15 Oscar-Baiting Films That Hilariously Failed To Win

Sometimes the try-hards just don't get the accolades they so obviously want...

By Jack Pooley /

As the annual campaign for the Academy Awards winds down, it's fun to remember those hopeful films that, months before nominations were handed out, we all expected to be Oscar front-runners. Though the likes of Gravity, 12 Years A Slave and The Wolf of Wall Street have fulfilled their potential this year in terms of scoring major nominations in most significant categories, what about the movies that were so clearly made to win Oscars, that audiences and critics ended up rejecting them? This typically resulted in a disappointing awards performance, be it just one Oscar win, multiple nominations without a win, or even not a single nomination at all. These 15 movies all had lofty ambitions, to tell a worthy, emotional story, and each was clearly vying for year-end awards attention. For every Slumdog Millionaire, there are dozens of movies that tried hard to play the awards game, and either disappointed or flat-out failed on an epic scale. It's a fickle game to play, but these movies were just too eager to earn our hearts, and as a result, they have mostly faded into the cinematic ether. Of course, Oscar bait is subjective, so feel free to add your own suggestions in the comments!

15. Seven Pounds

After scooping his second Best Actor nomination working opposite his son Jaden in The Pursuit of Happyness, Will Smith clearly got a taste for the allure of Oscar gold, and so went to work on scoring a third nomination for Seven Pounds. In the drama, Smith plays a man whose carelessness causes the deaths of seven people, and so he goes about finding a way to redeem himself for his actions. With its mature, serious subject matter, it was widely expected to be a major awards player, though when the movie began screening for critics and awards voters, it became clear that it just didn't measure up. The movie was largely criticised for being mawkish and emotionally manipulative. Though Smith gives one of his better performances, he can only do so much with the script, and so the film went away empty handed, not scoring a single Oscar nomination.

14. Conviction

A tale about a woman (Hilary Swank) putting herself through law school in order to save her brother (Sam Rockwell) who was wrongfully convicted of murder, Conviction has all the makings of an emotionally intense, Oscar-primed experience. To be fair to the movie, though it was far from the best of 2010, Conviction was a straight-forward movie that hit the right emotional beats and benefited from strong work from Swank and Rockwell, though this didn't prove to be enough to scoop a single Oscar nod. The movie did get a nomination from SAG and a few other lesser awards shows, but given the pre-release expectation that this would be an Oscar frontrunner, its non-performance at the Academy Awards was a huge surprise. It's a perfect example of "close, but no cigar".

13. The Lovely Bones

Peter Jackson's The Lovely Bones was one of the sure-fire Oscar bets of 2009: with Jackson's success scooping Best Director and Best Picture honours for The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King, he cemented himself as one of the most successful directors in adapting acclaimed novels. However, with its difficult themes of murder and rape, transferring Alice Sebold's cherished work to the screen was going to prove a challenge, all the more so considering the PG-13 rating Jackson had to deal with. Despite having its release date moved back in the year to a more Oscar-friendly period, The Lovely Bones ended up being a colossal disappointment to fans of the source material and those expecting much of Jackson. Though the movie offered plenty of visual splendour, this felt like a tame interpretation of the movie, de-fanging its thornier themes and turning it into a schmaltzy teen excursion. The movie was panned by most major critics, though Stanley Tucci was almost universally praised for his performance, which earned the movie its sole Oscar nomination for Best Supporting Actor.

12. The Iron Lady

To be fair to The Iron Lady, it was nominated for 2 Oscars and won both of them (Meryl Streep for Best Actress and Best Makeup), but when production began, the Weinsteins were no doubt hoping for a bigger push in meatier categories like Best Picture, Best Director and Best Screenplay. Given the period subject matter, major controversy surrounding Margaret Thatcher, and another Meryl Streep performance (who, if August: Osage County is any indication, can now be nominated for just about anything), it seemed like an Oscar slam dunk. So, what went wrong? For starters, the movie just isn't very good: it focuses far too much on bizarre asides in which Maggie speaks to an apparition of her dead husband Dennis, and skirts around the more contentious issues of Thatcher's active years, such as the sinking of the Belgrano and the miner's strike. So awful was the film, in fact, that it's a shock Streep still managed to win Best Actress, in what is easily one of her noblest failures: she's clearly up to the job, but the script is flat-out terrible.

