10 Successful Low Budget Films (That Weren't As Good As You Think)

Affordability and quotability don't always mean quality.

By Gavin Bard /

Inevitably the question of over-rated movies is a well trodden road, and generally speaking, when approaching the subject in general (and it's a painful inevitability for any cinephile to either accuse or defend something beloved in those terms) you have a fairly simple set of criteria. A lot of things win oodles of Oscars or gain mass acceptance yet can be clearly pointed to as overrated without ruffling too many feathers - seriously, does anybody get mad when you complain about Gone With the Wind anymore? There have been countless arguments about Forrest Gump or Titanic not actually being very good, and frankly, nobody really cares much when you are critical of the big Hollywood productions, because they're somehow classed as fair game or a justifiable target. When you turn that same critical eye towards low budget darlings however, you start threatening some real sacred cows. People are fiercely defensive of their favourite movies, and in an odd quirk, like the faithful exponents of underdogs the world over, that goes doubly for any film that could be classified as "indie" or low budget. But those titles, and those fans need to accept that their favourites are not untouchable, and that some movies just need to be taken down a peg thanks to their inexplicable or inflated popularity. Just because something cost very little, and managed an unprecedented or perhaps disproportionate level of success, does not mean that it is flawless. The film world is not a fairy tale land where everything comes out sugar coated, and no matter how much fire will no doubt be generated in debate, there has to be some logical approach to analysing even the most beloved of gems.

10. Clerks (1994)

Clerks is actually a good movie: if you were ever a teenager in the '90s desperate for something more interesting to watch than Forrest Gump and Angels In The Outfield, it is kind of hard to pretend that this movie didn't have a huge hand in your development as a frustratingly jaded 20-something film viewer. It is a movie with great dialogue that really does represent the classic low-budget ethos well, and its success is a great motivator to a lot of struggling filmmakers. It also launched the career of Kevin Smith, but whether or not that is a good thing is entirely dependent on your own personal preferences. What can't be argued is that Clerks does a fantastic job of representing the attitude of the typical "slacker" and does it better than any big budget movie ever would. With all that said, Clerks isn't one of the funniest movies ever. You wouldn't notice that from the praise though. It holds an impressive 88% on Rotten Tomatoes, and has the same score as Ferris Bueller's Day Off on IMDB. It is somehow ranked above Office Space AND Airplane. Even Roger Ebert liked it - presumably, his favourite scene was not the rattling off of as many pornos with the word "cum" in it as they could think of - and Empire rated it the 4th greatest independent film of all time in any genre. Even questioning Clerks sets off some sort of alarm that has angry mobs descend upon you, which is mostly because a lot of its most vehement fans seem to think "quotability" always means quality, and if that were true Adam Sandler would have won an Oscar for Billy Madison. Clerks is a movie where nothing really happens and nobody learns anything, which is a fantastic statement on life but not such a great thing to do in a film. It is also hard to forget that the original cut of Clerks featured an ending so hackneyed that no amount of pithy lines about oral sex could have saved it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ERDGH7SpzZ8

9. The Boondock Saints (1999)

The Boondock Saints has some good things going for it, including Willem Dafoe, some neat action scenes, and... Okay, so it has those things going for it. This is one of those movies that you feel kind of bad for "growing out of:" it does enough right that you couldn't call it bad, but it doesn't do enough to stand out from the crowd of vigilante/revenge flicks to really deserve its status as a hallowed cult hit. And a cult hit it was: while barely 20% of RT critics enjoyed it, over 92% of the common man liked it, giving it a better than the original RoboCop and a full 5 points more than The Terminator. No matter how much you like Boondock Saints, one would hope that you don't think it is better than the Terminator. The problem starts with a supporting cast that tries harder to keep the movie's head above the water than the main characters do - no offence Norman Reedus - and its constant use self awareness as an excuse to cover up some really goofy plotting. It is really hard to look at The Boondock Saints and figure out just what makes it so much better than so many other action films in the views of its fans, especially with an uneven pace and more plot related rectal-revelations than a movie about colorectal surgery. Maybe with a director who was less interested in promoting his band and worshiping Tarantino than carving out something original, it might have lived up to its legend. As it stands though, this is just a passable movie with a strangely passionate fanbase. .

8. Lost In Translation (2003)

Lost in Translation's absolute overdose on being underwhelming isn't really the fault of the cast: Scarlett Johansson put herself on the map here, and Bill Murray further solidified himself as Brooklyn's fry-stealing, party crashing hero even though they probably should loved him unconditionally already anyway. The pair is even more impressive when you consider just how little they had to work with: Sofia Coppola's script, which somehow won an Academy Award even though half of it had to be made up of stage directions like , is minimalist to a fault. How Bill Murray or Scarlett Johannson didn't win little naked gold men for giving great performances in a film with more pensive staring than dialog is one of life's great mysteries. See, the real problem with Lost in Translation is Sofia Coppola. In fact, the real problem with every Sofia Coppola movie is Sofia Coppola, except for her utterly gutless Marie Antoinette, where the problem was Kirsten Dunst and Sofia Coppola. With Lost in Translation, she goes for "quiet and ponderous" and ends up hitting "dull and slow" too often, and the film ends up being a simple little story held back by a privileged director with no real vision that has been propped up by myth and name value.

