Without an effective villain, the horror film would deteriorate into a banal drama with (if you're lucky) a slight character arc or two. Imagine for a moment Halloween with a wise-cracking jokester instead of the chilling stoicism of Michael Myers. Or, a mischievous goblin instead of whatever that invisible force is in Paranormal Activity. Our fear is directly linked to our intimate - albeit terrifying - relationship with the film's embodiment of evil. Without a strong threat against our moral authority, the horror film is dead in the water, like a boat without an ocean, or a chainsaw without a chain. And thus, I have delivered a smooth segue into that most loveable of classic horror villains, that flesh wearing fetishists we have all come to know and love as Leatherface. As his modest name suggests, this deranged killer wears a mask of human flesh. He treats his victims just like cattle in a slaughterhouse. No discrimination here, meat is meat. He carries a sledgehammer for bashing brains and a chainsaw for sawing lean muscle. He first appeared in the original The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974), but has become a figure synonymous with hardcore horror and slasher films. So, what makes Leatherface so interesting? After all, if one were to plan writing an article on a specific slasher villain, they would have a multitude of icons to choose from; Freddy Krueger, Jason Voorhees, Chucky, Pinhead, Candyman, Leprechaun, just to name a few. However, what none of these characters have that Leatherface does is a wide diversity of interpretation. Looking back at the Texas Chainsaw films, you find that each one shows an entirely new Leatherface with an entirely new set of disturbing traits. Depending on which version of Leatherface most frightens you, you can examine what that Leatherface represents, and in the process unmask what hidden anxieties have been festering inside you surreptitiously. Oh, what joy! Let us waste no more time then. We shall delve into the depraved, marvel at the macabre, and hopefully gain understanding of the unconscionable...
5. The Monster Mamma - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974)
"Look what your brother did to the door!" The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (1974) It's impossible to discuss Leatherface's character without mentioning the role he plays within his demented family unit. After all, the saw is family. In the original film, the cannibalistic clan from Texas is comprised entirely of men: three brothers and their grandpa. Naturally, as they are meant to be an aggressive perversion of the classic 50s nuclear family, all that testosterone is in need of some calming, coolheaded motherly affection. Unfortunately, instead of a Leave it to Beaver type figure, all they could muster was a sweaty, mumbling man dressed up in an old woman's face and frilly apron. Although Leatherface can do a disturbingly accurate rendition of a pig's squeal, I don't think he knows the first thing about baking apple pies. Yet, that is the role he fills. While the other "breadwinning" brothers are out in the world, Leatherface stays behind in the house to cook, clean and prepare meals (albeit by murdering and removing the skin from nosy hippies). When his brothers return, he is reprimanded for the poor state of the house, as if he is stuck in an abusive relationship with a particularly deplorable hubby. One almost feels sorry for him, despite his acts of viciousness, as he mistreated and beaten by the men. Even his high-pitched cries sound like an estimation of tormented femininity in a house void of any truly feminine presence. It's a deeply disturbing depiction of the insidious decay of the family unit - a heteronormative nightmare. The chaotic storm of gender subversion that Leatherface exudes in this film carries with it the potential for many anxieties to be stirred within you. You may relate primarily to the terror of an abused or abusive mother, or perhaps the terror of no mother at all and the inadequacy of filling that void. You could relate to the oppressed femininity not only of women, but also the femininity of men. If you're more of a macho type, you might find the way Leatherface is "feminized" to be one of his most disturbing attributes. If you expect to soon become a mother figure, then Leatherface can certainly embody your anxieties about that as well. All in all, there's a plethora of paranoia this character unveils for you to enjoy and explore. This emphasis on monstrous maternity makes sense if you take a look at the source material. The serial killer Ed Gein, on which Leatherface was based, had a morbid obsession with his mother. As a side note, the Norman Bates character from Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho (1960), who was also inspired by Gein, exploits the monster mama in a different way with incestuous necrophilia, repressed sexuality, and an overbearing mother. The implications of which are much different than in Texas, despite both being linked back to Gein.
