10 Wild Ideas For The Perfect Suicide Squad 2

Task Force X 101: this is how to get it done, and get it done right this time.

By Jack Morrell /

Let’s get this out of the way: David Ayer’s divisive Suicide Squad movie is not, by any stretch of the imagination, a perfect movie - but neither is it the horrendous abyss of movie-making that some of its critics made it out to be.

Advertisement

When James Gunn was reported to have taken on writer/director responsibilities for the Suicide Squad sequel, one of the first rumours we heard was that the film would be titled The Suicide Squad, and would represent a complete reboot of the property.

Now, there are things that Ayer’s movie does well, and then there are things that don’t work at all - but regardless of your opinion of that film, it was a hit, or they wouldn’t be doing a sequel. It simply didn’t make any sense that Warner Bros would alienate everyone who saw the original and enjoyed it.

Fortunately, this proved not to be the case - Gunn’s film appears at this early stage to be a straight sequel, with plenty of the original actors reprising their roles. So what’s the best way forward for him from here? How can he improve on the first film, make a sequel that’s actually better than the original?

As The Suicide Squad revs into through pre-production to shoot in September, here’s the lowdown on the Suicide Squad: as a concept, as an intellectual property, and as a franchise and storytelling engine.

Pay attention, now. This is the instruction manual on how to make the perfect Suicide Squad movie.

10. The Suicide Squad Is Not A Superhero Team

Yes, it’s set in the DC universe mainstream continuity, sharing a universe with some of popular culture’s most iconic superheroes - but Suicide Squad is not a superhero property and never has been.

Advertisement

It’s not even a superhero movie that subverts the genre to incorporate tropes from another genre, like Logan did with the western or the upcoming New Mutants supposedly does with horror. It’s the other way around.

The Task Force X conceit revolves around the use of incarcerated supervillains - costumed criminals, some with powers, some without - as black ops agents for the United States government. Superheroes only appear here through association: there are cops in The Usual Suspects, but it’s not a cop movie.

Suicide Squad is an espionage concept: a political spy thriller that riffs on superhero tropes. While John Ostrander’s 1987-1992 run of the comic book occasionally incorporated magic and alien worlds, it was heavily grounded in realpolitik, realistic geopolitical structures and hard-nosed tradecraft.

There were stories detailing disastrous covert missions overseas; the different cultural imperatives that inform how foreign powers would view superpowered agents; the way in which politics at home would affect interagency intelligence work; the dynamics that are called into play when criminals are tasked with taking down terrorists.

If a Suicide Squad movie doesn’t begin with this fundamental premise, it’s not a Suicide Squad movie.

9. The Suicide Squad Are Not Half-Assed Amateurs

It’s understandable that David Ayer felt the need to have the first film act as the first mission for Task Force X: it’s movie-making 101 to have the introductory story be an origin story. It doesn’t really work here, however.

Advertisement

In order to overcome basic issues of suspension of disbelief that anyone in their right mind would try to herd these violent, unstable cats into undertaking even brute force intelligence work, you need to show it working like clockwork. You need to drop the audience into the story partway through: show them how a typical mission goes for Task Force X.

Typically, a Squad roster will comprise a core group of professionals backed up by a superpowered wild card or two. The professionals are men and women with experience pulling off successful operations (often, armed robberies and assassinations, but sometimes proper intelligence work) against high level, high value targets: they excel at what they do and have the attitude and competency that goes along with that.

In order to understand how the concept really works, you have to see it really working. The first movie dropped us into the Squad’s inaugural mission and had it immediately subverted, with Task Force X head Amanda Waller having put the team together to cover up her mistake in losing control of one of the original members of the Squad.

Why would anyone in Washington DC authorise a second mission after that fiasco?

8. The Suicide Squad Are Not Your Family

The 2016 movie has the field team trading snarky quips and getting closer, finally realising the mission’s true nature and collectively giving it a hard pass... only to have a dysfunctional bonding session in a bar and decide that they need to prove themselves, step up and go back to work.

Advertisement

But that’s not how the Suicice Squad concept operates. These people haven’t chosen to stand together. They’re violent criminals who’ve been conscripted to put their lives on the line by people that can’t be trusted; spooks who placed bombs in their heads and told them they don’t mean anything. They’re paranoid, resentful and angry.

They’re not family. They’re not friends. At best, they’re like cellmates: passive-aggressive bros that share cigarettes and call each other ‘homes’, but that wouldn’t cross the street to spit on each other if they were on fire. At worst, they hate each other.

