Why The 8 Biggest Criticisms Of Christopher Nolan Are Wrong

Why the (Inter)stellar director doesn't deserve any of the hate.

By Alex Leadbeater /

The comparisons to Stanley Kubrick may be a little disparate, but there's no denying that Christopher Nolan is a mighty impressive director who stands as one of the most distinct cinematic voices of the 21st Century. Since breaking big with Memento in 2000 he's completely reshaped the movie landscape, bringing Batman back from suffocating camp and heralding in an age of realism in Hollywood blockbusters. This week sees the release of Interstellar, the director's ninth film, which is set to set the box office alight, mostly on the form of the director's name alone. Not bad for a guy who started out shooting Star Wars action figures in his back garden with a Super 8 camera. It's not all rosy for Nolan, however. His movies may bring in unbelievable box office receipts and eye-watering critical ratings, but that hasn't stopped his detractors becoming increasingly vocal. Whether it's recurring complaints about his directorial style or targeted attacks on certain movies (in the two years since its release The Dark Knight Rises has taken a bit of a grubbing), there's no shortage of people happy to criticise Nolan. And we think for the most part their issues are little off the point, so today are running down why the eight biggest criticisms of Christopher Nolan are wrong.

8. Exposition Dumps

The Criticism: Christopher Nolan movies tend to deal with complicated stories, be it through a lot of spinning character plates or brand new concepts. This naturally means there's a lot of information that needs to explained to the audience for them to subsequently follow what's going on. And his critics are keen to highlight how this exposition is poorly handled, with much of the dialogue simply dumping information on the audience in one go. The Defence: This strikes as one of the most nit-picky criticisms, trying to find overlying fault in his movies. The exposition isn't doled out through narration or any other hokey technique, but semi-organically in conversations that fit within the context of the movie. And when it is more overt it's normally at plot essential points, where the audiences actually wanting these sort of questions answered. Inception, certainly Nolan's most high concept film yet, has a lot to get across about the logistics of shared dreaming. Doing so through a mix of in-action examples and less-veiled teachings, it keeps the story going while getting the explanations across. There's certainly moments that exist for pure exposition purposes, but the likes of The Matrix were equally as guilty. And what Inception has that's different here is a clearly-stated and pressing narrative goal.

7. The Films Are Too Long

The Criticism: Since way back with Memento the run time of Christopher Nolan's movies have been touching two hours. And as he's developed over the past decade he's started making films more than double the length of his debut, Following (a spry 70 minutes); Batman Begins was 140 minutes, The Dark Knight 152 minutes, The Dark Knight Rises 165 minutes and Interstellar a whopping 169 minutes long. And long is really the word, with people keen to point out that they're really pushing the limits of what's necessary (and the human bladder). The Defence: There's a big distinction between a film being categorically long and being "too long". Lucy, the Luc Besson sci-fi clocked in at 89 minutes and yet felt like a slog. On the converse The Wolf Of Wall Street broke three hours and yet never lets up, feeling fully justified in using the time to explore the extravagance of Jordan Belfort. Each film in The Dark Knight Trilogy feels a suitable length, using the time to build the characters and the city of Gotham. It's pretty common to see a director given increasing freedom with success and thus make longer films because they can, but Nolan has thus far managed to provide a justification to this.

6. Weak Female Characters

The Criticism: This is one of the most prominent criticisms of Nolan's films; he consistently writes weak female characters. They tend to fall into three camps - good guy, bad guy and dead motivation for the male protagonist. No wonder only two of his films pass the Bechdel Test (The Dark Knight and Inception if you were curious). The Defence: There may not be women bursting from the seams of his movies, but to dismiss those that are there as weak is a little flat. The Dark Knight Trilogy has Rachel Dawes, Miranda Tate and Selina Kyle, Inception has Mal, The Prestige has Sarah and Olivia, Memento has Natalie and Insomnia has Officer Burr. None of these (not even Rachel, who, despite her explosive end being her most memorable moment, had a clearly defined characterisation) fit the traditional cinematic roles and while there's certainly some overarching types, they're far from generic cut-outs. They're not explored as in-depth as the male characters, but that stems from the aims of the movies; Nolan's films are all, to some degree, looking at perceived masculinity and thus will always have a more male-oriented slant. The hero troubled by the loss of a female loved one is one of his biggest running traits, which doesn't always allow for the most female interaction. But limited women does not equal weak characters.

