20 Things You Didn't Know About Arrival
Take a deep dive into a captivating story of language, time and first contact.
Denis Villeneuve's adaptation of the short story ‘Story of Your Life’ by Ted Chiang is one of the filmmaker’s best cinematic efforts. Arrival features impressive visuals, an eerie yet beautiful score from the late Johann Johannsson, restrained yet impactful performances (especially from Amy Adams and Jeremy Renner), as well as a layered and watertight narrative that does not betray its source material's insightful tale.
The latter benefits from a more grounded exploration of how humanity would initiate first contact with extraterrestrial life and ignores the bombast typically found in this genre. Instead, it wisely focuses on the relationships between its human and alien characters and how they would shape both species' development.
Despite making several changes to the story told by Chiang, the film is still able to convey its themes, such as determinism, the unconventional nature of time and the power of communication/language in shaping one's perspectives.
Due to Arrival's complexity, it is likely that some of its components were missed by audiences on first viewing, and others have taken on a new dimension in the years since the cinematic adaptation’s release. From enlightening uses of words in different languages, to references to other sci-fi films, Arrival is packed with fascinating details that enhance viewers' appreciation of it.
20. One Of The Film’s Most Important Scenes Almost Missed The Cut
It is common occurrence for some films to have a fair number of deleted scenes. Unfortunately, some scenes add much needed context to the stories and characters, and their exclusion works against the final cut’s comprehensibility. Arrival nearly joined the list of such films when Denis Villeneuve and editor Joe Walker almost left out a dream sequence that was key to the plot.
The scene featured Louise encountering a Heptapod in her trailer after a conversation with Colonel Weber (Forest Whitaker) and Ian Donnelly (Jeremy Renner). The sequence was almost cut for length purposes, but once the director and editor realized that this was the only scene with the mention of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis they attempted to salvage it and, in the process, gave it an unusual rhythm compared to the rest of the flick.
According to Walker, turning the moment into a dream sequence helped drive home the impact of the alien’s language on Louise as well as advanced her romance with Ian.
19. Time Is But A Flat Circle
When we are first introduced to Amy Adams’ Louise Banks, she is shown to be somewhat detached from her environment, as seen in the opening moments where she is completely oblivious to the commotion caused by the Heptapods’ descent on Earth.
While this serves to add to add to the movie’s idea of time being cyclical (albeit in a deliberately misleading manner), its visual depiction of the repetitive nature of Louise’s day-to-day life extends beyond her seeming indifference to external events. The film’s production designer, Patrice Vermette, designed the three main settings relevant to Louise (her house, classroom, and the alien ship) to have underlying similarities.
From the use of a minimalist design in her house, subdued lighting choices in the terrestrial settings and the recurring presence of a white wall - the large glass window in her house, her classroom’s whiteboard, and the display in the ship – Vermette and his team were able to convey how Louise’s past, present and future all impacted each other in a nonlinear fashion.
18. The Deeper Meaning Behind Abbott and Costello’s Names
Initially named Flapper and Raspberry, the alien Heptapods in the film were named Abbott and Costello - after the legendary duo - by Ian Donnelly. He specifically references their “Who’s On First?” bit while naming the extraterrestrial beings, and this served to hint at the picture’s themes.
In the 'bit', Costello wants to know the players of a certain baseball game but becomes increasingly frustrated by Abbott’s answers sounding like a mix of relative pronouns and other seemingly nonsensical (in context) statements. such as “I don’t know” or “I don’t give a darn.” Their multiple meanings only agitate the duo even more as it becomes clear they are not on the same page.
In addition to being humorous, the sketch highlights how simple misunderstandings can lead to a complete communication breakdown as the one seen after the Heptapods reveal their grand plan for humanity.
17. Ted Chiang’s Opinion Of The Film
Book-to-film adaptations are often tricky endeavors, and how key plot and character beats are handled is the difference between getting a stamp of approval from the author or leaving such a bad taste in their mouth that they never approve another re-telling of their work in the visual medium.
Fortunately, this was not the case with what would eventually become Arrival as author Ted Chiang was won over by Denis Villeneuve's effort. He mentioned that while the motion picture was a bit light on the original story’s scientific musings, it retained its emotional hook while still being its own artistic piece.
While the author is not too sure on which of his stories would translate well to the big screen, the hope is that what eventually sees the light of day is at least as good as Arrival.
16. Foreshadowing Done Right
If effectively used, foreshadowing can be useful in building narrative tension and ensuring that the payoff at the story’s climax is impactful. Fortunately, the 2016 sci-fi drama utilized this storytelling device to great effect early in the film by physicist Ian Donnelly (Jeremy Renner).
