11 Directors Who Won Oscars For Completely The Wrong Movie

Yes they won, but they could have won better.

By Simon Gallagher /

Summit Entertainment

If you listen hard enough at any given point during the year, you can probably hear The Academy either getting something wrong or preparing to. It now seems to be part of the Oscar culture - for the panel apparently entrusted as the Most Important People in Hollywood to throw in a couple of curveballs and a couple of fouls every time they unveil the annual crop of Oscar contenders.

Advertisement

Hell, it wouldn't be Oscar season without some good old-fashioned pitch-fork wielding.

But arguably worse than those mistakes that leave worthy winners snubbed or not even nominated are the ones you're not really allowed to complain about. Nobody in their right mind is going to stand up in front of everyone they've just beaten to an Oscar to complain that they probably should have actually won it for something else entirely. That'd just be ungrateful.

Advertisement

It happens, though, and both actors and directors have to live with the knowledge that their BEST work wasn't rightly acknowledged. That's a hell of a caveat to have to add to one of the greatest days of your entire career, and while it might seem trivial, it's got to be a background frustration...

11. Mel Gibson

Icon Productions

Won For... Braveheart

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Hacksaw Ridge

Of all of the films about Scottish independence and William Wallace, Mel Gibson's Braveheart is probably the best. Even though it takes considerable liberties with the historical facts of the time and features some fairly wishy-washy Scottish accents.

Advertisement

It has a knack for getting under your skin so you really feel its patriotic message even if you're not Scottish, and makes you hate the English even if you are one. It's not Gibson's best film though, and it certainly doesn't deserve to be recognised officially as such.

Both Apocalyptico and Hacksaw Ridge are better directed films, with the former's bravery of particular note. But it's 2017's war epic that really deserves the nod as Gibson's best effort, even with problematic swirls in the air around him: it's an achievement in film that actually learned from Braveheart, so it should rightly be considered a progression from it.

Advertisement

10. Billy Wilder

United Artists

Won For... The Lost Weekend & The Apartment

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Some Like It Hot

Nobody in their right mind would argue that The Apartment didn't deserve significant accolades or that The Lost Weekend isn't a brilliant film, but if it comes down to an "either or" situation, Some Like It Hot should have won Best Director for Billy Wilder.

Advertisement

Though the Academy is rather famously drawn away from comedies, the cross-dressing caper should have been allowed to score the iconic director a rare win for the funnies. It's a perfectly crafted comedy, and it has lasted longer in memory and appreciation than almost all of 1959's Best Film nominees (aside from Ben-Hur) - a category it was wrongly snubbed from too.

Some Like It Hot is a triumph of performances, which is down to Wilder's direction, and of comic timing - which again comes down to the director and it surpasses The Apartment (just about) on all fronts.

Advertisement

9. Damien Chazelle

Summit Entertainment

Won For... La La Land

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Whiplash

Before the witch-hunt kicks off, La La Land definitely deserved the Best Director win of the nominees in 2017 (just as it should have won Best Picture too), but if Whiplash could have won in its place, there should be no arguments.

Advertisement

La La Land is more an achievement in showy directing and choreography: it is beautiful and wonderful and the ending is affecting in the most disarming way. It messes you up, and that's testament to the strength of the story-telling. But Whiplash is incredible on a different level.

It can't rely on the grand staging or production design or musical numbers that its own success afforded Chazelle in his follow-up, and the fact that he squeezed so much tension out of drumming sequences and two person exchanges was stunning. And if La La Land's end was good, it was nothing compared to the way Whiplash ends.

Advertisement

8. Robert Zemeckis

Paramount Pictures

Won For... Forrest Gump

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Back To The Future

Some might think that Robert Zemeckis most worthy chance of a Best Film nod would be Cast Away, and it would definitely have been a more worthy winner than Forrest Gump, but really, Back To The Future is the director's magnum opus and it deserved the win. Even though there was no way in the world it would ever have been nominated.

Advertisement

As a deeply populist movie, it would have been overlooked by the Academy every single year, which is plainly unfair. It's not a popular movie because of any cynical ploy or manipulation (which some Oscar winners actually are), it's popular because it is a perfect entertainment experience. And it is one of the best examples of the best directing being invisible.

If you look hard enough, you see Zemeckis' skill in the tone of the performances (all of which, down to Crispin Glover) are excellent, in the way the wonderfully convincing period sets are framed, and how the music - a character in itself in this movie - impacts the emotional messages. It's no throwaway achievement, and it's far better than the cloying sweetness of Gump.

Advertisement

Hell, even Who Framed Roger Rabbit is a better shout for Best Picture than Gump.

7. Carol Reed

Columbia Pictures

Won For... Oliver!

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... The Third Man

The Academy has a thing for musicals, and it is pretty fair to say that any movie with grand musical numbers that require complex choreography is an impressive feat, but the ability to create good set-pieces around songs is not the same as directing a good movie as a whole.

Advertisement

And while Oliver! is still counted as a classic of the genre, it's in no way, shape or form the equal of The Third Man, which is not only a great movie but a great work in the art of directing. In it, Carol Reed perfectly channeled Graham Greene, putting his words to images that felt lifted from the page so astonishingly well that it's no surprise that Greene himself calls it a director's movie.

Reed changed Greene's ending, added layers of details that would take years to find and basically crafted a noir masterpiece. Oliver! is good, but it's not that.

Advertisement

6. Martin Scorsese

Warner Bros. Pictures

Won For... The Departed

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Raging Bull OR Goodfellas

The Departed is a wonderfully entertaining film with a great performance by Jack Nicholson and with good performances from Matt Damon, Leonardo DiCaprio and Mark Wahlberg, but what it isn't is Martin Scorsese's best directed work. Not by some distance.

