20 Most Controversial Movies Since 2000
21st century movies that kicked up a storm by pushing things as far as possible.
In one sense, the history of cinema can be viewed as a constant tug of war between the artist and the censor. The former strives to push the boundaries of acceptability and push forward with new and daring modes of expression, while the latter seeks to impose limitations, setting the boundaries of acceptability and "decency", acting as an arbiter of what is deemed morally permissible.
Battling the censors is as present today as it was decades ago - and it's not just the ratings board filmmakers have to contend with; the studios also often seek to impose a lower rating in order to maximize their profit margin. But nevertheless, we've certainly come a long way from the stringent censorship of the past, where uttering the word "damn" caused a stir and actors were only allowed to kiss for a few seconds before it was deemed lewd and inappropriate. And while the boundaries have clearly been pushed way back, movies continue to emerge which challenge our notions of what is acceptable, depicting acts of sex and violence in increasingly graphic style and often offending the sensibilities of the prudish and conservative.
This dynamic has been present in the new millennia just as it has through history - here are 20 of the most controversial movies since 2000 which have kicked up a storm by pushing things as far as possible.
20. The Pornographer
Porn actress Ovidie stars as Jenny in The Pornographer, written and directed by Bertrand Bonello. Jacques (Jean-Pierre Leaud) is at a career impasse - after a number of huge successes in the 1970s making pornographic movies, he suddenly finds himself struggling to make the transition to more artistic productions, but his efforts to make pornography with a more sensual flavour aren't going down well with his investors.
The explicit, unsimulated sex scenes in The Pornographer, released in 2001, ensured that the 21st century was kick-started with a touch of cinematic controversy. Using real life porn stars Ovidie and Titof, the controversial scene which had some up in arms, as Jacques films a sex scene for his film within a film, certainly raised questions about the point at which art and pornography converge. Unfortunately, The Pornographer itself fails to live up to its potential, and what could have been an interesting exercise in the nature of transgressive cinema ends up a long-winded borefest in which uninteresting characters deliver dry, uninspired dialogue. Skip to the sex scene and ignore the rest.
19. Battle Royale
In an authoritarian Japan of the near future, each year a class of schoolchildren are selected to participate in Battle Royale - sent to a remote island, each student is equipped with a weapon and forced to compete in a deadly game where only the last person standing will make if off the island alive. Masterfully directed by Kinji Fukasaku and with a wonderful cameo from the legendary actor/director Takeshi Kitano, Battle Royale pushes the boundaries of on-screen violence like few other films before or since.
The source of its controversy is clear - had the movie featured adults committing the atrocities we see it's unlikely the censors would have batted an eyelid, but since the carnage is carried out by kids it's a different story. Battle Royale was banned in a number of countries on its release, labeled "crude and tasteless" by the Japanese authorities and took eleven years before it was officially released in the US and Canada. All of which was something of an overreaction - Battle Royale's real strengths, beyond the subversive violence, lies is in its scathing commentary on politics and society, not to mention the fact that it's a whole lot of fun to boot.
18. The Passion Of The Christ
Mel Gibson is no stranger to religious-based controversy in his personal life, having made a number of anti-Semitic remarks which irreversibly damaged his reputation. That his movie about the final moments of the life of Jesus, The Passion of the Christ, also faced accusations of anti-Semitism is hardly surprising, although quite how the Anti-Defamation League were able to ascertain this before having actually seen the film is anyone's guess.
Jim Caviezel takes on the role of Jesus Christ as he travels the long road to execution via the path of long and excruciating torture. Gibson pares down the film to the raw essentials, and much of the film's running time is taken up with graphic portrayals of the destruction of Christ's physical form. As with all religious movies, its historical accuracy was called into question (although you could argue the same about the contents of the Bible), but it was the level of on-screen violence which truly got some critics hot under the collar - one even went so far as to describe it as The Jesus Chainsaw Massacre, proving that hyperbole is as commonplace in film criticism as squeamishness.
