5 Original Script Drafts That Would Have Made Popular Movies Unrecognisable

By Barry Marshall /

The finished draft of a film script is often completely different from what we all recognise as the finished article. A script frequently undergoes so many rewrites that the plot, characters or crucial scenes can bear absolutely no resemblance to the originally intended result. Some of the most popular mainstream movies of the past thirty years or so certainly fall into this category. The original scripts, often detailed in directors cuts or bonus documentaries on the special edition DVD, or on film websites, show just how drastically the central characters or crucial plot details were altered - some of them so much so that the premise of the film or beloved scenes became something else entirely. Mostly, but not always, this is a good thing. There are so many examples of altered script drafts changing the direction of a film that it would be impossible to list them all here. I've compiled 5 of the most striking, but feel free to add your own in the comments section below...

Advertisement

5. Leon: The Professional

Luc Besson's searing 1994 thriller marked breakthrough performances for both Jean Reno as the emotionally repressed and mentally slow titular assassin who takes an orphan under his wing after her family are murdered by a corrupt cop, and Natalie Portman, who plays the precocious youngster who becomes his protégé due to her lust for revenge. Reno played Leon as naïve and childlike to remove some of the sexual tension that was present in the finished cut between his character and the orphan, Mathilda. The cut was altered upon its American release to remove this element altogether, before it was later restored on further releases. How Did The Original Script Differ?Originally, Leon and Mathilda, who was written as a 13/14 year old, became full lovers. Did The Change Improve The Film? Unquestionably, yes. Part of the strength of Leon is the believability of the relationship between the innocent killer Leon, and his more worldly-wise protégé, as they learn from each other and develop a loving relationship as equals of sorts. A sexual relationship would have altered the characterisation completely, and come across as grubby and sensationalist. At an L.A.preview screening, the audience laughed uncomfortably at a scene where Mathilda asks Leon to become her lover. It was hastily, and wisely, dropped from the final cut.

4. Pretty Woman

Though it may be a bit too sugary for some tastes, Pretty Woman was the smash-hit romantic comedy of 1990, and made a star out of Julia Roberts as tart with a heart Vivian. Hired by successful but lonely businessman Edward as his consort for a week, love ensues, though not without complications and a lot of money. How Did The Original Script Differ? The film was originally conceived as a dark drama about the prostitution scene in LA, and the abundance of drugs within. Vivian was to be hopelessly addicted to cocaine, and her week long escort of Edward was conditional on her successfully completing a withdrawal from the drug. The film was also, until a late stage, entitled $3000, a reference to the fee agreed between the two for the escort service. It was dropped in order to deflect attention away from the fact that Vivian was essentially a money-driven prostitute. Did The Change Improve The Film? Your answer to this, I suppose, depends on whether you enjoyed Pretty Woman or found it too be a bit too cloyingly schmaltzy. While the film was massively successful as a romantic comedy, it would have been interesting to see if it would have had a similar effect as a dark, gritty drama. When you consider some of the names at times attached to the lead role -Pfeiffer, Basinger, Day-Lewis and Pacino amongst others were offered the parts or screen tested- the possibilities could have been endless. One element from the drug storyline remained in the final cut. When Edward burst into the bathroom to find Vivian innocently flossing her teeth, she was originally intended to be doing a line of cocaine.

3. Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back

Things go badly for our lovable bunch of star warriors, as Darth Vader and the Empire return after the events at the end of the first film, resulting in Han Solo being left in the cold and Luke Skywalker suffering from the mother of all Oedipal issues. How Did The Original Script Differ?The first draft, written by Leigh Brackett, was completed a month before the screenwriter died of cancer, leaving no chance for her to do any rewrites. As a result, George Lucas and Lawrence Kasdan performed many redrafts and rewrites before hitting upon one of the biggest twists in 1980's cinema - the widely misquoted "No, Luke, I am your father". In Brackett's original draft, Luke did have a twin sister, but it wasn't Princess Leia. A girl called Newth Skywalker had also been squired by an Anakin Skywalker who had no interest in wearing dark, gaspy headgear, and the twin Skywalkers hidden from the Sith at opposite ends of the galaxy. Did The Change Improve The Film?Of course it did. While Empire was expertly directed, and key elements of the finished film were in place in the finished film, the key appeal of the film, and one of the reasons that it is the most critically lauded of the saga, was the Big Reveal at the end. No Daddy Darth, no backstory trilogy and far less emotional investment in Return Of The Jedi with the dilemma facing Luke at the conclusion. For anyone who throws the brickbat at Lucas that he is a poor writer, this one line and idea changed the course of the Star Wars mythology forever.

2. Beetlejuice

One of the finest comedies of the '80s. Recently deceased couple Adam and Barbara Maitland need help to rid the new tenants of their beloved home, the ghastly Deetz family, yuppies to the core with the exception of goth daughter Lydia. Their largest problem is, having only just leapt the divide between life and death, they make pretty incompetent ghosts. Who ya gonna call? Wisecracking con artist, and ghoul with an agenda, Betelguese of course. How Did The Original Script Differ?In the original draft, Beetlejuice was imagined as an outright horror. Beetlejuice was to be a winged reptilian demon who transformed into a "small Middle Eastern man" to interact with the Maitlands and the Deetzes and was hell-bent on killing them instead of frightening them. Lydia was a minor character who was the victim of an attempted rape by Beetlejuice, and her 6 year old sister Cathy was the one who interacted with him, resulting in her mauling while the demon was in the form of, ridiculously, a giant squirrel. Did The Change Improve The Film?What do you think? Death by squirrel? Rape? Half the charm of the finished film was that Beetlejuice was a horrible, slippery bounder who you still ended up falling in love with, thanks in no small part to a mesmeric performance by Michael Keaton. The original draft sounds like a pumped up version of a ten-a-penny demon horror such as Jeepers Creepers, the likes of which the history of celluloid is already littered with. Thank the lord for a victory of ingenuity, and for Tim Burton.

1. Alien

Ridley Scott's masterpiece amongst masterpieces, a haunted house horror set in deepest space with one of the nastiest, scariest protagonists in cinema. The Alien franchise saw a birth of the horror/sci-fi fusion which didn't always satisfy, but it's high points remain amongst the highest in cinema. Sci-fi was also given a new kind of hero, with Sigourney Weaver's Lt.Ellen Ripley being a strong female character which was all too rare in the late 1970's. How Did The Original Script Differ?The climax of the film was markedly different to the one we all know and love. Ripley has seemingly escaped the xenomorph in the escape pod, only to be ambushed. A distress call is sent back to Earth, only for a pull-away to reveal that she has perished at the hands of her nemesis, who is using her severed head to 'speak' to control. Did The Change Improve The Film?Probably more significantly than any other film on this list, yes. Not only would the audience have been robbed of closure after the claustrophobic tension of what has went before but-and apparently the key reason that the climax was changed- the premise of a ventriloquist xenomorph would have both looked and felt utterly ridiculous. The tone of the film would have been irrevocably damaged, one of the great female characters in cinema would have been lost to a cheap, needless 'shocker' ending and we would never have had one of the strongest sequels of all time-James Cameron's deranged, brutal Aliens. Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.