20 Most Controversial Film Endings Since 2000

Sometimes it's impossible to please everyone.

By Andrew Dilks /

Movie endings come in all manner of shapes and sizes - happy or sad, clear-cut or thoroughly enigmatic, they wrap up the narrative (or perhaps don't) and leave the audience with an overall feeling and understanding of everything that has come before. For the most part, cinematic full-stops are accepted for what they are, but sometimes a film throws a curveball in the final act that generates no end of controversy. Whether that's because the director provocatively ignored the source material, or altered a character's established behaviour fatally, or simply delivered a radical shift or an unsatisfying ambiguous note, the results are invariably the same. Whatever the reasons, some endings cause pandemonium online, with fans and critics alike debating the ins and outs of what they've just seen and stirring the pot further. It's a dynamic which has existed for decades, and if the controversies surrounding movies released since 2000 is anything to go by, it's something which will be with us for some time to come. It goes without saying we're about to enter full-on SPOILER TERRITORY...

20. Kill List

What's it about? While struggling to come to terms with an operation gone wrong in Kiev, Jay (Neil Maskell) is talked into a job by his former army colleague Gal (Michael Smiley) in which they must assassinate three people for a shadowy client. After killing a priest and another man known as the "librarian" who has been cataloguing child porn and snuff movies, they set out to kill their final target - the politician. How does it end? Setting up camp and waiting until nightfall so they can take out the politician, a string of torches suddenly appear in the distance. As the hit men investigate an occult sacrificial ritual is revealed, set up by the cult for the benefit of Jay and pitting him against a most unexpected opponent in which he is forced into a knife fight with a "hunchback". Why was it controversial? The sudden shift from an admittedly very dark thriller into all-out horror territory as the cult reveals itself to the protagonists was considered too jarring and out of place by some critics and audiences. Some horror fans absolutely loved this "twist" ending (I count myself amongst them - director Ben Wheatley handles the genre-hopping very well), but for others the revelation of occultism was frustrating "hocus pocus".

19. Cabin In The Woods

What's it about? Part homage to the slasher film, part complete and total dissection of the horror genre, the Joss Whedon-scripted The Cabin In The Woods follows the ubiquitous group of high school kids as they take a break from civilization and find themselves picked off one by one by a sadistic family. Meanwhile, the audience sees that it's all part of a highly orchestrated and well-funded ritual to appease ancient gods with sacrifices. How does it end? The hapless protagonists survive until the end, thus failing to propitiate the Ancient Ones with their deaths and unleashing them on Earth, bringing about its destruction. Why was it controversial? Believe it or not, some thought the shift up into something as epic as the unleashing of Ancient Gods was taking things too far (hadn't they been paying attention to what went before?). It's a problem a lot of filmmakers have experienced when writing satire - some audiences just don't get it when things aren't meant to be taken literally.

18. The Mist

What's it about? After a thunderstorm knocks out the power in a small town, a group of residents meet up in a supermarket to gather supplies. As they stock up on essentials, a thick mist descends in which human-devouring monsters lurk, trapping the townsfolk inside the building. How does it end? Attempting to flee the supermarket, David (Thomas Jane) leads four others to his car and sets off, but when they run out of petrol he turns his gun on the other passengers and kills them to spare them a fate at the tentacles of the monsters. Moments later the army arrives, killing the monsters that surround the car and saving David's life. Why was it controversial? Aside from changing the ending from Stephen King's original novella (a move King was happy with) it was just too downbeat for some audiences. It's certainly a dark punch in the guts, but this is horror - fans of the genre on the whole were grateful that director Frank Darabont got his way and wasn't forced to tack on a predictable happy ending.

17. The Descent

What's it about? Neil Marshall's horror movie has a threadbare plot: after heading out for a weekend of spelunking, heading down into previously unexplored caving systems, a group of women find themselves being picked off one by one by flesh-eating humanoid creatures who have adjusted to life beneath the surface. How does it end? Lone survivor Sarah (Shauna Macdonald) pulls herself up to the surface caked in blood and speeds off in her car. But then she wakes up, revealing that her escape was a dream and that she's still trapped underground, the creatures closing in around her. The US version omits this reveal, suggesting that she does actually escape. Why was it controversial? The US version was the one which some found to be controversial, lacking the bravery to go full-on dark with the downbeat ending and instead concluding on a note of optimism which felt at odds with the otherwise grim material.