As Donnelly and Amy Adams’ Louise Banks were being transported to the Heptapods’ landing site, the former quoted his colleague’s renowned linguistics book, saying that “Language is the foundation of civilization. It is the glue that holds a people together. It is the first weapon drawn in a conflict.”
Unless you had read the book upon which this film was based on, this line probably did not hold that much weight aside from establishing Louise’s high regard of language. It is only towards the end of the second act when it is revealed that language holds far more significant weight in the film than expected.
15. The Inspiration Behind The Heptapods’ Appearance
The otherworldly beings key to the sci-fi short story’s adaptation were originally envisioned as being far different (visually) from their final appearance. In the book, the Heptapods were described as barrel-shaped and this was the original plan before Villeneuve and the production team opted for the cephalopod design seen in the final cut.
Despite this, the way the aliens carried themselves and how they were perceived came from different sources in the animal kingdom and, unexpectedly, mythology. Animals such as elephants, whales, spiders and even the Grim Reaper were key in developing the Heptapods’ movement and behaviour, specifically their inhuman intelligence and surreal appearance. Furthermore, some designs were far more surreal in nature and really leaned into the fact that these are, indeed, aliens.
These disparate sources of inspiration were key in ensuring that the strange visitors from another world were both vaguely familiar and yet far removed from anything seen on Earth.
14. Catering To The Italian Audience
Several films in Hollywood have certain elements in them changed when taken out into the international market. Some changes are for the best (Steve Rogers’ to-do list in The Winter Soldier) and others... not so much (muting LGBTQ representation in most blockbusters).
Arrival’s take on this trend in Italy was rather unusual but served as both something culturally specific without taking away from the story being told. In the original version, the Heptapods are named Abbott and Costello, and Sheena Easton’s music peaked in the 12 landing sites during the '80s.
The Italian dub had the above cultural icons changed to Tom and Jerry and Pink Floyd, respectively, as they are not as popular in the Mediterranean nation compared to the iconic cartoon frenemies and the British rock band.
13. Some Of The Flick's Ditched Ideas Were Best Left In Its Development Stages
It is expected that Arrival’s final form was not in line with its many initial drafts, but what is surprising is just how vastly different certain plot beats were from its inception and early stages.
For starters, the Heptapods were initially designed to be like their description in the novel (barrel-shaped and possessing seven eyes arranged in a ring shape) before the design team settled on the visage seen in the film.
In addition to this, the ending was almost nothing like what played in the final cut, as it had the aliens giving humanity blueprints for an advanced spacecraft. This was deemed to be to too similar to Chris Nolan’s Interstellar and was changed to the aliens’ language been used by humanity to perceive the future.
12. Development Hell
Tinseltown has seen a ton of films struggle in development hell for years or even decades in some cases, and Arrival was no different. Just like any other high-concept sci-fi tale, Ted Chiang’s novel was considered unfilmable due to the unconventional way the Heptapods express themselves and the tale's cerebral and meticulous nature.
Eventually, it was greenlit and screenwriter Eric Heisserer began working on it, but as a spec script. This meant that he would not get paid until Chiang gave his go-ahead on the script’s quality, and this was a daunting task as the screenwriter went through numerous drafts before having his work approved and securing studio funding.
It did not help that the film took a total of six years from being greenlit to the final edit, Fortunately, Chiang was impressed by the adaptation and the onscreen depiction of interstellar linguistics was a critical darling and box office hit.
11. The Logogram Bible
Most fictional languages in different media tend to be well thought out forms of communication that go beyond being simple collections of symbols and sounds lacking in any linguistic meaning or structure attached to them.
Fully fleshed languages such as Klingon, Elvish and Newspeak paved the way for newer tongues such as Dothraki, Na’vi and the dialect employed in Villeneuve's 2016 sci-fi opus. The director, picture’s screenwriter Eric Heisserer, production designer Patrice Vermette and the larger production team developed a fully functioning visual language that featured over 100 words (70 of which appeared in the film).
They (alongside famed coding experts Stephen and Christopher Wolfram) also developed a ‘Logogram Bible,’ a visual dictionary that helped give each symbol a specific meaning and weight behind that helped the artlang (artistic language) avoid the trappings of tongues of its ilk. Seeing that the film earned numerous nods for its screenplay and production design, it is safe to say that their efforts paid off.
