Batman films have been some serious bank for Warner Brothers since 1989, when Tim Burton breathed a bit of darkness into the character that had mainly been associated with the pop-art parody of Bill Doziers 1960s TV series. And since then we have seen seven movies from three different film makers, ecompassing a myriad of actors portraying a mini universe of different characters. During this time there have been some career defining performances that captured the tone of the source material, and elevated the vision of their director. The most obvious of these would be the two contrasting, yet equally ground breaking Joker depictions from Jack Nicholson and Heath Ledger. But it is fair to say that actors like Christian Bale and Michelle Pfeiffer created iconic depictions of their characters too, and particularly in Nolans films, there has been an ocean of strong supporting actors. Unfortunately though we have also seen some pretty woeful performances as well. Sometimes its simply a case of movie economics if one thing works in one film, then you simply take that same thing and make it even louder in the sequel, even if it doesnt make sense or is to the detriment of the overall product. Other times though, its simply a case of miscasting an actor, and making them swim in a pool that is well out of their depth. So here we present to you, not the best of the performances we have seen in the last seven Batman movies, but the worst performances. These are the ones that make you roll your eyes, grit your teeth, leave you confounded, and make you pine for hypothetical lost opportunities that could have been
Advertisement
10. Tom Hardy Bane (The Dark Knight Rises)
This is difficult because its less that the performance itself that is the problem, than how it is executed. Tom Hardy is an undeniable badass presence as Bane and his fight scenes with Christian Bales Dark Knight are the best in all of the Batman films. However, as much as this dead horse has been beaten, it needs to be re-iterated Hardys dialogue is really difficult to understand and to absorb. The accent that he adopts is kind of cool and different, but thats also the problem it feels like its different for the sake of being different. When you then place a mask on top of this it really makes things tough because half of how we understand what people says comes from reading their lips as we hear the words. When you take that away our feeble monkey brains can become stumped. Hardys performance seems like it was probably amazing on paper, and probably seemed amazing on set at the time when everyone had a script and could read along. However for the laypeople in the cinema, it was just unnecessarily difficult, even with all the work they did in post-production to clean it up and make it sound better. It was disappointing because it detracted from what was a spectacular film and left the audience talking about minor details rather than the film as a whole.
9. Andrew Bryniarski Chip Shreck (Batman Returns)
Its almost a credit to Bryniarski that despite only having a few lines in Batman Returns, he made such an impact that he is able to crack the top ten worst performances in a Batman film. But were sure its probably not something hed be rapturous with. Bryniarski makes this list because even though he had only a few lines in the film, he managed to deliver those lines with what can only be described as the third worst Christopher Walken impersonation of all time. Yes we understand that he was playing Walkens son but does that mean that by default he would have all his voice mannerisms and inflections? Hardly. This performance was like a bad Saturday Night Live sketch, and pretty much all Saturday Night Live sketches are bad, so thats saying something.
8. Anthony Michael Hall Mike Engel (The Dark Knight)
Okay, so this one is probably less about the performance itself than the casting, which admittedly is very dickish. But hey, Cest la vie. Mike Engel is a news caster who is overly serious to the point of parody. His moral stance against Batman is reminiscent of a blowhard from Fox News, and his soap boxing is infuriating. As a character this isnt actually a bad idea, and its this attention to detailed characterisation that sets Nolans Gotham apart from Burton and Schumachers versions. But Anthony Michael Hall? Really? He seems like hes probably an okay guy, but he just doesnt really have the chops for this part. Or maybe he does, but its just impossible to see past the little kid in Sixteen Candles who talked Molly Ringwald into giving him her panties.
7. Tracey Walter Bob The Goon (Batman)
How Tracey Walter, a bit part character actor who is essentially a glorified extra, got so much screen time in one of the biggest movies ever is simply inexplicable. Walter was in this movie so much that he managed to earn his own action figure, and this is all despite Walter having the range of something like a radish, and acting about as threatening as a senior citizen with a broken hip. All throughout the film Walter doesnt really appear to be trying all that much. He is so vacant that when he is shot by the Joker despite his undying loyalty, it provokes nothing more than a giggle or a shoulder shrug - when we should really be moved and horrified by just how cold and psychopathic the Joker really is. Maybe the apathy towards the role is part of his charm, but it seems more like a case of miscasting the character, and hoping for the best.
