5 Things Interstellar's Science Gets Right (And 5 It Doesn't)

Scientifically, McCounaghey shouldn't be that orange.

By Tom Baker /

When it comes to science, Hollywood is very rarely top of the class. Explosions, inexplicable romances and special effects that makes Tom Cruise look taller are more their forte - getting anywhere close to scientific accuracy trails way, way behind in terms of priorities. That'll be why people (the studio included) are making such a big deal about Christopher Nolan's latest blockbuster Interstellar, which was produced with the help of actual astrophysicist Kip Thorne. Interstellar deals with a lot of scientific principals and theories that currently exist, including Einstein's whole general relativity bag making up an important (and heartbreaking) plot point, and some of the wackier ideas about black holes and the like popping up as the story moves forward. Claiming that Interstellar is 100% realistic, however, is more than a little naïve. From the stuff that's on the cutting edge of current research to an unfortunate dependency on the worst kind of Hollywood tropes, here are the five things that Interstellar's science gets right - and five it really does not.

The Good

5. Multidimensions Could Be Real

The idea of multidimensional beings have existed in fiction for decades, from the tralfamadorians of Kurt Vonnegut's classic novel Slaughterhouse-Five who exist in all times simultaneously, to Superman villain Mister Mxyzptlk who comes from the fifth dimension and thus can alter our reality in a manner that resembles magic. Which he usually employs simply to pull pranks of the Man Of Steel, which seems like a waste of such huge power. It's also one of those goofier concepts employed in Interstellar that actually has a scientific basis. In physics and mathematics there are multiple theories on dimensions beyond the 3-D space that human beings occupy and conceive of, with those above it occupying a sort of impressionistic, theoretical space of the sort that Matthew McConaughey's Cooper drops into at the end of the film. It's also heavily rooted in the way that gravity can be used to manipulate electromagnetic forces and the like, something which comes into play with the film's climax.

4. The Theory Of Relativity

Not only is Kip Thorne a pretty big brainbox when it comes to most aspects of space science, he's actually one of the world's leading theoretical physicists and experts on relativity. You know, that whole concept that Albert Einstein came up with back in the day about how space contracts and time dilates according to the velocity of the observer, that space and time should be considered together and in relation to each other, and that the speed of light never changes. The latter of which really starts to muck things up for the crew in Interstellar. The theory of relativity becomes a huge plot point when it's revealed that the distance the astronauts are travelling, through the wormhole and off into distant worlds, will mean that time will be passing very differently back home - and even when they pop down to that first planet, they lose a few minutes in their own time, while as aboard the ship and back on Earth twenty five years pass. That's all speculation on what could happen based on Einstein's calculations, but also theoretically sound.

3. Other Inhabitable Worlds Might Exist

It's unlikely that, in the event that the Earth became uninhabitable (which isn't going to be for a little while, just so you know), humanity will find any other planets in our own solar system with with to emigrate to. Mars is way too hot, the atmosphere on most of the rest of them would be borderline toxic, and we can't even make our mind up as to whether Pluto's a real planet. Imagine the shame of living somewhere that isn't even a real planet. How would we be able to show our faces at the intergalactic meetings we'll probably be having by then? In which case, having a wormhole to fling ourselves off to a distant, different galaxy would definitely help. In fact scientists have long been theorising as to what worlds might exist beyond our own humble solar system. Earlier this year, in fact, NASA happened upon Kepler-186f, a planet which resides about 500 light-years away from us in the constellation Cygnus. It's years are 130 days long and it gets one-third the heat energy that we do from our sun, but it has enough water an atmosphere that could sustain human life: roughly a similar distance and challenges to the planets that the Interstellar astronauts were surveying.

2. We Can Freeze Fertilised Eggs

The suspended animation that the astronauts go under in Interstellar is still in its infancy - plenty of people have agreed to be frozen upon their death, but nobody's actually been successfully woken up yet - but another aspect of the mission's plan B that is entirely sound is the shelves full of frozen, fertilised eggs that are supposed to help the human race carry on on whatever new planet they find themselves. Whether or not they could stand up to being packed away on a spaceship and flung through the stratosphere has, well, yet to be tested, but the basic idea's sound. Freezing and storage of eggs is done using liquid nitrogen, removed from a patient whilst under anaesthetic and often helps with couples who are having trouble conceiving, or want to make sure they can have kids at a later date (often after serious illness like cancer reduces their chances). Usually they can only be stored for the better part of a decade, but nobody's bothered to apply the theory of relativity to how fertilised eggs age when they're flying through space with Anne Hathaway.

1. Multiple Worlds Is A Thing

The hard science Kip Thorne brought to the table helped to elevate sci-fi concepts to a more realistic level. Take, for example, the concept of alternate universes and multiple worlds that's hinted at within the wormhole that gets torn in the fabric of space time, the tesseract Matthew McConaughey's Cooper finds himself in after travelling through the black hole, and the fifth dimensional beings that are helping humanity get their butts off of the failing Earth. The concept of multiple worlds has been floated for decades, originally put into words by Hugh Everett (weirdly, the father of miserabilist indie rocker Eels) and since developed by applying concepts of quantum physics, the CERN hadron collider and random radioactive decay into the soup of scientific theory. What appears to be one of the more loopy, broad and unrealistic aspects of Interstellar is actually rooted in a hypothesis that's been around since 1957, and continues to develop.