11. Nine

Nobody likes a pretentious failure, and that's exactly what Rob Marshall's Nine was. Give that Marshall's previous musical, Chicago, won Best Picture at the Oscars (and scooped him a Best Director nomination), Nine was widely touted as a Best Picture front-runner before it even began screening for press and voters, and with an all-star cast including Daniel Day-Lewis, Nicole Kidman, Marion Cotillard, Penelope Cruz, Judi Dench, Sophia Loren and Kate Hudson, why would you expect anything less? Awkwardly straddled between being an aloof, campy musical and serving as a rousing homage to Fellini's 8 1/2, Nine was an ambitious if also rather pompous failure that turned off both audiences and critics in droves. It did scoop 4 Oscar nominations, for Art Direction, Costume Design, Best Original Song, and most peculiarly, a Best Supporting Actress nod for Cruz. Worst of all, Day-Lewis went home without even a nomination, which should be as big an indication of the movie's creative failures as anything.

10. The Soloist

There was considerable buzz around Joe Wright's first contemporary-set drama, The Soloist. The movie revolves around a Los Angeles journalist (Robert Downey Jr) befriending a homeless paranoid schizophrenic musical genius (Jamie Foxx), hoping to help turn his life around while scoring a great story for himself. With a skilled director, two great leading actors and a premise worthy of Oscar glory, what could possibly go wrong? Though The Soloist is actually a pretty decent movie, it just didn't quite have what it takes to become a major awards player, and strangely has largely fallen upon deaf ears since its release. Much criticism was turned towards director Wright, who many critics felt failed to balance the movie's tone while keeping the story focused, and that perhaps after his two successful period movies (Pride and Prejudice, Atonement), he wasn't as readily able to tackle a contemporary story. The movie didn't get a single Oscar nomination or even any consideration on any other major awards shows.

9. A Dangerous Method

One of the most disappointing awards players in recent years, how could a David Cronenberg-directed movie about the feud between Jung and Freud be anything less than a stone-cold masterpiece? What's more, it starred a brilliant trio of actors (Michael Fassbender, Viggo Mortensen and Keira Knightley), was adapted from literary source material, and had period detail that would give it a huge advantage in all the crafts Oscar categories, such as Costume Design and Makeup. In the end, it missed out on Oscar nods entirely, and scooped a single Golden Globe nomination for Mortensen's performance as Freud, as well as a few consolatory nominations from lesser awards shows. Given the potential and the fact that Cronenberg actually managed to secure an R-rating for his movie, it was a surprisingly tame, toothless depiction of what could have been a very sexy story, and as a result the movie was merely watchably decent rather than the electrifying psychological odyssey it should have been.

8. Diana

One of the most blatantly Oscar-baiting movies in recent years was last year's Diana, a biopic of the late Princess of Wales, starring Naomi Watts. From all outside appearances, this had the potential to be a major awards player, and even if it didn't quite measure up dramatically, it would at least be able to score a Best Actress nomination for Watts, and some other below-the-line nominations, right? Diana ended up being one of the most unexpectedly awful movies of 2013, despite as committed a performance as you'd usually expect from Watts. Skirting respectfully around the more notorious details of Diana's demise, the movie instead focuses on a soppy romance between the title character and a heart surgeon, essentially making the film feel like an adaptation of a lame romance novel with the only distinguishing factor being that it's about a famous figure. Watts ironically ended up receiving a Worst Actress Razzie nomination for the movie, which is its sole nomination in any significant awards show.

7. Amelia

A biopic about one of America's most enduring figures, directed by a popular, talented filmmaker, written by several Oscar nominees and starring an actress who has won both Best Actress Oscars she has been nominated for? Amelia should have been an awards slam dunk, but the most disappointing thing about this movie is that it's actually very boring and dull, not what you'd expect of a story about a famous aircraft pilot who disappeared under mysterious circumstances now, is it? You have to feel sorry for Swank, who tries hard but can't really gain any traction with the movie's twee script: she absolutely looks the part as Amelia Earhart, but basically everything else around her is poorly thought out and an absolute slog to sit through. As you can guess, Amelia didn't net a single Oscar nod or anything else on the awards circuit.

6. War Horse

War Horse is far from a terrible film, but it was clear from the moment the first trailer dropped that it was going to be the epitome of Oscar bait. With its visual splendour, epic tone and emphasis on an emotional story while Steven Spielberg directs, there was no question that War Horse would be in the Oscar conversation. The final product was more impressive as a technical feat than as a piece of storytelling, and though it delivered the basic goods, it totally smacked of a film trying oh-so-hard to win Oscars, and that may in part explain why it ultimately got 6 nominations without a single win. One of the more surprising omissions was Steven Spielberg not being nominated for Best Director, given the overall stylistic elegance of the piece, though War Horse did still scoop a Best Picture nod, alongside nominations for Cinematography, Score, Sound Mixing, Sound Editing and Art Direction. The lack of any notices for acting, writing and direction generally make the case clear: this is a technically accomplished movie that doesn't quite cut it in the narrative department.

