13 Disappointing Recent Films That Should've Been Great

Why you should never get your hopes up.

By Robin Baxter /

There are some films where everyone looks at each other and just thinks "What went wrong?"

Advertisement

With alarming regularity, a film with a lot of talent attached with no reason not to be a smashing success comes out, but then turns out to be a complete and utter waste of time.

Looking back through the past few years, there are multiple cases where a film is riding on a tidal wave of hype and then suddenly all the bad reviews start coming in. That's when everyone realizes: it's going to be another Phantom Menace.

These are the films in the last few years where everyone was fully expecting them to be a smash-hit but was instead greeted with a disappointing waste of potential. Not all of these are bad, but they all - frustratingly - had it in them to be brilliant and just weren't.

And that's why you should never get your hopes up too high...

13. Chappie

What Was Expected

Advertisement

Chappie looked like a thought-provoking and unique depiction of AI, with a strong cast, an interesting setting and a new adorable robot for the ages with Chappie. It also suggested a bounce back up for director Neil Blomkamp.

What We Actually Got

If Neil Blomkamp wants to destroy all the good-will he earned through District 9 he's certainly going the right way about it.

When you watch Chappie, prepare to be frustrated as the many interesting ideas about AI are neglected in favor of a bland, generic gangster plot. The movie is an endless mumbo-jumbo of different ideas with none of them truly being explored.

Viewers must be warned not to expect much actually to do with the AI themes the trailer appeared to hint at as the film is dominated by some excruciatingly annoying rappers who give very irritating performances. Meanwhile, Dev Patel and Sigourney Weaver are sidelined while Hugh Jackman gives a terrible performance. .

Chappie isn't terrible as it brushes up against a lot of interesting things, but whenever this happens all we get is another messy, generic and confused sequence focussing either on explosions or those blasted rappers.

12. The Purge

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A tense, thought-provoking horror film with one of the best premises to a film in... well, in recent years at all.

What We Actually Got

Just a boring home invasion thriller. The idea of The Purge is brilliant, but since the entire film is spent in a house with weak characters killing each other in the dark, social commentary goes out of the window. In the end, it's just another film with masked intruders attacking a house and nearly everything in this film has been seen before in better films.

The world wanted a thought-provoking and politically topical horror film, not another home invasion thriller. Considering the interesting plot and decent cast, it's disappointing that this turned out to be nothing more than a 2-star horror film with a cowardly refusal to do anything different.

Thankfully though, this franchise has since redeemed itself as the sequels have been improvements, so at least there was some redemption later on. That isn't the case with many similarly disappointing films.

11. Transcendence

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A strong debut for first-time director Wally Pfister with a strong cast, a fantastic central premise and plenty of potential to explore thought-provoking ideas.

What We Actually Got

A very strange film and not in a good way. The film has lots of good ideas, but doesn't do anything with them at all, instead seeking only to get weirder as it goes on. And as personality goes this film is as robotic as a Transformer.

Punishingly slow, wildly annoying and completely bewildering throughout, this went from being one of 2014's most anticipated films to one of its most derided with stunning speed.

As for its star Johnny Depp, he is so bad in this movie that you'll find yourself wishing he would put some white face-paint on and start going bananas. At least then he wouldn't be acting with the personality of a zombie. Aside from Mortdecai, this is probably his worst role ever.

10. Suicide Squad

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A vibrant, fun, stylish and thematically interesting movie with some great characters on screen, a strong cast and an exciting, different sort of vibe.

What We Actually Got

Oh dear.

To get the positives out of the way first, Will Smith, Margot Robbie and especially Viola Davis are very good, the soundtrack works well and the first half-hour is OK. After that, Suicide Squad reveals itself as nothing more than another story about a superhero team fighting faceless goons leading to yet another beam-in-the-sky climax with yet another terrible CGI villain.

Suicide Squad is worse than generic: it's a flaming dumpster fire and a complete betrayal of the values it promoted. None of the 'villains' feel genuinely villainous, they never feel like a team and there's little to no moral ambiguity or darkness in the story at all. It also boasts terrible editing, an emotionless approach and one of the worst finales to a superhero film ever.

While fans continue to debate the merits of the movie and whether or not critics are just biased towards Marvel, it should be accepted: no matter how much you might enjoy it on an entertainment level, no matter how exciting it is to see these characters on screen, this movie is, from a technical and story perspective, completely incompetent.

