6 Things Joss Whedon Hated About The Avengers
Working with Earth's mightiest heroes can make you a bit shouty sometimes. Just ask Nick Fury.
On balance, Joss Whedon doesn't regret his Avengers experience. He was successful long before taking on the franchise, but it still catapulted him from a TV producer with some wins and some losses into the exclusive club of billion-dollar directors. Moreover, he's a fan from way back and the chance to speak for his childhood heroes called him into action not once but twice.
But this greater level of success brought some frustrations with it. Pretty much every report on Whedon before, during, and after the movie's release has stressed how exhausted he is. Though he has pondered doing more creative consultancy with Marvel and maybe even contributing a script for Avengers 3, he's very clear on one point: Avengers 2 is his last Marvel movie as a director. Making Avengers 3 "would be four years of my life," he says, "after which I would be twenty years older."
Creative types know it well: no matter how much we put into the work, there's always something wrong that jumps out at us when it's done. And when you're making movies with a studio that has certain demands about how things need to go, sometimes that wrong thing is actually somebody else's idea. Or sometimes the thing will feel like the worst problem in the world during the creative process and turn out to be for the best. Spoilers for both movies to follow.
6. Hawkeye's Virus Arrow
As usual when telling stories about super-teams that put ordinary humans side-by-side with gods, there's a certain pressure to make the humans impressive enough to keep up or at least contribute to the story. This was especially challenging with Hawkeye in the first movie: much of his backstory was cut from earlier drafts and he spent much of the film as a mind-controlled puppet, serving Loki without complaint.
His assault on the Helicarrier, firing an explosive arrow into the kind of wind resistance you encounter at seven miles' altitude, is hella impressive, taking out one of the engines on the first try. He then leads Loki's minions into a full-scale hijacking of the ship. But Whedon seemed, upon reflection, to find Hawkeye's next move a little too impressive. Like, Bugs Bunny-level impressive.
Sneaking into position near the cockpit, Hawkeye lets fly with an explosive arrow, then a second arrow that strikes a special port in one of its computers. On impact, the arrowhead sticks out prongs that fit into the port and another of the engines immediately dies, sending the Helicarrier hurtling out of the sky.
"What? It's a virus arrow!" Whedon jokes on the commentary. "That could totally happen! Don't make fun of me."
5. The Invisible Spider-Man And Captain Marvel
The end of the second film is a nice enough moment. Captain America, rather than continue to yearn for the happy ending with Peggy Carter that will never be his, has embraced his identity as a soldier. The Avengers are now his home. Black Widow puts aside dreams of a different life but also the idea that she's doomed to be no more than an assassin, and they prepare to beat their new team into shape.
The rest of the team is made up of new members who have earned their place over the course of the movie. The Scarlet Witch, Vision, and War Machine were all pivotal in the final battle against Ultron. And the Falcon... talked apartments with Cap for a few minutes, that totally counts.
Still, that roster could have been a little more exciting. None of them are losers exactly, but none have quite the star power of an Iron Man, Thor, or Hulk. And at the time this scene was shaping up, Sony and Marvel were in talks about bringing Spider-Man into Marvel's cinematic universe and a Captain Marvel movie was at the pitch stage.
Whedon was naturally enthusiastic about the chance to debut Spider-Man and another female superhero in the final moments before the credits ran... or maybe even in an end-of-credits sequence like the ones in the first Avengers and Guardians of the Galaxy. But talks stretched on as they do, and when the deal was finally done, it was too late for Whedon to film even the merest, two-second glimpse of Spider-Man dangling on a slowly stretching webline from the ceiling.
4. The First Movie Had Only One Villain
Oddly, Whedon felt that the first movie was a little underpopulated. While he always felt Loki should be the mastermind, he worried that the film needed a second villain to balance the scales of power and make things a little tougher for the heroes, at least before the Chitauri showed up.
It was the one battle I lost completely. I definitely felt like I had Earths Mightiest Heroes. I have four of the biggest, baddest, toughest guys out there and I have one British character actor. And they believed very strongly they didnt want to add any more mythology. I wasnt gonna argue in the end. It was very difficult for me to make that work, but the ace in the hole was Tom Hiddleston because hes so compelling and commanding and gracious about it. It became how he got in their heads and its gonna be fine. It took me a long time to accept that because "They need someone to hit."
This seems like an argument in favor of studio interference, or at least a reminder that it's not always a bad thing. With no external threat, Whedon had to spend more time on the Avengers fighting each other, leading to exhilarating fight scenes and a more meaningful conclusion as the team finally comes together. With one fewer character, he got to spend that much more time on the others and Loki in particular. It's harder to side with Marvel in the next case.