5. J. Edgar

Clint Eastwood is no stranger to Academy Award recognition as a director, and in recent years it seems that pretty much anything he makes is touted as Oscar bait. This has never been truer than with his J. Edgar Hoover biopic, J. Edgar, starring long-time Oscar-snubee Leonardo DiCaprio in the title role. Few will argue against DiCaprio's solid effort in the lead role, but this is simply too conventional and generic a biopic to be anything more than watchably bland. Skirting around the seedier aspects of Hoover's life, Eastwood plays it far too safe, and frankly, the end result is just pretty boring above all else. The star-worshipping Golden Globes gave DiCaprio a generous Best Actor nomination, and SAG also recognised his efforts with a nod, but the movie didn't garner a single Oscar nomination, and given how much better the movie could have been, rightly so.

4. Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close

Alongside The Blind Side, Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close is one of the most questionable Best Picture nominees of the last decade: despite only scooping one other Oscar nod (for Max von Sydow's decent performance), the movie somehow still made the Best Picture slate, all this with a spate of scathing reviews from critics as well. On paper, though, it's easy to see why it's prime Oscar bait: it's an adaptation of a beloved novel with a 9/11 theme, it stars likeable actors Tom Hanks and Sandra Bullock, is directed by Stephen "Oscar bait" Daldry (The Hours, The Reader), and is written by four-time Oscar nominee and one-time winner Eric Roth (Forrest Gump, The Inside, Munich, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button). It's hard to argue with the movie's good intentions, but it's just too emotionally manipulative and keen to use a major national tragedy to earn your tears. The weird CGI imagery of Tom Hanks falling through the air also seems a bit tacky and tasteless. Thankfully the movie didn't win Best Picture (obviously), and quietly faded into obscurity.

3. Australia

The moment the first trailer for Baz Luhrmann's Australia dropped, it was clear that it was ready-made Oscar bait: with its period setting, fancy costumes, impressive visuals, two likeable leads (Hugh Jackman and Nicole Kidman) and Baz Luhrmann directing in his usual style-over-substance fashion, what was there not to like? Well, as it turned out, the 165-minute Australia was an outrageously over-indulgent melodrama that bored for most of its run-time, certainly giving neither Jackman nor Kidman material suiting their talents, resulting in the film being almost completely shut out of the awards circuit. Its sole Oscar nomination was for Lurhmann's costume designer wife, Catherine Martin, and the majority of its other honours were, unsurprisingly, from various Australian awards bodies looking out for their homeboy. One of the most laughable works of Oscar bait ever conceived, Australia is flat-out awful, if rather nice to look at.

2. The Reader

Stephen Daldry pops up again with The Reader, arguably the most stereotypically Oscar-baiting movie of the last decade. Involving an unconventional depiction of the Holocaust, the much-snubbed Oscar bridesmaid Kate Winslett in the lead role (The Reader was her sixth nomination, and until that point she had yet to win), and writers and directors who have flirted with Oscar before, there was little chance of The Reader not getting nominated. The movie ended up with 5 nominations (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, and Best Actress), with Winslett scooping the movie's single Oscar win. However, the movie being nominated for Best Picture caused a huge industry outrage, as significantly superior films such as The Dark Knight, WALL-E, Revolutionary Road and The Wrestler were all snubbed in its place, which is widely believed to be the reason behind the Best Picture field expanding from 5 nominees to a maximum of 10. Was The Reader a good film? Yes. Was it trying too hard? Yes. And should it have been nominated for Best Picture? No freaking way.

1. The Colour Purple

Some earlier Oscar bait to complete our list now, with Steven Spielberg's good-but-flawed The Colour Purple. The criteria to make it Oscar-baiting are countless: it's adapted from a book, boasts an all-star cast (Danny Glover, Whoopi Goldberg, and Oprah Winfrey), has a period setting, and is directed by Steven Spielberg. What's perhaps most shocking about the movie's awards status is that, despite earning 11 Oscar nominations, Spielberg somehow didn't get an Oscar nod for his direction, which seems like a glitch in The Matrix given how he had 3 prior nominations, and the movie was otherwise so highly regarded by the Academy. Still, the movie hilariously failed to win even a single Oscar, and despite being a pretty decent film overall, is the textbook example of a movie that's good enough for the Academy to recognise, but not to actually award anything outright. It all worked out for Spielberg, though, as he received his fourth directing nomination for Schindler's List eight years later, and went on to finally win the gong that time. Are there any other major works of Oscar bait we missed? Let us know in the comments!