7 "Perfect" Movie Endings That Are Way More Contrived Than You Think

Even some of cinema's best and most appreciated endings might not hold up under close scrutiny.

By WhatCulture /

There's no denying that the end of a movie is one of the - if not the - most important parts of any motion picture experience. It's the point at which everything you've been striving towards for the sum of two or three or even four hours comes to a kind of definite climax - a chance for the director to give a closing statement of sorts, and send you on your way with something to think about or ponder over (or not, as the case may be: we're looking at you, Mr. Michael Bay). One thing that all movies have in common, regardless of their quality, is that they eventually come to an end, then (unless the film in question was directed by D.W. Griffith - phew!). Endings are often controversial, of course, because they mark the last point at which we're invited to be part of the fictional world depicted on-screen, and an ambiguous ending can often prove unsatisfying. As a result of that, it's rare that movie-goers find themselves staring into what the general populace might deem to be a "perfect" ending - an ending that ties up the cinematic experience that preceded it in a seemingly faultless way, and has you leaving the theatre feeling like the writer or director really knew what they were doing. But even some of cinema's best and most appreciated endings might not hold up under close scrutiny. Here's 7 for your consideration...

Honourable Mention: Giant T-Rex Finds It Way Into The Building To Fend Off Evil Velociraptors - Jurassic Park

Not included on the main list, because, hey, this one has been covered so many times, it's probably not even considered to be all that interesting nowadays - you know what we're talking about, though: in the final big scene of the movie, a T-Rex turns up to rescue Alan Grant and his companions from velociraptor death... how did that monstrous lizard manage to find its way into the building, though? Surely he's much too big, even if he did conveniently come through that unbuilt section in the back of the room? Does anybody even care anymore? CLOSE THE PARK.

7. Marty Tells Doc "To Back Up" Because There's Not Enough Road To Get Up To 88; There Totally Is - Back To The Future

Back to the Future tells the story of one Marty McFly (Michael J. Fox), an awesomely cool teenager who gets sent back in time to 1955 in a time travelling DeLorean and accidently prevents his parents from meeting. His mission, of course, is to get them back together before he's erased from existence. To do this, he teams up with the younger version of the time machine's inventor, Doc Emmet L. Brown (Christopher Lloyd), who eventually helps Marty to achieve his goal and succeeds in sending him "back to the future" - that is, back to 1985. Upon driving him back to his house in the present, Doc speeds off at 88 miles an hour (the speed at which time travel is permissible) and goes on vacation to the future. The classic ending to this movie has Doc returning and telling Marty that they have to go to the future to prevent a crisis from occurring with Marty's kids. Marty, his girlfriend Jennifer, and the Doc climb into the DeLorean at this point, only for Marty to tell Doc: "Hey, Doc, you better back up, we don't have enough road to get up to 88." "Roads? Where we're going, we don't need roads," the Doc quips, as the DeLorean takes off from the ground - newly equipped with thrusters - and flies off. It's a seeming perfect ending to a perfect movie, with one contrived nitpick: when the Doc dropped Marty off on the same road earlier on from the exact same position, he drove off fine and managed to get to 88mph on the exact same amount of turf. Marty's line about not having enough road to get to 88, then, makes zero sense, because they're on that same darn road. The purpose Marty's dialogue cue, of course, was to initiate the now immortal final line of the movie, but it - ultimately - means zilch. And yet we'll forgive it, because this movie is too awesome.

6. Indiana Jones Knows Not To Look At The Ark For Some Unexplained Reason - Raiders Of The Lost Ark

Raiders of the Lost Ark tells the action-packed story of an archeologist's frantic quest to stop the Ark of the Convenant from falling into the hands of the Nazis. After successfully managing to find the secret location where the Ark is buried in Cairo, Dr. Indiana Jones (Harrison Ford) finds himself on route to a mysterious island where his adversary, Rene Belloq (Paul Freeman), who is working with the Nazis, has taken the Ark captive and is about to perform an "ancient ritual." He's also taken Indy's love interest, Marion Ravenwood (Karen Allen), as hostage. Indy is ultimately captured of course, and is tied up - alongside Marion - on a pole, as Belloq and the Nazis open the Ark. In the film's infamous finale, the Ark reveals itself to be an artifact of unspeakable evil, and unleashes a variety of terrifying ghosts and spirits, before firing out a series of electric bolts that kills everybody who happens to be watching the ceremony - Belloq and his cronies get their heads melted and/or exploded in an incredibly satisfying scene. Indy and Marion escape death, however, because Indy insists they shut their eyes. The problem with this ending, of course, is that Indy seems to just pluck this sudden death prevention tactic out of nowhere - for some reason, without explanation, he knows that he's not supposed to stare directly at the Ark. So are we supposed to just assume that Indy was guessing when he suggested this? His delivery of the line, "Shut your eyes, Marion. Don't look at it," tells a different story. Alas, in a deleted scene, Indy was apparently supposed to learn not to look at the Ark from the same shaman, Imam, that we meet during the whole "bad dates" debacle. So whereas this scene is iconic and brilliant, it does lack a dash of essential logic which most people tend to overlook. A simple line of exposition would've certainly helped.