That level of tension is what helps create the dramatic conflict: that barely concealed dislike and distrust is what keeps this loose alliance of scumbags and psychopaths alive when their handlers don’t care if they come home. They only person each of them can rely on is the one they see in the mirror.

You know what the 2016 movie gets right? When Boomerang persuades Slipknot to rabbit in order to verify whether the nanobombs in their necks are real and callously watches Flag blow his head off. That’s the Suicide Squad.

7. The Suicide Squad Aren’t All Villains

Having said all that, historically the Squad hasn’t always featured out-and-out villains. The comics have frequently had superheroes and vigilantes volunteer to work with Task Force X: characters like superspies Nightshade and Nemesis, the superhero Vixen, former assassin Bronze Tiger and extradimensional fugitive Rac Shade.

Advertisement

Needing government resources or intelligence for their own reasons, and working with the Suicide Squad as payment for those services, their job is to keep the criminal element in line and on mission - although their participation is voluntary and it’s made clear that Amanda Waller barely trusts them any more than she does the bad guys with bombs in their heads.

Without that useful dynamic, it doesn’t matter how alpha male Rick Flag is, or how scared they are of those bombs - at some point, the criminal element are going to make a play for freedom.

For storytelling purposes, it also means that you get to give the audience relatable, humanised characters to root for, allowing that criminal element to remain their gloriously sociopathic selves - compelling ciphers to mount plot points and set-pieces around.

This is something Ayer’s movie pays lip service to with the addition of Katana to the team as Flag’s bodyguard, and it’s something any sequel should lean into hard, as a vital part of the story.

6. The Suicide Squad Is The Amanda Waller Show

Viola Davis was fantastic as the founder of Task Force X, Amanda Waller, in the 2016 movie, and it’s currently understood that she’s been tapped for Gunn’s sequel, too. This is excellent news: because when it comes to the Suicide Squad, Waller is the star of the show.

Advertisement

A strong (often headstrong) and powerful middle-aged woman of colour in a field historically populated by white men, Waller is an anomaly in US intelligence circles. A former congressional aide who saw her opportunity to increase her political profile by pioneering the Task Force X concept, she’s made director of the programme under sufferance yet proves to be more than smart enough (and ruthless enough) to run the Squad… although she rarely plays by anyone else’s rules.

There are very few characters like this in movies, and none in comics, even thirty years after her creation. Throughout almost every incarnation of the Suicide Squad, Amander Waller - nicknamed ‘The Wall’ - has been the linchpin of the team, the vital cog that makes the machine work. She even memorably faced down the Batman himself, armed with nothing but a bad attitude.

Fundamentally, any Suicide Squad sequel that doesn’t feature Viola Davis front and centre as Amanda Waller doesn’t know what it’s doing.

5. The Suicide Squad Needs The Bronze Tiger

The current rumour is that Idris Elba, originally cast to replace Will Smith as Deadshot, may now have been retasked to play the Bronze Tiger in Gunn’s Suicide Squad sequel.

Advertisement

Now, there are plenty of incarnations of the Squad that haven’t featured former assassin Ben Turner, codenamed the Bronze Tiger - but arguably the best and most critically acclaimed iteration had the character in a prominent role throughout its entire run.

Waller’s original choice for field leader of the Squad, Turner was passed over for Flag by her superiors, creating the first little sliver of resentment on her part. Amanda believed it to be racially motivated, whereas Turner himself suspected that it was his past as a brainwashed member of Ra’s Al Ghul’s League Of Assassins that lost him the gig.

Whatever the case, the deprogrammed Tiger became one of Waller’s most valuable field agents: a good man who believed he owed her his soul and helped to act as her conscience when her worst instincts got the better of her.

That dynamic is storytelling gold, and having a non-sexual relationship between two people of colour in such central focus is exactly the kind of representation that Hollywood should be all about in the 21st century.

4. The Suicide Squad Does Not Need Harley Quinn

Unfortunately, another casting rumour indicates that Margot Robbie will be back in Task Force X as the cheerfully loopy Harley Quinn, the Joker’s (former?) main squeeze.

Advertisement

It’s true that Robbie was fantastic in the role in Ayer’s Suicide Squad, despite the cheesecake clothes, and the character is due to front the Birds Of Prey movie next February, a flick which is already getting phenomenal word of mouth despite still being in post-production.

With Harley rotating towards being more of an anti-hero than an out-and-out villain, it makes little sense to have her return to the fold in the Suicide Squad. Indeed, it makes little sense to have her on the team regardless of whether she’s reformed.