The Bad

5. NASA Couldn't Work Like That

NASA is bleeding huge. At the height of the Apollo space programme they were being given something like $43,554 million dollars a year in today's money, or 4.41% of the annual federal budget, with 411,000 people being employed. Something like 369,900 of those were contractors drafted into help with all this stuff. In Interstellar, NASA is shown to be a covert operation that's still managing to build both spaceships that can withstand travelling to the other side of the galaxy, and a space station that's designed to save the rest of humanity. That's despite them existing outside of the public eye, because it's thought the general populace would get a little peeved at the amount of government money being spent on a pie-in-the-sky space programme when they should be concentrating on dealing with the dust storms and famine that are blighting them on Earth (similar arguments are going on now, in fact). The NASA in Interstellar is supposed to be a bare bones operation and, honestly, that simply wouldn't work. No way could a reduced operation like that manage to pull off even a fraction of what they do in the film.

4. Those Transmissions Wouldn't Travel

The theory of relativity for some reason doesn't come in for any close scrutiny when it comes to the messages the crew of the Interstellar receive from Earth. The particularly tragic scenes where Coop has accidentally spent twenty five Earth years on one planet, leading to a tearful catching up with decades of messages from his kids as they grow up, get married, and having their own children, and the moment that Murph has to be the on to tell Brand of her dad's own passing - and betrayal - appear to be messages that arrived almost instantaneously. Which, obviously, wouldn't happen. Radio transmissions are pretty powerful things - that's why things like SETI exist, to probe the galaxy for messages that might be pinging about the galaxy from alien civilisations or whatever. It's also why SETI so often get their hopes up over nothing, because they're actually just getting messages from ages ago that are still echoing throughout the cosmos, or else amateur transmissions. Anyway, powerful though they are, they're still susceptible to the vast distances they have to travel to reach the spaceship.

3. Robots Don't Work Like That

Right now we are making some amazing leaps in robotic technology. Honda have got their ASIMO, who can successfully walk up and down stairs (seriously, getting working joints in a cybernetic being is a big deal). DARPA have got those creepy military robots going, from the spider-like tanks to the metal soldiers who can also leg it across rough terrain like living, breathing troops. There are even those creepy ones that look like people and are programmed to have conversations in the way that humans apparently do. None of those things have quite been perfected, however, which makes the charming, sharp-tongued robots that help out in Interstellar fairly beyond the pale. Obviously the future in Interstellar is, well, in the future - but nothing seen on screen hints that it's so far-flung for humanity to have made such huge leaps in their robotics, to the point that they're crazy transforming things with different levels of humour and honesty, which are quick with the one-liners. Sadly.

2. That's Not How Black Holes Work

The ultimate depiction of the cosmic marvels that appear in Interstellar is pretty far from the accepted, real life iteration, from minor quibbles all the way up to what happens when McConaughey purposefully flings himself into one and the film goes full 2001. Remember the planet that was right next to a black hole? Landing there wouldn't only be dangerous, but night impossible. No way that planet would be stable. Plus the planet should be in pitch blackness, since there's no sun nearby and black holes absorb light rather than release it. Worst of all, though, is the tesseract. The fifth dimensional construct Cooper winds up in is closer to magic than science, according to one expert. Apparently you can find some equation where time manipulation though a black hole "sort of, maybe works", but all the time travel malarkey has absolutely no scientific backing, and is more in line with a silly Hollywood plot device than anything approaching reality. Nobody knows what happens when you enter a black hole - nobody's been brave enough to leap in first - but it's probably not that. Speaking of pseudoscience...

1. Love Isn't The Greatest Force In The Universe

If there's a moment that Interstellar jumps the shark, it's when Anne Hathaway's Brand - previously a totally rational, almost uncaring genius scientist - reveals her romantic weakness for one of the lost astronauts the crew is hoping to track down, leading to a rambling monologue about how love is the most powerful and unquantifiable force in the universe. What's even worse is that, by the time of the film's climax, she's proven to be right: somehow, Cooper's love for his daughter Murph is what helps him return to her in the tesseract, and get the message out about leaving Earth. Yeah, no, that's not science even in the slightest. That's the worst kind of Hollywood cliché being shoved into what's otherwise film that trades on hard science, abandoning that intellectual edge in favour of indulging in the idiotic trope that love conquers all. That's silly. Love is nice, obviously, but it isn't some great, unknowable cosmic force, like a nice Chutlhu. Love is mysterious, but there's plenty of stuff in science and biology that's mysterious, and romantic. Love is almost certainly just the firing of chemicals in human brains to kick start reproduction vital to continuing the species. Powerful, but not universe-shaking.