Before the success of Paranormal Activity made found-footage horror the next "big thing" in fright flicks, Hollywood's go-to place for ideas was eastern Asia. Following the 2002 smash hit The Ring, based on Hideo Nakata's 1998 Japanese success Ring, no fewer than 10 additional wide release American features based on Asian horror films were released up through 2009, with four in 2008 alone. Some - The Grudge, mainly, and The Ring Two to a lesser extent - were big hits, while others like Pulse disappointed at the box office. With critical reception no better than any other horror subgenre (2008's One Missed Call remake got a pitiful 0% on RottenTomatoes) and dwindling consumer interest, the fad died off after the early 2009 release of The Uninvited.
Although it's not totally over - the Japanese film Apartment 1303 has a 3D remake coming to limited release and on-demand services this summer - this period ended before many other interesting offerings from the region got the chance to be redone for Western audiences.
Advertisement
Here are ten Asian thrillers worth a look that, for better or worse, were never given a Hollywood do-over...
10. Nightmare
Advertisement
Year: 2000 Country: South Korea Director: Byeong-Ki Ahn Byeong-Ki Ahn is a prolific South Korean horror director (you'll see him again later in the article), and this is his earliest feature film. The story is a sort of cross between Ring and I Know What You Did Last Summer, in which a bunch of old friends from school reunite when the vengeful ghost of a former accomplice begins to kill them off one by one. The non-linear narrative is told as a series of nested flashbacks, with the necessary twists and turns and revelations all along the way. This can make it hard to follow for some viewers on a first watch. Nightmare is admittedly not the best-made film, as Ahn makes a few typical first-feature mistakes. But the scares are usually fairly effective, with the killer ghost popping up in all sorts of interesting places, and the wild, constantly-evolving story can be quite engaging and surprising. It's also pretty fast-paced compared to many horror films from the region, which helps stave off any chance of boredom.
9. Suicide Club
Advertisement
Year: 2001 Country: Japan Director: Shion Sono Suicide Club has a complex narrative that begins with 54 cheery schoolgirls joining hands and jumping in front of a moving train in a mass suicide. A bag is left at the scene containing a roll of human skin, and a dot appears on a mysterious website for each girl killed in the event. The police spring into action trying to find the explanation for the seemingly ritualistic group suicide and uncover the secrets of the website. Meanwhile, a rash of suicides springs up across Japan, some counted by the website, others not. The investigation becomes ever more convoluted and hopeless as more and more people end their own lives and more bizarre leads turn up by the minute. Part detective thriller, part gory horror flick, and part pitch-black comedy, Suicide Club is above all a powerful social critique. It examines consumerism, conformity, and the nature of individualism in an over-the-top, brutal manner. It's by far the most convoluted and cerebral film on this list, and probably also the most controversial. Some (myself included) think it's a very solid, layered work, while others find it sloppy or irresponsible in the delivery of its message. Others miss the point entirely and see it as nothing more than a sick slaughterfest. No matter what your reaction, though, it's unlikely you'll forget it once you've seen it.
8. Phone
Advertisement
Year: 2002 Country: South Korea Director: Byeong-Ki Ahn Not to be confused with the Japanese One Missed Call franchise (which did spawn an American version), Phone is Byeong-Ki Ahn's better-crafted followup effort to Gawi. Like that film, this one takes a central element from a well-known American horror film (in this case, the possessed little girl from The Exorcist) and merges it with traditional Asian ghost story tropes to create a surprisingly effective synthesis. Investigative journalist Ji-Won is trying to escape a stalker connected with a pedophilia case she uncovered, so she moves into a rich friend's uninhabited house and changes her phone number. But she starts to experience odd visions in the house and get strange calls on the phone. When her friend's daughter, Young-Ju, answers Ji-Won's phone, she becomes possessed. Meanwhile, Ji-Won discovers the last few people who had her phone number all died mysteriously. She attempts to get to the bottom of the cursed phone number's mystery in order to save herself and Young-Ju. Much of Phone is a standard-issue Ring emulation, but it's very stylish and well made, making particularly good use of Beethoven's Moonlight Sonata. The real standout, though, is little Seo-Woo Eun's performance as the possessed girl Young-Ju. She's frightening and intense, giving Linda Blair a real run for her money. An American Phone remake directed by Byeong-Ki Ahn himself was announced in 2004, and continuously delayed until settling on an early 2010 shooting date. We're now three years past the proposed shooting date with no new information - a sure sign the project's been condemned to development hell or quietly abandoned.