Advertisement

Goodfellas deserves directing acclaim for that one extended shot through the restaurant alone, never mind for the infinite little touches that bring its characters and tensions together. The choice to open with a voice-over, the framing of the scenes around Henry Hill's paranoia, the editing in almost every high-impact scene... It's a movie with directing touches visible all over it.

But Raging Bull is arguably even more impressive as a director's work, because of the way it plays around with tone and framing as the material requires: it is brutal and balletic, sentimental and stunningly raw, and the fight scenes are some of the best that have ever been captured on film. It makes The Departed look like a student film.

Advertisement

5. Danny Boyle

Fox Searchlight

Won For... Slumdog Millionaire

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Trainspotting

Some will tell you that Danny Boyle should have won his Best Director Oscar for Sunshine or the excellent (but entirely unlikely) 28 Days Later, but you have to go further back to find the really worthy film that should have won instead of Slumdog Millionaire.

Advertisement

While that film was a good one framed around an excellent story, it was nowhere near superior to Trainspotting - the film that announced Boyle's arrival as a Big Deal in film-making terms. He'd already made Shallow Grave and played with tense, dark atmosphere and he took those lessons and ran with them in the follow-up to create a chilling undercurrent.

Trainspotting is a triumph of married tones: it is at once weirdly aspirational at the same time as showing the horrors of heroine addiction and poverty (ODs and all); triumphant, tragic and trying with performances that are as shocking as they are memorable. It manages to be both funny and fury-inducing and no film has EVER managed to capture an identity quite as well.

Advertisement

4. The Coens

Paramount Vantage

Won For... No Country For Old Men

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Fargo

No Country For Old Men is certainly a well-directed movie and it deserves to be remembered for lots of brave decisions as well as capturing a stunning performance by Javier Bardem that is as terrifying and irresistible as Jack Nicholson's starring role in The Shining. But it is not better than the Coens first great movie - Fargo.

Advertisement

As the spin-off TV show would later brilliantly recapture, Fargo is all about capturing a personality. Its portrait of small town life is both claustrophobically spot-on for anyone who has lived it and also oddly familiar for everyone who hasn't. The directors managed to paint ideas that were both incredibly specific and hugely accessible, which is the contradiction at the film's heart (and at the heart of their achievement).

As Roger Ebert said they "made a movie that is completely original, and as familiar as an old shoe," which was brave and bold and stunningly well-observed with a tone that is infectious and curious and essential. It's still the pair at their best.

Advertisement

3. Alfonso Cuaron

Warner Bros.

Won For... Gravity

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... Children Of Men

Gravity is a good film and Alfonso Cuaron's work on it was happily well celebrated with his Best Director win, but it wasn't his finest work. It wasn't even his third finest.

Advertisement

The director could have won for Y Tu Mama Tambien. If the Academy had any sort of affection for populist franchises, he wouldn't have been unfairly rewarded for his exceptional transformation of the Harry Potter franchise for The Prisoner Of Azkaban. But he definitely SHOULD have won for Children Of Men.

Stunningly, the film wasn't even nominated in 2007 when it was overlooked in favour of No Country for Old Men, There Will Be Blood, Michael Clayton, Juno and The Diving Bell and the Butterfly. It was more deserving than three of those at least.

Advertisement

But the argument here is in its superiority over Gravity, which is unquestionable. Watch those extended single-shot sequences or listen to Cuaron's use of sound and music and his skill in crafting atmosphere and tension is unquestionable. It's a masterpiece of directing sorely overlooked.

2. John Ford

Republic Pictures

Won For... The Informer, The Grapes Of Wrath, How Green Was My Valley, & The Quiet Man

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance OR The Searchers

John Ford might be the most decorated director of all time in terms of Academy Awards, but his three best films didn't even win. To be fair, he was nominated for wins a lot more - to the extent that him winning more might have looked a bit too much like favouritism.

Advertisement

The Grapes Of Wrath is probably the best of Ford's four wins, but the fact that neither The Searchers nor The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance - literally the two greatest Westerns OF ALL TIME - didn't win him Best Director is nothing short of a scandal. The idea that How Green Was My Valley should somehow be remembered as a better achievement in directing is ridiculous.

Both feature astonishingly beautiful scenes and both basically invented the vocabulary of Western movies as we probably all imagine them now. Ford inspired career-high performances from John Wayne (aside from True Grit obviously), and that's no mean feat at all (it sometimes feels like it would be akin to turning marble into rubber).

Advertisement

1. Frank Capra

Columbia Pictures

Won For... It Happened One Night, Mr Deeds Goes To Town & You Can't Take It With You

Advertisement

Should Have Won For... It's A Wonderful Life

It's one of Hollywood's great, fortuitous tragedies that It's A Wonderful Life was cast off when it was first released. But the critical apathy that met its release wasn't universal and nor was it entirely reflective of its appreciation. Otherwise, it wouldn't have been nominated for five Academy Awards (unsuccessfully) as well as being given a special technical achievement for inventing a new way of simulating snow on screen.

Advertisement

But while the Golden Globes recognised Capra's achievements in directing, he didn't win the Oscar he should have (not just over his other three wins, but also legitimately over the rest of 1946's contenders). And that simply isn't right.

While affection for the film has grown hugely since the 70s, watching it now it's impossible to not feel Capra all over it, in the tone that wanders from bleak to heart-bursting triumph and in the way the story tumbles on gathering weight. It's sublime, simple, sentamental film-making at its very best.

Advertisement

Which other directors won Oscars for entirely the wrong film? Share your suggestions below in the comments thread.