5. Charlotte Teleports To Downtown Tokyo Ahead Of Bob So He Can Conveniently Spot Her In A Crowd - Lost In Translation

Lost in Translation tells the melancholic but ultimately life-affirming tale of two lost souls, Bob (Bill Murray) and Charlotte (Scarlett Johansson), who spend a week together in Tokyo, eating weird foods, singing karaoke, and generally being "foreigners in Japan." Bob is a faded movie star there to shoot a whisky commercial; Charlotte is a college graduate accompanying her photographer boyfriend on an assignment. They meet in their hotel one night and instantly connect. At the end of the movie, though, Bob must return to Los Angeles ahead of his new favourite person, and he bids farewell to Charlotte in a sad and awkward scene in the hotel lobby. As Charlotte returns in the lift to her hotel room, Bob gets into his limo and drives away, staring solemnly out of the window, wondering what could have been. And then... hey, wait a minute! Downtown, he spots somebody in the street walking amongst the crowds. It's Charlotte! He leaps out of his limo, follows her, kisses her, and whispers something unheard into her ear. The soundtrack kicks in at the point as if to say, yeah, that's the perfect ending we wanted, and the fate of Bob and Charlotte's relationship, though unclear, feels a little more hopeful. Still, what most fail to notice during this scene is how contrived it is in its set-up: how did Charlotte, who went back upstairs in the hotel elevator, suddenly appear in the middle of a street in downtown Tokyo... ahead of Bob? Bob left long before her, remember, and Charlotte has no means of transport. It makes no sense that she'd have been able to be in that specific location for Bob to spot her! It's a lovely ending - perfect in many ways - but it does take a bit of a narrative leap to get our characters into position for their final encounter.

4. Ramon Refuses To Shoot Joe Anywhere But His Heart Just Because Joe Tells Him To - A Fistful Of Dollars

In Sergio Leone's western remake of Yojimbo, A Fistful of Dollars, Clint Eastwood's "Man With No Name" character - nicknamed "Joe" in this movie - rides into a one horse town called San Miguel to find that it has been torn apart by two rival families, the Baxters and the Rojos. With nothing better to do, and because it's the plot of the movie, Joe decides to free the town of its misfortune, and slowly begins on a complicated plan to tear the two factions apart. Eventually they get wind of his schtick, and Joe realises that it is the Rojos Brothers who are causing all the real problems, led by the most intelligent member of the clan, Ramon, who also has a penchant for shooting people square in the heart. After the Rojos slaughter the Baxter clan in a horrific massacre, Ramon takes Joe captive and orders his men to beat the gunslinger within an inch of his life. On the brink of death, Joe manages to escape Ramon's clutches, and flees to the outskirts of town to regain his strength, repair his gun-hand, and devise a plan. Joe eventually returns to San Miguel and confronts Ramon, who - at Joe's request - shoots him in the heart over and over again - each time, Joe gets up, apparently unscathed. It's then revealed that he's devised a makeshift bullet proof vest from an iron sheet and is wearing it beneath his poncho. At this point, Joe gets into a shootout with the Rojos clan, kills Ramon and wins the day. What we have to consider here, though, is... would Ramon legitimately have chosen to shoot Joe over and over again in the same place? Why not just shoot him in the head? It's a classic ending to a classic film, but - despite Ramon's fetish for shooting hearts - it still feels a little contrived, even with Joe's taunting. It just doesn't ring true that - if he really wanted to kill him - he wouldn't have just put a shot right between the Man With No Name's eyes.