7. Acacia
Advertisement
Year: 2003 Country: South Korea Director: Ki-Hyeong Park Ki-Hyeong Park wasn't new to the horror genre when he made this film; he'd had a considerable hit in 1998 with his film Whispering Corridors, which spawned a five-film franchise. That film was a ghost story set in a high school, but was just as focused on critiquing South Korea's infamously harsh education system as it was on delivering supernatural scares. For his next horror film, Acacia, Park chose to tackle another social problem: the state of adopted children, especially in his home country. The movie concerns a wife and husband who want a child but cannot conceive. They take in a young boy named Jin-Sung who is artistically talented and has a strange fascination with insects and trees. Someone once told him his birth mother had been reincarnated as a tree after her death, and upon moving in with his new family he latches onto the idea that the dead old acacia tree in the backyard is actually his mother. But when his new parents miraculously have a baby of their own, Jin-Sung becomes jealous and begins acting out, before finally disappearing entirely one night. After he vanishes, the acacia tree somehow comes back to life... Acacia is deliberately paced and has a heavier focus on atmosphere and human drama than sudden shocks. That's not to say it isn't scary - a handful of scenes are quite frightening and a palpable air of dread hangs over the whole film - but it's not a shock-a-minute rollercoaster ride. Instead, it's a carefully-crafted thriller/mystery with beautiful music, luscious cinematography, and some excellent editing (especially in the climax). The overall tone is not one of utter terror but of haunting, dark beauty and sadness.
6. Marebito
Advertisement
Year: 2004 Country: Japan Director: Takashi Shimizu Shot by Shimizu in a matter of days between filming for two entries in his more famous horror franchise - Ju-On: The Grudge 2 and the first American installment The Grudge - Marebito is an almost unclassifiable experience. It's totally, vastly different from his famous money-making series in the best way possible. The film follows a freelance cameraman who films a man's suicide in a subway station and becomes obsessed with the nature of fear and discovering what it is that drove the man to kill himself. He ventures beneath Tokyo's subway tunnels and discovers a whole other world, bringing back a starving humanoid girl he finds in chains. This decision drives our protagonist deeper and deeper into his dark and insane obsessions as he struggles to keep her alive. Teeming with references to classic literature and urban legends, Marebito is every bit as insane as its main character. It's never entirely clear exactly what is going on, even at the end - multiple and equally valid possibilities are presented. But it doesn't matter, because despite its microscopic budget and rushed nature, Marebito is positively chilling and deeply disturbing. Out of all the movies listed here, this is the one that's stuck with me the most - and the only one that still gives me chills just thinking about it.
5. Infection
Advertisement
Year: 2004 Country: Japan Director: Masayuki Ochiai Masayuki Ochiai is probably most recognizable to Western audiences as the director of the dreadful American remake of Shutter, but before he was handed that unfortunate assignment he helmed this disgustingly effective chiller in his home country. The plot concerns a run-down hospital that's overcrowded, low on supplies, and saddled with unskilled workers. After a mistake by one of the doctors kills a patient, the staff decide to try and save their jobs by covering it up. Meanwhile, a patient with an unidentified, rapidly-spreading disease that is liquefying his organs is left in the hospital by a desperate ambulance driver who can't find anywhere willing to accept him. The doctors decide to examine the subject in hopes of getting rich and famous on their discovery, but his body disappears and the infection begins spreading amongst the staff, along with some seemingly ghostly happenings. Infection is not for the squeamish, but it's a tense, dour, and effective horror film about flawed individuals facing overpowering forces both mundane and supernatural. The combination of a medical drama, a killer disease thriller, and a supernatural horror flick is quite compelling. While the ending is a head-scratcher - moreso than usual for these kinds of movies, even - the journey is worth taking for anyone with a strong enough stomach.
