5 Changes That Would Have Improved Man Of Steel

By Ryan Kim /

When Warner Bros. announced that they were rebooting Superman, I thought "What happened to Bryan Singer? Better yet, what happened to Christopher Ree... Brandon Routh?" I was actually in the minority of people who thought Superman Returns was decent. I liked Singer's approach to the film as a continuation from the original Superman I and II, which would place Superman Returns as an unofficial Superman III. Unfortunately, no one else did. There may have been several reasons as to why people didn't flock to the theaters to watch Superman Returns. Since stars attract, casting may have been an issue as Routh was an unknown much like his predecessor, Reeves (R.I.P.) and Kate Bosworth really didn't do it for anyone as Lois Lane. Kevin Spacey gave it his best, but his Lex Luthor was much like Gene Hackman's and was too goofy to take seriously as a villain. In a post-9/11 world, we were too cynical to believe that a Messianic figure could save anyone, plus Superman saving the world from Kryptonian real estate wasn't the most entertaining to watch. Hence WB decided to reboot and since the bar was set low, expectations weren't at an all time high. Until Christopher Nolan was brought on to produce and his former writing collaborator David S. Goyer was on board to script. Expectations increased exponentially. Would the new Superman be on the level of Batman Begins? Hopes of Nolan possibly directing got fans riled up. Would Nolan just concede and direct the reboot himself? Unfortunately, no, but there was a list of directors including Guillermo Del Toro, Ben Affleck, and Darren Aronofsky that would satisfy the masses. However, in the end Zack Snyder was offered the job and although I was among the perplexed, I was willing to give Snyder a chance. With Nolan and Goyer helping Snyder, I expected a pleasant surprise. Man of Steel came, broke box office records for June, and went. The consensus? Meh. Man of Steel featured high flying, skyscraper destroying, unnecessary action. Casting was great, but almost none of them were used to their full potential. Henry Cavill was the right choice for Superman, but the story along with characterization and writing left something to be desired. While Snyder, Nolan, and Goyer crafted a Man of Steel for our times, the film was underwhelming on both emotional and cinematic levels. With a sequel in the works already, let's hope they make a few changes to improve on the original. Here's five to get started. SPOILERS AHEAD.

5. Krypton, We Hardly Knew Ye

Besides crystals, Marlon Brando, and his glow in the dark suit, we never got much of a view of Krypton and what that world was like in comparison to Earth. That's why it was kind of cool to see Krypton in all its Apocalyptic glory. Lasers, explosions, and flying dragons oh my. Unfortunately, Krypton was a bit of a mess and it made the film messy as well because while it was interesting to watch, it was also unnecessary. For the first 20 minutes, we were immersed in Krypton and introduced to elements that would come into play later on in the story such as the codex and General Zod, but for all intents and purposes it could've been condensed. The film could've started out with Jor-El and Lara infusing the codex into Kal and General Zod busting through the doors. It would've saved an extra 10 minutes and then we could've gone right into Clark's present as a cast member of Deadliest Catch. In all seriousness, what was captured on Krypton was more pleasing to the eye than anything; we did get a sense of how Kryptonians lost their sense of humanity as Kal was the first "natural birth in centuries," but it fell short of any real thematic impact just as Zod exploded onto the scene and lasered a council woman without batting an eyelash. We weren't given enough time to process everything. As Lara launched Kal into space with the codex, I was confused more than anything because at that point I didn't know what the hell a codex was, why it was infused into Kal, and why Jor-El waited until the last minute to pick a planet to send his only son to. I'm not against the sense of mystery, but there needed to be a sense of urgency and significance to the actions in the beginning. Instead, everything felt rushed.

4. Clark's Past

There's not much to be known about Clark's past. 10 seasons of Smallville will do that for anyone and then some, but I enjoyed the way Snyder shot the bits and pieces of Clark's past. The little details of a door slamming, laundry hanging to dry, and the country grass presented a nice little collage of how Clark grew up in humble surroundings. However, the see-sawing between Clark's past and present hindered the flow of the film. Again, we weren't given enough time in the past and in the present to really grasp the emotions of Clark's identity crisis and self-doubt. Each snippet was a piece to the puzzle, but it felt like some pieces were missing. Pa Kent holding Clark back from using his powers because the world wasn't ready for it yet was an appropriate theme for the world we live in, but Pa Kent handled it pretty well. If the world wasn't ready for Clark, maybe he could've taught him how to hone his powers or how to be human. If Krypton had become machine like and Clark was the first natural birth in ages, then it'd fit the theme of the film to have Clark to be more human, more normal to hide his abilities. This could've been done in a pivotal scene where Clark ends up overusing his powers and hurting someone he cares about. He would then be more reticent to use his abilities and reluctant to don the cape which he magically appears in with a shaven face in the middle of the film. There would be a struggle the film was lacking before; whereas Clark was a vagabond wandering around looking for answers, he'd be actively fighting against himself for a purpose he knows he must fulfill and not wanting to repeat the past and risk hurting people, which he certainly did going through skyscrapers like butter in mid-day Metropolis.