10. The Deeper Meaning Behind Louise's Earring
Costume design in a film is used to showcase a character’s sensibilities, convey their emotional and physical state, and sometimes make commentaries on the world the characters inhabit. Sometimes, the design choices go beyond an iconic pairing of black shades and a trench coat, or a well-known fedora.
The most minute costume pieces may hold significant meaning to the film’s plot, even if does not feel this like at first glance. Louise’s earring in Arrival’s climactic flashforward is similarly shaped to a nautilus shell. As the name suggests, it is a protective casing of the cephalopod that is well known for its near perfect logarithmic spiral.
The earring’s distinct shape may be a reference to the Heptapods’ cephalopod-inspired design as well as the Fibonacci sequence, which was briefly mentioned by Ian Donnelly (Jeremy Renner) earlier on in the film. This mathematical principle is visually represented by a spiral (resembling a nautilus shell) and based off this; the earring’s use may be a nod to the cyclical nature of the film’s narrative.
9. The Inspiration Behind The Picture's Visual Style
Before filming took place, Villeneuve and cinematographer Bradford Young decided that Arrival’s aesthetic would go for the ‘’Dirty Sci-fi’’ look. According to a LA Times interview that featured the cinematographer, he described this as a “boring Tuesday morning then the aliens show up’’, and also made reference to the director’s desire to avoid symmetry and the sheen found in most sci-fi epics.
Furthermore, the work of Swedish photographer Martina Hoogland Ivanow, specifically her exhibition ‘Speedway’, influenced Young when he was building up the film’s visual style. Speedway is the photographer’s second solo effort and its focus on speedway drivers and the locales they race in is evocative due to its soft and dark lighting.
This stylistic sensibility can be seen in the aliens’ ship, with its visage being almost opaque in nature, and the scene where Louise receives the ability to perceive time cyclically from the Heptapods being shot in an almost painterly, naturalistic manner. Villeneuve and Young’s sensibilities paid off handsomely, as the film received numerous accolades for its restrained yet otherworldly cinematography, including an Oscar nod for the DP.
8. The Strange Yet Fascinating Connection Between Denis And Martin Villeneuve
It goes without saying that our family members can be some of our biggest influences in our lives, and this goes for directors and other creatives. Denis’ youngest sibling, Martin, is a filmmaker in his own right and has created various films, including Mars et Avril, which many consider to be Quebec’s first science fiction film.
Clearly, an affinity for science fiction filmmaking runs in the Villeneuve household. However, Martin's 2002 music video Jouisseland is the film most relevant to the purpose of this article, and with good reason. The surreal video features Canadian singer Jean LeLoup as a clown who is writing to his ex-lover while at the same time playing with an octopus-like creature.
The impressionist style is striking and Leloup is appropriately strange as the lovelorn clown. On the surface, Arrival and Jouisseland have little to no connections beyond featuring the creatures, but this latter connection is an amusing piece of trivia, especially for fans of the Villeneuves' projects.
7. Albert Einstein And Carl Sagan's Influence On The Story
Arrival is far from your regular bombastic sci-fi actioner. The film is more restrained and not does not feature over-the-top action, and for the most part tries to feel as real as possible. It is true that it plays fast and loose with some linguistic theories, but it generally sticks to some real-world scientific principles.
As a result, Arrival makes note of the works of science legends such as Albert Einstein and Carl Sagan. Towards the film’s end, Ian calls his young daughter Hannah ‘Starstuff’. This is in reference to Sagan’s famous 1980 documentary, Cosmos, where the esteemed astronomer states that “we are made of starstuff”. Einstein’s work is somewhat referenced in the book that inspired the film.
The physicist once said that “the distinction between the past, present and future is only a stubbornly persistent illusion.” This means time as we categorize it is a human construct, and that reality is not as linear as imagined. This quote’s sentiment rings true in the book and film and can be seen in the Heptapods’ distinct perception of time.
6. References To Other Sci-Fi Classics
It is not uncommon for films to reference other movies of their ilk, and Arrival is no different. It pays homage to sci-fi classics in several ways, especially those that have initial communication between humans and aliens as a key part of their narratives.
The film’s most overt homages are about Contact (a picture written by Carl Sagan himself) and Star Trek: First Contact. They are referenced when it is revealed that there are alien ships in Hokkaido (where the secret spacecraft was constructed in the former film) and Montana (where the first point of contact between humans and aliens was made in the latter film).
Another (possibly unintentional) reference is Colonel Weber, as played by Forest Whitaker. Arrival was not the first time Whitaker played a character who was involved in the recruitment of experts in order to establish first contact. In the 1995 film Species, he plays Dan Smithson, a telepath who is recruited as a part of a team to stop a newly emerged alien threat.