7. Almost Anything That Can be Called "Mumblecore" Non-Ironically

The thing about the vast majority of these movies is that they only seem to exist to give fodder to the people who, in 2014, still spend time whining about the hipster strawman they've created in their head to represent "things I don't personally like." They can't possibly serve any other purpose. Maybe you grow a dwarf beard in the summer; maybe you know people in folk bands; maybe you wear a keffiyeh and worry about it being culturally appropriative but still wear it anyway; maybe you own "Transaction de Novo." On vinyl. Maybe you go to art galleries for more than just the free wine... you'd still be hard-pressed to find a single person who actually enjoys these indistinguishably quirky coffee house conversation pieces. You are a person reading movie lists on the internet and, based on the law of averages, probably own a pair of skinny jeans - do you know anybody that likes Baghead? Hannah Takes the Stairs? Tiny Furniture? Of course you don't. None of these movies have higher viewer scores than critic scores on any website you can find. They are what The Average Joe pictures when they think of an "indie movie." The worst thing about the genre is that mumblecore movies that can't even be parodied, because the movies themselves already seem like parodies of something that you might not have seen but totally know you would hate. Watch trailers for any Duplass brothers' film, just pick one at random, and you will immediately realise it is the kind of thing you'd expect to see if that one guy from SNL and the guitarist from Sleater-Kinney ever made a Grindhouse homage and needed some fake trailers to wedge in between their entries. Speaking of which...

6. Chelsea Girls (1966)

It is a little known fact that Dante actually had 11 levels of hell, and that the eleventh is being stuck for all of eternity in a room full of people explaining how Chelsea Girls was a brilliant piece of innovative art and not just 3 1/2 hours of Andy Warhol performing autofellatio while figuring out where he can score some obetrol. This split screen effort somehow comes off as if it is trying way too hard and not trying enough at the same time. Maybe that was the point, but that still doesn't make it entertaining at all. In the 50 years since its release, it has become suspect if there is any cross over at all in the Venn diagram of people who "liked" Chelsea Girls and people who "saw" Chelsea Girls. Considering Warhol's history as a self-promoting artist, it could be possible assume that he and Paul Morrissey made this movie entirely to expose just how far the art community will contort itself in order to sound knowledgeable and hip. If that is the case, than this was a rousing success. This is just Warhol using "anti-film" as an excuse to not have to make anything actually interesting: Chelsea Girls is 210 minutes of absolutely irredeemable and unwatchable amateurish preening. Definitely Andy Warhol's best work.

5. (500) Days Of Summer (2009)

500 Days of Summer is like most movies on this list - you can't call it terrible, just absolutely criminally overrated. Hailed as some fantastically clever take on the stalest genre in movie history, its only real cleverness was being able to disguise just how cloying and pandering it actually is. There is nothing entirely unique about 500 Days of Summer, as it almost immediately falls into the romantic-comedy trap of having two majorly unlikeable characters just sort of bump against each other for a while in the hope that something entertaining happens. Then nothing really does. You can try to hide your shortcomings with witty banter, nonlinear editing, and douche-chillingly forced references to The Smiths all you want, but under it you still need to have some substance. Instead, 500 Days of Summer ends up being a movie that is essentially High Fidelity if somebody completely misunderstood the point of High Fidelity. When you take into consideration the title card and the fact that writer Scott Neustadter has admitted this movie was about actual relationships he had, things just become even murkier and less enjoyable. He frames 500 Days of Summer as a film that treats relationships fairly realistically since, generally, there are no actual villains in a normal relationship. Just two different people who might end up wanting different things. Except the tone of the movie doesn't actually accomplish that. It tries to show that Tom Hansen is being unreasonable and projecting too much onto a clearly unwilling relationship partner which is completely laudable in a genre that often confuses cringe inducing obsession with storybook romance, but by the end those wheels just fall entirely off and the character ends up as the same unbalanced dude who learns absolutely nothing.

