10 Ways to Make an Awesome Terminator Sequel
Although many fans often get angry when they hear about reboots or sequels this many years later (just look at the negative response Star Wars Episode VII is getting) I for one miss the Terminator franchise and at this point couldn't care less if they reboot the thing or come out with the much rumored Terminator 5... you know, as long as they are good. As bad as the Star Wars prequels were (and they weren't all that terrible), they didn't have any effect in ruining the greatness of the originals- if anything, in comparison, they made those films even better.
I am perhaps one of a few people who didn't hate Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines or Terminator: Salvation... but those films were unarguably and quite considerably also the worst in the franchise. There were many, many reasons for this, and this following article explores what made the first two movies so great, what made the next two movies somewhat lackluster, and from this, 10 ways any future production company who may buy the rights to the franchise, and any writer and director should remember when making Terminator 5.
10. Don't Forget Time Travel
Terminator: Salvation wasn't quite Terminator because it missed out one of, in not THE most important element and selling point from the original movies... Time Travel. People love their Time Travel movies (Back to the Future, Looper, The Time Machine) and have done for years, so to not include any element of Time Travel in a film in the Terminator franchise is a massive mistake.
Although Terminator 5 should be heavily involved in exploring the war with the machines in the future (or now, our present), we still expect to see this idea explored somewhere in a sequel. My suggestion would be to split the narrative somewhat, with half of the film focused on John Conner, and half the film focused on a battle for survival in the past, with these stories intertwining somehow... but more on this later.
This idea of a time machine which enables people and machines in the future to send back warriors to protect or cause havoc in the past is ingrained in the Terminator franchise, and now that the series has stepped into this future we expect to see what these machines look like, how they were made, why they were made, and why they had to be destroyed. There is a lot of fun filmmakers can have with this idea of time travel (some ideas I will explore later) so to not include any element of this in Salvation was the biggest mistake of the film, and perhaps went someway into killing this franchise.
9. Split the Narrative
Terminator isn't a war movie and never should be... but this still doesn't mean we don't want to see the future machine and human war explored in great detail, and we would still very much like to see what has become of John Connor in the future. But Terminator: Salvation lost much of the charm of the original films because it was unrelatable to most people. It followed people in an apocalyptic future battling for survival, as opposed to people in a still very human world, battling against a villain that shouldn't exist in the current time-line.
A way to deal with this would be to split the narrative. My suggestion would be to have an adult, future John Connor witness a "Terminator" being sent back in time to destroy his past, and then witness this time machine be completely destroyed, giving him no way to chase after the machine. His half of this movie would focus on a battle through the war zone in order to find a way he can head back in time and prevent this machine from messing up his future.
Whereas the other half of this film would focus on some very human protagonists (more on my suggestions for these later) trying to survive, much like the first three films, an attack from this "Terminator". Although, unlike the second and third, in this film they will be without the help of a robot savior... and unlike the first film, no one from the future would be on their side. That said, to combine the narratives, I would later have John Connor find himself a time machine, head back to the past, and help save the humans from destruction.
8. Focus on Weak Humans Who Have To Become Strong
The reason the first film was so effective was because Sarah Connor started off the film just like us. She had no army training, she had no experience with guns, and she probably should have been easily killed by the Terminator. Although, with the help of Kyle Reese, we watched her slowly grow to the point that at the end of the film, though she wasn't the badass she is in Terminator 2, we could see she was becoming this empowered female hero we all know and love.
The second film could have suffered because its leads in this film: a good version of the Terminator from the original and a now incredibly strong and tough Sarah Connor were somewhat inhuman by this point. That is why James Cameron focused much of the point of view of the film from the young teenage John Connor, who was still very weak and needed protecting. Without this element, this film wouldn't have worked.
Terminator 3 practically copies the model of characters set up in Terminator 1 and this is the element from the film that is spot on. Terminator: Salvation mostly fails in this respect because of the apocalyptic world we spend our entire time in. Although Kyle Reese in Terminator: Salvation is still very much human and somewhat weak, he is still a warrior in this world. Sam Worthington's character may think he is human for much of the film, but as soon as we realise he is a robot, we don't so much worry for the fate of his character because he is super strong and therefore pretty much invincible (yes, he dies at the end, but no one really cared).
The films get this right when they are either focusing on characters that don't know what the hell is going on like Sarah Connor in the first film and Claire Danes in the third, or when they have strong characters trying to protect weak and innocent characters who can't really protect themselves like in all of the films except for Terminator: Salvation.
7. The Connor Family
The first two films were all about family. Sarah Connor in the first is told that her unborn and at this point not even conceived son will save humanity in the future. At this point in the franchise she hasn't yet found out her place in the world, and she is so young she couldn't even imagine having to be a mother, let alone a very good one, let alone perhaps the most important mother in the history of the human race.
This film explores this theme for the character until at the end, before she has even given birth to John Connor, she is that protective and loving mother. The second film explores the bond between mother and son, and even between robot and "son". Although the good Terminator in this movie isn't Johns father, he effectively takes this role. Family is a very important theme in the original two movies and much less so in the later movies.
The sequel (Terminator 5) should make family a very important theme once again. My suggestion would be to have a "Terminator" sent back in time to an unexplored area of time because of the knowledge of the previous Terminator's failed missions. I'd personally suggest sending the Terminator back to the 60's and have him/her attempt to kill Sarah Connor's parents. You could even possibly send the Terminator back further, in an attempt to kill one set of her grandparents, but the 60's would suit the Terminator franchise well, and offer a wonderful juxtaposition to the machine heavy future. Having said this, sending him back further to the 40's (Connor's Grandparents) could be interesting due to World War 2... although I think it's best to keep these genres separate.
