11 Movie Casting Choices The Public Couldn't Handle
Can K-Stew prove the doubters wrong?
You can have a great script, a wonderful director, and an ultra-talented crew, but there's no mistaking the paramount importance of getting a movie's casting right.
Pick the right actor to play a part and you've got instant cinematic dynamite, but screw it up and an ill-fitting actor can single-handedly sink the entire production.
As much as Hollywood loves to play things safe, bold casting choices are certainly a way to get people's attention - both for better and for worse.
Who among us can forget the negativity surrounding Heath Ledger's casting as The Joker in The Dark Knight, only for him to win an Academy Award for his performance?
Audiences are historically pretty poor at being open-minded about casting, and so it's little surprise that these left-field picks left many viewers vocally infuriated.
While in some cases the frustration was at least understandable - if not calling out some of Hollywood's more cynical casting practises - in others it simply allowed audiences to reveal their own closed-mindedness to the world.
But regardless of how it turned out, these casting choices immediately ignited the ire of audiences worldwide...
11. Michael B. Jordan - Johnny Storm (Fantastic Four)
Because racists can always be counted on to kick up a fuss, there was a significant outcry online when it was announced that the brilliant Michael B. Jordan would be playing Johnny Storm aka The Human Torch in Josh Trank's 2015 Fantastic Four reboot.
Though some cried foul that Storm, a traditionally white character in the comics, wouldn't look "source-accurate" as played by a black man, other impossibly angry comic book fans opined that Jordan's casting stank of the ever-fearful "political correctness gone mad."
This was while completely ignoring that Storm's race is of little relevance in the comics, and better still, that Jordan was a terrific choice for the part.
The backlash was significant enough that writer-director Trank reportedly slept with a gun on his nightstand during production.
Furthermore, Trank also wanted to cast a black actress to play Sue Storm, but was overruled by Fox, resulting in Kate Mara - who Trank ultimately clashed with throughout production - being cast.
Though the movie turned out pretty terrible all-around, Jordan at least seemed philosophical about the silliness of the casting controversy. He said:
"You’re not supposed to go on the Internet when you’re cast as a superhero...Some people may look at my casting as political correctness or an attempt to meet a racial quota, or as part of the year of 'Black Film.' Or they could look at it as a creative choice by the director, Josh Trank, who is in an interracial relationship himself - a reflection of what a modern family looks like today."
10. Megan Fox - April O'Neil (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles)
The Michael Bay-produced Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film courted plenty of controversy throughout its production and release, but not even the uncanny valley CGI humanoid turtles were able to entirely upstage the bizarre casting of Megan Fox as the Turtles' intrepid ally April O'Neil.
Given Fox's rather dubious array of acting credits and her association with Bay through the Transformers franchise, it seemed like a lazy, cynical casting choice intended largely to appeal to the hormonal teenager demographic.
In addition to the fan response, TMNT's co-creator Peter Laird himself expressed his polite disappointment with the casting, saying:
"My only exposure to Megan Fox as an actress is through her role in two Transformers movies and the wretched (but happily forgettable) Jennifer's Body. It may not be fair to judge her range of acting skills just from those three movies, but I think it is safe to say that there are probably hundreds of better choices for the role of April O'Neil. Of course, her name has promotional value, and maybe that's what they want. Who knows? I can't get myself too worked up about it."
In the end Fox wasn't a terrible April, but hardly particularly good or in any way memorable. Considering the material she had to work with, though, that's hardly surprising.
9. Jai Courtney - Kyle Reese (Terminator Genisys)
Long-suffering fans of the Terminator franchise have had to endure countless re-casts of all the major characters over the years, especially with regard to Sarah Connor and John Connor.
But in the fifth film, Terminator Genisys, this once again extended to resistance soldier Kyle Reese, who was of course played with gruff brilliance by Michael Biehn in the original film, while Anton Yelchin put in a solid effort as his teenage equivalent in the mostly terrible Terminator Salvation.
But for Genisys, Jai Courtney was cast to play Reese, a decision which was immediately met with derision from the fanbase.
At the time, Courtney was largely known for a string of unimpressive performances in the likes of A Good Day to Die Hard, I, Frankenstein, and the Divergent series.
