8 Films That Would Make Great Musicals

"I drink your milkshake!"

By Robert James /

Film to musical adaptations are currently thriving. Last year, every single Tony Award nominee for Best Musical was an adaptation of a film - Kinky Boots, Bring it On, A Christmas Story, and - yes - Matilda. Films becoming musicals is a tradition of the industry, of course, as they tend to be more financially-reliable because people are already familiar with the properties. Musical theater, despite being an older medium, has grown to rely on film for inspiration and content, much as film has grown to rely on novels and comic books. A good musical adaptation of a film will highlight the strength of its original characters and story, or improve on the same as a way of creating a new piece altogether. Some succeed, like The Lion King (Tony Award for Best Musical), and some fail miserably, like Carrie (Broadway run ended after 5 performances). 2014 is seeing a new flood of rumors concerning stage musicals in the works, including Frozen, Mean Girls, Rocky, and Pan's Labyrinth. Some of these seem inspired choices for musicals, others more like cynical cash-grabs. The most recent (and substantial) of these claims is Robert Zemeckis' announcement of a musical version of Back To The Future, due to premiere at London's West End in 2015. With so many classic films headed for the stage, what more great options have they missed? As always, if there is a painfully obvious choice we missed, be sure to mention it in the comments (or to the nearest musical producer).

8. Tootsie

Back in 1982, Dustin Hoffman proved he had what it takes to make a drag classic. The story of a self-absorbed and difficult to work with actor finding his inner woman contains more than its share of laughs, farce, absurdity and pathos. This Academy Award-winning picture relies on insightful satire on show business in general, as well as many very keen insights about sexism. Cross-dressing and musical theater go together better than anything else. The adaptation of Billy Wilder's Some Like it Hot and the aforementioned Kinky Boots are proof that men-as-women musicals are often a roaring success. Sydney Pollack's Tootsie has all the clever plotting and comedy of those films, but with an added depth and drama that could only make the musical adaptation more compelling. Drag-acting is not just a gimmick in this story, but a clever plot mechanic for character development.With the right actor in the lead role, Tootsie: The Musical could be an excellent commentary on sexual identity in a modern context. Show-Stopping Numbers: "One Nutty Hospital" - finale, featuring the live TV broadcast and Michael's "Big Reveal" (Chorus)

7. Blade Runner

Many musicals get their narrative strength from conflicted main characters. In the realm of neo-noir science fiction, there are few characters more conflicted than Rick Deckard, the titular Blade Runner. Alongside antagonist, Roy Batty, the pair share an existential criss that are ripe fruit for the sort of soul-searching you find in musicals everywhere. While science fiction is not a genre commonly adapted for musicals, the timeless story of what it means to be human contains all the right themes to make a dramatically compelling and resonant Rock opera. On top of the character drama, there are few grounds more fertile for creative staging than the world Ridley Scott created in Blade Runner. The dramatic beams of light and shadow playing throughout this futuristic Los Angeles would make for a beautiful and stiflingly ominous stage, if the set designer sticks close to the same stylish aesthetic. Show-Stopping Number: "Tears In Rain" - Roy Batty's final solo.

6. Annie Hall

Annie Hall was a huge success when it debuted back in 1977 - famously winning Best Picture and Director at the Oscars over the original Star Wars. For a film so beloved in its time period, then, it comes as a shock that a musical adaptation has never been considered. Probably the most lighthearted film on the list, Annie Hall makes it here for the simple watchability of its concept. A quirky, original love story is what people usually flock to musicals to see. Finding the love of your life and then losing her again is musical gold, even when tampered with by Woody Allen's laconic storytelling. The protagonist, Alvy Singer, is also a playwright, something that helps tie the film to stage in a more meaningful manner than most ripped from the screen adaptations. Show-Stopping Number: "A Spider the Size of a Buick" - comic centrepiece of the show, and a duet between Annie and Alvy.

5. Star Trek

The genre Star Trek inhabits is called "space opera" for a reason. Star Trek's plotlines feature big spectacle, a diverse cast of characters, and true pathos, all of which make a musical adaptation seem like a no-brainer. The crew of the Starship Enterprise is one of the most iconic science fiction casts of all time, their character dynamics a firm part of pop-culture. Their consistent dire predicaments at the hands of Klingons, the Borg, and random alien life are already plenty epic and overdramatic for musical theater - not to mention Shatner's tendency to overact in the original series. Trekkie or not, there is no one who can deny how absurdly enjoyable it would be to see the entire crew lined up on the Enterprise Bridge belting out a "To Boldly Go" anthem - featuring Scotty on Bagpipes. Show-Stopping Number: "The Needs of the Many" - duet between Spock & Kirk in Wrath of Khan's most famous scene.