16. Kingsman: The Secret Service

What's it about? Taron Egerton stars as Gary "Eggsy" Unwin, a wayward London youth who is drafted as a potential recruit for a secret spy organization by veteran Kingsman agent Harry Hart (Colin Firth). As he undergoes his training his operations become "real world" as Richmond Valentine (Samuel L. Jackson with a wonderfully ridiculous lisp) prepares to trigger the end of the world. How does it end? Inside Valentine's secret base, Eggsy discovers a princess trapped in one of the cells who promises him anal sex if he saves the world and rescues her. After killing Valentine he returns to her cell to collect his "reward". Why was it controversial? Some feminist groups didn't take too kindly to what they saw as a crass joke, accusing director Matthew Vaughn of being a "misogynist". As well as being a deliberate exaggeration of the familiar Bond girl ending, Vaughn argued that it was actually empowering and should be taken with tongue firmly in cheek.

15. Source Code

What's it about? Captain Colter Stevens (Jake Gyllenhaal) wakes up inside the body of school teacher Sean Fentress as part of the government's secret Source Code program, in which he occupies the body for the last 8 minutes of the man's life in order to track down a terrorist bomber on a commuter train. Each time he fails he is sent back into the Source Code to attempt to complete the mission again. How does it end? Having successfully prevented the terrorist from setting off the bomb, Stevens' colleague Captain Goodwin (Vera Ferminga) receives an email telling her that history has been changed and to inform Stevens from the new timeline that "everything is going to be okay". Why was it controversial? Source Code's ending was certainly confusing for many, which is one good reason why people kicked up a fuss. With the terrorist attack prevented, what happened to the Stevens from the previous timeline? Was he trapped in the body of Fentress, or was he dead? Director Duncan Jones pointed to a parallel reality in which a Stevens existed both inside Fentress and also at the military facility, no longer needed for a mission which doesn't exist. You can listen to his explanation in full here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9TCkUUAKoQ

14. Shutter Island

What's it about? U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels (Leonardo diCaprio) arrives at the titular island and home to the criminally insane to investigate the inexplicable disappearance of one of its patients. As the probe deepens and he uncovers sinister practices, it is revealed that the agent has ulterior motives for his visit - to track down Andrew Laeddis, the arsonist who killed his wife.How does it end? With the revelation that Daniels is in fact Laeddis, and that his "arrival" at the island and subsequent investigation was a role play arranged by his doctors in order to come to terms with the fact that he murdered his wife after she'd drowned their children. At first appearing to understand, the film ends with him reverting back to the Laeddis persona and being taken away for a lobotomy. Why was it controversial? A lot of people read a degree of ambiguity into the ending which isn't really there - the twist reveal in which Daniels is shown to be Laeddis is clear cut, something which is even more self-evident on a second viewing. Perhaps more ambiguous is the degree of madness in his character, particularly in light of his last line, "which would be worse €“ to live as a monster, or to die as a good man?" implying that he may be faking his relapse. There's a place for interpretation here, and the idea that perhaps he has a flash of realisation that he is actually insane and welcomes his lobotomy ends Shutter Island on its most satisfying note.

13. Gone Girl

What's it about? Following on from the disappearance of his wife, Amy (Rosamund Pike) Nick Dunne (Ben Affleck) comes increasingly under suspicion as being the primary suspect for her murder. But Amy isn't quite as gone as people think, and a complex plot to frame her husband is slowly revealed. How does it end? After a television appeal from Nick urging his wife to return home, Amy murders an old lover, making it look as if he'd kidnapped her before returning to Nick's side. Nick threatens to reveal her sociopathic nature to the media but stops when she announces that she is pregnant. Why was it controversial? Those who like to see that justice is served in the conclusion of thrillers were none too pleased that the film (and also the book) ended with this decidedly amoral status quo. Amy literally gets away with murder while Nick is stuck in a relationship with the woman who tried to frame him for murder. Director David Lynch isn't shy when it comes to twisted endings like this one, although his depiction of such a psychopathic woman led some feminists to lambasted it with the same accusations they'd levelled at the author of the original Gone Girl novel, representing a "deep animosity towards women."

12. It Follows

What's it about? After having sex with her date near an abandoned building, Jay (Maika Monroe) is tied to a wheelchair and shown a strange person insistently walking towards her, whom her date tells her is an otherworldly entity which will kill her if she lets it get near her. Only by sleeping with someone else can she pass on the curse. How does it end? With the help of her friends, Jay waits for the entity to find her in the school swimming pool where they plan on luring it into the water and electrocuting it with household appliances. Instead, Jay's friend shoots the entity in the head as it tries to drown her in the water. Why was it controversial? Having behaved relatively rationally throughout the movie, the plan to electrocute the entity in the water - with no evidence to suggest that this could work - was considered by some viewers to be out of keeping with the decisions they'd made up to that point. Director David Robert Mitchell defended the ending, saying, "It€™s a kid-movie plan, it€™s something that Scooby-Doo and the gang might think of, and that was sort of the point ... instead, they do their best to accomplish something, and we witness its failure." Could that mean a sequel is on the way?