4. Donnie Darko (2001)

Donnie Darko isn't an awful movie by any means: it is entirely inoffensive as long as you don't think too much about the slipshod plot, or how Donnie Darko ended up letting a pedophile roam free to commit more crimes. It did have Echo and the Bunnymen on the soundtrack and a really cool visual style, so it is easy to forgive its glaring shortcomings as long as nobody tries to pretend it is the smartest movie ever made or something. SPOILER ALERT: That is precisely what people did. The internet in 2001 was a scary place where you couldn't swing a guy in a rabbit suit without hitting somebody willing to yell at you about how profound Donnie Darko is. Not much has changed since, and this merely-okay-sort-of-nostalgic film has turned into an unassailable classic to a lot of people. The problem inherent in Donnie Darko is that it isn't nearly as smart as it thinks it is, and almost none of it holds up to any real scrutiny. This was proven drastically correct when the director's cut was released: imagine how poorly written a movie has to be for it to get worse when you explain more of it and fill plotholes. This and The Butterfly Effect were the "Baby's First Mindmelt" duology and on the surface there isn't really anything wrong with that - it is just that when you learn how to ride a bike you are supposed to take the training wheels off, and as soon as you saw Lost Highway or something, you should stop getting super angry when people point out they don't like Donnie Darko. And Southland Tales was Richard Kelly's best movie. Think about that for a minute.

3. Juno (2007)

The sort of distaff counterpart to Juno was a little movie by the name of Superbad. The reason Superbad worked as one of the best "teen" movies was that, finally, a movie had dialogue that sounded like something an average awkward teenager would really say. Considering Superbad had a license to print money, it would make sense to think that the painful days of every teenage movie being full of characters that were nothing but hyper-witty wish fulfilment vessels were now past. One month later, Juno came out. The greatest trick Diablo ever played was convincing people that she was a talented writer: she somehow won an Academy Award despite every single one of Juno's lines sounds like it was whispered to her from a futureself who spent the last ten years since high school sitting around going "man, if only I said this instead" about every conversation she ever had. The only time there are any sort of interesting moments between two characters are the parts where Juno would interact with the husband-half of the couple who wanted to adopt her baby, and that is only because it sort of teased an outside chance that this was going to turn into Hard Candy 2: Electric Boogaloo. Instead, that character just turns into yet another excuse to make references to other Super Cool Things in lieu of actual character development. Considering the hour and a half before it, the only logical ending to Juno would be the entire cast laying on the ground twitching while frothing at the mouth due to a deadly overdose of irony and smug satisfaction.

2. Napoleon Dynamite (2004)

Remember all those words ago about how people who get super mad when somebody points out Clerks wasn't perfect do so because they confuse a movie's "quotability" with its quality? Now, imagine that same issue but instead of witty dialogue you have barely coherent memetic pablum that can easily be turned into a shirt in Hot Topic's "Viciously Beaten Dead Horses" section. Voila! You are now imagining the reason Napoleon Dynamite wasn't a good movie at all. Not only did it unleash Jon Heder on the world, but it made an entire generation of people think that saying "gosh" in a funny voice is a perfectly acceptable substitute for a punchline. At least Jon Heder is doing a pretty good job as the Philadelphia Eagle's quarterback now though. Good for him. Napolean Dynamite is a movie about poorly written characters saying nothing interesting for an hour and then a reminder that Jamiroquai existed. It is actually more catchphrase than movie. Sometimes it's nice to imagine that this is the version of Gummo made in the Darkest Timeline by a Wes Anderson robot clone and painstakingly marketed towards people who think The Big Bang Theory is the pinnacle of sitcom humor.

1. Garden State (2004)

The movie that started it all - if "it all" means "almost every cash grab faux-indie film-making trend that makes movie fans want to lock themselves in a room and only watch Gamera: The Revenge of Iris until every movie producer is dead." Garden State is what would happen if an advanced artificial intelligence typed "Quirky" into DuckDuckGo and just generated a movie based on the search results. Heavily medicated, depressed, struggling actor who waits tables and has goofy fashion sense? Added. Paralegal epileptic pathological liar with an adopted African sibling? Throw it in there. Grave digging stoner jewel thieves? Successful childhood friend with a fortune from a zany invention? Method Man? QuirkBot 2000 must have it all! Even despite that, Garden State would have almost been tolerable if it wasn't for critics, fans, and most annoyingly Zach Braff, all clamoring desperately for this to become The Graduate for a generation that really didn't need The Graduate. Zach Braff actually called Garden State a "life-affirming state of the union address for 20-somethings." He had that thought and then said it out loud with complete earnestness. Frustratingly, nobody made fun of him for that until he started begging for money on Kickstarter. It is hard not to agree with him though. Garden State is an over-hyped, efficiently marketed, disappointing mess where nobody really knows what they are doing, everybody is unhappy most of the time, and indie music never stops playing. So, yeah, pretty spot on representation of being a 20-something Zach. Between this and Napoleon Dynamite, 2004 was objectively the worst time in human history. Thank god White Chicks came out that year to redeem it. Which other beloved indie gems deserve to be on this list? Share your own suggestions in the list below.