10 Things The Oscars Want You To Forget

Because #OscarsSoWhite isn't the Academy's first embarrassment.

By Taylor Burns /

If there's one thing that the Oscars love, it's a good cock up. Not content with simply doing what they're ostensibly supposed to do, i.e. honour the year's best performers, films, technicians, etc, they instead continually present themselves as stuffy, passe organisation, one that every year seems to dabble in some new farce that in turn leads us to question what the point of the awards even is anymore. Such cock ups, as we'll see, range from the fairly minor - baffling winners, shocking presenters - to the shamefully major, best exemplified by this year's #OscarsSoWhite campaign, which, after building momentum during last year's awards, has looked to finally call bullsh*t on the Oscars' all-encompassing whiteness. That hashtag looks set to bring about some serious change at AMPAS, but no amount of future referendum can ever erase some of Oscar's very worst mistakes, ten of which are presented here as a list of things the Academy really want you to forget.

10. Never Naming Stanley Kubrick Or Alfred Hitchcock As Best Director

They're perhaps the two iconic directors in the history of film, but neither Alfred Hitchcock nor Stanley Kubrick were ever awarded the Best Director Oscar by the Academy, a startling oversight when you consider their importance and stature (and even more so when you consider some of the far inferior directors who Oscar have otherwise bestowed the award upon). All of Hitchcock's five Oscar nominations (a paltry amount when you look at his output) came in the Best Director category, but he lost every time, including twice to Billy Wilder (for The Lost Weekend and The Apartment). Perhaps the real travesty is not that Hitchcock lost five times, then, but that some of his greatest films never even earned him a nomination for Best Director in the first place, a notion that baffles most when you remember that he wasn't even nominated for Vertigo, a film routinely cited as the greatest of all time. Kubrick was nominated for thirteen Oscars in total, winning one, for the effects on 2001: A Space Odyssey. Of those thirteen, only four were for Best Director, where he too lost each time, here to the likes of Carol Reed (Oliver!), William Friedkin (The French Connection) and Milos Forman (One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest). Again, these are fairly formidable opponents, but it remains that Kubrick, one of the greatest of all artists, was never recognised by the Academy as being worthy of that acclaim. Add to this the staggering fact that only one Hitchcock or Kubrick film ever won Best Picture (the former's Rebecca), and you have some idea of just how under-appreciated the pair where in Academy circles.

9. "Marlon Brando's" Acceptance Speech For The Godfather

If you're wondering why "Marlon Brando" is in ironic quotation marks, it's because the actor didn't himself collect his Best Actor Award for The Godfather in 1972. Instead, in the most famous Academy Award acceptance speech ever (as well as a contender for the most Marlon Brando moment ever), the actor arranged to have Sacheen Littlefeather, a member of the American Indian Movement (AIM), collect the award by proxy, the actor choosing to boycott the ceremony in protest against the ongoing siege at Wounded Knee, and the constant misrepresentation of Native American's on film and television (Brando, fully in his activism period, had recently aligned with the AIM). The speech prompted a mixture of nervous applause and even some jeers, and it ensured that Brando's status as a divisive firebrand continued, the actor provoking mixed responses from his fellow actors in the aftermath. (Most vocal was Michael Caine, who criticised Brando for letting "some poor Indian girl" accept on his behalf). As a consequence of the whole affair, the Academy has since disallowed proxy acceptance, except in instances where it is unavoidable, vis. posthumous awards. As a side note, Roger Moore (in perhaps the most Roger Moore moment ever), not knowing what to do with the award he so awkwardly holds throughout the speech, simply took it home, where it stayed overnight until armed guards came to collect it in the morning.