4. The Simple Sadist - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: Part 2 (1986)
"You've got one choice boy: sex or the saw." The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: Part 2 (1986) As a warning, I predict you will be reading the word "phallus" a lot in this section. Only time will tell, of course, but don't say I didn't warn you. In the Texas Chainsaw sequel, which was directed by Tobe Hooper who also directed the original, the critique on the family unit was almost entirely dissolved. In its place comes a far more business minded unit, resulting in a bold, bloody attack on the capitalist structure, and appropriately so since Texas Chainsaw 2 was made in the middle of the excess obsessed 80s. It's also worth noting that the stark realism of the original has also been replaced by a garish, nightmare carnival kind of vibe. The blood is redder, the blade is shinier, and the ride through the funhouse has become even more bizarre. With the cannibal family setting up business in an abandoned theme park, where does this leave our beloved Leatherface? He becomes a lackey, an errand boy, an everyday man. At least he does until he spots a pretty girl. Then the sexual confusion begins and he revs up for some action. During one particularly disturbing scene, Leatherface enters into a macabre kind of foreplay with the lead heroine where he uses his chainsaw to molest her. In an interesting turn of events, the heroine takes note of this vulnerable confusion and in order to avoid being cut into pieces, she tells the masked maniac that, "You're really good. You're the best." In this film, Leatherface becomes the conduit through which the sadistic appeal of horror films gets flipped on its head. The film pushes the metaphor of the erect chainsaw out of the realm of safe subtext or subtle innuendo and into the arena of undeniable phallus (can we get a phallus counter? This is number one, well, technically three). Leatherface is a juvenile sexual predator with a powerful lust. The terror of his new incarnation is very different from his previous one, but equally as disturbing. What does this mean for the viewer? Well, you have to ask yourself, what happens when you get sexually frustrated men with little to no ability for empathy? You get sexual harassment, misogyny, and rape, just to name a few lurid byproducts. On the other side of things, Leatherface's character may speak to the fear you have of your own sexuality, whether or not it's truly depraved. He's a bit of a pubescent boy in this movie, frightened and bewildered by his own phallus (there's another). It's as if the chainsaw is wielding him, instead of the other way around, and who can't relate to that? It's an anxiety that has been explored in horror movies stretching all the way back to the Wolfman, and probably further. Sex, death and horror are always a potent mix.
3. The Angry Adolescent - Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III (1990)
"Go get the meat!" Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III (1990) Arguably, Texas Chainsaw III is the first time the Leatherface character really conforms to typical slasher modus operandi (or should that be morbid-us operan-die? Sometimes I feel like the Crypt Keeper and I would have been besties). In this third installment, he appears much like Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers. Most of his intriguingly depraved characteristics have been stripped away, leaving him just a disgruntled boy with a chainsaw in Texas. Much like a disgruntled boy with a machete in Camp Crystal Lake. Since his family was entirely destroyed in Texas Chainsaw Part 2, Leatherface had to find himself some new relatives. He ended up settling with a pre-Lord of the Rings Viggo Mortensen along with an eclectic group of degenerates. Not bad. This time there are even some fanatic female family members as well, which perhaps takes care of his need to fill the role of mother. The problem is, it's unclear what role that leaves him to fill. Despite these detractors, characterization of Leatherface has not been entirely abandoned. At least, not yet. One charming little scene depicts Leatherface trying to better himself by learning how to spell. Unfortunately, he keeps spelling the word "clown" as F.O.O.D. On top of that, he rebels against authority, is interested in sex and listens to loud music. Now, you try to tell me he isn't a product of teen angst. Adolescence is an awkward part of everyone's life. Perhaps the appealing (or disturbing) quality of Leatherface in this film is the fact that he seems to be going through universally relatable changes. Homicidal tendencies aside, he's just a kid struggling to make sense of the turmoil both within himself and in the world around him. He's just growing up, and who can't empathise with growing pains? However, you don't necessarily have to be an angry teenager to relate to this incarnation. In this film, the character might appeal to you because of your own desire for unrestrained anarchy. Perhaps you long to break free from whatever it is that oppresses you, be it your annoying high school teacher, or your new tyrannical boss who strangely reminds you of your annoying high school teacher. Or, Leatherface could represent your fear of the chaos that inevitably ensues once anarchy is embraced. To break free and ride a wild bull can be liberating, but also devastating. This is Leatherface's enticingly devious duality. He just might unleash the anarchist in you.
