15 Things Horror Remakes Did Better Than The Original

Remakes aren't entirely worthless...

By Robin Baxter /

When it comes to horror, few things annoy people more than remakes. After all, they're pointless beyond measure and are usually pretty weak so it's an undeniable relief that there haven't been very many in the past few years, but are horror remakes always a bad thing?

Advertisement

Interestingly, they do have their advantages. They often add interesting new spins on the old material and although a remake surpassing the original is extremely rare, they often do certain elements better.

Yes, there are those remakes which are worse than the original in every single way (looking at you, Wicker Man) but it's arguable that with the majority of horror remakes, even mostly terrible ones, the filmmakers do take advantage of the opportunity to fix or upgrade something from the original film.

It's like they say: every cloud has a silver lining...

15. Black Christmas (2006) - Claire's Relative

This is an interesting one, since Black Christmas (2006) is one of the worst horror remakes ever made and is an unscary, cringe-worthy and completely dire butchering of the excellent 1974 original, yet it does manage to do something better than the original film. It's a small thing, but still.

Advertisement

In both films, Claire (played by Lynne Griffin in the original and Leela Savasta in the remake) is one of the first of the luckless sorority girls being stalked by a killer to bite the dust and in both cases a relative shows up looking for her.

In the original, a fairly uninteresting father character turns up but in the remake, instead it's Leigh (Kristen Cloke, who horror fans might recognise as Val Lewton in Final Destination), Claire's half-sister.

Leigh is a surprisingly entertaining character and Cloke gives a good performance too. Alongside the reasonably solid protagonist Kelli Presley (Katie Cassidy), she's definitely one of the best elements of this otherwise useless train-wreck of a horror film and the inclusion of this character was a very smart move indeed, since it's one of the only things in the movie that's actually fun.

14. One Missed Call - Pacing

A poorly done horror film without a single scary moment (literally), this is another one of the worst horror remakes out there and it has a rare 0% on Rotten Tomatoes despite having 80 reviews. Ouch.

Advertisement

In fairness though, it was fighting a losing battle from the off since the original One Missed Call (2003), a Japanese horror flick, isn't actually that great and has many issues of its own. One of these is its excessive length and this is something the remake managed to fix.

The original film is nearly two hours and this remake is roughly 80 minutes, yet it is actually pretty faithful and has most of the scenes from the original film. As awful as this remake is, it did have far better and more economical pacing and showed that the original could have told its story in just 90 minutes, which would have improved it.

13. A Nightmare On Elm Street -  Freddy's Backstory

A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) is not ageing well at all, but it still retains a reasonable amount of bite and it's certainly better than this 2010 remake.

Advertisement

A lifeless and sleepy (sorry) horror flick with almost no scares, this is yet another terrible slasher remake that falls short of the original in most, yet not all, areas.

The remake Freddy's backstory far better. In the original, Freddy was a child-murderer when alive and he's going after the children of the adults who killed him after he was released on a technicality and this is just conveyed through exposition.

In contrast, the remake gives Freddy a far nastier and more effective origin story that's shown partly through some very creepy flashbacks, meaning it follows the "Show Don't Tell" rule of screenwriting better.

In the remake, Freddy was a paedophile who sexually abused the main characters at their nursery when they were children; they told their parents, who then killed Freddy.

This was arguably a good narrative change and the only thing in this remake that was actually shocking and disturbing. Yes, it's very unpleasant as well, but the genre is called Horror for a reason.

12. Child's Play - The Protagonists

Though not an outstanding film, Child's Play (1988) is a very entertaining and effective horror film which introduced audiences to Chucky, one of the Greatest slasher movie villains of all time.

Advertisement

After years of rumours, a remake was eventually released in 2019 and it's OK. It's not scary at all and it feels pretty disposable, but the script and cinematography are solid.

Better still, although the film is definitely weaker than the original and has a less compelling incarnation of Chucky as the villain it does do a better job with characterisation in terms of Andy Barclay (Gabriel Bateman), his mother Karen (Aubrey Plaza) and Detective Mike Norris (Brian Tyree Henry).

Henry makes for a very likeable and engaging Mike Norris while the Barclay characters, as well as the mother-son relationship, are well-written and developed as well.

The characters in the original film are OK but a bit under-developed. By making the mother a less conventional, more entertaining character and adding things like Andy being hearing-impaired and struggling with his mother relocating them and having a new boyfriend, this remake makes these characters far more interesting. The cast do a strong job as well.

11. Halloween - The Bracketts

Rob Zombie's 2007 Halloween remake gets far more hate than it deserves since it's an OK-enough modern slasher film that offers some good thrills and character moments. It does ruin Laurie Strode (Scout Taylor Compton) but it also upgrades two of the original's side characters, Annie Brackett and her father, Sheriff Leigh Brackett.

