20 Things You Didn’t Know About Whiplash

There is more to this intense character musical drama than meets the eye...

By David Ng'ethe /

Damien Chazelle is commonly hailed as one of today’s most talented filmmakers. His 2014 breakout Whiplash cemented him as a trailblazing director and with good reason. The character study is an unsettling and well-crafted exploration of ambition and the price one pays in the search for perfection.

Advertisement

These themes are expertly embodied by Andrew Neiman and Terence Fletcher, the picture’s leads. Played to near-perfection by Miles Teller and J.K. Simmons, respectively, the teacher-student duo’s increasingly taut relationship highlights the dangers of obsessing over technical flawlessness and sky-high success in whatever field one is pursuing.

The movie’s decision to focus on jazz is an inspired one, as it lends its thematic content a level of stylistic flair that is propped up by the filmmaking on display. The film’s editing, sound design and subtle bits of musical accuracy deftly complement the aforementioned performances and create a viewing experience that is both disconcerting and remarkable to witness.

With all this working towards to the drama’s benefit, it is unsurprising that it garnered critical success, a decent (if relatively mild) box office haul as well as a triumphant awards run. Simmons won a well-earned Oscar for Best Supporting Actor (in addition to similar awards in the Golden Globes and BAFTAs) and served as Chazelle’s launching pad into bigger and flashier fare.

Nearly a decade later, the intense jazz-centric flick still has a fair number of hidden details to offer its fans and cinephiles in general.

20. The Leads’ Surprising Musical Talent

It does not hurt to have actors who are musically talented (or at least musically inclined) when bringing a rhythm-heavy story like Whiplash to life. That kind of talent lends the proceedings a level of realism that simply cannot be replicated with a combination of professional doubles and clever editing alone.

Advertisement

While the 2015 Best Picture nominee certainly had its fair share of stand-in and filmmaking magic at its disposal, Miles Teller and J.K. Simmons’s respective musical backgrounds ensured that their characters’ talents were well-realized as far as their musical talent was concerned.

Teller had been playing drums since he was 15 and took on additional classes before filming to sell Andrew’s sublime skill on screen. Simmons on the other hand has a musical degree and played piano in the past and was able to sink into his role after a bit of practice before filming began.

19. Enforced Method Acting For The… Win?

Despite having a relatively brief career, Damien Chazelle has built a reputation for being a very hands-on director who fixates on precision in the footage he captures. While this ensures that his projects are finely-tuned, it does not always lend itself to the most conducive filming environments.

Advertisement

For example, Miles Teller’s drumming scenes (the punishing ones in particular) felt authentic because the actor was exhausted while shooting those sequences. Chazelle would let the scene play out until his lead had nothing left in the tank, never even yelling “Cut” in the process.

These scenes definitely left an impact on audiences, but Teller would have probably preferred a more relaxed means of conveying his character’s toils than exhaustive take after exhaustive take.

18. Buddy Rich And Foreshadowing

Near the movie’s beginning, Andrew is seen listening to Birdland by legendary jazz drummer Buddy Rich. On the surface this seemed like a neat little bit of character building, but keen jazz fans in the audience probably saw the added layer that the album suggested.

Advertisement

Rich was known for his firebrand temper (even feuding with the likes of Frank Sinatra and Dusty Springfield) and this short fuse saw him insult his bandmates when their musical craft was perceived to be below what he expected.

The jazz legend’s persona is not far removed from Terence Fletcher’s own explosive portrayal and it is clear that the album’s presence served as a harbinger of what the young drummer was to experience.

17. Sometimes, Absurd Dialogue Works

While the 2014 feature is not an exact carbon copy of the 2013 short film that inspired it, there is one line of dialogue that made its way into the big screen that surprised one of its leads.

Advertisement

After having successfully played Andrew to his own twisted whims, Fletcher decides to verbally abuse the unfortunate freshman during which the cruel instructor menacingly states that he “will f**k him like a pig”.