3. Less Cheese, Please

There are bits and pieces of dialogue that you never want to hear in a movie. Expository dialogue and cheesy lines are among them, but sometimes these lines can be forgiven if they are funny or ironic. Lines such as "I can't love, I don't know how to. I never learned how to as I was growing up in the ghettos of Beverly Hills" or "Pain? I don't feel the punches. I only feel your absence. It's hurts worse than a one-two combo to the gonads." In Man of Steel cheesy and expository dialogue was delivered, but they weren't funny. It was painful. Lines such as "I'm Pulitzer Prize winning writer, Perry!" Thank you, Lois Lane. We now know you are a very talented writer indeed and that you like to toot that horn whenever possible. "You're a monster, Zod and I'm going to stop you." Hmm. As if you had any other choice. "You can save them, Kal... You can save all of them." Except for the 100,000 dead buried underneath glass and steel beams from the buildings you collapsed on them. Please, please, please David Goyer, let me get what I want and no more cheesy lines or expository dialogue. We can't take it. Silence really is golden during these times. I wish that these were the only lines I had a problem with in the film, but a certain villain fell flat because of what came out of his mouth, leading me to my next point...

2. No Need To Yell

Michael Shannon is a great actor. I still can't believe how he got snubbed for Take Shelter. With that being said, he's less than great in Man of Steel, in fact, he's the guy who yells all the time thinking that yelling makes him villainous, but it doesn't. You know what yelling does? It makes you loud and annoying to listen to. I don't know why Goyer thought it was a good idea to have Zod repeat the line "I will find him" over and over in escalating volume, but it wasn't threatening or scary. It was redundant. Zod appears to go hot and cold; he's calm and collected in one scene and extremely angry in another. He appears to be intelligent, but at the same time indifferent to everything except his purpose. This is good, but lines like "There's only one way this ends, Kal. Either you die! Or I do" make me question his character. Shannon tries with what he has, but he's not given much to work with. We automatically assume he's the villain when he blows down doors and barges in taking control, but we don't see it or feel it. We don't really feel much for any of the characters especially Zod. Although, you may not want to sympathize with the villain, you want the audience to empathize so that the villain's actions have weight and meaning behind them. We want to hate the villain as we hate the worst part of ourselves. But the only thing we really end up hating is the yelling. It's one note, it's silly, and it's got to go, which leads to the real issue at hand...

1. Clark! A Rewrite, Pronto!

I'm sure on paper, Man of Steel had all the necessary elements. High stakes, an evil villain who killed the protagonist's father, a love interest with brains, and a journey from zero to hero. Making dots is one thing, but connecting them is another and connect the dots, this did not. Goyer may have received writing credit on Batman Begins, but Nolan was responsible for extensively rewriting it and making it his own. That was exactly what was needed, a rewrite. I could blame Snyder for his lack of involvement with the script as a director as he should've been aware of the story and plot unfolding in front of the camera, but before Man of Steel Snyder had only written 300 and Sucker Punch, the latter being an original, so I can understand. Some of the main issues of the script that I could tell from viewing the final product was the lack of characterization and chemistry between the actors. Lois and Superman making out didn't make sense to me as a payoff or logical conclusion to their budding relationship. There was no scene that established Superman's romantic interest in her and vice versa. Yes, Henry Cavill and Amy Adams are hot and if you put two hot people together chances are they might make out, but it felt random in the context of the film. We also didn't feel for any of the characters, I wanted to, but I couldn't feel Clark's frustrations or Zod's pain or Lois's whatever. When Pa Kent died in that tornado I felt more angry than anything because Clark just stood there like a dummy letting his dad die when he previously he saved a school bus full of children and even after letting his dad die, he still goes and saves a bunch of people from the burning oil rig. It's inconsistent. If Clark wouldn't save his dad in front of a bunch of strangers, why would he save workers who are clearly going to remember the man who walked through fire and ripped open a steel door. Were they ready for it? And completely demolishing Metropolis when the world engine was already doing enough damage was adding insult to injury. Are we to believe that Superman wouldn't do his best to fight conservatively to protect the innocent from getting hurt? Instead, we count IHOP, Sears, and multiple skyscrapers along with other small buildings among the casualties. The action was brute and uncoordinated and more devastating than a terrorist attack. Feel safer with Superman around? And what was up with the codex? Did Jor-El really send Kal to repopulate Earth with Kryptonians to co-exist? And if not, was it necessary for him to fuse the lineages of all Krypton with Kal? Will I ever stop asking questions? Yes, I will. Amongst other issues, Man of Steel desperately needed a rewrite to sharpen the characters and plot; what could've been if Nolan had, but that's another question without an answer. I really hoped this Superman would've been the one for our times, however I found the basic elements of story that made Superman Returns likeable for me was missing in the latest installment. Here's to a better sequel.