Advertisement

In the original, Annie (Nancy Kyes) was very irritating, but Rob Zombie's remakes offered a far better version of the character, who was played by franchise veteran Danielle Harris.

She's very likeable and engaging, while Harris does a remarkably good job with her and gives a far better performance than the material demanded. She also returned in Rob Zombie's sequel to his remake in 2009. She was one of the few bright spots in that one and as such, her eventual death at the hands of Michael Myers was far more affecting than most slasher movie deaths.

Similarly, Leigh Brackett (Charles Cyphers) is OK in the original, but he's great in the remakes. He's superbly played by horror icon Brad Dourif and is given more nuance and depth this time around.

10. The Ring - The Protagonist

This American remake of the Japanese horror masterpiece Ring is pretty terrible (ignore the inexplicably generous reviews) and worse still, it launched a wave of terrible horror remakes in the noughties, many of which remade either Asian horror movies or slasher flicks. This, combined with two ghastly sequels, ensures that this movie has an awful legacy,

Advertisement

Still, it did surpass the mostly brilliant original film in one area and that's in its protagonist. The original film's protagonist is Reiko Asakawa (Nanako Matsushima) and although Matsushima is very good as Reiko, the character is somewhat underwritten and she doesn't always seem very bothered about the tragic events occurring around her.

In contrast, Rachel Keller (Naomi Watts) is a more engaging, human and compelling lead who's well-played by Naomi Watts, so she is a better main character than Reiko was.

The Ring fails in successfully translating every single other character from the original, especially when it replaces Ring's compelling male lead (Hiroyuki Sanada) with a boring and annoying sidekick (Martin Henderson), but at least it got the lead right.

9. Quarantine - Prelude

The 2007 Spanish horror film Rec is definitely one of the best found-footage horror films out there (although there's not much competition since most such films are dreadful) and the American remake is actually pretty good too. It's very faithful to Rec in a somewhat lazy manner, but in doing that it remained just as disturbing and scary as the first film.

Advertisement

As a result, the two films are more or less on a even keel, although Quarantine's backstory for the zombie outbreak is less compelling than the backstory in Rec.

That being said, there is another big change Quarantine made for the better and that's that it waits a bit longer before diving straight into the quarantined apartment building and viewers are allowed to get to know the characters more.

The original film is only 78 minutes and that does hurt it a bit since the characters aren't given much in the way of development. With Quarantine, the extended opening does work very well and the characters, although still not especially developed, at least feel more relatable.

8. Friday The 13th - The Set-Pieces

The 2009 Friday the 13th remake is a very solid and entertaining effort overall that gets ripped on for no clear reason. Yes, it's very derivative of the earlier films but that doesn't make it bad.

Advertisement

This ultra-loose remake of Friday the 13th (1980), which also has elements of the first three Friday the 13th sequels, actually provides a welcome update on the original since it does the violence, pacing and intensity a hell of a lot better.

Friday the 13th (2009) isn't scary, but this has always been a franchise which offered intensity over scares anyhow and this is a highly brutal, thrilling and punchy horror film that is, all things considered, superior to the original film.

The original film is a solid slasher film but it's ageing awkwardly and feels rather tame with its set-pieces, while it's also let down by uneven pacing. This remake fixes both of those issues but also avoids simply redoing the story of the original film, allowing it to stand as arguably the second-best film (after 1981's Friday the 13th Part 2) in this now forty-year-old franchise.

7. Dawn Of The Dead - The Scares

George A. Romero's Dawn of the Dead (1978) is one of the most iconic and deliriously entertaining horror films of all time but nevertheless, for all of its overwhelming strengths, it isn't actually scary since it's really more of a horror comedy. If you want a scarier, more intense experience, Zack Snyder's 2004 remake will be a better option.

Advertisement

2004's Dawn of the Dead is OK. The characters are weak, the social commentary is ditched and it's ultimately little more than a series of zombie set-pieces, but it is an entertaining viewing and there are more scares than in the original thanks to the ramped-up intensity, more serious tone and the faster, far more frightening zombies.

The original is actually ageing very well for the most part and those gore effects are still stomach-turning, but the zombies not only move slowly but just look like stoners with painted faces, so although George A. Romero criticised how the zombies were in the remake, the fast zombies are considerably better.

These two versions are very different experiences and you'll get different things out of each version; since so many horror remakes are just tedious copies of the original, that's very satisfying indeed.

6. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - The Characters

The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) is a great horror movie and possibly one of the scariest films of all time, but it does have one glaring flaw that brings it down a little: the characters are very underdeveloped.

Advertisement

The performances are fine, but only one of the five main characters - the wheelchair-bound brother of the film's Final Girl, named Franklin - is given much characterisation. Unfortunately, the whiny, obnoxious personality he's given makes him Extremely annoying. Still, in fairness, the villains are great.