17. Ken Park
Larry Clark is no stranger to courting controversy - from his early film Kids through to Bully he's proven that he isn't afraid to tackle the subject matter of youthful experimentation warts and all. That his films have sometimes been considered exploitative isn't remotely surprising - underage sex and excessive drug use are common themes, frequently depicted with an unflinching - some might say voyeuristic - camera.
Ken Park is no exception - co-directed with Ed Lachman and based on a story by Harmony Korine, it follows the life of a suicidal teen who casually shoots himself in the head in a crowded skate park. Featuring a roster of lost souls dealing with emotional and physical abuse, it's a sordid tale of masochism, degradation and unfulfilled lives. It's also not particularly insightful - Clark, it seems, is overstretching himself with what seems to be an uncomfortable ongoing obsession with the corruptibility of youth, and by this stage in his career his voyeuristic approach can't help but come across as lewd and exploitative.
16. The Piano Teacher
Another filmmaker who, like Larry Clark, has frequently drawn controversy for his transgressive and subversive approach to making movies is the Austrian writer-director Michael Haneke - unlike Clark, however, Haneke is clearly a filmmaker for whom intellectual grist is of paramount importance, and despite the controversial nature of much of his output it's impossible to deny his depth and maturity.
The Piano Teacher is just one example of Haneke's ability to tackle the obscure darkness residing in human nature with a subtle degree of empathy while at the same time refusing to pull punches. Focusing on the life of Erika Kohut (Isabelle Huppert on fine form) as the eponymous teacher with a penchant for self-mutilation and paraphilia (in which sexual arousal derives from everyday objects and situations - figure that one out if you can), it's an uncompromising yet riveting portrait of a woman for whom bizarre and uncontrollable desires ultimately consume her daily life, one for which Haneke fully deserved the Grand Prix at the Cannes Film Festival.
15. Hard Candy
The internet can be a potentially dangerous place for the young and the vulnerable, the anonymity it affords providing cover for weirdos, perverts and sexual predators who set out to groom children online and lure them into meeting up in the real world. This is the subject matter for Hard Candy, which serves up the concept with a few neat twists, not least subverting the roles played by adult and child and transforming the victim into the aggressor.
Starring Patrick Wilson as photographer with a sordid secret,Jeff Kohlver, and Ellen Page as Hayley Stark, the young girl he attempts to groom online, director David Slade delivers a revenge thriller turned on its head, as Stark lures Kohlver into a trap and tortures him in order to get him to admit his guilt ffor the kidnapping and murder of another girl. Paedophilia is a subject matter likely to draw controversy more than most others, and Hard Candy was no exception - scenes of torture only added more fuel to the reactionary fire. Thanks to fine performances from the leads, especially Ellen Page, Hard Candy is more than the sum of its controversial parts, recalling the misanthropic films of Neil LaBute.
14. The Human Centipede (First Sequence)
Any film which takes Pier Paulo Pasolini's 120 Days of Sodom and the films of Japanese shock master Takeshi Miike as sources of inspiration is bound to ruffle a few feathers and cause a bit of a stir. Throw in some sadistic Nazi experimentation for good measure and The Human Centipede certainly delivers, even if in actual fact very little gore - or feces - is actually depicted on screen.
Writer-director Tom Six got the idea for the film while joking about punishing a child molester by stitching his mouth to the anus of an overweight truck driver, and as twisted as that is from a humour point of view, there's an undercurrent of sick comedy running throughout The Human Centipede, as Dr. Josef Heiter takes great pleasure in stitching unwitting tourists ass to mouth. More than a few squeamish reviewers lambasted the film, labeling it "disgusting" and "repellant" - it's hardly a masterpiece, but perhaps they should develop a better understanding of the objectives of the genre before reviewing horror in future.
13. Hounddog
Deborah Kampmeier writes, directs and produces Hounddog, a coming-of-age drama starring Dakota Fanning as a troubled young girl called Lewellen living in 1950s Alabama who finds comfort in the music of Elvis Presley as darker forces lurk around her. It's a familiar tale told in mediocre fashion, and iif there's a cliche to be found you can be sure that Kampmeier has unearthed it and presented it on screen.
