12 MCU Mistakes Thor: Ragnarok Must Avoid
Hopefully Ragnarok is more than just "fun".
Thor: Ragnarok's release is fast approaching, and though some early screenings reports have found their way online, it's always best to read these hot takes with a pinch of salt, especially when they're so effusively positive (as they always are).
Still, these opinions combined with the film's generally terrific marketing certainly suggest that Ragnarok should at least be another enjoyable Marvel romp, even if it remains to be seen whether or not director Taika Waititi can avoid the Marvel Cinematic Universe's litany of nagging issues.
The Kiwi filmmaker will be powerless to fix many of the problems for sure, but there's still genuine hope that a filmmaker as smart as him can at least push back against Marvel Studios a little and challenge their more formulaic demands.
While it's likely that Ragnarok's still going to be subject to at least a few of these pervasive MCU issues, Waititi will hopefully also find some creative ways to subvert and dance around the more eye-rolling aspects of the universe...
12. Being A Slave To The Wider Universe
This is arguably the most prominent issue that pervades across the entire MCU, that the individual films too often feel overly in service of the bigger picture, where they're ultimately just flashy advertisements for the next ensemble Avengers movie.
It's the reason that Edgar Wright bailed from Ant-Man after working on it for so many years, and though some of the Marvel films do get away with being mostly standalone, for the most part it's clear that Marvel Studios wants each of their films to tie into the overall tapestry, whether it serves the focal story or not. Case in point: that cool but admittedly forced Ant-Man/Falcon fight scene.
Will It Be Avoided?: Early screening reports have called Ragnarok "self-contained", so it seems that any nods to the exterior world will be minimal at best, perhaps reserved for the inevitable credits scenes.
11. Forced & Unnecessary Romance
Because studio executives refuse to believe casual viewers will go see a superhero movie unless there's a love story, unconvincing romance has been shoehorned into so many MCU movies, perhaps worst of all the Thor franchise, given his atrociously forced love-in with Jane Foster (who thankfully doesn't appear in Ragnarok).
At this point in the MCU, with billions of dollars in box office receipts in its rear view, do fans really need to put up with such pandering nonsense?
Will It Be Avoided?: Tough to say. The obvious potential for a needless love story here is between Thor and Valkyrie (or possibly Sif, if she actually made it into the final cut).
At least with a director as smart as Taika Waititi at the helm, there's a good chance he might choose to subvert or openly mock the idea.
10. An Excessive Runtime
As the MCU has become increasingly successful, the scope of the individual films has grown considerably, resulting in movies with decidedly longer run-times.
Captain America: Civil War, for instance, is the longest MCU movie to date at a staggering 147 minutes, and the majority of the franchise's films clock in at between 130-140 minutes, with barely any daring to linger around the two-hour mark.
Do the movies really need to be that long? In a time where some audiences are experiencing fatigue with both blockbuster and Marvel formula, shouldn't less be more?
Will It Be Avoided?: Thankfully, Taika Waititi promised back in July that Ragnarok will be around the 100-minute mark, and even if that doesn't include credits, that means a likely final length of around 110-115 minutes.
Very reasonable by MCU standards, then, and hopefully an indication that the typical superhero bloat has been streamlined for maximum energy and entertainment value.
9. A Lack Of Life & Death Stakes
It's a general problem with comic book movies that it's hard to establish a steady set of stakes when the majority of the focal characters are near-indestructible superheroes.
The MCU has particularly suffered here, by magicking characters back from the death (Coulson), pulling too many fake-out deaths (Nick Fury, Loki) and generally only killing superheroes nobody cares about in the first place (Quicksilver).
And then there's the collateral damage debate regarding civilians, which Captain America: Civil War took a decent stab at addressing even if it's surely going to be forgotten about once again.
This just indicates that Marvel is afraid to take any real risks with its characters. With these huge trilogies carved out years in advance, there's no chance of anyone significant dying, and more to the point, actually staying dead. Why, then, should audiences get emotionally invested at all?
Will It Be Avoided?: The Thor franchise is arguably the hardest to tackle in this regard because it revolves around so many God-like entities who can simply die, go to Hel, and then return to Earth because reasons.
