10 Short Sentences That Ruin Major Films

Blowing a hole in the logic of some well-known movies.

By Scott Campbell /

Movies are a great source of both entertainment and escapism, and it is for that reason audiences are more likely to forgive the occasional lapse in logic when it comes to something that happens on the big screen. For instance, if a news bulletin or documentary played as hard and fast with the facts as the movie business does, then there would surely be riots in the street. People go to the movies to enjoy themselves and more often than not don't even notice many of the narrative problems until after they've left the theater, and sit around with friends and family dissecting what they've just seen over a meal or a beer. However, there are plenty of instances when movies have shown complete disregard for both logic and common sense, relying on the viewer to suspend their disbelief a little too much. It can be anything from a plot that relies too heavily on coincidence to propel the story, some questionable character motivations or a plot point so ridiculous and unconvincing it takes you right out of the movie altogether. With that in mind, this article will take a tongue-in-cheek and ever so slightly cynical look at ten movies that can have their plots picked apart in just one brief sentence. Each of these brief statements potentially undermines the entire movie and poses plenty of room for discussion, so read on and see if you agree. Do you agree that these brief statements put major holes in the stories of these movies? Are there any others that you would have included? As always, sign off in the comments below.

10. Training Astronauts To Drill Would Be A Lot Quicker - Armageddon (1998)

Michael Bay's Armageddon was the highest-grossing movie of 1998, earning $553.7m at the box office despite a decidedly mixed critical reaction. Like most of the director's output the movie threw logic, sense and scientific accuracy out of the window in order to create a crowd-pleasing blockbuster full of massive-scale destruction. The plot centers on a motley crew of deep-core drillers that face a crash-course in astronaut training in order to save the world. However, Armageddon would be a much shorter movie if they had just switched things around and trained the astronauts how to drill instead. Becoming an astronaut requires immense dedication and years of intense training, but Bruce Willis and company only have a matter of weeks to train themselves for their dangerous mission. That being said, if the astronauts had learned how to drill then the script would probably be about ten pages long, as much of the second act is dedicated to the light-hearted shenanigans and training montages of the drilling team. In the DVD commentary for the movie, Ben Affleck reveals that he posed the very same question to Michael Bay when they were making the movie about how much easier it would be to train astronauts to drill. The director's response? 'Shut the f*ck up'.

9. Nobody Hears Charles Foster Kane's Last Word - Citizen Kane (1941)

Citizen Kane is still rightly regarded as one of the greatest movies ever made, with Orson Welles making an unforgettable debut theatrical feature. After Welles' wealthy newspaper magnate dies, an intrepid reporter decides to delve into Charles Foster Kane's past in order to discover the meaning behind 'Rosebud', his dying word. The only problem is, the character died alone on his vast estate so nobody was actually there to hear him say it. Later on in the movie, the butler does recall that he heard Kane mention the phrase a while before his death, but that doesn't cover up the fact that the entire plot of the movie revolves around the meaning behind a word that nobody actually heard the character say firsthand. Perhaps the butler was telling the truth, or perhaps maid the heard him, seeing as she enters the room moments after he passes away. Either way, it remains quite a large oversight in a true masterpiece of American cinema.

8. Nobody Shoots Nice Guy Eddie - Reservoir Dogs (1992)

Quentin Tarantino's debut feature instantly established the former video store clerk as a talent to watch, as he deconstructed the crime movie by delivering a heist flick without a heist, a fractured narrative structure and rapid-fire dialogue that influenced a generation of independent filmmakers. In the movie's climactic Mexican standoff, Chris Penn's Nice Guy Eddie is killed despite the fact that nobody actually shoots him, and Tarantino decided to keep it in the movie anyway in order to generate debate amongst fans. Joe has his gun aimed at Mr. Orange, Mr. White has his gun pointed at Joe and Nice Guy Eddie has his weapon trained on Mr. White. In the original script, Mr. White reportedly turns his gun on Eddie after shooting Joe, but apparently Chris Penn's squibs went off too soon and he dropped to the ground anyway. Even if the ending of the movie no longer makes any sense, Reservoir Dogs is still a classic, while Penn missing his mark and dying onscreen too early went on to spawn plenty of 'Who Shot Nice Guy Eddie?' merchandise in the process.

7. Nobody Dials Cypher In So He Can Meet The Agents - The Matrix (1999)

In the Wachowski's game-changing sci-fi actioner, the characters make it very clear that you can only enter and exit the Matrix if there's an operator there to dial you in and out, and that's after finding a suitable hardline from which to make your exit. Yet somehow, Joe Pantoliano's Cypher manages to arrange a meeting inside the Matrix with the nefarious Agents in order to betray Morpheus, even though he's the only member of the crew that is awake and couldn't possibly jack in and out of the Matrix with such ease on his lonesome. Even if the writer/director's have seemingly forgotten the rules of their own universe when creating this scene, a theory amongst Matrix fans have devised an explanation to cover this fairly gaping plot hole. This theory posits that Morpheus initially thought Cypher was the One, which is why he was removed from the Matrix despite the movie explaining that older people don't tend to be unplugged, and also helps explain his genius credentials and ability to see the code just by looking at it. Perhaps the Wachowskis intended this all along, or maybe its was just an oversight on the siblings' part.