Initially, the line was supposed to be “I will gut you like a pig” but Chazelle found the former hilarious (especially since that Simmons misspoke while delivering the line) and opted to use it despite J.K. Simmons deeming the colorful piece of dialogue ridiculous. This explains why the scene cuts to Andrew's face when Fletcher utters the ludicrous line.

16. Ignoring Studio Notes Paid Off

Few things are dreaded by filmmakers during the process as much as invasive studio notes, and Damien Chazelle is one such individual who has had to deal with possibly out-of-touch industry bigwigs.

Advertisement

During a 2017 Oscars screenwriting event, the director pointed out that studio executives suggested that the climactic drumming scene in Whiplash be trimmed for brevity’s sake. The auteur decided to ignore the studio notes and the rest is history.

While some may consider the near ten-minute sequence a bit indulgent, it actually serves the story as well as Andrew and Fletcher’s different journeys. Here, Andrew is shown to have become exactly what Fletcher wanted, and what his father (Paul Reiser) feared the most would happen to his young son.

15. Andrew Appears In Every Scene

One thing that stands out about Whiplash is that its protagonist is in every scene from start to finish. It is possible that this was due to budgetary/logistical constraints, but regardless, it works in the film’s favour as audiences get to experience the new world of Schafer Conservatory alongside Andrew and his descent into obsessing over perfection.

Advertisement

A few months after the movie’s release, one of its deleted scenes was put out for the world to see. In it, Fletcher is seen listening to music in his apartment after a long day at the job. This scene paints the otherwise harsh instructor in a more positive light than his other appearances.

Jason Reitman convinced Damien Chazelle to omit the scene from the final cut as its presence would have distracted from Andrew’s journey and the immersion that came along with it.

14. The Film’s One Dubious Honour

Whiplash definitely has its fans, got stellar reviews upon release and won a slew of awards (especially for J.K. Simmons’s performance). This level of success unfortunately did not quite translate to its box office earnings.

Advertisement

The film made just shy of $50 million at the box office, only of which 13.1 million came from North America. Technically, this is a success seeing that the film cost a mere $3 million and was always considered an indie underdog next to the likes of Birdman and Boyhood.

That said, the feature is one of the lowest grossing Best Picture nominees, making less domestically than The Hurt Locker, which was the lowest grossing Best Picture winner until 2021’s Nomadland. While box office receipts are not the sole bar for success, it is a shame that the film did not reach a wider audience.

13. Taking The Phrase” Break A Leg” To The Next Level

Acting is for the most part a demanding physical activity. This is due to factors such as the long shooting schedules and forms of physicality and/or skillsets that may be far removed from the actor’s own capabilities.

Advertisement

That said, some actors took the dedication to their craft a bit too far, and Miles Teller and J.K. Simmons fall into this not-so enviable position. The picture’s intense musical sequences saw Andrew drumming for so long that he began to form blisters and actually bleed in some cases. This was closer to reality than one would expect, as Teller did bleed while filming these exhaustive scenes.

Simmons himself had a nasty taste of intense acting after he cracked a rib during the scene where Andrew violently confronts Fletcher. These scenes may have achieved their desired intent but there was no need for the leads to endure these on-set accidents.

12. What Could Have Been

Right now, it is hard to imagine anyone else playing Andrew Neiman the same way Miles Teller did. His portrayal of a doe-eyed freshman descending into an unhealthy state of obsession felt painfully authentic and was able to stand on its own next to J.K. Simmons’ towering performance.

Advertisement

This is why it was somewhat surprising to learn that Teller may have not gotten the role during the early days of the film’s development. Johnny Simmons (Evan Almighty, Scott Pilgrim) played Neiman in the story’s 2013 short film version and was slated to reprise his role due to Teller’s unavailability at the time.

Ultimately, Teller’s schedule opened up and he won the role due to his experience as a drummer and his larger status in the industry. In addition to this, Dane DeHaan passed on the role in order to star in The Amazing Spider-Man 2, a decision that he probably is not too proud of.

