20 Things You Didn't Know About A Serious Man

Shedding light on little known facts about the Coen Brothers' most personal film.

By David Ng'ethe /

The Coen Brothers' award-winning A Serious Man is equal parts quirky and somber, following math professor Larry Gopnik (Michael Stuhlbarg)'s crisis of faith as he goes through a series of difficult and surreal events in his life. The film's oddities and whimsical yet bleak tone are grounded by a fantastic breakout performance from Stuhlbarg, who perfectly conveys Gopnik's mild-mannered nature and sells his reaction to his current woes.

Advertisement

The film's exploration of faith and one's religious leanings (specifically Judaism) is thought-provoking and honest, even if its sequence of events becomes increasingly and hilariously absurd. Larry's questions and feelings of hopelessness are elements that most viewers can relate to on some level and the everyman's journey to answering these questions mirror real-life scenarios fairly well.

Such a film with a surplus of thematic as well as narrative-based content is bound to be filled to the brim with trivia that may have escaped viewers, especially on their first viewing. The trivia covers a wide range of topics from the film's musical choices, Biblical inspiration, references to other Coen works and even the film's unlikely narrative beginnings.

20. The Possible Meaning Of The Mentaculus?

In the film, Larry's brother, Arthur (Richard Kind) is working on the Mentaculus, a 'probability map of the universe' - a notebook filled with intricate doodles that supposedly detail the known universe's structure. This is obviously a virtually impossible endeavor to undertake, but it fits well in the quirky world the film has created and ties into its theme of making sense of a chaotic world.

Advertisement

It is interesting to note that the eccentric mathematician's cosmic cartogram contains a page with the words 'Higgs-Boson' written backward. This is a clear reference to the Higgs-Boson particle (infamously known as the God Particle), a fundamental particle in quantum physics that is used to explain why objects in the universe have mass.

Given how Arthur wrote the particle's name in his map, in addition to its nature, can be interpreted as Larry trying to ground himself in an increasingly confusing world.

19. ''What's Going On?!''

The embattled Larry asks this question several times throughout the movie, and with good reason. The professor's personal life is gradually falling apart in an often surreal manner and it is only natural that he would attempt to make sense of it. The occasions when the question is dropped are often accompanied by similarly-themed questions/statements such as ''Why is this happening to me'' and ''I didn't do anything.''

Advertisement

This is a natural reaction from a man such as Larry, an individual whose passive morality would lead him to attempt to absolve himself of the events that he may see as divine punishment. The lack of direct guidance from the Rabbis he interacts with only furthers the idea that comprehending God's motives and actions is an ultimately futile act.

The lack of clarity is cemented in the Gopnik household, where Larry directs his most notable question to his children, who do not even bother to provide the slightest hint to their bewildered father.

18. The Art Of The Possible

In one of Larry's nightmares, Sy Abelman (Fred Melamed) appears to him in a dream and paraphrases former German chancellor Otto von Bismarck's famous quote to him, framing it as ''mathematics is the art of the possible.''

Advertisement

Given the original meaning of the saying, it is a possible reference to (the often difficult) compromises Larry had made in his family and professional life. These include moving out of his home to accommodate Sy Abelman's relationship with his wife Judith (Sari Lennick), looking after his older brother Arthur, taking a bribe from one of his students, and even paying for Sy's funeral despite his financial troubles.

The paraphrasing of the quote may also symbolize Sy's manipulative and selfish nature and it may be Larry's way of trying to see through the laidback and gentle front Sy affects in order to make sense of his marital woes. It would make sense, given how the nightmare is set in his lecture room, and prior to Sy's visit he was solving a complex mathematical equation.

17. Alternate Casting Choices For Larry Gopnik

Michael Stuhlbarg was not the only actor considered for the role of Larry Gopnik. Marc Maron and Patton Oswalt auditioned for the role before it went to the Broadwalk Empire alum, an inspired piece of casting that gave Stuhlbarg new levels of notoriety.

Advertisement

There is no doubt that Maron and Oswalt would have made fine casting choices due to their Jewish background and comedic chops but Stuhlbarg knocked the role out of the park. He effortlessly conveyed Larry's mild-mannered but increasingly exasperated nature and his line delivery (especially his delivery of the famous ''What's going on?'' line) helped create a character that is seriously out of depth in his current life.