6. Katie Holmes Rachel Dawes (Batman Begins)
This is a performance that simply hasnt aged well. Because the character of Rachel Dawes got such a meatier role in the second of Nolans films, and because they cast the always brilliant Maggie Gyllenhaal to take on this more substantial character, it really makes Holmes depiction look timid and weak in comparison. Inevitably then, Katie Homes is admittedly a bit of a soft target for this kind of list. But in saying all that, while she does try with the material, it seems she is well and truly miscast in this world. Its frankly a bit hard to take her seriously because she looks like she is about 22 playing lawyer with her friends, and when she is meant to be a no-nonsense attorney she seems more petulant than bold. It also is almost impossible to understand why it is that her and Bruce are supposed to be attracted to each other the chemistry is almost non-existent and as far as we can tell their romance is simply built off being friends as children (although Bale is as much to blame in that regard as she is). It would have been interesting to see how Holmes handled the new material in the second film, and whether or not this would have made her performance in the first flick look like part of an ongoing character development. Unfortunately for her well never know this, and shes going to have to put up with years of keyboard warriors (like this scribe) comparing her to someone she didnt know shed be in competition with. Regardless of the criticisms though she is still a far more rounded and realistic female character than the next entry
5. Nicole Kidman Dr Chase Meridian (Batman Forever)
Based off how Kidman performs this character its really kind of difficult to decipher whether or not she is actually supposed to be a sympathetic character, or an antagonist. She is allegedly a brilliant Doctor, yet Kidman delivers every line either passive aggressively to Bruce (indicating she is really just a bit of b*tch) or like a school girl with a crush to Batman (because women are obviously either b*tchy or gooey with no in between). There is supposed to be sexual chemistry here, but she is overacting and over channelling the flirtation so brutally that it would make Marilyn Monroe blush. In Kidmans defence, the hackiest of all Hollywood hacks Akiva Goldsman was in charge of shaping her character, so its no wonder that it is an absolutely woeful role with lines that make you want to punch yourself in the face for having listened to. But still this is Nicole Kidman, one of the finest actors in recent Hollywood memory. She can do better than this train wreck of a performance.
4. Tommy Lee Jones Two Face/Harvey Dent (Batman Forever)
Oh boy. Where to begin with this one? A lot of people point to Jim Carrey as being the poorer villain in this film, but thats not totally fair. At least Carrey had an idea behind what he was doing he was channelling Frank Gorshin. And besides, in 1995 people employed Carrey for one reason, and that was to be a rubber faced clown. In that regard he delivered, so its difficult to be upset. But Tommy Lee Joneswow. Justwow. Jones is one of the finest actors Hollywood has produced in the time that Hollywood has been a thing. Sadly though for this role, here he took a page out of the Jack Nicholson Joker book and decided to ham it up and turn his performance up to about 17. Admittedly hes not the only one guilty of this (as well see shortly), but he really should have learned from the mistakes of others and given the role a bit of nuance. The biggest problem aside from the fact that he goes absolutely bananas during 98% of the scenes he is in, is that he forgets that his character is supposed to be one of duality. Two Face is one part of the character, and the other is Harvey Dent. Yet it seemed that as soon as they buried his face under gaudy prosthesis Jones could just see the fat dollar signs earned by Nicholsons joker, and figured that his character was just the same thing. He then decided to mimic Nicholsons manic craziness when theyre two completely different characters. Its painful, its exhausting, and more importantly it is a wasted opportunity for one of the finest thespians of our era, to tackle one of the great comic book villains of all time.
