8 Problems With Pulp Fiction That Nobody Wants To Admit

In the words of Winston Wolfe: "Let's not start sucking each other's d*cks quite yet."

By Sam Hill /

Pulp Fiction is without a doubt one of the most popular and influential movies of all-time. Beloved by critics and cinephiles, and revered by many contemporary filmmakers as the motion picture that inspired them to make their own films, Quentin Tarantino's 1994 follow-up to his debut, Reservoir Dogs, is a modern classic. Its influence on popular culture is arguably unparalleled, with lines still quoted on a daily basis, over 20 years after its release.

Advertisement

"You get intoxicated by it," wrote critic Owen Gleiberman back in 1994, "high on the rediscovery of how pleasurable a movie can be," a testament to Pulp Fiction's inherent fun factor. Ken Dancyger wrote: "A new phenomenon, the movie whose style is created from the context of movie life rather than real life," playing to the idea that Tarantino's movie is built from the bones of countless other movies - a pop cultural hodgepodge.

There's no denying that Pulp Fiction is a great movie. There are few motion pictures that offer up such a giddy sense of escapism - without it, audiences might have been doomed to spent the '90s watching very slow and very serious psychological thrillers. Pulp Fiction is arguably the definitive movie for Generation X: apathetic, wry, and ironic. Saying that, it is not perfect; like all pictures, it has its own flaws and faults and shortcomings.

Advertisement

Here, then, are 8 problems with Pulp Fiction that nobody seems to want to admit...

8. It's Essentially About Nothing

"Only in this age could a writer as talented as Tarantino produce artworks so vacuous, so entirely stripped of any politics, metaphysics, or moral interest." - James Wood, The Guardian
When you think about it, Pulp Fiction isn't about anything it all. It doesn't stand for anything, it doesn't tell you anything, and it doesn't say anything. In the quote highlighted about, writer James Wood expands on this theory with regards to Tarantino's entire output, but Pulp Fiction seems to be the most guilty of being without politics and opinion and morals.

Though one could certainly argue that its vapid nature is actually the very point of the movie, that the very intention of Pulp Fiction is as tribute to the vacuous, popular culture-obsessed nature of the '90s, so what? On a fundamental level, Pulp Fiction has nothing to say - it is fun and exciting and cool and perhaps even brilliant, but it's a hollow experience.

Advertisement

However you look at it, a piece of art with a legacy as huge as this one that also has nothing of importance to say... well, it's a sad state of affairs, really.

7. "The Bonnie Situation" Isn't Up To Scratch

Pulp Fiction is made up of three distinct chapters, though the movie actually consists of five stories: these are "Vincent Vega and Marcellus Wallace's Wife," "The Gold Watch," and "The Bonnie Situation." The fourth and fifth chapters remain unnamed, but these are the diner scene that opens the movie, and the scenes with Vince and Jules as they encounter Brett and his goons (also where Jules unleashes his famous "great vengeance" speech).

Advertisement

The first four chapters - that is, the unnamed chapters, "Vincent Vega and Marcellus Wallace's Wife," and "The Gold Watch" - are each equally watchable and deliciously entertaining from start to finish. But by the time Pulp Fiction gets around to "The Bonnie Situation," some of the film's energy falls away and things never really picks up again until the final scene, in which Jules confronts Pumpkin and Honey Bunny in the diner.

"The Bonnie Situation" just doesn't have enough of the tension or vitality of the previous chapters, and as a result - and despite the appearance of Winston Wolfe - Pulp Fiction begins to lag at Jimmy's house. The scene feels stretched out and lacks the tightness of what came before. Thus, the skillful momentum of the picture - arguably perfect up until this point - is brought to a disappointing halt (although nobody wants to admit that, of course).

Advertisement

6. It's Kind Of Soulless

In Sam Moore's New Statesmen essay exploring Pulp Fiction's twenty years legacy, he echoes the aforementioned idea that the film has nothing to say, but he adds to this criticism when he writes that Pulp Fiction "doesn't make you feel anything." The emphasis here is on the word "feel," in the emotional sense - and he's completely right.

Advertisement

Pulp Fiction, after all, is more concerned with crafting cool scenes and dropping badass musical cues than it is with getting the audience to feel anything. The movie is essentially the cheeseburger that Jules and Vince talk about during the car ride at the beginning; you eat it and you feel good in the moment, but nothing afterwards. Because Pulp Fiction doesn't want you to empathise or sympathise. It doesn't want you to relate to anything.

Jackie Brown, Tarantino's best movie, works in the opposite way. Audiences are made to care about characters like Jackie and Max, and the film is stronger as a result. It doesn't take away from the fact that - just like Pulp Fiction - it's essentially a homage built out of other movies, but it does give the movie something that Pulp Fiction sorely lacks: soul.

Advertisement

5. The Internal Logic Of The World Is Inconsistent

Pulp Fiction doesn't pretend to exist in the "real world," but that doesn't mean it's set in an alternative Kill Bill-styled universe, where it's possible for somebody to kill dozens of people with a samurai sword without the cops ever showing up. So there are quite a lot of moments scattered throughout Pulp Fiction that ultimately don't make a whole lot of sense.