5. The Films Are Too Serious

The Criticism: Christopher Nolan movies take themselves seriously. It's just one of those universal truths. Whether it's Tesla-invented cloning or a man in a bat suit jumping off rooftops there's no consideration for embracing the silly side of the ideas. And, in the eyes of some, this is all taken a bit too far. The Defence: Are people's problems with the seriousness of Nolan's films actually to do with the content of his movies, or the effect they've had on wider Hollywood? Things were already taking a turn away from the earnest camp of nineties in the early 21st Century, but his films, particularly The Dark Knight, opened up Hollywood's eyes to the beauty of realism, beginning a period where every movie, no matter the source, went all brooding. And while that doesn't really work for, say, Superman or Alice In Wonderland, it does in Nolan's films. He understands how to provide enough justification for the down-to-Earth feel so that it's palatable, with it only really possible to find too serious if you go in expecting The Avengers. There are some downsides to this effect, making it hard for some people to swallow the more extravagant elements in certain films, but really they should highlight that we're not entering Mallick levels of self-sincerity.

4. He Can€™t Frame Action

The Criticism: This is particularly aimed at The Dark Knight Trilogy, although the criticism has spilled over into discussions of his other films. He may be behind some of the most successful action movies of all time, but when actually directing action Nolan leaves some glaring holes behind him; the spatial awareness of fight scenes seems to fluctuate as they unfold, while the high numbers of extras means there's some more than questionable choreography. The Defence: There's no denying that the editing hides some curious issues (in The Dark Knight's truck sequence things fly in directions that make no logical sense) and the backgrounds of shots features some clear stage fighting, but the fact that for the most part this doesn't get picked up on by general audiences shows how these micro-issues have little impact on the overall effect. Action is all about creating the feel of the fight. That's why the fast-cutting shaky-cam style from the Bourne movies has become so prevalent and also why the logical inconsistencies within Nolan's individual fight sequences aren't movie-destroying issues. He may be going for a generally wider scope to his action, framing things like traditional Hollywood epics rather than modern spy movies, but the idea is the same.

3. His Movies Are Pretentious

The Criticism: There's a lot of damning things for film to be called - cliché, unoriginal, boring - but one of the worst has to be "pretentious." It's not only criticising the film on its own merits, but where it comes from as well. Nolan's movies have, at least since Batman Begins, straddled the divide between blockbuster and think piece, so it's really only to be expected that eventually people would start to accuse them of not being as smart as they think. The Defence: A central part of this criticism is that his films manage to have a wide audience appeal as well as positing big concepts, prompting the suggestion that despite thinking of themselves as profound the films are really just scratching the surface of grand ideas. But to enter into that school of thought imagines that a film can only ever play to one type of audience. And while that may be true in the case of, say, Transformers or 12 Years A Slave, it's not a universal rule, proven by the likes of The Prestige and Inception. In fact, The Prestige is a very potent example because it manages to wear the overarching theme on its sleeve while also leaving enough for analysis upon re-watch; the whole duality element runs much deeper than a quick viewing reveals.

2. He€™s Only Liked By Fan-Boys

The Criticism: Any Nolan-sceptics out there have probably already had this point run through their mind a couple of times during this list. More so than any other director working today, Nolan has his very own fanbase who invest themselves as much in his new releases as Trekkies do in Star Trek (OK, maybe not that far, but you get the idea). Unfortunately this provides those who aren't too hot on him to simply dismiss any positive praise of his career in a general sense as part of a fan-boy mentality. The Defence: A simple look at the level of success Nolan has received should show this to be hokum. It's not just those who will love a Nolan movie unconditionally who bolster his films to consistently be the biggest movies of their respective years. Critics, whose careers rely on not being biased, and mainstream audiences, who don't have the same level of loyalty, come out to watch his films with overwhelmingly positive reactions. Nolan has, like a pre-Cars 2 Pixar, one of the most consistent outputs in modern cinema, so it's only natural for there to be those who will staunchly defend his entire filmography, but when it's so unanimously good that doesn't mean it's being done out of blind love.

1. A Lack Of Emotional Engagement

The Criticism: Nolan may be able to craft visually striking images and narratively grand plots, but there's one thing that people all seem to think is lacking from his movies; a sense of emotional engagement. His movies are treated as cold pieces that technically impress but don't stir anything more. The Defence: This is probably the most waylaid element of any criticism of Christopher Nolan. As said earlier, the haunted man is a Nolan archetype and its inclusion immediately lends each of his movies a decidedly human protagonist. But beyond that, the sense of loss ties into the plot; each of his films not only contains an emotional centre, but is actually driven by it. Inception is the pinnacle of this, delivering an emotionally wrought journey is an incredibly visually creative manner. Dom Cobb struggles will the loss of his wife, something he blames on himself, and enters into the plot in an attempt to move on from that. The final shot, which left audiences the world over on the edge of their seats, remains such a potent talking point not because of whether the top falls of not, but because of its implications on the whole outcome of his journey; does he actually get to be with his kids at the end? What are your opinions on Christopher Nolan? Do you agree with our points or is he over-rated? Let us know in the comments below.