3. Chris ODonnell Robin/Dick Grayson (Batman Forever)
Well everybody knew this one was coming. Much has already been written and said about the fact that Chris ODonnell is far, far, far too old to be playing the character of Robin in this film, but lets rehash anyway. Dick Grayson is meant to be Bruce Waynes ward, who he takes under his wing because Grayson is too young to live on his own. Chris ODonnell seems to be about thirty here, so it makes him less a sympathetic hero, than it does a guy that is going through a severe case of arrested development, who is nowhere near as rebellious as he thinks. However its not simply an age thing its an attitude thing as well. Chris ODonnell is a nice guy, who looks nice, talks nice, and just radiates nice. Urban dictionary should just have a link to his IMDB profile when you type in the word nice. But here he is confusingly trying to play a badass and it just doesnt work. When he is supposed to be cool he just seems like a juvenile dimwit. When he is supposed to be funny, it makes us groan. And when we are supposed to empathise with him and become emotionally invested in his journey, he comes off as an ungrateful free loader. The casting is wrong admittedly, but the performance leaves a lot to be desired. It doesnt help that he is woefully unprepared for crime fighting and does things like dry his laundry using Kung-Fu. But thats probably an issue for a different article entirely.
2. Danny DeVito The Penguin/Oswald Cobblepot (Batman Returns)
As said earlier, when Tommy Lee Jones ramped up the intensity of his performance in Batman Forever it was irritating. However, if Jones pushed his performance to the edge, DeVito actively went over the cliff, landed in a pit of broken glass, climbed back up the cliff, and dived off again. For some reason people think of Batman Returns as being a grounded film - but you only have to look at DeVitos turn as the penguin to get a sense of just how campy a film it is. DeVito is absolutely vile in the film. His voice is like gravel, his mannerisms are sickening, and in general he is absolutely nothing like the character he is supposed to be. Everything about this performance is pantomime and melodrama, and this makes it impossible to sympathise or empathise with Cobblepot because there is not a shred of humanity or subtlety in the character. It is obvious that like Jones, he was blinded by Nicholsons turn as the Joker, but even a fleeting few seconds of research or discussion would have made him realise that they are in fact different characters, and not all villains have to be this cartoonish. Burton is obviously to blame as well in this case, but as someone who should understand the nuances of characterisation, DeVito really dropped the ball on this one, and arguably tainted the character of the Penguin so badly that it has never been considered again even though the Penguin would arguably be the easiest character to do.
1. Everyone Everyone (Batman And Robin)
No doubt you will have noticed by now that this list has not featured any performances from the 1997 abomination Batman and Robin. But there is good reason for this the article is only about the ten worst performances in Batman films, and the performances in Batman and Robin could warrant an entire list on their own. Nobody in this horrific film is really worse than the other, so we've put them all at number one, since quite frankly, they are all atrocious. Arnold Schwarzenegger - Mr Freeze. The decision to cast Arnie was mind blowing. Aside from the fact that the original Mr Freeze is not an Austrian Goliath, Arnie does not have the skillset to do justice to the beautiful Heart of Ice storyline that clearly inspired this awful rendition of an amazing character. Uma Thurman - Poison Ivy. This rendition by Thurman makes Nicole Kidmans performance in Batman Forever look as good as Nicole Kidmans performance in The Hours. George Clooney Batman/Bruce Wayne. Some people might argue that it was a bold and innovative idea by Clooney to do no acting whatsoever when taking on this role. Some people would be wrong. Chris ODonnell Robin/Dick Grayson. If you think he was an immature brat in Forever, wait until you see how petulant a thirty year old man can be in this film. Alicia Silverstone Batgirl/Barbara Gordon. Its hard to find a sympathetic character less likeable and more juvenile than ODonnells Robin. But Silverstone absolutely nails this achievement. Robert Swenson Bane. If you gave a small child a Bane action figure and they played with it, it would be exactly the same as Swensons performance right down to the sound he makes when he is growling. Elle Macpherson Julie Madison. The best proof we currently have that supermodels should never try and act. John Glover Dr Jason Woodrue. He is so cartoonish and so ridiculous that as viewers we are happy to see Thurmans awful Poison Ivy destroy him. Vivica A Fox Ms. B Haven. You cant do much if this is your characters name and your role is to flirt with a bald, blue Arnold Schwarzenegger. But Foxs ongoing flirtations with Freeze will still make you want to vomit with discomfort. Elizabeth Sanders Gossip Gerty. This is why family members (in this case Sanders is Bob Kanes wife) should not just get access to film roles by default.