wicker Man

Oh, Nicolas, how far we have fell. As you will have gathered from this list, there is good over-the-top and bad over-the-top and this performance definitely sits in the later category. In an alternate universe, this would be one of the funniest film performances of all time, except The Wicker Man is supposed to be a horror film, so Lord knows what script Cage was reading from. A remake of the 70's cult classic was never a good idea, but nobody could envision it would turn out this hysterically bad. Cage could easily have featured on this list several times as his performances in Wild at Heart, Con Air and Bad Lieutenant all warrant inclusion, but one performance per actor meant it had to be this. The eyes are wilder than they have ever been before and the frantic intensity has reached levels never before recorded. By the time the credits roll, he's kicked a little girl, dressed up as a bear and punched a woman (yes, really), gotten chased by some horribly bad CGI bees and had his legs broken. Altogether now: "not the bees, not the bees!"