9. X-Men: Apocalypse

What Was Expected

Advertisement

Another strong X-Men movie to continue the run of good movies the franchise has been delivering recently, with a strong cast and Bryan Singer in the director's chair.

What We Actually Got

A very mediocre X-Men installment, which is disappointing considering how consistent the franchise has often been in the past. First Class and Days of Future Past had been the best X-Men films to date at that point, so there was no reason for this to be so flat.

The truth is, this movie is just hollow, lacking an emotionally engaging story and is generic, thin superhero formula. As if that wasn't bad enough, Apocalypse is a pretty lame villain as well. When the film actually bothers going into emotionally compelling material, it's just the same old stuff about how hard it is to be a mutant and after 16 years, it all just feels very stale.

With no arcs and no dramatic weight, this movie is a narrative flop. The action can be fun, but much of it is messy and the final battle is just CGI nonsense. Wolverine once again mostly sits this one out and none of the great cast are at their best here at all.

Perhaps the most distracting thing of all is the talented Sophie Turner's terrible performance - as well as her hideous attempts at an American accent.

8. Alien: Covenant

What Was Expected

Advertisement

Something in the vein of Aliens (1986); a thrilling science-fiction horror film with a renewed focus on the Xenomorphs, and also with Michael Fassbender returning and Ridley Scott at the helm.

What We Actually Got

This was nothing more than Prometheus... with Xenomorphs. The dumb decisions, flat characters, hollow story and bad dialogue remain firmly intact.

Of course, Michael Fassbender is unreal in his double performance as David and Walter and the character of David continues to be very interesting, but nothing around him is nearly as refined.

There is absolutely no need for a Xenomorph origin story. An entire trilogy explaining how the Alien was created is a tragic waste of money. And on top of that, when you go to see a horror film, you expect to be scared. Sadly, Covenant was never scary at all.

Sure, the gore is cool, but this is noticeably light on actual suspense. This tension-free crafting of this film proves that Ridley Scott has been given far too many chances, and he may be a good visual stylist, but he's no master director.

Emotionless, un-scary and frustratingly dumb, this is a bitterly disappointing experience.

7. Only God Forgives

What Was Expected

Advertisement

Another triumph from Nicholas Winding Refn, as he did a film similar to Drive with more of his masterful visuals.

What We Actually Got

Drive was great. Only God Forgives was not.

The latter is all about style and oozes it from every frame. Visually, it's a beautiful movie, but it's very much style over substance - and a particularly bad type of style-over-substance. It's skin-deep and shallow, but thinks its extremely deep and its obnoxious arrogance is likely to induce plenty of walkouts.

In other words, it's style pretending to be substance.

Apparently, endless instances of Ryan Gosling staring at his hands and people singing in karaoke bars are supposed to be deep, but they're not. There needs to be a plot to back up the film's amazing style, and since this film doesn't have a plot, it just doesn't work.

This is clearly supposed to have a thematic message, but due to the film's pretentiousness and its expectancy of the audience to work everything out from finding meaning is near impossible.

It isn't without its moments, but there's no denying the film's lack of characterization and compelling plot, no matter how many critics try to defend this film as a five-star, misunderstood masterpiece.

6. The Raid 2

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A mind-blowing martial-arts action spectacular, with more plot and characterization this time.

What We Actually Got

This is an anomaly. On first viewing, this seemed like a big success in every way, but on the second and third viewings, it all falls apart. The action scenes are pure heaven and show you don't need a massive budget to provide the exhilaration and adrenaline rushes. There's no denying that - it's just what surrounds them that's the problem.

The film works its way through an endless stream of exposition-filled and tedious dramatic sequences. It's trying its best to be like The Godfather, but with underdeveloped characters, an ugly tone and far too much content for a film of this type, it just isn't as deep as it thinks it is.

It's a stunningly violent film and Gareth Edwards remains a fantastic action director, but there was no need to try and add so much drama. All audiences needed was more amazing action with some bits of story here and there.

Here's the recommended viewing: skip the plot scenes and just watch all the action sequences. You'll have a great time there, and there's probably 30-45 minutes of material there too. But viewed with the misjudged story, even the action scenes start to become a bit dull. It's sad how poorly this has endured multiple viewings, considering the first film only gets better every time.

5. Sunset Song

What Was Expected

Advertisement

This looked like a successful adaptation of a much-loved novel and it had an acclaimed auteur helming it with Terrence Davies.

