Iron Man is the most popular hero in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, of that there is no doubt. Tony Stark's armoured superhero has so far spawned three titular movies, as well as a cameo at the end of the Incredible Hulk and a starring role in the Avengers movie and, despite the climax of Iron Man 3 which could suggest an end to Stark's hero days, it is widely expected that another Iron Man movie will surface at some point (as well as an inevitable starring appearance in Avengers: Age of Ultron). In the event of another Iron Man movie, there are still loads of great villains from his rogues gallery who could be adapted for the big screen - the Living Laser, Fin Fang Foom, Ultimo, even a proper adaptation of the Mandarin - but there are several that should be avoided, for various reasons. On that note, here are five villains to avoid using in future Iron Man movies...
5. Melter
The Melter has actually already made an appearance in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (sort of), when he appeared in a spin-off short called Iron Man: The Coming of the Melter, which was a comic that was set before the events of Iron Man 3. The Melter is soundly defeated by Iron Man and War Machine in the comic, and any temptation to bring him back for the big screen should be heartily resisted. He is a terrible villain, with a horrible concept and a ridiculous name, and armoured villains have been done to death already with Iron Monger and Whiplash, so if Marvel insist on using anymore, they'd better make them good. The Melter isn't good. His armour is as tough as Tony Stark's, but its main offensive output is energy rays that melt metal. It doesn't get any more boring or unimaginative than that. The character, whose alias is Bruno Horgan, a business rival of Tony Stark's, first appeared in Tales of Suspense #47 in 1963, so he is a long-standing villain, but he's not right for carrying a whole movie.
4. Scarecrow
First appearing in Tales of Suspense #51 in 1964, Marvel's Scarecrow (a blatant rip-off of DC's Batman rogue of the same name) is nowhere near as interesting a character as his DC counterpart, despite the obvious similarities. He first appeared while working as a contortionist in a circus, when he actually helped Iron Man to apprehend a criminal, but he decided to use his skills for criminal purposes in an attempt to get rich quickly after that, and came into conflict with a variety of heroes, notably Iron Man. In addition to his obvious athletic and acrobatic abilities, Scarecrow is also injected with a pheromone that gives him slightly superhuman strength and a healing factor (as well as the ability to inflict fear in others, like the character he is clearly based on). However, he also has the ability to control crows (oh dear), which he uses to carry out a variety of tasks, including attacking his victims en masse and killing them. On the off-chance that Marvel think "a Scarecrow character worked in the Dark Knight trilogy, why not in the Marvel Cinematic Universe?", they should quickly reconsider.
3. Detroit Steel
Detroit Steel, which first appeared quite recently in 2010 in Iron Man (vol. 5) #25, is not actually a character, it's simply an armour. Marketed by Stark Industries' rivals Hammer Industries, the armour is available for hire to the highest bidder, meaning that anyone who can afford it can wear it - which makes it pretty meaningless as far as a villainous identity goes. It can be spray-painted to suit the wearer's preference and has been painted in a Japanese flag design, while it has also been said that it could have the McDonald's logo on it if the price was right. In addition to the identity problem that would come with using Detroit Steel in a movie, it would also inevitably receive criticism for resembling a Transformer (much like Avengers received criticism for the giant Chitauri space whales resembling some of the crafts from Transformers: Dark of the Moon, which preceded the Avengers movie by a year). And, again, if Marvel must use an armoured villain again, at least make it further removed from previous efforts than this one, which offers nothing new.
2. Mallen
On the off chance that Marvel feel the need to continue the Extremis angle in their Iron Man movies (perhaps with a perfected version of the virus and a subsequently more powerful wielder), they should avoid it and they should definitely avoid using Mallen. First appearing in Iron Man (vol. 4) #1 in 2005, Mallen possessed the same abilities as Aldrich Killian did in the Iron Man 3 movie, but with the added "bonus" of having claws and being able to generate electricity. The worst thing about the character, however, was that he emerged from a horrible scab-like coccoon when he first developed his powers, which would look disgusting on screen in a live action depiction. Scabs aside, Extremis has been done and shouldn't be repeated, even though I can see the temptation to use a "perfected" version of the virus as a means of conveying an increased threat to the titular Iron Man character.
1. Unicorn
What a ridiculous villain. Unicorn first appeared in Tales of Suspense (vol. 1) #56 in 1964. He is Milos Masaryk, a Soviet intelligence agent who battles Iron Man after he is tricked into siding with America, but ends up spying on Stark Industries while doing so. He has a ridiculous helmet that should be avoided on the big screen at all costs; it is more phallic than unicorn-like and would look stupid. The name "Unicorn" just isn't threatening enough either. The character has aged badly and comes across as stupid in modern times. His helmet projects energy of variable levels of force, while mutagenic radiation treatments gave him superhuman strength and endurance, meaning he is a physical threat to Iron Man, but that simply isn't enough to make up for his appearance, name and overall concept. Definitely one to avoid, Marvel. Which of Iron Man's long list of rogues do you think should not be considered for use in future movies? Let us know in the comments box below, and please feel free to follow me on Twitter!