2. The Traumatized Transgender - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: Next Generation (1994)
"She's got a body to die for." The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: Next Generation (1994) The fourth installment in The Texas Chainsaw lexicon is quiet a peculiar little ditty and marks the return of one of the franchise's creators, Kim Henkel. In the original film, he was a co-writer, but now serves also as director. The film boasts major star power with wild performances by Renee Zellweger and Matthew McConaughey. A wacky sense of humour saves Texas Chainsaw: Next Generation from being a complete failure of a film, but it is easily the weakest of all the sequels. One of its most fascinating attributes, however, is how far it pushes Leatherface's transgender qualities. On some level, it marks a return to form, and Leatherface is seen once again donning the skin of both sexes. But, the character doesn't stop there. By the end of the film, Leatherface is dressed in a fabulous flowing black dress and the flesh of one of his bustier victims. He has transformed into a true femme fatale with, shall we say, a haunting kind of beauty. The film concludes with an intense chainsaw dance fit for a bedlam ballroom. In some sense the character could be taken as slightly transphobic since the film undeniably seeks to horrify the audience with spectacles of transgender mutilation. However, you could also look at Leatherface as the embodiment of queer rage, a symbol of a repressed minority. Then, he becomes almost an anti-hero. If you accept him as the pure unleashed frustration of a persecuted section of society, then why shouldn't he be a little chainsaw-happy. After all, these films do take place in Texas (nudge, nudge). For the viewing audience at home, these two readings of the character could cause some conflict within you. You could find yourself worrying, "am I transphobic?" Well, no, I wouldn't go that far. I mean, Leatherface is still wearing human flesh which is disturbing in and of itself. However, if you find yourself repulsed by his feminization on top of his necrophilia, then perhaps there's something there for you to face. On the other hand, if you connect with the pain of Leatherface's anguished transformation, or even sympathize with it, then kudos to you and your open mind, whether you're going through a transformation yourself or not. Very few slasher films deal with transgender people, so when one comes along, like Sleepaway Camp (1983) or Psycho, it can feel like a breath of fresh air, and we shouldn't be so quick to demonise them. They can offer some healthy catharsis in their horror, as the promotional poster for Texas Chainsaw: Next Generation can attest, "If looks could kill, he wouldn't need a chainsaw."
1. The Offish Ogre - The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006)
"You can't have a creature like that around normal folk..." The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (2006) As is the fate of anything that captures the imagination, eventually it is repeated enough that it loses whatever power it had. The character of Leatherface is no different as the remake of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003), The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning and Texas Chainsaw 3D (2013) can attest to. In each fairly tiresome film, Leatherface is depicted not with a provocatively morbid psychosis, but rather as a big, dumb, lumbering thing an animal. As frightening as a rabid dog with a chainsaw might be, the truth is it's just not that interesting. Concerning the remakes, Leatherface is reduced to nothing more than a gruesome troll stored away in the family's basement. He is called upon from time to time to offer some brute force when needed, but not much else. Beyond the plot point of a flesh eating disease that forced him to wear a mask, and therefore, theoretically led him to butcher and skin his fellow humans, there is little characterization added to answer that most chilling question: why? Without that, Leatherface becomes just another faceless slasher, despite his excess of faces. The character of Leatherface has been pushed out to pasture into this thematically deprived wasteland of remakes, prequels and one unnecessary continuity-inept sequel. It's ironic that Texas Chainsaw 3D presented Leatherface's one-dimensional characterization in three-dimensions. Seems a little gratuitous to me... and not in a good way. Sadly, most horror icons suffer the same fate. They become unchallenging, soulless. Time, or perhaps familiarity, disconnects them from whatever deep-seated terror they used to embody. They are inevitably reduced to "scary guy who stabs you". Although the fear of penetration does have a few fascinating implications, it is also the slasher film's most derivative theme and present in any film featuring a madman with a knife, or an axe, or a gardening spade. The resulting horror is straight forward. It has it's place, just not a very important one. If out of the generous bounty of Leatherfaces that exist, you happen to relate to this one the most, then you probably like your horror safe and simple. Bad guys are big and scary, heroines are manicured and scantily clad. You want the thrill of the chase without any lasting creep factor. You'd rather deal with the predictable splashes of blood and screams than a gravedigger unearthing your private hidden terrors. This could point toward a fear of being challenged; the anxiety that if you were truly shaken, there's no telling what might come falling loose. Perhaps one day Leatherface will once again find the teeth for his chain and regain his buzz. Until then, however, we'll have to be satisfied with the contemporary mindless goon in all his uninspired goonishness. Well, at least we are left with a eclectic group of chainsawed faces to choose from. And so we are compelled to ask, which one fits the best? Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.