Inheriting a role as tightly tied in the popular imagination to one actor as the Joker now is to Heath Ledger is a tough gig. However, now that we've all had a closer look at Jared Letos Joker via the cover of Empire magazine, we're getting a proper grasp on what kind of a spin he's going to put on his iteration of the Clown Prince of Crime. Naturally, youd be mad to try and take on the part with the express intention of copying a performance as definitive as Ledgers, but where do you go with the performance then? Its still, roughly speaking, the same character after all. Or maybe not - the signs are all there that Letos Joker is going to be very, very different from Ledgers in all sorts of ways, and I don't just mean the fact that he's wearing sweatpants. The malevolence, the psychosis and the nihilism will, obviously, stay; theyre the cornerstones of what makes the Joker the Joker. Its in what proportions Leto decides to mix these ingredients, and the extent to which the writing and storyline give him rein to explore the outer limits of the character. Then again, well only know for sure when Suicide Squad eventually opens. After all, the one thing the Joker should never, ever be is predictable, right?
7. Different Origins Means Different Themes
How the Joker comes into being in the first place makes a huge difference to the dominant themes of his storyline. Ledgers Joker explained at some length how he got those scars in The Dark Knight - depending on whether you believe him or not, he either get slashed up by his dad or chewed a razor blade. Regardless, both stories are, at root, about broken relationships and the emotional damage they can do. Along with that, Ledgers wardrobe gave him a scruffy, shambling twist with the beaten up shoes and straggly hair. That gave the impression of a once-proud man whose mind had unravelled. By contrast, with Letos Joker looks like its going to follow the traditional origin tale of having been knocked into a vat of chemicals which bleached his skin, turned his hair green and made his lips bright red. Certainly, the first promotional shot of Leto's Joker aped the panel from The Killing Joke which follows the incident. That implies that where Ledgers Joker was trying to prove that the world is unfair, and that control can only be found in creating ones own chaos, in taking on the Joker's traditional origin story Letos Joker will more likely look more closely at how noble people can be corrupted by trauma.
6. The Make-Up Reveals Altered Psyches
Both characters have the same basic features, but present it very differently; Ledger's Joker wore white make-up with panda eyes and a ragged red slash for a mouth, but Leto's Joker is far more tidily made up. That tells us a lot about the differences between the two in terms of their motivations and worldviews. The smudged, sweat-cracked look of Ledger's make-up was a great visual metaphor for his fractured psyche and crumbling sanity, but also a constant reminder that there was a man underneath the scars and greasepaint who had been corrupted by a world which hadn't been kind to him. The Joker mantle was one he chose to take on as a response to that. By contrast, Leto's is trapped within this alien-looking face by rather than making a deliberate choice to look like a clown to terrify people. He can't drift into anonymity like Ledger's could if he wanted to, there is no alias to take cover under; he is the Joker entirely and irrevocably, but it was forced upon him. That might point to Leto's Joker being a more tragic character than Ledger's. Certainly, Leto has said recently that his character is "almost Shakespearian", which bodes well.
5. Ledger Was A Gangster, Leto Is A Ringmaster
Leto's Joker's wardrobe has attracted a lot of criticism, but, whether you like it or not, it's a pretty huge marker of how his Joker differs from Ledger's. Look, if you can stomach it, at Leto's Joker's sweatpants. That is the legwear of a man who is completely at ease, and who doesnt have to run many errands; he has people to run around doing those sorts of things for him. That might be the key difference between the two: Ledger was involved in the dirty business of conducting bank robberies, firing rocket launchers, and even infiltrating the Gotham City police department to shoot Jim Gordon; Letos Joker looks to be more of a puppet master. All the shots weve seen of him so far have had him looking pale and crazed in dark rooms; it doesnt look like the guy gets out much, put it that way. Ledgers Joker was very traditional in the sense of sticking to the purple frock coat and waistcoat combo, but Letos goes for a bare, muscular chest, slicked hair, a cane, shiny grills and an iridescent calf-length fur coat and ends up looking like a psychotic pimp from a dystopian future. Ledger looked and acted like a gangster, whereas with Leto you get the feeling that hes leading the circus from a distance, directing the action but at a remove from it.