8. Marisa Tomei's Best Supporting Actress Win For My Cousin Vinny

It's been vehemently denied by all parties since, but there's always going to be controversy surrounding Marisa Tomei's Best Supporting Actress win for My Cousin Vinny in 1992. Tomei, a virtual unknown in a pool of prestigious talent that included Vanessa Redgrave, initially surprised everyone when she was nominated for her turn in the sleeper hit that was released over a year before the ceremony, a surprise that doubled when she actually won, beating out the perceived lock, Redgrave (nominated for her work in Howard's End), in the process. This is no mere upset, though, because it's long been rumoured that Tomei's win was actually an outright mistake. There isn't enough space here to really convey the diffuse nature of the rumour, so, in a nutshell: Presenter Jack Palance, a bona fide wild-card who the year before accepted his own Oscar by doing one-armed push-ups and who preceded Tomei's award presentation by getting fellow nominee Judy Davis' name wrong (he called her Joan), supposedly read the last nominee's name off the teleprompter, rather than the actual winner's. It was presumed he was either drunk or stoned or both. It's been the subject of debate for many years, but unlike most rumours, this one just won't seem to go away, and as a consequence it has forever lingered over the Academy, serving as perhaps the most prevalent Oscar conspiracy theory to date.

7. The Hoop Dreams Controversy

Even more diffuse is this, the story of Hoop Dreams' failure to land an Oscar nomination for Best Documentary at the 1995 Oscars, a snub so great it provoked Roger Ebert, who had championed Hoop Dreams as The Great American Documentary, into writing a blog entry entitled The Anatomy of a Snub; a snub so profound it caused a change in the Oscars' rules and forced the creation of a new branch of AMPAS. Ebert suggests that the film's 165 minute run-time was a contributing factor in its snubbing, suggesting further that the AMPAS voters simply couldn't be bothered to sit through a film that long, instead electing to have it turned off after fifteen minutes via the flashlight system* which has since been abandoned as a consequence of the whole Hoop Dreams debacle . The truth is actually something closer to a small number of members manipulating the voting process - as outlined in this piece by Steve Pond, who has the requisite space to explain fully - but however it happened, it remains that the Academy, through their own shortsightedness and sheer incompetence, managed to force a change in their own voting process, ensuring that Hoop Dreams gained far more exposure for this reason than any Oscar could ever give it. *To briefly explain: Each member was given a flashlight. If, after fifteen minutes, enough members flashed theirs at the screen, the film was stopped.

6. Crash's Best Picture Win Over Brokeback Mountain

Best epitomised by presenter Jack Nicholson's what-the-f***-happened face (he can be seen mouthing it in other clips), Crash's win over Brokeback Mountain (and Munich, let's not forget) is far and away the most prevalent Best Picture upset in Oscar history, and it makes this list as a consequence, as an example of the time where the Academy Awards really, truly, irredeemably got it wrong. Though other Best Picture upsets like Dance With Wolves over Goodfellas - or Forrest Gump over Pulp Fiction - are often cited, it's Paul Haggis' mawkish, racism-is-bad Crash - over Ang Lee's stunning, gorgeous masterpiece Brokeback Mountain - that most people remember. Brokeback had already swept the Best Picture award at the BAFTAs and the Goldem Globes, and what's more Ang Lee had triumphed over Paul Haggis in the Best Director category earlier on in the night, all pointing towards the obvious, inevitable, absolutely worthy win for Lee's far superior film. Instead, Crash's name was read out, to the chagrin and bafflement of Nicholson, the audience, and anybody with even a passing interest in cinema. If there was always going to be an on-the-night snub on this list, it was always going to be this one.

5. Giving Three 6 Mafia An Oscar For Best Original Song

Not that I'm personally begrudging Three 6 Mafia their Oscar success (how could anyone begrudge a group who showed up to the Academy Awards dressed like that^), but there's a strong chance Oscar is, such is the sort of joke it has since become. (Well not really a joke, but a kind of so-and-so doesn't have an Oscar but Three 6 Mafia does, kinda thing). Host John Stewart certainly wasted no time in announcing that it was Three 6 Mafia 1, Martin Scorsese 0, in terms of Oscars, and the group's elated acceptance speech prompted Stewart to proclaim "now that's how you accept an Oscar!". It's true that Three 6 Mafia were a brilliant antithesis to the stuffy, self-serious awards, and in honouring them the Academy perhaps inadvertently highlighted this. Since the group's win in 2006, Oscar has reverted to generally awarding the Best Original Song prize to bigger, brassier, more overtly serious fare, ensuring that Three 6's win feels all the more special - and all the more like an anomaly - in its own bling-and-baseball caps kinda way.