11. The Talented (But Fictional) Jackie Hill

During his first date with Nicole (Melissa Benoist) in a pizza parlor, Andrew hears a song on the radio and immediately identifies it as being a 1938 piece from an artist known as Jackie Hill.

Advertisement

While the scene works for narrative purposes, what stands out about is that Jackie Hill is not a real-life artist.

A solid chunk of the jazz music heard in the background was actually created by composer Justin Hurwitz, who did an admirable job in capturing the stylings of 1930s American jazz. The reason why they chose original music for that sequence was due to budgetary constraints, but Hurwitz was able to work around this by creating an artist (and music) fitting for the film’s story.

10. A Rather Unexpected Turn At The Academy Awards

The various awards that make up the Oscars (and awards bodies in general) have had their fair share of controversy and confusion over the years. From unnecessary categories, baffling wins and misplaced nominees, the most prestigious time of the film year can be an unwieldy beast to predict and control.

Advertisement

Whiplash was not spared this kind of bewildering treatment during the 2015 awards season as it received an Adapted Screenplay nod at that year’s Oscars instead of the expected Original Screenplay nod. Damien Chazelle noted that, although the short film’s existence led to the feature being shot, it was meant to serve as a proof of concept that a feature film could work, meaning that the screenplay was indeed, an original piece of work.

Award misplacement aside, it is without doubt that the flick’s three Oscar wins were anything to be complained about.

9. One Of The Movie’s Most Well-Known Lines Is From A Meme

Referencing memes (or internet culture in general) in film is always a tricky line to walk as half-hearted attempts to “plug into the online discourse” can easily leave your story feeling dated in a couple of years. That said, it is possible to add the odd reference or two without it detracting too much from the movie.

Advertisement

This was seen after Terence Fletcher rips into Andrew for not knowing if he was on time or not during the picture’s first act. At some point, the Draconian instructor asks the embattled student if he looks like a “double f***ing rainbow”, a reference to the late YouTuber Paul “Yosemite Bear” Vasquez who enthusiastically reacted to seeing the natural phenomena.

The inclusion of the line does not quite ruin the immersion of the scene, but it must have served as an unexpected bit of amusement for some viewers in an otherwise tense scene.

8. An Effective Bit Of Improvisation

Since the 2014 feature is largely similar to the 2013 short that inspired it, one would assume that there was no room for improvisation in the final product. This is not the case, however, as J.K. Simmons made up one line on the fly during filming, and its inclusion in the final cut was the best call.

Advertisement

During the infamous scene where Fletcher berates a tearful Neiman, the former calls his student a “self-righteous little prick”. On the surface, this line might be yet another of Fletcher’s harsh barbs, but this takes on new meaning when you remember that Andrew told his instructor his backstory and that Fletcher saw it as a means to further belittle the young drummer’s dreams.

In addition to the above searing line, the moment where Fletcher slapped Andrew was very much real after Simmons and Teller agreed to not mime the action.

7. The Picture’s Swift Filming To Festival Circuit Pipeline

It’s no secret that Chazelle’s 2013 short essentially served as a proof of concept to get a bigger budget meant to realize what would eventually become the 2014 feature. The process to get to this point, however, is stunning in its brevity.

Advertisement

The film itself was shot in a breezy 19 days, with actors being on set up to a grueling 14 hours a day. After shooting came to a close, Chazelle and editor Tom Cross cut the film in a few weeks so as to make the 2014 Sundance Film Festival deadline.

All in all, the entire process took 10 weeks from the first day of filming to the final edit. While speedy filming schedules are sometimes questionable, this one paid off handsomely at the end of the day.

6. The Film’s Real-World Inspiration

It is commonly suggested in storytelling that your narrative will be well-served by drawing on your own experiences. While “write what you know’ is not the only means to craft a compelling tale, it certainly helped Damien Chazelle when he was developing Whiplash.