It seems pretty likely that Odin might actually die for good in Ragnarok, though, and if it's exploited for maximum impact, it could certainly be one of the more affecting death scenes in the MCU (and given Anthony Hopkins' age, there's actually a good chance he'll stay dead).
8. Forgettable Villains
As successful as the MCU is, it's impressive how few of the villains have actually had much lasting impact at all.
Though Loki is fantastic, Helmut Zemo was great and Vulture proved surprisingly decent, for the most part the antagonists are bland villains lacking much personality or intrigue, wasting thoroughly talented actors in the process.
The most egregious examples are Thor: The Dark World's Malekith and Guardians of the Galaxy's Ronan, but Yellowjacket also felt like a dull afterthought, and you can certainly argue that Mads Mikkelsen's Kaecilius deserved a little better.
Seriously, how hard is it to hire a talented actor, give them compelling motives and not have them be forgettably offed at the end of the movie?
Will It Be Avoided?: Well, Cate Blanchett certainly looks like she's having a ton of fun in the role of Hela, and while it's best not to expect a huge amount of nuance to her character, it's hard to imagine her ending up as boring as the aforementioned dud baddies.
And then there's Surtur, though he's probably not going to have a particularly substantial role if the marketing is any indication.
So, yes and no, basically.
7. Being "Fun" But Nothing More
A lot of fans despise the fact that pretty much every MCU film is described as "fun" as soon as it comes out, which some have interpreted to mean "an enjoyable but insubstantial movie you won't remember in a week".
It's the cinematic equivalent of eating McDonald's: you gorge yourself on its strong flavours, but it leaves no lasting impression and you're quickly hungry for more.
This is a valid descriptor for many of the solo MCU movies in particular, most recently Spider-Man: Homecoming, which was entertaining but had almost no visceral impact whatsoever and little to stick with audiences once the credits rolled.
Will It Be Avoided?: From what's been shown off so far, it does seem like Ragnarok is focusing on being a "fun" time above all else, so it's probably best not to expect too much in the way of substance here.
It's a winning formula that works, so regardless of what people complain about online, it's hard to imagine Marvel Studios changing things up while the box office receipts remain healthy.
6. Minimal Use Of Female Characters
Despite women accounting for 50% of the population, the superhero genre still has a problem giving females substantial roles, and it's telling that almost a decade into the MCU's existence, there still hasn't been a female-led superhero film. Hell, even DC got there first.
The overall point here is that the female characters in MCU films generally aren't important enough, with the major exceptions being Black Widow and Gamora.
Elsewhere women are shoved into terrible love interest roles (Jane Foster), or weirdly sidelined despite their clearly enormous potential (Sif). Given how these films are generally overflowing with testosterone, some more meaty roles for women would be warmly welcomed.
Will It Be Avoided?: There's definitely some potential here, with Blanchett's villain and Tessa Thompson playing Valkyrie, not to mention the possible appearance of Sif (most likely in a cameo, though).
If Waititi can't give at least one of these actresses one of the most memorable female roles in the MCU, then something's gone horribly wrong somewhere.
5. Not Letting Directors Just Direct
Marvel Studios has occasionally hired auteur directors to tackle their movies, with the likes of Kenneth Branagh and Shane Black managing to operate just fine within that framework.
However, it's clear from Edgar Wright's departure from Ant-Man that the MCU's films have a very specific "house style" both aesthetically and narratively that cannot be tampered with.
As such, Marvel tends to hire lesser-established filmmakers from the indie scene who can be easily shaped to fit the MCU mould, rather than directors who are a recognisable brand onto themselves, because it can create unwarranted conflict.
Will It Be Avoided?: This is an interesting one, because though Taika Waititi has only directed four movies prior to Thor: Ragnarok, all of them low-budget indies, there's a consistent style and tone across them, and a genuine worry that his eccentric originality as a filmmaker could get lost in the Marvel sausage factory.
It's probably reasonable to expect some sort of middle-ground here: the action will adhere more to the typical Marvel style, while the dialogue and visual wit will hopefully give Waititi plenty of room to place his own personal stamp on the movie (but not too much, of course).