Harley Quinn is a loose cannon: a mentally unstable psychiatrist-turned-gangster. Her value as a field agent for the Squad has always been questionable - what can she do that a special forces soldier can’t do better? - and she’s far more likely to be a horrendous liability, go off the reservation and do her own thing rather than stick to the mission.

Not only that, but she’s loud, brash and multi-coloured from top to toe - hardly covert operation material even if she can keep it together and hold to the plan. No, the Suicide Squad doesn’t need Harley Quinn... but there are any number of female badasses (with powers! or specialist weapons!) who could easily replace her (Duchess, Vixen, Nightshade, Killer Frost, to name only a few).

3. The Suicide Squad Needs A Supporting Cast

Ostrander’s iteration of the Suicide Squad incorporated supporting cast characters to interact with the colourful core cast: the employees of the prison, Belle Reve in Louisiana, that functioned as the Squad’s de facto base of operations.

Advertisement

As mentioned before, the 2016 movie chose to give the conscripted members of the Squad redeeming features and saving graces to make this bunch of career criminals and homicidal recidivists more relatable to the audience at home.

On a storytelling level, transferring that relatability to human/civilian characters in a supporting role allows you to retain the villainous qualities to your villains that made them compelling characters or ciphers in the first place.

It also allows you to create new relationships and interpersonal conflicts that don’t require the various members of your Squad roster to bond and ‘share moments’. This then frees said Squad members to have other, more interesting and arguably more realistic interactions with one another, both at home and in the field.

Examples of character filling these roles from the comics include psychiatrists Simon LaGrieve and Marnie Herrs, or the paternal prison chaplain Father Richard Craemer. As an example, the latter had a memorable encounter with Deadshot in the comics that featured the two of them walking the streets of Gotham and talking about Lawton’s violent past, as the padre tried to talk the unstable hitman out of embarking upon a killing spree.

2. The Suicide Squad Needs A New Deadshot

Currently, scuttlebutt (like gossip with wrist-mounted Magnums) is that Deadshot won’t now be back in James Gunn’s upcoming Suicide Squad sequel. The rumour is that Will Smith has a scheduling conflict preventing him from reprising the role, and that the powers that be have decided not to recast, but to simply omit Deadshot from the film to allow Smith to return at a future date.

Advertisement

The thing is, Floyd Lawton is a vital part of the make-up of the Suicide Squad, and has been in pretty much every iteration of the team since its revival in the 1980s. His nihilistic, laconic perspective and latent death wish also perfectly embody the vibe and ethos of the Suicide Squad as a high concept and an intellectual property.

Now, you might be reading that and thinking that this doesn’t sound like the Deadshot from the 2016 movie… and you’d be right. Will Smith was never suitable casting for the character. The part was clearly rewritten beyond all recognition to accommodate the only genuine movie star in the cast - hence why you get Lawton constantly cracking wise and spending most of the movie without his headgear on.

Just to make this crystal clear: it’s nothing to do with race. There are plenty of black actors who could and would play Lawton as he is in the comic books (Jamie Foxx, Michael B. Jordan or Ricky Whittle, for example) and the part should definitely be recast. The Squad needs Deadshot, not the Fresh Prince with a hangover.

1. The Suicide Squad Needs To Be Shut Down

Bit of a red herring in the header, there - no one’s suggesting that the movie ceases production, or that Task Force X itself should be disbanded. But the threat of being shut down constantly hangs over the Suicide Squad like the sword of Damocles, and it’s caused some of the richest storylines in the Squad’s history over the years.

Advertisement

Firstly, there was the uneasy alliance between Senator Cray and the Squad’s UNSC liaison, Derek Tolliver, to blackmail Waller into helping Cray get reelected. Waller had her own blackmail material ready to go, but neglected to inform Flag, who took it upon himself to go black ops on US politicians to protect the Squad, with tragic consequences.

Then there was the intervention of the Dark Knight himself. In one of the standout stories from Ostrander’s standout run, when Batman found out that a US government initiative was putting superpowered criminals back on the streets, he infiltrated Belle Reve to put a stop to the Squad, confronting them on their home turf.

Or there's the appointment of Waller’s replacement as director, revealed to be an actor paid by Waller to pretend to take her place while she continued to run the Squad from behind the scenes. When the Squad's next target exposed her ruse to the American public, Waller was on borrowed time, personally taking the Squad on one last ditch assassination mission to take out all of her enemies once and for all...

Advertisement