Interestingly, Stuhlbarg originally auditioned for the role of the Jewish man in the film's opening, but was at a disadvantage due to his inexperience in the Yiddish language. Fortunately, the Coens overlooked this and chose to cast him as Larry due to the strength of his audition.

16. ''All The Hope Within You Dies''

Following Danny's near-miss of a Bar Mitzvah ceremony, the young Gopnik is sent to the famed Rabbi Marshak for spiritual advice. Given how the boy is stoned and the Rabbi has been set up as an aloof traditionalist, hilarity is bound to ensue.

Advertisement

The encounter is amusing as expected, but not due to the age difference or presence of marijuana in the mix. Seemingly unaware of the boy's current state, the spiritual leader gives Danny his transistor radio and he misquotes ''Somebody to Love'' by Jefferson Airplane, a 1967 song that Danny was listening to when it was confiscated by his teacher.

The song (and more so the Rabbi's misquote of it) is apt as it shows unexpected common ground between the elderly teacher and young Gopnik son, and as a thematic bonus highlights Larry's ever-increasing despair due to his current situation.

15. The Film's Setting And Its Religious Basis.

During his Bar Mitzvah, Danny reads a portion of the Torah known as Behar (part of the Pasha cycle), a section that details the events of the Jubilee Year. This year includes events such as the return of slaves as well as ancestral land. The reading of the portions takes place on an annual basis and due to this, it is implied that the event takes place in early May, 1967.

Advertisement

This portion may have been selected due to its preceding of Bechukotai, the next portion of the cycle. This portion is read together with the Behar by Jewish communities in the diaspora and is well known for its stance on obeying the law and consequences for not following it.

It also comments on the dangers of being faint of heart (something Larry is known for). Finally, the significance of 1967 may also boil down to the fact that Joel Coen himself had his Bar Mitzvah in the same year.

14. Acknowledging The Coens' Production Posse

Mary Zophres is a costume designer who has worked with the Coens on the vast majority of their films and even received an Oscar nod for her work on 2018's The Ballad of Buster Scruggs. As a token of appreciation, the directing duo named one of Larry's students after her when he was changing one of his students' grades following extensive..' persuasion' from a student who comically misunderstands the fundamental idea behind examinations.

Advertisement

This act of gratitude was extended to other crew members that worked on the film, as their names also featured in Larry's grade book. In addition to this, the film's location manager, Tyson Bidner features as the magbiah (the individual who lifts the Torah scrolls) at Danny's Bar Mitzvah due to his past experience in the role.

13. A Boy, A Blunt And The Unlikely Makings Of A Film

The whole film owes its existence to young Danny Gopnik's Bar Mitzvah, or at least the idea of it. The film was already envisioned as a short film by the Coens that was focused on the rite of passage and the Gopnik family's youngest being stoned on his big day. The directing duo claimed that they based Rabbi Marshak on a spiritual leader from their youth who was just as enigmatic and wizened as his onscreen counterpart.

Advertisement

It is easy to see how the rest of the film's elements emerged from this idea due to the Coens' childhood experiences, as well as the sheer hilarity/absurdity of a stoned teen meeting an aloof elder. Furthermore, this (in addition to the children in the film named after the directors' childhood friends) cements the film as one of the more personal and relatable entries in the Coens' filmography.

12. The Film's Indirect Endorsement From Harold Ramis

It is a fairly well-known fact that esteemed actor and director Harold Ramis preferred directing and writing to acting. This was evident in his choices as one of the many behind-the-scenes creative voices in films such as Ghostbusters (in addition to having a starring role), Groundhog Day, and National Lampoon's Vacation.

Advertisement

So it came as something of a surprise when his daughter, Violet Ramis Stiel, stated in her memoir that A Serious Man was one that the late filmmaker was interested in acting in. She stated that he never got the chance to be in the film despite auditioning for a yet unknown role.

It is interesting to speculate on what the role could have been, though it is easy to imagine him in the role of Sy Abelman due to Ramis' calm demeanour and would have served as a fitting final film for the comic giant.

11. The Coen Cinematic Universe?

It is no secret that the films directed by the Coens have narrative and thematic similarities that tie them together despite their seeming differences at the surface. Some of the most notable themes in their films include the questioning of God, the worth of artistic value and integrity as well as the nature of evil in human beings.