5. The Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis' Narrative Relevance… And Inaccuracies
The titular theory was suggested and developed by Edward Sapir and Benjamin Whorf. It posits that a language’s structure influences its speakers' thoughts and worldviews. This version of the theory is mentioned when Dr. Donnelly references how language can rewire an individual’s mind.
Its relevance to the film is strong due to its exploration of how the Heptapods’ language structure is closely linked to their perception of time (and vice versa), biological structure and home world. The influence of language on one’s perceptions can be seen in the way Louise’s perception of time changes as she learns the extraterrestrials’ language.
That said, a lot of linguists in later years have challenged the tenets of this theory, suggesting that language cannot change the fundamentals of an individual’s mindset. The movie was right in demonstrating that the aliens’ different sensibilities influenced their language, but the ‘rewiring of the brain’ as suggested by Donnelly was probably to serve the narrative and emotional core rather than achieve actual scientific accuracy.
4. The Movie's Interesting Wordplay
As is expected in a tale with language and communication as some of its focal themes, Arrival features an intriguing use of English and non-English words to highlight certain plot points. The word ‘kangaroo’ is mentioned when Louise is confronted by Colonel Weber due to her choice to teach the Heptapods English.
She tells the colonel that the word Kangaroo is an Aborigine term for “I don’t know”. Although the story is a myth - it turns out aggressive English settlement and influence means that these words’ true meaning, kangaroo included, were lost in translation - it proves the need for both sides to learn each other’s languages and linguistic nuances.
Another notable word in the film is ‘Szalamitaktika, a Hungarian term that roughly translates to salami tactics. It is referred to by Agent Halpern (Michael Stuhlbarg) in reference to the (false) belief that the alien ships around the world are going to gradually take down humanity piece by piece. It is brief but gives insight into how governments perceived the heptapods’ presence on Earth.
3. The Emotional Use Of On The Nature Of Daylight
Max Richter’s The Blue Notebook is one of the most prolific classical music albums of the 21st century, and with good reason. Its melancholic composition served as an understated yet powerful critique of the 2003 invasion of Iraq has made it one of the weightier modern pieces of music. On the Nature of Daylight in particular is renowned for perfectly encapsulating the album’s themes.
It is used in Arrival’s opening and ending scenes, where it is revealed that Louise’s memories of her late daughter Hannah are actually flash-forwards to a time after the events of the film. The imagery at the beginning is affecting enough, but takes on a new level of emotional weight once it is used to bookend the picture. Richter’s composition underscores these cyclical scenes and beautifully complements their poignancy.
In addition to emotional relevance, the musical piece’s anti-war sentiments somewhat reflect the film’s insistence on cooperation rather than conflict. Its use in Arrival may have disqualified it from being nominated at the 2017 Oscars, but its pathos within the film’s context cannot be denied.
2. Playing With Palindromes
Some would say that the bookended structure of Arrival, as well as its non-linear storyline, makes it some sort of filmic palindrome. While this is not exactly accurate at least as far as the film’s structure is considered, certain elements in it do fit the word’s description. After the feature’s main events, Louise and Ian have a daughter named Hannah, a word that also doubles as a palindrome.
This is fitting because the young girl’s most crucial moments (her life and death) happen in the film’s bookends. The Heptapods’ language is also palindromic, at least visually. Depicted as logograms, Louise and the other experts note that it expresses meaning despite not having sound as a part of it, and most importantly, reflects their non-linear experience of time.
Sonically, On the Nature of Daylight’s violin arrangement is palindromic in nature, and its sublime use in the film’s opening and closing scenes is very apt, given the scenes’ emotional weight.
1. Louise's Message To General Shang
One of the film’s most notable scenes sees a future version of Louise interacting with General Shang at a United Nations event. Here, the Chinese general informs the linguist that her actions 18 months earlier changed his mind and helped usher in the newfound peace the world is experiencing.
It turns out that Louise’s ability to perceive time non-linearly enabled her to see this event, retrieve General Shang’s personal number and share with him his wife’s dying words, words that change the General’s decision to strike at the alien ships. Now, these words are unfamiliar to non-Mandarin speakers but the movie’s writer Eric Heisserer revealed the crucial words on a Reddit AMA following the movie’s release.
The words translate to “In war, there are no winners, only widows.” The screenwriter mentioned that he took considerable effort to come up with this line (and ensure it is accurately translated) but Villeneuve ultimately opted to keep the line untranslated in the final film. The line is simple but expertly highlights the consequences of an armed attack on the well-meaning extraterrestrials.