4. A New Enemy Demands A New Modus Operandi
We don't know yet how the Joker will slot into the storyline, but given the supervillain nature of the film then the dynamic he has with the characters will be very different to the mano a mano good-versus-evil face-off of The Dark Knight. Obviously, thats partly to do with the fact that he would be attempting to battle the combined forces of several of worlds biggest baddies; such a comprehensively different set of adversaries necessarily means formulating a comprehensively different method of evil-doing. Its not the same battle between good and evil - or, more accurately, order and chaos - which Ledgers Joker fought. Its more about the battle of egos and pride between villains who are all acting in their own interests, doing good with the Suicide Squad not because they want to but because they need to get out of prison. The Joker taking a band of enemies who basically agree with his viewpoint but cant defect because of the micro-bombs sat inside them to ensure good behaviour is a really interesting conceit and is likely to mean the Joker's propensity for random acts of violence is likely to get dialled down a bit - random acts of violence are kind of what the Suicide Squad are all about anyway - and instead something more maniacal.
3. He Might Not Actually Be The Joker At All
Ledger's Joker was, quite apart from anything else, very definitely the Joker. However, there's a school of thought which holds that Leto's Joker isn't the Joker, but a pseudo-Joker. Whichever way you look at it, that's a fairly hefty shift from the norm. Basically, the Joker we see in Suicide Squad is actually one of Batman's former companions, a young lad by the name of Jason Todd. He was the second man to take on Robins cape and who was killed in an explosion by the Joker (there was a phone vote to decide poor Jasons fate, which the Jason dies option won by a mere 72 votes out of 10,614). The theory is that the J under Letos eye either references the Batman: Arkham Knight video game, in which Jason is branded with a J in that spot by the Joker himself, or that the J stands for Jason rather than Joker, a constant reminder for Batman that he failed Jason whenever he looks at him. Add to that the display case which shows off Robins suit in a very lest-we-forget kind of way in the Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice trailer, and the taunting graffiti scribbled across it in the Jokers handwriting, and it starts to look semi-plausible.
2. Harley Quinn
Harley Quinns presence will open up a side of the Joker which Ledger never got to explore: that of the crazed lover whose beau is as insane as he is. Of course, whether the Joker actually cares about Harley Quinn at all is highly debatable, and shes often little more than a prop to stroke his own ego with. The control which the Joker holds over her will likely be a key emotional lynchpin of Suicide Squad, and fan sites abound with theories that involve Harley falling for the Joker, assisting him in one of his schemes against the Suicide Squad, and then being betrayed. Theres one theory doing the rounds that the person Letos Joker is preparing to torture at the end of the teaser trailer is in fact Harley Quinn, which certainly fits their abusive relationship. Of course, the whole romance thing could all be intensely embarrassing, but its a completely new conceit for the Batman movie universe - this will be Harley Quinns first celluloid outing - and as such it promises to show a different, more controlling and manipulative side of the Joker than during Ledger's tenure.
1. He's A Sociopath, Not A Psychopath
Suicide Squad producer Charles Roven has said of Letos Joker that hes: More social... a very successful and smart businessman besides being a sociopath. It sounds like hes diverged from the blood-and-thunder intimidation which Ledgers Joker was characterised by, and has become a more slippery villain entirely. He sounds more like a Patrick Bateman than the kind of glorified gangster his predecessor was at times, though admittedly Patrick Bateman didnt signpost his malevolence by having HAHAHAHAHAHA scrawled all over his shoulders. The trailer might appear to give the lie to the idea of Letos Joker being a superficially lovely chap (as a rule, nice guys dont make threats about really, really hurting people) but just because he indulges in a little bit of light torturing doesnt necessarily mean that Leto isnt pushing the Joker into a subtler, more Machiavellian mode. The Empire cover feature also tells us that Leto prepared for the role by reading up on his Shamanic lore; if thats not a sign that hes going to play up the charismatic, persuasive side then I dont know what is. Ledgers Joker was extraordinarily charismatic, sure, but he didnt use it to execute his plans; he much preferred to rely on massive wads of cash as a social binder, preferring not to trust such fanciful notions as friendship and loyalty. He revelled in seeing the world as inherently absurd; Letos might see this flawed model as one which is ripe to be exploited rather than scorned. What do you expect from Leto? Can he actually top Ledger? Let us know down in the comments.