3. John Doe Goes Against His Established Character And Kills Tracy Because The Movie Needs Him To - Se7en

Se7en is a movie about a psychopathic serial killer who murders people in an unnamed American city, using the "seven deadly sins" as his M.O.. On the case are newly paired detectives William Somerset (Morgan Freeman) and David Mills (Brad Pitt). After a cat and mouse chase ensues - and to the surprise of pretty much everyone - the killer - known only as "John Doe" - hands himself in to the cops. Placed under arrest, he agrees to plea guilty if one demand is met: he is to be driven out to the desert at a certain time, where he'll disclose the place where the final missing bodies are hidden. With no other choices available, they are forced to agree. Upon arrival in the desert, Mills and Somerset realise that something is up: a delivery van arrives at the set time, and presents Somerset with a box, which has been pre-organised for delivery by John Doe. Somerset opens the box, and it's revealed that it contains the head of Mills' wife, Tracy. Doe's plan all along, of course, was to push Mills into killing him, therefore rendering them as the final sins - envy (because Doe tried to "taste the life of a simple man" by playing husband with Tracy) and wrath (Mills' revenge). Mills obliges, and John Doe "wins." At first, this all seems to be meticulous planned, by both screenwriter Andrew Kevin Walker, and the character of John Doe himself. What you realise on closer inspection, however, is that Walker - and therefore Doe - betray the internal logic of the film's premise and of Doe's plan by having him murder Tracy. According to Doe, after all, he's not out to punish innocent people... and yet he murders Tracy, who has committed no sin. The problem with this is that Walker hopes we won't notice the contrived way in which the final plot points are pieced together; the death of Tracy is shocking, of course, but it doesn't fit in with the rest of the story in the ways we're led to believe. For a "genius" who has devised his plan to a precision point, the death of Tracy stands out like a sore thumb when you look into it further - would a man as meticulous as John Doe compromise the entire point of everything he did by killing an innocent woman? Smell that contrived ending?

2. The Animals Come Home One By One (Because It's More Dramatic That Way) - Homeward Bound

Disney's Homeward Bound, the remake of another Disney movie called The Incredible Journey, tells the heartwarming story of three charismatic pets - two dogs and a cat - who come to think they've been abandoned by their perfect suburban family, and make their way across country (and several mountains) in order to find their way home. They haven't been abandoned, of course - the family have simply gone on vacation, and leave their pets with a friend. Animals can't understand humans in this movie, though, so there's a big misunderstanding. After crossing a devastating mountain range, facing off against a variety of terrifying wild animals, crossing a river and escaping from the pound, Shadow (voiced by Don Ameche), Chance (Michael J. Fox) and Sassy (Sally Field) come to an old train yard, where Shadow, an old golden retriever, falls into a hole and is horribly injured. The movie creates a sort of cliffhanger at this point - will Shadow get home? Back at the house, the worried family Seaver mourn the loss of their pets, when all of a sudden there's a bark and... it's Chance! He's come home! Chance bounds up from the bottom of the garden, barking ecstatically, as the Seavers react exactly as you would in such a situation: shocked as hell. At this point, we're wondering where the other pets are, and then, after a minute, Sassy returns and is greeted with a similar sense of awe. But where's Shadow? As Shadow's favourite family member, Peter, gets upset and heads towards the house, the dog suddenly appears at the end of the garden, muddy and old, but still alive. Thing is, why - when these animals have spent every second together since the moment the movie started, refusing to separate - would they return home, one by one, minutes apart? Are we really supposed to believe that Chance left a nearly dead Shadow two minutes behind him? Of course, the scene unfolds as such because it's more dramatic that way, but - when you think about it - the "perfect" ending to this jolly flick is contrived as heck. Great soundtrack, though.

1. Lars Thorwald Takes Ridiculously Slow Steps For Absolutely No Reason Whilst He's Being Flashed - Rear Window

Alfred Hitchcock's Rear Widow tells the story of L.B. "Jeff" Jeffries (Jimmy Stewart), a war photographer whose latest assignment ends in a broken leg; he's confined to his New York apartment (and a wheelchair) so he can heal up for a few months. An inquisitive man by nature, Jeffries soon finds himself obsessed with staring out of his window and into the courtyard of his building, where he begins to find entertainment in the lives of his fellow occupants. Soon enough, though, Jeffries begins to suspect that something isn't quite right in the apartment directly across from him - has the tenant, one Lars Thorwald, murdered his wife? Jeffries' existence is soon focused entirely around this suspicion, and he enlists his girlfriend Lisa (Grace Kelly) and his housekeeper Stella (Thelma Ritter) to help him solve the case. After much deliberation, it turns out that yes, Lars Thorwald did kill his wife after all, but whilst Lisa is snooping around his apartment, Thorwald spots Jeff peeking and makes his way across the yard to get some revenge. As Thorwald enters, Jeffries comes up with the apparently genius idea of switching off all the lights and using the flash of his camera to stop Thorwald from getting at him - as the great, burly murderer enters Jeffries' apartment, he sets off the camera flashbulbs, temporarily stunning him. Each time Thorwald begins to move towards our wheelchair-bound hero, Jeff flashes off another bulb, stopping him from moving. Thorwald does eventually grab Jeff anyway, but the whole "bulb flash thing" - the most famous part of the ending - ultimately feels badly devised. Which is to say, Thorwald's great, bumbling reactions to being blinded over and over again (like some goofy incarnation of Frankenstein's monster) seem out of place - anybody else would have just moved forwards to attack, regardless of being flashed. The ending set piece, then, neat as it is, can't help a feeling contrived - which is odd, given that Rear Window's final scenes are often lauded as being some of the best and most tense in the entire Hitchcock canon. Like this article? Got anything to add? Let us know in the comments section below.