Dubbed "the new Sam Worthington" by many - a bland white actor Hollywood was desperately trying to make happen - his casting didn't seem worthy of such a legendary sci-fi character, especially amid reports that the far better-suited Boyd Holbrook had also been considered for the part.
In the end, Courtney wasn't worse than anything else in the movie - which, of course, was painfully mediocre - though failed to make much of an impact.
Still, his performance at least proved more convincing than Emilia Clarke's risible turn as Sarah Connor.
8. Jennifer Lawrence - Katniss Everdeen (The Hunger Games)
The Hunger Games' lead role of Katniss Everdeen was intensely sought out in Hollywood, with reportedly 30 name actresses reading for the part including Hailee Steinfeld, Abigail Breslin, Emma Roberts, Saoirse Ronan, Chloë Grace Moretz, Emily Browning, Shailene Woodley, and Kaya Scodelario.
But it was of course Jennifer Lawrence who won the role, with her casting announced just weeks after she received her first Best Actress Oscar nomination for Winter's Bone, and mere months before she became a veritable A-lister by playing Mystique in X-Men: First Class.
Despite Lawrence's clear talent, fans of Suzanne Collins' YA novel series felt that the actress simply didn't fit Katniss' physical characteristics.
In addition to being four years older than her paperback equivalent, Lawrence lacked the straight black hair, olive skin, and "tomboyish" look described in the book, and many felt she was simply too curvaceous to convincingly resemble an underfed warrior struggling to stay alive.
In the end, Lawrence dyed her hair darker, and fans' reservations largely melted away once the movie was released.
While Katniss didn't net Lawrence any major awards, it remains her career-defining performance, and is absolutely one of the strongest blockbuster turns of the last decade.
7. Robert Pattinson - Edward Cullen (Twilight)
As further proof that YA fans can be very particular about the casting of their beloved movie adaptations, we have the much protested casting of Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen, the hunky vampiric lead of the Twilight franchise.
Pattinson, known only for playing Cedric Diggory in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire at the time, was perceived to lack Edward's expected physical features, especially given that author Stephenie Meyer had originally written the character with Henry Cavill in mind. Oof.
Pattinson himself stated that his casting caused "unanimous unhappiness" among the fanbase, and admitted he had to stop reading blogs about the movie due to negativity.
Worse still, he received "bags of letters" from angry fans who felt he couldn't possibly play Edward because he was already Harry Potter's Diggory.
The fanbase soon enough came around once Twilight hit screens and became a box office phenom, with the four-movie franchise eventually grossing a stonking $3.3 billion worldwide.
Pattinson and his co-star Kristen Stewart made it incredibly obvious while doing press for the later movies that they weren't particularly fond of the films, yet in the years that followed managed to cultivate successful and respected careers away from the blockbuster realm.
6. Tilda Swinton - The Ancient One (Doctor Strange)
Tilda Swinton is a chameleonic credit to practically any movie production she lands a role on, though that didn't stop many fans expressing frustration at her playing The Ancient One in Doctor Strange.
In the comics, the all-powerful character was a Tibetan man, and so many felt that casting Swinton in the role was "whitewashing" a part that could've been played by an Asian actor.
Yet it was very much a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" situation, with co-writer C. Robert Cargill explaining that the casting was primarily an attempt to avoid making the movie's Ancient One a Fu Manchu-esque stereotype of the wise, Asian mystic.
Director Scott Derrickson absolutely confessed the difficulties of casting the role, saying, "What I did was the lesser of two evils, but it is still an evil."
In the end, the controversy dissipated relatively quickly once the film hit screens, with Swinton's performance being widely praised alongside the film's generally diverse cast.
5. Johnny Depp - Gellert Grindelwald (Fantastic Beasts & Where To Find Them)
Despite the first Fantastic Beasts movie being largely well-received by fans, there were a lot of raised eyebrows at the last-minute inclusion of Johnny Depp in cameo form as the villainous Gellert Grindelwald.
Warner Bros. made tremendous pains to keep Depp's involvement secret, and despite word leaking shortly before release, most audiences were completely shocked to see Depp revealed as the true face of the series' antagonist.