4. Voice
Advertisement
Year: 2005 Country: South Korea Director: Equan Choi
Voice is the fourth in the unconnected Whispering Corridors series of Korean horror films, with a title literally translated as Girl's High School Horror 4: Voice. Like the other films in the franchise, it's set at an all-girls high school and involves some ghostly goings-on but does not follow the story of any other film. This particular installment is about Young-Eon, a dedicated music student who is killed by a ghost in her school. She comes back as one herself, but she is invisible - and only her best friend Seon-Min and the weird loner girl Cho-Ah can hear her. Furthermore, she cannot leave the school building, and her memory is fractured and unreliable. The story predictably moves into an investigation of the ghost who killed her in the first place, but surprisingly that's not the movie's only main focus. At its core, Voice is a film about the grieving process. Seon-Min can only hear Young-Eon's voice because of the strong emotional attachment she still has to her dead friend. Even as the mystery behind the other ghost unfolds, the true main conflict is Seon-Min's internal struggle with her friend's death and her decision on whether to let her go or cling to her last remnants in the mortal world. Although it's sold in America with a hilariously inaccurate DVD cover showing bloody hands clawing their way out of a screaming mouth, Voice is far from a shocking gore-fest. It's not even really scary, and there are only a handful of scenes where it actually tries to be. However, its intriguing mystery elements and surprising emotional depth make it well worth a watch.
Advertisement
3. Cello
Advertisement
Year: 2005 Country: South Korea Director: Woo-Cheol Lee
Unlike many of the films in this article which were understandably not remade since they didn't fit the standard of Ring-inspired Asian horror movies, Cello is a perfect cousin to that film and its many imitators (or, less charitably, a rip-off). There's a long-haired ghost girl, spooky haunted recordings, a creepy little kid, a big final twist, and all the other tropes associated with the subgenre. But that doesn't mean it should be counted out immediately; it's actually a pretty well-done example of the format. The story is about Mi-Ju, a part-time cello instructor whose life is falling apart. In addition to the stress of raising a family which includes a mentally-handicapped daughter, she has a spiteful former student stalking her, a creepy new maid with a tragic past, and she's getting mysterious text messages. Things only get worse and worse, building to deaths, ghostly encounters, and the revelation of a dark secret in her past. The movie is capably-made and manages to have a decent selection of effective scares, despite its obvious similarities to earlier films. If anything makes the movie stand out, it has to be how utterly cruel the ghost is to Mi-Ju - the events in this film go far beyond creepy nightmares and a curse that will kill her in so many days. It's not a bold new direction for horror, but if you liked Ring and its ilk and are interested in seeing more like it, Cello is easily worth a look.
Advertisement
2. Reincarnation
Advertisement
Year: 2005 Country: Japan Director: Takashi Shimizu
Another entry from Grudge director Takashi Shimizu, this one is considerably more conventional than Marebito but still a welcome change from his most famous franchise. Reincarnation tells the story of an actress, Nagisa, who lands a part in a new horror film based on the true story (in the film universe, not reality) of a mass murder at a hotel. She is plagued by ghostly visions of the murder victims, which only get worse when the cast and crew visit the real hotel and build an exact replica to film on. She even seems to remember things she should have no way of knowing... The title obviously gives away one of the key plot elements, but there are still more surprises and twists to come. Reincarnation has some effective scares - anyone freaked out by creepy dolls will be especially traumatized - and is rather intelligently-written, which is a nice departure from the often haphazardly-plotted Grudge / Ju-On films. It's well-made and just different enough to stand out from the pack of overly-similar Ring cash-ins that tend to get a lot of attention (especially from American studios).
Thailand isn't considered an A-List country for Asian horror by Hollywood, with only one big American remake to its name (2008's Shutter, which was confusingly set in Japan and directed by a Japanese man). But The Victim is a strong entry into the subgenre that's well worth checking out. The story is about Ting, an aspiring young actress who lands a job working in re-enactments of violent crimes staged by the police for the media (a real practice in Thailand). She is good enough at her job that the spirits of the real victims take notice. When she is entrusted with the role of Meen, a supermodel who was apparently murdered by a scorned lover, she thinks of it as her big break - but Meen's ghost is haunting her, desperately trying to help her uncover the real truth behind her death. The Victim is effectively scary in places, and actually even has some satisfying comedic elements in the beginning. It's fast-paced and never boring. But the real reason to watch it is for its great, jaw-dropping twist. I won't dare reveal it here as it's something that really needs to be experienced, but it's easily the best I've seen in a long time. The rest of the movie doesn't really quite live up to that element, but it's still an enjoyable horror romp with a very memorable revelation.