Fanning is perhaps the film's only saving grace, and her performance is the one thing which prevents Hounddog from descending into an almighty mess. Utilizing such a young actress for what many fairly perceived as an unnecessarily exploitative rape scene was far less forgivable than the copious cliches, and the film was roundly panned on its release on account of this scene. It proved to be the final nail in the coffin, while at the Sundance Festival its legacy became reduced to the title "The Dakota Fanning Rape Movie"
12. Baise-Moi
On its release, Baise-Moi was touted by some as something of a feminist answer to the violent excesses of the likes of Quentin Tarantino. Graphic and uncompromising, it tells the story of Manu (Raffaela Anderson) who kills a man with his gun and steals his money before joining forces with Nadine (Karen Bach) and going on a killing spree. To call it unsophisticated would be an understatement - this made little difference to its box office takings, and Baise-Moi was a huge success in its native France.
Unfortunately, the film lacks the great screenwriting and direction of the better movies it seeks to emulate, emerging as a Thelma and Louise pastiche riddled with problems from start to finish. The main drawback lies in its inability to make any interesting points about the onslaught of violence, murder and nudity which gets paraded on screen throughout the film - instead, audiences are treated to cheap thrills and exploitation which in the end comes over as little more than adolescent fantasizing.
11. Requiem For A Dream
Movies about drug addiction are often sources of controversy, with the ongoing debate about the glorification of drug use on screen a constant source of admonition for filmmakers attempting to explore the dynamics of this sensitive subject. Darren Aronofsky's Requiem for a Dream was no exception, although any suggestion that the heroin addicts portrayed are potential role models falls flat when you witness to depths to which their lives plummet.
Still, Requiem for a Dream did cause a storm upon its release, and Aronofsky fought tirelessly with the MPAA in order to try and lower the NC17 rating they wanted to impose on his film. It's a squalid, dirty depiction of both heroin addiction and addiction to weight control amphetamines, and the snazzy editing and mixture of visual styles lends it a deceptively stylish look which sits at odds with the degradation of life and the characters' abandonment of hope as the addiction ruins their lives. It's often unbearably bleak, but then it is adapted from the novel by Hubert Selby Jnr., whose Last Exit To Brooklyn similarly explored moral impoverishment and lives on the brink of collapse.
10. Inside
The home invasion horror subgenre is a tricky one to pull off - with limitations set by the single location and small number of characters, a certain tightness and economy of writing is required in order to sustain the set up for the duration of a movie. Inside, starring Alysson Paradis as a widow awaiting the imminent birth of her child on Christmas Eve and Beatrice Dalle as the woman hell bent on taking it from her womb lies at the better end of the spectrum.
It's certainly a taught, well acted effort, with Dalle in particular clearly relishing the avenging creature she's portraying, and for horror fans who like plenty of blood and gore on display it doesn't disappoint. Making a pregnant woman the object of so much violence certainly upset some viewers, and it's not hard to see why - after all, a movie in which a psychotic woman performs a caesarian section with a pair of knitting scissors seems almost designed to kick up a storm. Relentlessly brutal, Inside is one of the better films to have emerged from the new wave of extreme French cinema.
9. Shortbus
The Pornographer might have kick started the 21st century by causing a bit of a stir with its depiction of unsimulated sex, but Shortbus, released five years later, took on-screen sex to new levels and offered audiences a no holds barred celebration of the diverse sexual lives of New Yorkers, revolving around the visitors to the eponymous salon where experimentation, voyeurism and sexual liberation are openly practiced.
Any movie which features a scene in which two gay men sing the American national anthem whilst pretending their penises are microphones - and hollering into one another's backside - is bound to offend the sensibilities of the more prudish members of any audience, and Shortbus isn't short of further scenes of hardcore sex, penetration and ejaculation throughout its running time. Beyond the explicit scenes, however, lies a delicate portrait of lost souls trying to find someone to connect to in a bit city, and the taste Shortbus leaves after the credits roll is one closer to emotional truths rather than crude and exploitative arousal.