With this 2003 remake, it's the opposite case pretty much. The film is an uninteresting and unscary two-star film that has a terrible set of villains, but the protagonists are all pretty good. They're well-played, likeable, feel like real people and none of them are any near as irritating as the original's Franklin. Erin (Jessica Biel) is a good Final Girl too.

Essentially, this remake sorted out the original's biggest flaw but then failed miserably at capturing the brilliant atmosphere, directing and nightmarish antagonistic forces that made the original so unbearably frightening.

5. Invasion Of The Body Snatchers -  The Sound, Visuals And Special Effects

Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) is a brilliant and terrifying work of science-fiction horror that is one of the finest political allegories of all time. Somehow, the first remake is very good as well.

Advertisement

It doesn't quite reach the five-star heights of the original film, but it is still a very frightening and well-judged horror flick that interprets in a concept in a newer, but still compelling fashion. While the original felt like a Cold War thriller, this remake feels like a conspiracy thriller in the vein of movies like All the President's Men. It's also better than the original on a cinematic level.

With chilling camerawork and superb sound-design, this is more memorable on a technical level than the original which, as great as it is, was more straightforward on a visual and sound level.

The remake also has some fantastic special effects and there are some absolutely horrifying scenes of body horror here. These different elements add up to a remake that might not be quite as essential as the original, but is still one of the best horror remakes out there without a doubt.

4. Carrie - Margaret White

This one will be controversial, but it's arguable that 2013's Carrie remake offered a better incarnation of Margaret White than the 1976 film did.

Advertisement

Piper Laurie's performance in the original film is very strong and certainly iconic, but that version of Carrie's insane mother is essentially a hammy pantomime villain and it's impossible to understand why Carrie feels a semblance of affection towards her.

In contrast, Julianne Moore's version of the character is more nuanced and there's a palpable, understandable sense of love between the mother and daughter despite their dysfunctional relationship.

The Carrie remake is OK. It was painfully unnecessary since it added nothing to the masterful original film, but it is still a decent supernatural horror film all things considered and it did at least offer one update on the original film, largely thanks to Julianne Moore's fantastic performance.

3. Let Me In - The Romance

From one 2010s horror remake starring Chloe Grace Moretz to another, this remake of the Swedish vampire classic Let the Right One In is actually really, really good, although there are a few things in it that don't work and it's a little too faithful to the original film.

Advertisement

Let the Right One In is better since it's more complex and ambiguous, but Let Me In comes surprisingly close and it does offer a better love story in many ways, since there's more warmth and emotion between the characters. The original film offers a better exploration of thought-provoking themes and is scarier, but Let Me In has the better romance.

It's actually well worth seeing both the original and remake since not only are both of them really good, but you can appreciate them in different ways too.

2. Suspiria - The Story

Suspiria (1977) is a great horror film that's full of energetic scares, powerful violence and brilliant visuals, but it is very much a visceral experience that's light on story and only runs for 90 minutes.

Advertisement

In contrast, the superb 2018 remake packs a much more intellectual, dramatic punch thanks to its layered, haunting story, heightened complexity and historical context.

Admittedly, the historical stuff doesn't always work, but other than that this is one of the most interesting horror films of recent times. The great performances, especially from Tilda Swinton, also stick out compared to the good but not massively memorable acting in the original.

The original is a kaleidoscopic, brightly coloured nightmare that never lets up in its intensity, but the remake manages to combine fantastic visuals and horrifying violence with a very engrossing and powerful story about national trauma, guilt, motherhood and power, so the remake is far better on a narrative level.

Overall, which is better? It's a close one but, with many apologies to the original, it's arguable that the remake is better since it's such an unusual, artful and entertaining film and it also has a better climax. Still, both are essential viewing.

1. It - Literally Everything

There's no use beating around the bush: 2017's It remake annihilates the original 1990 TV miniseries on every conceivable level.

Advertisement

It's got better acting, better writing, better directing, better pacing, better editing, it's more faithful to the terrifying book, it doesn't shy away from the gore...there just isn't any comparison.

2017's It is a mostly strong studio horror film while the TV film is ageing atrociously and is just a really wooden, tedious bit of television that might be scary for kids, but for adults the fear factor will be practically non-existent.

It's even arguable that the remake delivered a better Pennywise the Clown, for as great as Tim Curry's performance was he was stuck within a fairly weak production. Bill Skarsgard's performance as Pennywise was absolutely terrifying and he totally did this iconic character justice.

It (2017) isn't a masterpiece thanks to the lack of scares and dodgy CGI but it is an impressive, suspenseful and beautifully-acted four star film and there are few remakes in history that trumped the original film as much as this one did.

Advertisement