Advertisement

The La La Land filmmaker mentioned that he based the narrative on his time in band school (specifically Andrew’s struggles) on what he went through during that time. Fortunately, the director was not subjected to physical abuse as his protagonist was. That said, he did mention that he was greatly intimidated by his band leader's presence during practice.

It would be safe to say that Andrew (and Chazelle)’s experiences under a sadistic teacher/authority figure were relatable to many viewers regardless of profession/area of study.

5. A Hint Towards The Depths of Fletcher’s Cruelty

Before Andrew performed for the first time in Fletcher’s class, we get to see what kind of teacher (and person) the latter is after he viciously scolds a student for not knowing if they were out of tune or not. Shortly after, Andrew finds himself in the hot seat as he struggles to be on Fletcher’s tempo.

Advertisement

At first it seemed like the aspiring drummer still had some ways to go before he could keep up with a teacher of Fletcher’s calibre, but this was far from the truth.

It turns out that Andrew was on his instructor’s time and played the beat as expected, but Fletcher is deliberately gaslighting his student into being a better (his version, at least) musician.

4. Misinterpreting History

Early on in the film, Fletcher recounts the well-known (at least in jazz circles) tale of legendary drummer and bandleader Jo Jones hurling a cymbal at Charlie Parker for making a mistake during practice. This in turn pushed the renowned saxophonist to refining his craft to an obsessive degree.

Advertisement

This interaction foreshadows what Fletcher would eventually do to Neiman, but beyond that, is completely false. While Jones did throw a cymbal at Parker, he threw the instrument at the latter’s feet. This was done to tell Parker to get off the stage because veteran musicians were not keen on his improvisational style (something he later became popular for).

This mistaken recounting of history (plus Andrew’s own false beliefs about the jazz legend) might showcase the student and teacher’s warped perspectives on perfection and how to achieve it, or was simply an error that no one set noticed/bothered to correct.

3. Damien Chazelle’s Unnerving Commitment To Filming

As mentioned before, the Oscar-winning director is very particular about his craft, and he is not one to let any hurdle stand in the way of creating his vision. This was taking to unsettling heights during the filming of his 2014 opus, where the-then 28-year-old got into a car accident.

Advertisement

This is in itself horrifying as Chazelle had to be hospitalized after having suffered a concussion. However, what makes this particular anecdote rather bizarre is that he returned to work the next day in a scenario and level of commitment similar to what Andrew went through during the film’s second act.

While it is incredibly fortunate that the storyteller was not gravelly injured, this was a creepy instance of the lines between art and life becoming increasingly blurred.

2. The Surprising Contrast Between Andrew And His Idol

Throughout the movie’s run, it is clear that Andrew takes his practice seriously and is willing to push himself to a harmful extent to perfect his craft. He is shown practicing day in and day out so that he can become a jazz great in the vein of a legend such as Buddy Rich.

Advertisement

Ironically, Rich was known for two things in addition to his unconventional style and tumultuous life. He did not receive any formal training (instead honing his craft as part of a vaudeville act from an early age), claimed to have never practiced and did not even know how to read music, instead relying on a fellow drummer to play an upcoming chart that he would then memorize it in that moment.

While this highlights the stark differences between skills borne of talent and those developed after years of hard work, it also sadly underscores the absurdity of Andrew’s obsession to be one of the greats.

1. The Reason Behind The Ambiguous Ending

One of its most famous attributes, Whiplash’s ending was the source of debate for a great number of film fans over the years. While it is suggested that Andrew is on the path towards perfection and succession and he overcame Fletcher’s initial plan to sabotage his career and even won his approval, it all comes at the expense of his wellbeing.

Advertisement

Damien Chazelle mentioned that Andrew’s skill as a drummer was bound to grow, but it would come at the expense of his mental health and in the process, he lost some of his humanity. However, he did note that that the intense process could be productive in the right scenario, just not in music school.

Either way, the director does not see a happy ending for his story’s protagonist, and any other conclusion would simply undermine the film’s message.

Advertisement