Advertisement

A Serious Man and the 2008 film Burn After Reading both share the Tuckman Marsh law firm, a nice reference that may for some fans tie the films into a shared universe of sorts. It helps that the films are tonally similar, so it is natural that keen viewers see these similarities as signs of interconnectivity.

Unfortunately, the Coens disproved this theory and could not see the connection between their characters so the theory does not hold water. However, this does not rob the films of their whimsical yet profound connective threads, even if it is unofficial for the time being.

10. Growing Old And Alone

Nearly every scene set in the Gopnik household has the Yiddish folk song ''The Miller's Tears'' playing in the background. The song's (composed by Ukrainian-American singer Sidor Belarsky) subject of a sad miller living out the rest of his days alone and away from his mill mirrors Larry's current fears and struggles to some degree.

Advertisement

The song's subject is an allegory for late 19th-century anti-Semitic expulsions that took place in Czarist Russia. These expulsions, known as pogroms, was triggered by the assassination of Tsar Alexander II and the accompanying belief that the conspirators were of Jewish origin. However, only one of these individuals was of Jewish descent but unfortunately, the Russian media exaggerated the presence of Jewish people, sparking the riots.

The pogroms saw mass forced migrations of Eastern European Jews to countries such as the United Kingdom and the United States and it would not be far fetched to assume that the Gopniks may be descended from immigrants fleeing the riots. Furthermore, the song's turmoils mirror Larry's own eviction, both physically (when he lives at the motel) and metaphorically (he is uprooted from a sense of normalcy due to the movie's events).

9. Hire Ron Meshbesher

Don Milgram (Adam Arkin), Larry's divorce lawyer, proposes he hires Ron Meshbesher, a prominent lawyer who also happened to be a real-life person. This suggestion is made once it is discovered that Arthur is charged with solicitation and sodomy, accusations that are beyond the scope of a typical divorce lawyer.

Advertisement

The choice to use Meshbesher in the film was influenced by the Coens seeing ads featuring the esteemed attorney in their childhood days. However, Meshbesher wasn't as well-known in the late sixties as the movie portrays as he was still making a name for himself in the legal arena.

Despite the anachronistic choice, the film still had scenes set in the Minneapolis office of Meshbesher and Spence as a homage to the celebrated advocate and to highlight how desperate Larry's situation has become.

8. The Film's Title Drop

It is common for films to mention their titles, and this artistic choice varies greatly from film to film (see Jurassic Park and Suicide Squad for how to and how to not do this respectively). The Coens chose to use this device to highlight its protagonist's nature and his role in the film's increasingly surreal events.

Advertisement

The film's title is used in reference to Sy Abelman might be an allusion to the book ''the Ethics of Ambiguity'' by Simone de Beauvoir. In the book, she describes a serious man as ''someone who gets rid of his freedom by claiming to subordinate it to values which would be unconditioned''.

This could also describe Larry Gopnik's nebbish persona to some degree as he commits to a particular ideal of how life should play out and seeks to understand what God has intended for him.

7. Well, That Happened In Real Life (Sort Of)

Following the film's odd yet humorous events, it seems that Larry's life is turning around for the better. His son's Bar Mitzvah was successful, his marriage may have found a new lease in life, and may even get tenure at the university he teaches at.

Advertisement

However, this is a Coens-directed film so a bleak ending is guaranteed, with the film concluding on a shot of an incoming tornado heading towards Danny's school. The tornado at the end of the movie is somewhat based on historical fact as Southern Minnesota experienced an outbreak in 1967, right around the same time as the movie's setting.

The American Midwest and South was devastated by a series of tornados from late April to early May 1967 and in their wake, thirteen lives were lost and small Minnesotan towns were irreversibly affected by the destructive force of nature.

6. Where's Frances? Where's John?

This is one of the few Coen brothers' films that does not feature their actor mainstays such as Frances McDormand, John Turturro, and George Clooney. This helps the film maintain its grounded feel since the actors are relative unknowns and/or underrated character actors.

Advertisement

Given that the film's setting is a small Minnesotan town and its lead is an everyman (in an admittedly strange situation), it is fitting that its actors are not on the Hollywood A-list. The most recognizable faces in the cast are veteran character actors such as Richard Kind and Adam Arkin, and Michael Stuhlbarg himself was a relative unknown prior to this film's release.