What We Actually Got

A frustratingly mediocre work that's visually stunning but otherwise is just another boring indie film that thinks it can get by just because it's not mainstream. If things like this and boring Oscar-bait films are the only blockbuster alternative, of course people are going to go and see the next Transformers film.

This is an art-house movie through and through and it ticks the art-house checklist: gratuitous nudity, pretentious voice-overs, a slow pace, beautiful cinematography, deep themes and a lack of respect for mainstream conventions. But it's ultimately not a great example of an art-house film. There are definitely good bits, but there are many dull ones as well. Similarly, some of the cast is good but Agyness Deyn is awful as Chris, the main character, and murders the Scottish accent.

You know you're in trouble when you're relieved WWI, one of the most horrible events in history, begins because you're waiting for something to happen.

For all its artiness, Sunset Song is only a three-star film at most. The wildly inconsistent script just has too much thematic superficiality, too many inexplicable character decisions and changes, and worst of all too many ghastly voice-overs from Chris, who for some reason describes herself in the third person and speaks some of the most pretentious lines in recent memory.

4. Suburbicon

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A dark, quirky crime thriller with the Coen Brothers being as awesome as always and the cast giving strong performances.

What We Actually Got

Suburbicon had no right to be so weak considering all the talent involved, but Oscar Issac is the only one who actually does genuinely good work. George Clooney's direction is largely flat, Julianne Moore is mediocre, and Matt Damon is flat-out bad.

Even the script feels like it must have been edited down by Clooney and Grant Heslov, since the Coen Brothers' usual stuff is certainly miles ahead of this.

Part-race commentary, part-dark comedy, part-social satire, part-crime thriller and all-failure, this jumbles several different elements together and the result is a mess. There's plenty of potential with the story-line, but the film lacks the pathos and dark comedy that Coen movies like Fargo did with ease.

As well as being a boring mess, it's also a very unlikable movie, with characters so loathsome you'll find yourself wishing a meteor would hit the titular town and have done with it.

3. High-Rise

What Was Expected

Advertisement

A fascinating story, a talented director, a great cast and a terrific marketing campaign. What could possibly go wrong?

What We Actually Got

Alas, High-Rise is really, really bad. A good portion of the film is genuinely unwatchable.

This is a film which doesn't seem to have any sort of plot at all, and the social commentary its supposed to have just comes down to lots of visually stunning but utterly incoherent imagery.

It's a story is so badly told it's one of the most confusing movies of recent times. Incoherently told and dramatically lifeless, this film largely feels like a painful, intolerable nightmare you'll want to wake up from immediately.

The thing which makes this so infuriating is how great it looked. Director Ben Wheatley's Kill List was marvellous and for a small British film this had a great cast. The trailers also made the film look great, but it ended up being such a pretentious and annoying mess.

Overall, this is a crushing disappointment and yet another case of lots of talented people being brought together and then being given nothing to do whatsoever.

2. The Monuments Men

What Was Expected

Advertisement

An Oscar-worthy triumph with the great cast, fascinating story and George Clooney's strong directing track record leaving no reason not to be optimistic.

What We Actually Got

This one was a big shock and without a doubt the biggest disappointment of 2014. This is a film with an amazing cast and story, but it takes well over an hour for the story to actually get going, and once it finally does there's simply nothing there.

The truth is, the trailers didn't show a lot, and that's because there's nothing to show. It's one of the most laid-back, relaxed, effort-free films you'll ever watch where nothing much is ever really going on.

Juggling different tones and many different characters and locations, as well as being intensely boring, this is also a complete mess. Admittedly, it's watchable at times and is a two-star film so it's not irredeemable, but it's simply about as bland and shrug-inducing as they come.

1. The Snowman

What Was Expected

Advertisement

One of the best films of the year. How could it not be? With a great cast, a talented director and brilliant source material, this looked like a slam dunk.

What We Actually Got

The Snowman is watchable from time to time, but the actors are wasted, Michael Fassbender gives an extremely rare weak performance, the plot is a confusing mess full of useless subplots and as well as being a film that lacks an emotional pull, it's also largely devoid of actual thrills- and this is meant to be a thriller. It's such a misfire even director Tomas Alfredson has apologized for it.

The movie really makes how bad it is truly clear with one of the worst third acts to a film... well, ever. The big reveal is completely messed up and there are no thrills and no kind of psychological depth. And frankly, the final battle is simply laughable.

In short, it's the epitome of a movie that should've been great but was a complete and utter failure.

Any other disappointing recent films that we've missed? Shout them out in the comments.

Advertisement