For me, the 80's is such an important element of the first Terminator movie that such an iconic and visual decade such as the 60's would work just as well. Plus, wouldn't it be awesome to show Sarah Connor's mother and father as hippies, having to fight off this completely juxtaposed robot from the future killing them both... although either ones death would result in Sarah Connor not being born and therefore no John Connor. On the other side of things in the future, I would also show a more adult John Connor, raising kids of his own in this apocalyptic world for the future films to potentially deal with after 5.
6. Nod to the Past
A lot of us were excited about Terminator: Salvation before seeing the movie (which wasn't all that bad, just not all that great either) because of all the potential nods to the other films the film would have the privilege of included. Yes, the film did include quite a few, but there are so many important elements it would be awesome to show in the fifth movie.
I would love to see John Connor in the fifth send back Kyle Reese to save his mother in the first, perhaps as an opening scene before he witnesses another machine travel back to kill some earlier ancestors of his. It would also be awesome to see Robert Patrick's T-2 Terminator being sent back as well, or having John Connor come across an army of these Terminators in the future. We could also see how the first time machine is made and why it is made as well, because this is an element of these films that has been kept very much in the dark.
5. Recast John Conner
John Connor has been played by three different actors over the course of the franchise (four if you count the TV series) but none so far have been as good as Edward Furlong in Terminator 2. In an ideal world I would suggest recasting the original John Connor for the sequels, but Edward Furlong grew up a little strangely and isn't a good enough actor anymore to be able to pull off this role. Plus, physically, he doesn't look like the adult John Connor we imagined from the original film. Nick Stahl from Terminator 3 is a slightly better choice, but he has been having many personaly problems of late and again, probably isn't the right fit for John Connor anyway.
As much as the world loves Christian Bale, his portrayal of John Connor was without a doubt the worst acting performance I have ever seen Christian Bale give. There was absolutely no emotional depth or interest what so ever with this performance that I would go as far to say that Christian Bale, despite being the better actor of the three people who played John Connor, is the worst John Connor to date. Physically he may be better for the role, but I think he is just too famous for the part... never did I think he was the same John Connor from the other movies and that is a problem.
This is why I would suggest casting a virtually unknown actor in his 40's for the role of John Connor in the sequel, with younger actors in their 20's for the role of his grandparents (or who ever they end up being) in the future. I would also suggest casting an actor who looks at least a little like a grown up version of John Connor from Terminator 2. Although I'd probably prefer someone completely unknown in this role, an actor like Billy Crudup wouldn't be all that terrible.
4. Keep Arnold Schwarzenegger Away
OK, so this choice is somewhat against my original mission statement in working out what made the first two films as great as they were and the last two not so stellar because Arnie was a big part of what made the first two so memorable. But Arnold Schwarzenegger is too old for this franchise now, and any attempt to try to cover up his wrinkles in CGI is going to be too distracting.
Arnold Schwarzenegger also isn't that somewhat charming Austrian man from the 80's anymore... he is now that dumb Californian Republican governor who fathers mysterious illegitimate love children with his maid and writes tell all autobiographies. Arnold Schwarzenegger, despite said to be making an acting comeback in the next few years in roles such as Conan, and is said to be extremely interested in being in Terminator 5, is now too much of a parody of himself and comes with way too much baggage.
Plus, as much as I was looking forward to his "cameo" in Terminator: Salvation, that particular part of the movie was arguably the worst part, and could have easily done without it. It just made the whole movie seem tacky and cheesy. I think the franchise could very easily and very successfully live without Arnold Schwarzenegger... and personally I would prefer they keep any super muscled men out of any future roles as the Terminators. Robert Patrick was just as good a Terminator as Arnie was, and a much better actor to boot.
The only way I would be on board with Arnie returning to the franchise would be in a brief scene at the beginning of the film where John Connor witnesses Arnie being sent back by the machines to kill his mother.
3. Bring Back Linda Hamilton
This is a tricky suggestion, but I think, in the super futuristic world these movies live in there are probably many ways in which this could happen. Terminator 3 suggested that Sarah Connor died of cancer between Terminator 2 and Terminator 3... but we never see this scene, so maybe this was all a hoax, and John Connor could find her alive and well as an old women living in the apocalyptic future.
There could also be a possibility in which this film could explore that before she is able to die of the disease, the future John Connor... or perhaps his wife or even enemy in the film sends back someone to retrieve Sarah Connor and potentially cure her of her disease so she can live with the adult John Connor in the future... but having written all this out just now it does actually sound somewhat lame this way doesn't it? I am sure part of Sarah Connor was happy that she wasn't alive to see the war, though having said that I know she would also like her chance to kick some robot ass, so maybe this plan of retrieving her from the past isn't as lame as it sounds.
Potentially also, John Connor or again, someone working against him, could have a Sarah Connor "Terminator" made to either act as comfort and guidance for John, or she could even play the evil "Terminator" in the movie and could be the one who is sent back to the past to stop her human self from being born. I am not sure how I feel about this option... part of me would love to see Linda Hamilton play a dead eyed Terminating machine... though unless this was done right (and there is a 90% chance it wouldn't be) this could potentially make the viewer lose all respect they have for this actress and Sarah Connor as a character.
A better option to include Linda Hamilton (which I really think they should seeing as she carried the first two films and was the best thing about them) would be to do either one of three things. Firstly and most simply, include her in flashbacks exploring parts of her and John's life together we have yet to see.
Secondly, just like Helena Bonham Carter in Salvation, you could use Linda's face as the face of a computer program that could act as a sort of guide to John Connor throughout the films. But my favorite suggestion, and what I would do, is to cast Linda Hamilton as the mother of the young woman who will in the future give birth to Sarah Connor... therefore effectively have Linda Hamilton play Sarah Connor's grandmother.