4. The Dark Knight Rises

If there was any problem with The Dark Knight Rises, it has no doubt been expounded to death by comic book fans in comment threads online. A grandiose epic by a director more used to directing lean thrillers, it requires very little explanation as to why it isn't considered as complete a success as its predecessors. One thing that the story does recall to some success however, is that Batman is a quintessentially operatic character. He was created in a comic book world of characters drawn in broad strokes with dark pasts and a penchant for showiness. While his antics have produced more than a few musical parodies - the latest being "Holy Musical Batman!" by Starkids - an irony-free musical drama based on The Dark Knight Rises could be just what the character needs. Dialling back the spectacle to stage level and putting more emphasis on the disillusioned Batman as a character could also solve many of the film's narrative flaws. Not convinced? Listen to this Dark Knight Rises-inspired song composed by The Escapist's Musician Gavin Dunne here. Show-Stopping Number: "Knightfall" - massive Chorus number ending Act I, featuring Batman, Selina Kyle, and Bane.

3. Casablanca

It is a little known fact that Casablanca, considered one of the greatest films of all time, was based on an unproduced stage play written by Murray Burnett and Joan Alison. It was called "Everybody Comes to Rick's", and they sold it to Warner Brothers when they could not find anyone to produce it on stage. Turning the classic film back to the stage the second time after its release (the first being in 1991, when the original play was finally produced), a musical adaptation feels completely and utterly logical. A relatively small-scale story to begin with, it can be confined to a handful of sets, with Rick's Cafe as the centrepiece. The arrival of an old lover into the midst of World War II espionage provides inner conflict that any songwriter would love to sink their teeth into. Beside, it's a story that features intrigue, wit, and more than a dash of decidedly non-cliche melodrama - put all that to a smooth nightclub soundtrack and you have an instant gem. Show-Stopping Number: "As Time Goes By" - what did you expect?

2. The Room

It would not come as a surprise to anyone to find out this has become an independently financed musical in some black box in Los Angeles. If there is anything to be said about Tommy Wiseau's unintentional masterpiece it is that it has some bafflingly dedicated fans. Like The Rocky Horror Picture Show, The Room holds midnight screenings across the country, marked with their own special ceremonies and in-jokes. A musical adaptation of this beloved so-bad-it's-good classic would depend heavily on The Rocky Horror effect working in reverse. That is, an underground cult film becoming a successful musical as opposed to the other way around. The material in the film is ripe for riffing - subplots that go nowhere, inscrutable character motivations, and some of the most truly perplexing dialogue ever written. While it cannot be self aware, as that could ruin the appeal of the whole deal, this laughable tragedy presented as melodramatic drama has undeniable appeal to a certain niche audience off-Broadway, who want to see their beloved (if ludicrously erratic) characters rendered on screen. Show-Stopping Number: "You're Tearing Me Apart!" - melodramatic bombast from Johnny (solo), facing the emotional stress from his manipulating future-wife, Lisa.

1. There Will Be Blood

Paul Thomas Anderson's classic is one of the most operatic dramas ever put to screen. A thoroughly engrossing story of how ambition turns to greed and then to violence, this is the kind of sweeping character arc that would work flawlessly on the stage. The actors throw their whole bodies into their performances, as if begging to be given epic Sondheim anthems as their backing. Despite being an epic, There Will Be Blood is a bare-bones enough film that the pacing would not be hampered by the introduction of inter-character musical numbers flushing out motivations that remain subtextual on screen. Daniel Plainview, his son, and the Sunday brothers all have feelings about the oil drilling that bubble up in strong enough emotion that bursting into song wouldn't feel out of place in the film itself. The collapse of Daniel Plainview's oil rig and Eli Sunday's violent end can be turned into rousing ballads of both the epic and intimate scale found in the film, harkening back to the musical epics produced in the 80s - the period that birthed such musical spectacle as Les Miserables and Phantom of the Opera. This musical is unlikely to ever get made, because there will never be as impressive a Daniel Plainview as Daniel Day-Lewis, but this story is with deep and powerful enough it is nigh begging to be presented in an even more emotionally grandiose form on stage. Show-Stopping Number: "Daniel's Confession" - duet between Daniel Plainview and Eli Sunday, in which the former confesses to his poor parenting, amongst other things ("I abandoned my child!"). Like this article? Agree with these choices? Let us know in the comments section below.