One advantage of writing an article on experimental film as opposed to avant-garde film is that it automatically gives one much more leeway in terms of films to be selected as well as overall writing approaches. While avant-garde cinema can be regarded, by and large, as a distinct body of work with its own traditions, history, and critical literature, experimental film is a rather more subjective and ambiguous category, and one that cuts across certain forms of commercial as well as avant-garde filmmaking. Hopefully this list will entice you to watch one or twoor fiveof these essential experimental films...
5. Battleship Potemkin
Battleship Potemkin (1925) is no longer my favourite Sergei Eisenstein film (Id take October or Alexander Nevsky), but it is still the best place I know of to start thinking about Eisenstein. The film records the birth of revolutionary consciousness among the crew members of the battleship Potemkin, anchored at Odessa in 1905. The essence of cinema, Eisenstein has told us, is montagein a practical sense, editing; in the most general sense, the placing side-by-side of disparate elementsand Eisenstein, putting side-by-side two sequences of images that illustrates the ideological notion of montage, illuminates and catalyses a technique that has long been meditated. P.S.: one of the greatest epiphanic moments in Eisensteins films, I think, is the one in October (1927) where the image of Jesus is compared to Hindu deities, the Buddha, and the Aztec godsand that instantaneous transfiguration becomes, in effect, the motivating spirit of a great historical movement.
4. Un Chien Andalou
I cant say that Ive been an adherent Luis Buñuel fan; aside from Los Olvidados (1950) and Nazarín (1959)maybe Viridiana (1961) if it werent so hamstrung in its depiction of traditional religious valuesIve always seen Bunuels films as being unnecessarily egotistic. Take the recurring scene in The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie, where six people walk silently and purposefully on a long, isolated country road towards a mysterious destination. Even with these reservations, and despite the fact that Buñuels debut film is clearly his most ostentatious, Un Chien Andalou had a radical effect on cinema, when it was released, in 1929. It was made in the hope of administering a revolutionary shock to society. For the first time in the history of the cinema, wrote the critic Ado Kyrou, a director tries not to please but rather to alienate nearly all potential spectators. That was then, this is now. Today, its techniques have been so thoroughly absorbed even in the mainstream that its shock value is dilutedexcept for that famous shot of the slicing of the eyeball, or perhaps the shot of the man dragging the grand piano that has the priests and the dead donkeys on top of it. . . . From a surrealist perspectivethat is, an art movement that aimed to resolve the previously contradictory conditions of dream and realitythe movie couldn't have been better.
3. Breathless
A number of directors have created one singular film that critics point to as the film. Gance had Napoléon (1927), Dreyer had The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928), Welles had Citizen Kane (1941), Ford had The Searchers (1956), and Godard, now 82-years-old and still producing, has Breathless (1960). Shot on a shoestring and none the worse for it, Godard's gritty and engaging first feature had an almost revolutionary impact when first released in 1960. It lays down most of the Godardian repertoire that the later films would build upon: male bravado spiced with plug-ugly mugging and amusing self-mockery (brought to perfection in Jean-Paul Belmondo's wonderful performance); a fascination with female beauty and treachery (the indelible Jean Seberg as the archetypal American abroad); an emulation of the American gangster movie, and a love-hatred for America in general; radically employed jump cuts that have the effect of a needle skipping gaily across a record; and a taste for literary, painterly, and musical quotations, as well as original aphorisms. Less characteristic of Godard's later work are the superb jazz score (by French pianist Martial Solal), a relatively coherent and continuous narrative, and postsynchronised dialogue.
2. La Jetée
I suppose it could be argued that Chris Markers 1962 masterpiece is the most neglected film in the history of cinema. La Jetée (which means The Pier) is a fictionalised account of a post-World War III Paris, where underground commanders run time experiments on prisoners. The entire film is a series of black-and-white still photos (except for one brief series of images) that help narrate one prisoner's fate. Like Sans Soleil, Markers 1983 film, La Jetée speaks to issues around time and memory, but this film is much more accessibleand thrilling. The bittersweet music, the narrators steady voice that sounds like a scientists, the museum-quality photos, and the gripping plot all make La Jetée an inimitable experience.
1. Persona
In Ingmar Bergmans 1966 film, Persona, Bibi Andersson and Liv Ullmann exchange identities to the accompaniment of much musing about art, life, and politics, all of it, admittedly, is much more obscure than is strictly necessary. Bergman, when questioned by interviewer John Simon, a writer for The New Leader, about the meaning of his film, and the many images it brings to its viewers, responded, On many points I am unsure, and in one instance, at least, I know nothingFor this reason I invite the audiences fantasy to dispose freely of what I have put at its disposal. Though silent about the films meaning, Bergman cannot help but reveal, though the portrayals, images, and realities of his characters livesclues to what is behind the many masks he himself wears in his personal and public life. Like his viewers, Bergmans identity is a result of his experiences, his culture, his associations and relationships with othersacquaintances, friends and family. And, like his viewers, his personality is a product of his pain, suffering, and disappointments. For all of his cunning creativity and artwork, Bergmans disguise as silent filmmaker belies itself once viewers witness the film. Many of his stories are assumed to have autobiographical significance, to analyse weaknesses he finds in his own character.