The Dark Knight Rises may just be the most debated, discussed, and outright polarizing comic book film ever made. Even nearly two years after its release, there are wars raging online between those who are still harboring a stinging resentment towards the movie, and those who will defend it to the death. Any other comic book movie might simply be cast aside, forgiven for its mistakes, or even forgotten with time; but for some reason this fascinating debate surrounding The Dark Knight Rises just won't go away. When emotions run high, it's difficult to focus on what's actually being presented and what we perceive is happening, and with a film as complicated and dense as this one it's easy to see where some may get lost in the shuffle. As time goes on and specific criticisms against the movie remain consistent, it's important to take a look back at what it's actually telling us, as opposed to what we might remember or misunderstood from earlier viewings. It is a long movie, after all, and after nearly three hours of bombastic Hans Zimmer music, I don't blame those who staggered out of the theater suffering from a bit of sensory overload. Here are six common misconceptions about the film, with further explanation that should help shed some light on the controversy and heal some of those old battle wounds.
6. Bruce Is A Recluse For 8 Years
One of the most frustrating arguments lauded against the film is that "Bruce just hid in his mansion for eight years." It's easy to see how the timeline of the film got misconstrued; it takes place eight years after The Dark Knight, and at the start of it, Bruce has seemingly gone mad, grown a creepy beard, and has locked himself away from the world. But, if you listen closely to what other characters say at the start of the film, you'll see that he hasn't been reclusive for that entire eight year gap. After Bruce put away the cape and cowl he turned his attention to doing philanthropic work as Bruce Wayne, rather than dressing up at night and fighting criminals. He attempted to start a clean energy project, creating a fusion reactor. According to Miranda Tate, he worked on that project for five years before inexplicably pulling the plug, then disappearing from public life. So, just for the record: Bruce hangs up the cape, tries the energy project for 5 years, then becomes a recluse for three. He didn't become one because he quit being Batman; he tried saving Gotham as Bruce but failed and that's why he gave up. It's an important distinction because many just assume that since he's not Batman anymore, he hides for 8 years and that's some big knock on his character. When in fact, that's not the case at all.
5. Bruce Is Actually Dead, The Cafe Scene Is All In Alfred's Head
Nothing in the film supports the "Bruce is actually dead," theory, other than the fact that Christopher Nolan, a man known for his mind-bending twists, made the movie. I bet that if Inception hadn't come out first, this theory wouldn't exist. Many believe that the cafe sequence at the end of the film takes place in Alfred's head and that Bruce died while saving Gotham from the neutron bomb. This theory exists because we don't actually see Bruce escape the explosion, and instead are made to believe, up until the second-to-last scene in the movie, that he sacrificed himself for his city. One sign that the scene is actually real is the presence of Selina Kyle, whom Alfred only met one time at the beginning of the movie. He had no idea that she and Bruce would wind up together or that Bruce would give her the pearls. So why would he imagine that she was there with him? If he was really imagining the scene, it wouldn't be so specific.
4. Bane Is Just A Henchman
One of the biggest complaints about the movie is the revelation of Bane's backstory. We're led to believe that he's the child of Ra's Al Ghul, who escaped the prison pit as a young boy. As it turns out, Ra's had a daughter, Talia (who it's revealed is pretending to be Miranda Tate), and the child was, in fact, her. Bane was the man who helped her, and was severely beaten because of it. Later, when Ra's brought the League of Shadows in to take over the prison and avenge the death of his wife, he found Bane and took him under his wing. According to Talia, Bane was banished from the League because Ra's saw him as a monstrosity and a constant reminder of the Pit. Many have claimed that Bane being an ally of Talia's makes him nothing more than a henchman, but I think that's the wrong way of looking at it. Bane wasn't just her servant, but a partner in the plan to destroy Gotham. He's not just hired muscle, and does many things on his own accord. He is responsible for a coup in West Africa that brings John Dagget exclusive access to resources there. Bane uses this as leverage to get Dagget on his side and bring mercenaries into Gotham City. Bane is the one who crashes the plane in order to kidnap and fake the death of Dr. Pavel, and leads the occupation of Gotham City. Oh, and let's not forget that he single handedly beats Batman and breaks his back. Sure, he may be doing these things under Talia's direction, but Bane is a smart, calculating villain that undoubtedly has input into the overall plans. Plus, he doesn't follow every order she gives him; she asks him to keep Batman alive in time to see Gotham's demise, but Bane turns to him and says, "We both know that I have to kill you now." To simply call Bane a henchman takes away all of the evil and badass things we've watched him do throughout the film. The fact that he's working with Talia doesn't make him a lesser character, it simply fills out his backstory while tying his actions into Ra's Al Ghul's original plan to destroy Gotham.