Between the utter ridiculousness of Depp's sudden appearance and his well-publicised legal issues with Amber Heard at the time, many fans were left either laughing or groaning - if not both - rather than excited to see what Depp could bring to the table.
More to the point, given that Grindelwald was played by Colin Farrell for most of the movie - albeit in disguise as wizard Percival Graves - it felt like a totally pointless rug-pull that only deprived audiences of a recurring Farrell role in future films.
With the Depp-Heard controversy ramping up further before the release of the sequel, The Crimes of Grindelwald, it perhaps wasn't terribly surprising that Depp's involvement was a huge distraction, and the movie ultimately disappointed both critically and commercially.
In its wake, word spread that Warner Bros. was considering re-casting the part for the third film, and at least if they do, Grindelwald's slippery penchant for changing his appearance would make the switch relatively seamless.
4. Gal Gadot - Diana Prince (Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice)
Even more so than YA adaptations, comic book movie casting can bring out the most vitriolic and childish facets of the fanbase.
To that end, the casting of Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman for a recurring role in the DCEU was met with a ferocious backlash by fans.
The primary complaint wasn't an entirely unreasonable one - that the slender Gadot lacked the muscle tone and build expected of the super-heroine - albeit voiced in highly disrespectful terms by many, using it as an excuse to launch vile personal attacks against the actress.
Though Gadot didn't bulk up too much to play Wonder Woman in the end, her role in Batman v Superman was one of the film's easy highlights, and she absolutely made the part her own with the superhero's solo movie released the very next year.
3. Chris Pine - Captain James T. Kirk (Star Trek)
Gadot's Wonder Woman co-star is himself no stranger to fanning the fires of an enraged fandom, as he experienced first-hand when he was cast as Captain Kirk in J.J. Abrams' 2009 Star Trek reboot.
Kirk is of course one of the most statuesque and iconic characters in all of sci-fi, and one originally played quite inimitably by the great William Shatner.
By comparison, the relatively unknown Pine smacked of "generic white guy," unaided by the movie's marketing failing to showcase one drop of his actual charisma.
Despite the anxiousness of Trek fans, the final film acquitted Pine exceptionally, revealing his Kirk to be a cocky, charming rogue with a beating heart just barely detectable underneath.
Pine did a fantastic job growing into the part in the two sequels, and while never capable of replacing Shatner, took up the mantle with grace and respect.
2. Kristen Stewart - Princess Diana (Spencer)
The most recent major casting furore is unquestionably the shock announcement that Kristen Stewart has been cast to play Princess Diana in the upcoming drama "Spencer," which will focus on a weekend in the early 1990s when Diana decided to split from Prince Charles.
Naturally, online reaction to the casting choice was "divisive" to say the least, with K-Stew's usual band of haters coming out of the woodwork to criticise her apparent lack of charisma, while more reasonable concerns about Stewart's ability to nail the necessary English accent also came to the surface.
Looks-wise, Stewart can probably bear a decent enough resemblance to the late Princess with a solid makeup job, yet even with acclaimed filmmaker Pablo Larraín (Jackie) at the helm, given how 2013's Naomi Watts-led Diana biopic turned out, it's reasonable to be at least a tad skeptical.
Stewart's blossomed into a terrific, risk-taking actress in her post-Twilight career, but Diana is so far removed from who she appears to be that it'll require plenty of hard graft on her part to win the doubters over.
1. Emma Stone - A Quarter-Chinese, Quarter-Hawaiian Woman (Aloha)
And finally, we have perhaps the most baffling, inexplicable casting of an A-list actress in recent Hollywood history.
For Cameron Crowe's 2015 rom-com Aloha, Emma Stone was cast as Air Force pilot Captain Allison Ng, a quarter-Chinese, quarter-Hawaiian woman, which Stone very clearly is not.
This sparked a significant public outcry, that the part could've been given to a more ethnically appropriate actress, rather than cynically handing it off to a bankable white actress like Stone.
In the end, Crowe and Stone both appeared to apologise with absolute sincerity, stating that the character was intended to reflect the diverse cultural melting pot that is Hawaii, even if outward appearances suggested otherwise.
Whether you object to the casting or not, we can all agree on one thing - the movie is terrible, and this controversy is pretty much the only thing most people actually remember about it.