Advertisement

Whilst a lot of the "issues" could be put down to creative license, there are some things that just don't ring true - even according to the logic of the world that Tarantino conjures up (this is a world where it's possible to reverse a heroine overdose using an "adrenaline shot").

How about the fact that Jules and Vincent have a conversation right outside Brett's door, and yet the three men inside don't hear a thing and seem genuinely confused when the gangsters turn up? Mia Wallace overdoses on heroine, and yet Vince decides to take her home instead of to a hospital? And where are the cops, anyway? They don't respond to any of the incidents that occur - despite the film sharing a movie "world" with Reservoir Dogs.

Advertisement

Yes, you can put most of it down to "Who cares?" but there are a lot of plot holes and plot errors that occur across the span of Pulp Fiction that get lost in amongst whatever else is going on. Whilst Tarantino is free to do what he wants and has never attempted to make a movie set in the real world, fans seem to give the director far more leeway than they would with any other director, whose film would likely be called out for being "unrealistic."

4. The Rape Scene Is Really Odd

One of the most memorable moments in Pulp Fiction occurs when Butch and Marsellus Wallace find themselves tied up in the back room of a pawn shop by two hillbillies with horrific intentions. Whilst Butch manages to break free before any harm can be done to him, poor Marsellus ends up being graphically raped. Butch goes back to save Marsellus, despite the fact they're sworn enemies, because who could leave a man in that situation?

Advertisement

Whilst the scene itself is arguably one of the best and most gripping in the entire movie (especially when audiences realise that Butch is going to go back, and surveys the pawn shop to find the appropriate revenge weapon), there are a few inherent issues here.

Firstly, the scene feels out of place and clashes with the rest of the movie; though Pulp Fiction is packed to the brim with cursing and violence, this feels like a step too far. It's almost too much, and as a result it jars somewhat with the rest of the picture. Secondly, the hillbillies - Maynard and Zed - feel like little more than homophobic stereotypes. Then there's the Gimp, which is arguably the strangest part of the scene. Like, what the hell? Seriously?

Advertisement

No wonder Uma Thurman almost passed on the movie based on this scene. It's not bad, exactly, but it's certainly a weird moment with a lot of problematic elements at its core.

3. Quentin Tarantino Almost Ruins It... With His Acting

In case you've forgotten the part where Quentin Tarantino appears, the scene in question occurs in partway through "The Bonnie Situation," in which Vincent and Jules bring the dead body of one of their associates - who Vincent shot and killed accidently, mind you - to the house of Jules' friend and partner, Jimmy. Jimmy is played by Tarantino.

Advertisement

Tarantino has a horrible knack for occasionally putting himself in his own movies, in which his levels of self-awareness drop to an all-time low, and though he makes extended appearances in Reservoir Dogs and Django Unchained, he plays his most substantial part in Pulp Fiction, which seems to exist to prove that the man can't - and should not - act. Ever.

Which brings us to...

Advertisement

2. That "Dead N*gger Storage" Line Is Seriously Uncomfortable

During the scene in which Tarantino's Jimmy berates Jules for bringing a dead body to his house, he falls into an infamous rant in which he uses the term "dead n*gger storage" - not just once, but three times; it's supposed to be one of the film's trademark speeches in that pre-meditated Tarantino fashion. It's also one of Pulp Fiction's lesser moments.

Advertisement

As Michael Green wrote in his essay titled "Cinema, Race and the Zeitgeist: On Pulp Fiction Twenty Years Later," of all the uses of the n-word in Tarantino's movie (and there are a lot scattered across the span of the two and a half hour picture), this particular usage of the word feels the most inappropriate and the most contrived. As Green points out:

"No white man would speak to a black man in this manner; it€™s just Tarantino€™s colourblind fantasy."
He goes on to write that hearing that word coming from Tarantino's mouth, over and over again, evokes a "nails on chalkboard" effect. It is awkward to hear, no matter how many times you watch the scene, and endlessly grating - the sort of line that causes you to shift uncomfortably in your seat, wondering why the writer/director ever thought it was a) a good idea to include this line and b) a good idea to cast himself as the guy who delivers said line.

1. The Non-Linear Narrative Is Ultimately Pointless

One of Pulp Fiction's defining features - if not its most defining feature - is its non-linear narrative - a flourish that Tarantino borrows from films of the French New Wave in order to make what are arguably three "generic" stories (at least, they are generic in the sense that they are hard-boiled fiction clichés) more compelling than if audiences viewed them in chronological order.

Advertisement

But apart from rendering events in a way that makes just a few individual moments more "shocking" (the moment when Vincent is killed, for example, only to seemingly return to life in the next chapter; the moment where audiences realise that at the end of the movie they're in the same diner as they were in the beginning), the effect is ultimately inconsequential.

There is no "need" for the movie to be non-linear. It doesn't serve a purpose as it does in a film like Memento, where the technique is used to convey the frustration felt by its amnesia-clad protagonist. Ultimately, Tarantino makes his picture appear far more clever than it actually is in his use of a non-linear narrative; the problem is that it is not hard to implement such a device, and - all said and done - it has no true bearing on the story being told.

Advertisement

Agree or disagree with these problems regarding Pulp Fiction? Got any to add? Let us know in the comments section below.