3. It's Humorless
In any other year, this criticism may not have arisen. However, this was the year that The Avengers came out, a few months before TDKR hit theaters, and that set the bar pretty high when it came to what superhero films could do that summer. We'll get to the box office in a minute; instead I'd like to take a look at another problem lauded at the movie: "It's humorless." TDKR is, simiply, not humorless. Is it chock full of jokes like, say, The Avengers? Absolutely not. But that's like comparing apples to oranges. Yes, both movies are comic book films, but they have completely different goals and are made by people with completely different visions. The Avengers revels in its comic book roots, while Nolan places TDKR solely in reality. The debate about which film is "better" will go on forever, so I won't even try to sway public opinion one way or another. I will simply say that just because this movie isn't as overly funny as the other, doesn't mean it's not funny at all. In fact, there are several moments of levity throughout the film, mostly coming from Bruce's interactions with characters like Selina Kyle and Lucious Fox. Selina is a very funny character, and Lucious is, as usual, always giving funny one liners to Bruce. Alfred gives a few good laughs, and Bane himself is funny at times as well. Though the film definitely has its darker moments and its overall tone comes nowhere close to comedic, calling it humorless suggests that there are no moments of levity at all; which simply isn't true.
2. It Wasn't A Success
TDKR's $1.08 billion box office haul should have been seen as an outright victory. It absolutely is. However, because The Avengers shattered records and became the third-highest grossing film of all time, people look at TDKR's numbers and count them as a failure. TDKR is the ninth highest grossing film of all time, while The Dark Knight sits at number 17, the last of the "billion dollar club." Yet, people are more apt to point to The Dark Knight as an outright success than TDKR. Critical reaction is something that's also been forgotten with time. Because TDKR is so polarizing in the geek community, many think it was an outright failure or a bad end to the Dark Knight trilogy. In fact, it enjoyed much critical praise, sitting at 88% on Rottentomatoes, which makes it the highest-rated third film in a superhero trilogy of all time. Because of the internet and because so many people online actively debate the merits and quality of this film, it's easy to forget that a large percentage of those who saw and enjoyed the movie aren't reading articles like this one or talking about it on Twitter. Also, when looking at the overall "success" of a film, it's important to not only look at box office numbers or what critics thought. Film is a subjective thing, so what's successful to one person might be successful to another, and we'll just have to wait and see how the film holds up over time before casting such harsh judgement.
1. Bruce Quit Being Batman Because Of Rachel's Death
The biggest misconception about The Dark Knight Rises is Bruce's motivations for putting away the cape and cowl. Many simply point to Rachel's death as the catalyst and reason for his retirement; but they're only looking at part of the larger picture. Yes, her death had an impact on him emotionally, but was only one of several factors that went into his decision. First and foremost, it's worth noting that Bruce never intended to be Batman indefinitely. He always went into it knowing that he couldn't, and wouldn't do it forever. His desire is to become a symbol of hope that will allow the rest of Gotham to follow his example. In The Dark Knight we see a glimmer of hope in Harvey Dent. Bruce believes that Harvey can become the symbol that Batman can't, and even tells Rachel that the time is coming where he won't need to be Batman anymore. Of course, things don't quite work that way once Harvey becomes Two-Face, and its Harvey's death that becomes the first step towards Bruce's retirement. Bruce takes the fall for the murders Harvey committed, destroying any positive image that he'd built up around the Caped Crusader and instead gives it all to Harvey. Harvey became the white knight, and before long the Dent Act was passed, which eventually made Batman unnecessary. The Dent Act effectively put an end to organised crime, taking the various mob bosses and important figures in criminal organizations and placing them in Blackgate Prison without the possibility of parole. This of course put an end to organized crime in Gotham, by not only locking up members of the mob but deterring others from committing similar crimes. There was obviously still crime, as in any city, but with the Joker in Arkham and without the big mob bosses like Falcone or Marone, someone like Batman wasn't really needed anymore. This all happened right after Dent's death, which is why Bruce hasn't been Batman for eight years. There's a chance he continued to fight crime for a little while until the mob bosses were all locked away, because Detective John Blake at one point says it's been eight years since the "last confirmed sighting" of the Batman. He could still have done things for a little while without being seen by police, but then once the streets were cleaned up, he took a step back. So, though Rachel's death affected Bruce deeply and took away his hope or desire for a normal life, it had very little to do with his retirement from being Batman. And there we have it, 6 common misconceptions about The Dark Knight Rises. What did you think of the list? Do you agree or disagree with what I had to say about these interpretations of the film? Make sure to comment down below so we can get a good discussion going, and be sure to follow me on Twitter!