It's hard to imagine a director as singular as Waititi signing on if his sensibilities were going to be massively neutered, so fingers crossed it still feels like one of his movies.
4. Wasting Awesome Comic Book Characters
Yes, not every great Marvel character can get their full due on-screen, but the MCU has wasted quite a few terrific characters, especially when it comes to villains.
Most prominently, of course, is The Mandarin, who was wasted in the service of a controversial plot twist in Iron Man 3, but there's also the likes of Baron Strucker and Crossbones (who died after mere minutes of screen time), and in terms of heroes, has it ever really felt like Hawkeye got his proper due?
Yes, these movies are aiming at the broadest, most casual audience possible, but they still need to do adequate service to the source material for the comic book fans who have made these films possible in the first place, no?
Will It Be Avoided?: Expect a mixed bag, to be honest. It's already looking like Karl Urban's Skurge is probably going to be an after-thought, and Surtur's likely not going to figure in the plot much, but Hela, Valkyrie and Jeff Goldblum's Grandmaster seem like pretty promising renditions of their comic book counterparts so far.
3. Making The Avengers' Absence Distracting
Every time a new solo MCU movie comes out, someone will ask where the hell the rest of the Avengers were while all this world-threatening mayhem was kicking off.
It's a reasonable question, if one that rarely has a satisfying in-universe answer, because it of course comes down to nothing more than money and scheduling. Plus, would you really want Tony Stark in every single Marvel movie? His charm would wear thin eventually.
This is an incredibly tough problem to combat, and as much as fans love to bring it up, Marvel Studios will probably just continue to largely ignore it.
Will It Be Avoided?: Ragnarok has a fantastic get-out clause here, because most if not all of the movie will be set off-Earth on Asgard and the planet Sakaar, so there'd be no conceivable reason for any of the Avengers to even know where Thor and The Hulk are.
At least until the Guardians of the Galaxy join The Avengers in Infinity War, there's a wall between the Earth-set MCU and the shenanigans in space, so that's one less thing to worry about in Ragnarok.
2. "Because...Magic"
Yes, superhero movies require audiences to more often than not just accept a heap of slippery logic and the fact that things happen...just because.
Still, this doesn't usually make for the most rewarding viewing, especially when some sort of magical ability or trinket is introduced to get the hero out of a bind (the Eye of Agamotto for one), or perhaps even return them from death. Moreover, remember the laughable excuse for Thor getting back to Earth in The Avengers (Odin's vague "dark energy" out of nowhere)?
More than anything, these moments feel like lazy writing, but because the MCU has no clearly-defined, unbendable rules, the movies just about manage to get away with making things up as they go along.
Will It Be Avoided?: It's pretty daft to expect no magical nonsense in a Thor movie, especially as it seems quite probable that either Thor or The Hulk is going to die at some point in the film, visit Hel and then be brought back to life.
Still, if Waititi manages to train the film's focus more on the buddy dynamic than silly magical objects and power levels, then the possible resurrection shenanigans might not seem quite so sloppy. Honestly, this one could go either way.
1. Mediocre Original Music
Aside from Alan Silvestri's memorable signature theme for The Avengers, the MCU is shockingly lacking in memorable original music, which seems especially disappointing with the abundance of colourful characters within this universe.
Why don't The Avengers all have their own signature themes? The Hulk should have a leitmotif for every time he shows up, for instance, but instead, the impact of so many iconic moments is diminished by the utter lack of any remotely memorable music.
The Guardians of the Galaxy movies basically realised that exploiting well-known pop music was easier than writing original music, but at least it tied into the plot well enough, and pandering though it is, it works more often than not.
Original scores, though, have been hugely underwhelming for the most part, with even the brilliant Michael Giacchino recycling parts of his own Star Trek score for last year's Doctor Strange.
Will It Be Avoided?: Early screenings reports state that Ragnarok mostly goes the Guardians route and uses a lot of pre-existing music (to admittedly entertaining effect), so no.
Plus, the film's composer is the relatively workmanlike Mark Mothersbaugh, so it's best not to expect much memorable in this department, sadly.
Will Thor: Ragnarok fall into the MCU's classic pitfalls, or can it rise above? Make your prediction in the comments!