4. Having Only One Woman Win Best Director In Its Entire History

On a more serious note, it's absolutely staggering that in the Academy's near ninety-year history, only once has a woman director been named the best in her field, an peculiarity that occurred in 2009 when Kathryn Bigelow won Best Director for The Hurt Locker (which also won Best Picture, hence the two Oscars in her hand in the picture above). That's one woman out of the 69 directors (or directing teams) who have won the award. What's more, only four women have ever even been nominated for Best Director, starting with Lina Wertmellur in 1976 (for her Italian film, Seven Beauties), and getting to Bigelow by way of Jane Campion (The Piano, 1993), and, a decade later, Sofia Coppola (Lost in Translation, 2003). By the Academy's reckoning, in the near-entire history of cinema a woman has only directed a film worthy of being called the Best once, and has only been considered for that title four times, which, without beating around the bush, is pretty shameful. Of course, that doesn't mean that this notion (of women not being worthy directors) is even remotely true, but it does mean that the Academy is still hopelessly retrogressive in its beliefs, not to mention terribly passe as an organization.

3. And Then Not Even Nominating One Since

If Kathryn Bigelow's win was supposed to usher in a new, more progressive era of women directors being more regularly honoured by the Academy, then that supposition has been well and truly disavowed, to the point where not one single woman has even been nominated for Best Director since. Counting the Coens as one and including this year's nominees, there have been thirty Best Director nominations handed out since 2009. The Academy should've used Bigelow as the foundation, the springboard from which to progressively leap off. Instead, they have made Bigelow an anomaly, a pub-quiz trivia question instead of the example-setting example. There have been notable snubs since '09 (Bigelow again for Zero dark Thrity, Andrea Arnold for Fish Tank), but none more so than the refusal to nominate Ava DuVernay for Selma, which was nominated for Best Picture but not deemed worthy enough of a Best Director slot, which seemingly somehow went to Morten Tyldum for The Imitation Game instead (the other four nominees were pretty much locked).

2. James Franco's And Anne Hathaway's Hosting Gig

Best summed up by this great Tina Fey joke from her much more successful Golden Globes hosting gig (her first of three with Amy Poehler), James Franco's and Anne Hathaway's ceremony in 2011 is surely one of the worst in recent memory: a cringeworthy, searingly unfunny disaster in which Anne Hathaway tries her hardest and James Franco doesn't try at all, leading everyone to ask why the Academy even tried to make the pair work in the first place. An absolute abomination from the minute they both step out, the couple's lack of chemistry and/or comedic ability is evident as soon as the opening monologue, the thing by which all great Oscar hosts are chiefly judged, begins. I could go on, in sentences that would use words like humourless, woeful, embarrassing, supercilious (on Franco's part, anyway) and just plain old crap, but in this instance it really is better to just watch this absolute car-crash for yourself. You will wince; you have been warned: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82fIpQjOxmc

1. The Whole #OscarsSoWhite Debacle

Before the 2016 Academy Awards have even kicked off, this year's ceremony looks set to be an all-encompassing debacle. And, though #OscarsSoWhite is perhaps a reductive hashtag (because it suggests that the lack of diversity in populist cinema is the Academy's fault, rather than a much deeper-lying problem at the heart of Hollywood itself), it remains that it has become a powerful weapon against the Academy Awards and their glistening, unanimous whiteness. In a year that should've seen numerous nominations for black performers (most notably Michael B. Jordan for Creed), the Oscars again selected an all white nomination pool, ensuring that, in the last two years, there hasn't been a single actor of colour nominated in any of the four acting categories across the board. The Oscars are an alabaster 40-for-40. As a result of #OscarsSoWhite (which is surely the most successful ever hashtag, by the way), the Academy have vowed to fervently reassess their voting procedure, which can only be a good thing (though the Bigelow argument means we should take this with a pinch of white salt), but it remains that, no matter what the actual outcome of this year's awards, 2016 will forever be the year shrouded by white clouds.