While it would have been interesting to see Turturro portray Larry's increasing anxiety or Clooney ooze slimy charm as Sy Borgman, it was far more interesting and engrossing to see a different side of Tinseltown embody these eclectic roles.

5. Doesn't This Remind You Of Something?

The story of Larry Gopnik's ever-increasing misfortunes acts as an allegory for the Book of Job, given that both characters are men of faith who go through various struggles and begin to question their faith in the process.

Advertisement

The only difference is in execution - the Biblical tale is uncompromising in its bleak nature, while the Coens' film is a dark comedy that handles a man's breakdown in an unexpectedly humorous manner. It has been noted by a number of religious scholars that Job was self-righteous and prideful and his trials and tribulations served as a way to remind him of his place in relation to God (a fairly harsh approach if you ask this writer).

It can be interpreted that Larry is self-righteous to a degree, and his attempts to find spiritual guidance from the Rabbis is similar to Job's own consultation of his friends - an attempt to make sense of these divine events without introspection.

4. Where is all this leading to, Rabbi?

Our embattled protagonist seeks spiritual guidance throughout the film and he encounters the specific guidance of Rabbi Marshak, who is unavailable. Therefore he engages two rabbis, Ginsler and Nachtner, each less helpful than the last. Nachtner in particular tells an amusing but confusing tale of a dentist who becomes fixated on various symbols in his patients' teeth.

Advertisement

It is clear from the onset that this oral parable is not going anywhere, and leaves Larry more frustrated than he was before. The spiritual leader's penchant for telling quirky and inconclusive stories may be the Coen brothers acknowledging their tendency to do this in their work. Their filmography is populated with colourful and eccentric characters as well as stories with humorous mean streaks.

Some have even called their work nihilistic and (intentionally) vague and this is reflected in the Rabbi's tale. It helps that this film is one of their more personal works and is a possible acknowledgment of how they are perceived as filmmakers.

3. Reliving The Good Ol' Days

As mentioned earlier, the Coens named the students in Larry's class after members of their production posse. The directing duo takes this a notch higher with the children who ride the bus with Danny and named them after actual children in their childhood.

Advertisement

This is apt given the brothers grew up in a family descended from Eastern European Ashkenazi Jews and grew up in a town similar to the one depicted in the film so it would only be natural that they would find inspiration from their formative years. This adds to the film's understated nature as well as its realism as it features characters such as the neighbourhood bully as well as the teen who just discovered the joy of expletives and runs with it.

This, plus the religious background, further reinforces the idea that this film is their most personal creative effort yet and gives viewers a unique view into their lives and worldviews.

2. What Was All That About?

The film begins on a decidedly unexpected note as it takes viewers into a 19th-century Jewish settlement (or Shtetl) and follows a Yiddish man who invites an elderly man to his house for dinner, to his wife's dismay. A somewhat awkward meal turns unsettling when it is heavily implied that the unexpected visitor is a Dybbuk, a restless spirit that wanders the Earth due to its sinful past.

Advertisement

The opening is seemingly unconnected to the remainder of the film due to its setting and overall tone. The Coen brothers acknowledge its lack of thematic connection to the rest of the film and state that it was meant to get audiences settled into the unconventional nature of the film.

The world of 19th-century Eastern Europe and mid 60s Minnesota may be worlds apart, but the opening scene adds some cultural weight to the film's strong Jewish sensibilities.

1. ''I Don't Want Santana Abraxas!!''

One of Larry's recurring problems in the film lies with his son's unplanned subscription to Columbia House Records. During a rather heated argument with one of the employees, he states that he doesn't want the album ''Abraxas'' by Latin rock band Santana.

Advertisement

This could be interpreted as Larry rejecting religion and/or God's will since Abraxas is an archaic term of Greco-Roman origin that refers to an entity that encompasses or is superior to both the Judeo-Christian God and Devil. The story behind the album's title may also be a reference to Larry's simultaneous disillusionment with his faith as well as his desire to seek refuge and answers in it.

The mention of the album's name is an anachronistic error on the Coens' part as the album was released more than three years after the film's setting. Despite this, it has unexpected thematic relevance to the film's narrative.

Advertisement