3. Marvel Was As Impatient As Quicksilver
If you thought Avengers 2 was a little frantic, what with over a dozen main characters vying for attention, you should see what it would've looked like if Whedon had let the studio have its way. And if you thought the scenes in the farm, the cave, and the Avengers' own heads were a little confusing, you might've liked them better if they'd run at Whedon's intended length - or if, as some Marvel executives preferred, they were almost skipped altogether.
In other words, Whedon and Marvel clashed repeatedly about his trademark character development and how much of it would end up on the cutting room floor. Thor's sequence in the cave was cut the most, and partly as a result, Thor has very little screen time in the second movie altogether - less than any other Avenger except the Vision, who doesn't even exist for about two-thirds of it. Ironically, the original Thor cave scene was more visual, with the Norns possessing Thor and Selvig asking them questions. But it didn't play well to test audiences, and something had to go.
The dreams were not an executive favorite eitherthe dreams, the farmhouse, these were not things they liked, they were things I fought to keep. With the cave, it really turned into: they pointed a gun at the farms head and said, "Give us the cave, or well take out the farm,"in a civilized way. I respect these guys, theyre artists, but thats when it got really, really unpleasant... I was so beaten down at that point that I was like, "Sure, okay. What movie is this?" And the editors were like, "No. You have to show the . You can't just say it."
Whedon did go on to say that the film is, to his mind, only a couple of minutes too short. You know, just 120,000 milliseconds to a perfectionist.
2. Coulson Died
Whedon knew it had to happen. The Avengers were wildly different people, each an alpha in his or her own way, and Loki barely even needed his magic scepter to get them to start snapping at each other.
Coulson was the glue that held the team together without their realizing it. He was the one person whom Steve, Tony, Thor, Nick and Natasha all liked and trusted, and his death gave the team the unity it so badly needed. His dying words might as well have been Whedon narrating: "This was never going to work, if they didn't have something... to..." Avenge.
The only problem was that Whedon had a certain... reputation for killing off his most lovable characters. His body-count could inspire a list of its own: Buffy's mother Joyce Summers, Jenny Calendar, Tara Maclay, Winifred Burkle, Anya, Shepherd Book, Hoban Washburne, Penny from Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog... and those are just the ones who didn't get better. Oh, and Quicksilver. As he started Avengers, he'd hoped to get away from that tic, but Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige convinced him it was necessary. Whedon agreed as long as Feige would be the one taking the bullets.
In our first meeting Kevin Feige said, "This is what were gonna do" and I said, "Oh, but you have to go out there and tell everybody that it was your idea because this is going to get me so much sh*t. Because they are all going to be like, 'Oh, he did it again!'"
1. Coulson Lives
Even though some of Whedon's deaths stare deeply into the finality of death in our world, he's indulged the fantasy of resurrection more than once, too. Buffy alone came back from the dead twice. Whedon's run on Astonishing X-Men ends with one apparent death (Kitty Pryde), but reverses another (Colossus). Even the Avengers movies have a couple of seeming deaths reversed minutes later-- Tony in the first film and JARVIS (more or less) in the second. Even as Whedon was filming Phil Coulson's death scene, he was planning to revive him and make him the star of TV's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. But in an interview this year, Whedon seemed to have some regrets.
The Coulson thing was, I think, a little anomalous just because that really came from the television division, which is sort of considered to be its own subsection of the Marvel universe. As far as the fiction of the movies, Coulson is dead.
But I have to say, watching the first one with my kidsI had not watched the first one since it came outand then watching it with my kids and watching Coulson die but , Yeah, but I know that he kind of isnt, it did take some of the punch out of it for me. Of course, I spent a lot of time making sure he didnt. And at the time it seemed inoffensive, as long as it wasnt referenced in the second movie, which it isnt.
Theres a thing where you can do that so many times and theres nothing at stake. But its difficult because youre living in franchise worldnot just Marvel, but in most big filmswhere you cant kill anyone, or anybody significant. And now I find myself with a huge crew of people and, although Im not as bloodthirsty as some people like to pretend, I think its disingenuous to say were going to fight this great battle, but theres not going to be any loss. So my feeling in these situations with Marvel is that if somebody has to be placed on the altar and sacrificed. Ill let you guys decide if they stay there.
A couple of weeks later, Whedon came up with a snarkier way to address the issue.
Yeah, hes dead. The entire television series is just a fever dream. Its a Jacobs Ladder moment hes having at the point of death, but we dont give that away until after season seven. And theres a snow globe. Now Ive given it away. !*$%!