8. Hostel
The "torture porn" label has been around for some time now, but it was Eli Roth's 2005 movie Hostel which kick started it all. Set in Slovakia, it tells the story of a backpacking holiday gone horribly wrong, as a group of unwitting travelers find themselves kidnapped by a powerful group whose clients pay top dollar to torture to death without fear of prosecution from the authorities.
Watching Hostel and you can certainly see where the "torture porn" label came from - Roth's camera isn't shy of fixating on the many scenes of torture scattered throughout the film, as people are drilled, slashed across the throat, attacked with chainsaws before finally being dispatched in all manner of gruesome ways. Perhaps not surprisingly, the bulk of the complaints about Hostel came from the Slovakian people, who were more than a little outraged at having their homeland depicted as a breeding ground for psychopaths. Roth responded that, despite the films in the Texas Chainsaw Massacre series people still visited Texas, and that the geography wasn't the issue but rather Americans' ignorance about the world around them.
7. Nymphomaniac
If you had to pick a director currently working who deliberately goes out of his way to provoke audiences, Lars Von Trier would be as good a choice as any. From his early movies such as The Idiots, which caused great offense for many with its depiction of a group of adults who go around pretending to be mentally handicapped, Von Triers has established himself as the enfant terrible of the international and art house scene.
His latest movie, Nymphomaniac, is clearly no exception, as the title alone implies. Split into two parts and running at four hours long, it revolves around Zoe (Charlotte Gainsbourg), a woman addicted to sex who is taken back to the apartment of a kindly bachelor (Stellan Skarsgaard) after he discovers her beaten in an alleyway, where she recounts her sexual life in all its juicy - and often sordid - detail. Von Triers' interesting method of deconstructing sexual desires by comparisons to fly fishing and the music of Bach makes for a fascinating approach to the subject of nymphomania, but no amount of cleverness disguised the graphic on-screen sex, and the film was unable to avoid the NC-17 rating - not surprising, then, that the studio chose instead to release the film unrated.
6. Team America: World Police
If any movie can be positively said to have been designed to offend as many people as possible, that movie is Team America: World Police, written and directed by South Park creators Matt Parker and Trey Stone. From beginning to end, Team America throws up one crude stereotype after another while lambasting everything from the arrogance of American imperialism to North Korean dictators.
Using Thunderbirds-style puppets certainly allowed Parker and Stone to go to town on the parodies, and there are more send ups than you can shake a stick at, from Michael Moore to Tony Blair and the Queen. Thunderbirds creator Gerry Anderson was just one person who found Team America too much to stomach, complaining about the expletives liberally scattered throughout, while the MPAA returned the movie to Parker and Stone no less than 9 times with an NC-17 rating before finally passing it with an R. Predictably, the person most offended by the film was North Korean leader Kim Jong-il, who even tried to get the Czech Republic to ban it. They refused.
5. Visitor Q
A film which opens with a title reading, "Have you ever done it with your dad?" needs little explanation as to the cause of controversy, and Visitor Q, directed by perhaps the most radical and controversial director currently working in Japan, Takashi Miike, certainly earned its reputation as a movie difficult to stomach.
Opening with an incestual sex scene in which the daughter prostitutes herself to her father - and then increases the price when he ejaculates too early - is pushing boundaries that in real life only a complete pervert would stretch to - that Visitor Q is fairly unrelenting from this point on, as a mysterious stranger seduces each member of the household in turn, shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone who's seen any other Miike films. It's also humorous in that incredibly dark (you might say pitch black) manner that Miike relishes, but any laughter is inevitably followed by an uncomfortable silence as you wait to see what Visitor Q will throw at you in the next scene.
4. Martyrs
Another film often mentioned in the same breath as Inside, Martyrs falls into the category of New French Extremity but bears a closer resemblance to Hostel - at least, on the surface. Years after being tortured as a child in a strange abandoned abattoir, Anna Assaoui (Morjana Alaoui) believes she's finally tracked down the perpetrators and calls on the assistance of a friend Lucie to help her clean up the mess.