6. Buzz Freezes Even Though He Doesn't Realize He's A Toy - Toy Story (1995)

The premise of the first ever full-length computer animated theatrical movie is genius in its simplicity; what if toys came to life as soon as their owners left the room? One of the main plot points of Toy Story is that new arrival Buzz Lightyear refuses to believe that he is actually a toy, so why does he freeze just like the rest of them whenever a human is nearby? Buzz's reluctance to accept the fact that he is a child's plaything causes plenty of tension between himself and Woody, so it seems a bit strange that he would follow suit with the rest of the gang if he believes himself to be a real-life Space Ranger. Perhaps all that training at Star Command had taught him to blend in with the locals on a strange new planet, or maybe he's just being polite and following the crowd in order to assimilate into his new and unfamiliar surroundings.

5. Bruce Wayne Magically Reappears In Gotham - The Dark Knight Rises (2012)

As one of the most highly-anticipated movies in history, Christopher Nolan's concluding chapter in the Dark Knight Trilogy was always going to come under intense scrutiny. While the movie is still great and is often judged incredibly harshly, the narrative does have several plot holes large enough to drive the Tumbler through, the biggest of which is Bruce Wayne's miraculous return to Gotham just in time to save the day. A character that is not to be underestimated simply because he's the goddamn Batman, Wayne's sudden reappearance on home turf does stretch the limits of credibility in a movie where an entire police force is sent underground at the same time. Despite being beaten to a pulp, imprisoned by his arch nemesis and having absolutely no resources to his name, Bruce manages to escape the prison ruled by his enemy, travel halfway across the world, sneak into a fortified city that is under Bane's control, reacquire his gadgets and engineer an elaborate flaming Bat-signal without anybody noticing. Surely word would have reached Bane somehow that the guy he had engineered a plan to dump in an inescapable prison had managed to find his way out?

4. Indiana Jones Is Completely Unnecessary To The Plot - Raiders Of The Lost Ark (1981)

Blame The Big Bang Theory for this one; in the episode The Raiders Minimization, Amy makes a staggeringly valid point to Sheldon regarding Indiana Jones' role in the story of Steven Spielberg's classic adventure, saying 'if he wasn't in the movie the Nazis would have still found the Ark, taken it to the island, opened it up and all died... just like they did'. Based on this point of view, Indy's only real contribution to the story is making sure that the Ark is securely locked away in the warehouse by the time the credits roll. With a story by George Lucas, perhaps it isn't that surprising that such a huge flaw in the narrative exists. However, the Indiana Jones franchise isn't really about whatever MacGuffin the intrepid archeologist is chasing after, its about Harrison Ford's iconic portrayal of the character and the dynamic action sequences more than anything else. However, the notion that the title character is largely irrelevant to the plot still left a lot of people smarting at the revelation, even though it can be argued that Indy leading the Nazis to Marion Ravenwood is the real catalyst in the search for the Ark of the Covenant.

3. Andy Dufresne's Poster Was Put Back Up From The Outside - The Shawshank Redemption (1994)

One of the most uplifting an inspiring movies ever made, The Shawshank Redemption is a universally-beloved tale that somehow managed to disappoint at the box office before people actually realized just how brilliant it really is. The moment that the Warden discovers Andy Dufresne's decades-in-the-making escape is an all-time classic scene, although the question remains; how the hell did he manage to reattach his Racquel Welch poster from inside the tunnel? Many people believe that reattaching the poster had been practiced over and over again by Andy during the dry runs of his escape, or maybe he was able to do it by only fixing it to the wall via the two top corners. Think about it; Andy has dug himself a tunnel that he can just about manage to crawl through, and in the movie we see that he goes in headfirst. He must have been one hell of a contortionist to be able to twist his body around in such a confined space in order to cover his tracks, or maybe we should all just overlook such trivial things and revel in a truly magical moment of cinema.

2. The McFly's Don't Notice Their Son Looks Exactly Like Calvin Klein - Back To The Future (1985)

Back to the Future created many time-travel paradoxes and theories of alternate universes that have been dissected by fans of the movie for almost 30 years, and overlooking the fact that Marty McFly's mother wanted to bang him there is another plot point that would surely have caused tensions in the McFly household; the fact that both George and Lorraine seem oblivious to the fact that their son is an exact doppelganger of Calvin Klein, the mysterious teenager who appeared out of nowhere 30 years before and both brought the couple together and influenced George's eventual career as a science fiction writer. Perhaps they do know, and shy and timid George McFly just doesn't want to admit it. Although you'd imagine he'd confront his wife at least once on his suspicions about the fact that their son looks completely identical to the guy that had taken her to the dance all those years ago, who she claims never to have heard from again. Then again, maybe so much time has passed that they can barely remember what Calvin Klein looked like, regardless of the impact he had on their lives. Would you be able to instantly recognize someone that you had known for a week if you saw them 30 years later?

1. The Time Travel Device That Is Used Once And Never Mentioned Again - Harry Potter And The Prisoner of Azkaban (2004)

It may seem a little harsh to pick holes in the Prisoner of Azkaban, a movie from a franchise that is so deeply rooted in fantasy, featuring all manner of wonderfully imaginative magical creatures and a world so inventively different from our own. However, given the events that transpire throughout the remainder of the Harry Potter series, you would think that even one person would remember that there is a device that lets you travel back in time and alter the past for the better, which would be a lot easier than traveling the country in order to hunt down and destroy Horcruxes. The central trio use the Time Turner in order to save the day in the third movie's final act, and then conveniently forget that the thing ever existed in order to carry on with their adventures in the wizarding world for the next five movies. Granted, Dumbledore made sensible use of time travel by trusting Hermione with it so she could take extra classes and not abuse her newfound power, but given the ensuing rise of Voldemort and his Death Eaters along with the heavy civilian casualties that follow in his wake, the almost-omnipotent headmaster would surely realize he could stop all of this from happening by traveling back in time and making a few minor alterations to wizarding history that would stop the entire thing from happening in the first place.