Martyrs swiftly moves beyond this revenge thriller conceit upon the discovery of a concealed entrance leading down into a subterranean torture chamber where Anna discovers a half dead woman. When she is accosted by a group of strangers it isn't long before she finds herself being tortured. What sets Martyrs apart from other similar movies is the lofty aspirations which motivate the strange cult performing the torture - rather than getting off on it for their own sadistic gratification, they see themselves as part of a secret society seeking enlightenment regarding the true nature of death, and Anna's role, as the title implies, is not that of a victim but of a trailblazer into new insights into the human condition. Its downbeat ending is one of the most memorable of recent horror movies - needless to say, expect the nihilism to be stripped from the upcoming US remake, given that the first director on board said of the project, "The American approach would go through all that darkness but then give a glimmer of hope."
3. Antichrist
A few years before Nymphomaniac kicked up a stir with its portrayal of a sex addicted woman, Lars Von Trier collaborated with Charlotte Gainsbourg on another project which had people up in arms: Antichrist. Also starring Willem Defoe, Antichrist is the first installment in Von Trier's unofficially titled "depression trilogy", for which the aptly titled Melancholia made up the centerpiece.
The title might seem like it was designed to provoke ire amongst religious organizations - and that was certainly the case on its release - but Von Trier attempts to use his film Antichrist to explore deep theological concerns, albeit within a horror framework inspired by the moody and suspenseful works of Hideo Nakata. Still, graphic scenes of genital mutilation were enough for plenty to be shocked at, regardless of their religious beliefs, and several people were reported to have fainted during a screening of Antichrist at the Cannes Film Festival. It's one of the most provocative films from a director noted for his transgressive approach to filmmaking.
2. Irreversible
You'd have to have spent the last ten years living under a movie-free rock to have avoided hearing about Gaspar Noe's film Irreversible - perhaps only one other movie since 2000 (which we'll get to in a moment) has caused such a storm of controversy on its release. Noe deconstructs the formulaic revenge thriller by reversing the order of the scenes, as Marcus (Vincent Cassel) and his friend Pierre (Albert Dupontel) hunt down the man who raped the beautiful Alex (Monica Bellucci), leaving her for dead in an underpass.
Reversing the chronology, the film begins with the brutal murder of the man thought to be Alex's rapist, as Pierre repeatedly hammers his head in with a fire extinguisher until all that remains is a bloody pulp. Perhaps the most brutal beatdown in cinema history is later followed by one of the most uncompromising rape scenes ever committed to film, as the camera sits directly in front of Alex for all of 9 minutes as she is violated from behind then beaten to a pulp. Everyone from feminists to homosexual rights activists attacked Irreversible, and yet the outrage overshadowed what is actually a more interesting exercise in the nature of fate, shot with technical bravado.
1. A Serbian Film
If there's a controversial movie made since 2000 which has shocked, disgusted and outraged more people than A Serbian Film, we'd love to hear about it. With a set up which reads like a shopping list of themes guaranteed to cause offense - pornography, child rape, necrophilia and snuff movies are all thrown into the mix - it's clearly a movie made with every intent to elicit a response from as many people as humanly possible.
A struggling porn star (Sran Todorovi) agrees to play a part in what he believes will be a more "artistic" porn film and finds himself caught up in a world of more horrors than you could imagine in your worst nightmare, most of which is too shocking to describe here. Shot in digital, the producers found themselves facing questions from the police after sending the film for conversion to 35mm, proving that its controversial legacy began even before anyone else had seen it. Director Sran Spasojevi responded to the slew of criticisms upon its release in theatres by explaining, "It's about the monolithic power of leaders who hypnotize you to do things you don't want to do. You have to feel the violence to know what it's about." While the violence and brutality is depicted in such a dark and disturbing fashion it's hard to accuse him of being exploitative, nevertheless you're left wondering whether his justification of A Serbian Film as a political allegory for Serbia's past is really all that convincing.
Which controversial movies have you seen since 2000? Did we miss anything off the list? Why not let us know and post a comment below?