8 Ways Darth Vader Almost Turned Out Completely Different
If things had gone differently we could have all been screaming "NOOOOOOOOOO!"
Is there anyone in the entire history of cinema more iconic than Darth Vader? The evil-villain-cum-tragic-hero of the Star Wars Saga has been a part of the popular consciousness for nearly forty years, with his menacing helmet, rasping breath and flirty sand-based conversations making an unforgettable character whose appeal spans generations. If you've never owned a piece of Vader merchandise you're definitely in the minority; there's action figures, desk lamps, slippers, watches, replica lightsabers, Mr Potato Heads, backpacks, cake tins, bowl holders, even golf club covers. Heck, you can buy a toaster that toasts his iconic fizzog onto your bread.
Star Wars is a franchise built on its tie-ins and Vader really leads the charge. He's so captivating that we've had a whole trilogy of films based off the twist of his secret identity. But things could have turned out very, very different.
With decisions made right from the character's conception through to his latest on-screen appearance, Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader could have been changed beyond recognition, eight examples of which we'll look at today.
Honourable Mention - Obi-Wan Killed Your Father
Although in the pre-internet age script leaks weren't as prevalent as they are now, George Lucas was still keen to keep Episode V's big twist a secret, going to extents even the likes of J.J. Abrams and Christopher Nolan would find extreme.
Telling only a handful of people the truth of Luke's parentage, the screenplay replaced the saga-defining reveal with something potentially more menacing, "Obi-Wan killed your father". Mark Hamill only got told the truth just before shooting (so his on-screen shock is actually somewhat real), while all the other actors (minus James Earl Jones, obviously) didn't find out until the premiere. It was never going to be part of Vader's actual backstory, but it's fascinating that the most well known twist of all time was once treated with such protection.
Watch our video below, or click "next" to read the article...
8. He Wasn't Going To Turn To The Dark Side Just To Save Padmé
As we've shown before, George Lucas had a pretty good idea of where his prequel films would go way back when the original films were released. As he wrapped up Return Of The Jedi, his mind fell back to the notion of showing Vader's origins. About this time he came up with the broad strokes of the prequel's narrative - Palpatine's political rise to power and Anakin's fall to the dark side and eventual dip in a lava pool - setting in motion films that wouldn't emerge for another decade.
The original plan for Anakin's fall was going to be him turning against the Jedi, slowly cutting them down unbeknownst to his (very public) wife, with Obi-Wan solving the mystery. That's similar to what was eventually delivered in Revenge Of The Sith with one major difference; in the finished product the motivation has a lot more to do with Padmé.
That's because up until the eleventh hour the story had always about how Anakin became disenfranchised with his own order which seems a lot more believable than moaning over his girlfriend. Lucas, for some crazy reason, decided on a shift in focus, but not until after principal shooting of Episode III, meaning the importance on Padmé's death had to be greatly expanded upon in reshoots done at the last minute. That's why those romance scenes feel a bit forced.
7. He Wasn't The Emperor's Apprentice
In very early drafts of The Star Wars, the Emperor was far from the big bad the character would become. Essentially a figurehead of the Empire controlled by the various Admirals (including Peter Cushing's Grand Moff Tarkin), he was conceived as little more than a puppet. While this already changes the balance of the franchise, it has a direct effect on Vader, removing his apprentice status and making him seem like more of a wild card, reporting to no one.
Even after it was decided the Emperor was very much in control there was still a question of how much direct control he had over Vader as a Sith. The question of whether Palpatine was a Force user was common in the scripting process and had he not been given the finger-tip lightening we could still have been left with more uncontrollable Vader.
Despite subsequent films making clear Palpatine is an all-out-evil Force user, it took a while for the earlier concepts to shake; in the expanded universe fiction following the original trilogy many authors shied away from identifying Palpatine as Sith, with the prequels being the first official conformation of him as Vader's actual Master.
6. He Almost Had A Blue Lightsaber
Some bits of Star Wars iconography just can't be messed with. There's such a visual shorthand that builds on traditional conventions; the enemies wear darker, more muted colours reflected in the shades of their sleeker fighters and dominating spaceships, while the rebel's aesthetic is much more thrown together.
The colour of laser blasts is even different for them; green for Imperial, red for Alliance. And, of course, the lightsabers are coloured depending on the character's allegiance; Jedi have green or blue (or purple if you're Samuel L. Jackson), Sith have red. Simple, right?
As you can see in the above concept art by Ralph McQuarrie based on an earlier draft of the script that wasn't always the case; here Darth Vader wields a blue blade and Deak Starkiller (a brother of the character who would become Luke, killed in the opening scene) has a yellow one.
From a modern perspective it seems bizarre and given how much of McQuarrie's original drawings ended up informing the design of the galaxy far far away it's a surprise it didn't stick.
Would Vader has been as menacing with such a light colour? Probably a good thing he ended up going with red.
5. Lucas Was Going To Kill Him Before The Emperor
When he'd first written Star Wars Lucas realised the story was so expansive there was enough material for many more films, with the idea of two or three trilogies being thrown around from the early days; there was a time when a sequel trilogy was more likely than a prequel one. The idea for these Episodes VII, VIII and IX are very different from the ones we're going to get over the next few years; in these Luke goes out looking for his sister, who is not Leia, with the two teaming up to finally take on the Emperor in number nine. But the big changes begin in an alternate Episode VI.
A slight hangover from early drafts (which will be expanded upon later), the original Revenge Of The Jedi would see Vader killed in the second confrontation between him and Luke. Not only would this obviously change Vader's arc, removing his redemption, but it would place him back as a supporting role in the story, bumping Palpatine up to the focal villain.
Lucas would later decide to end things with Return Of The Jedi (the title changed because, well, there wasn't any revenge) and thus these threads were all compounded into that one Episode, leading to all loose ends being tied up.
4. He Was Going To Be A Minor Character (And Not Even Called Vader)
It's easy to forget in a galaxy full of Mauls and Tyranus' that Darth Vader was originally the character's proper name; during their duel in Star Wars Obi-Wan refers to Vader as Darth, implying that's actually his first name. This is evident from Vader's very early script origins where he was just another imperial with a cool name.
Called General Vader in the first draft, he was a rather unremarkable villain who only appears a couple of times. A Sith Lord was in the story in the form of Prince Valorum (a name that would be reused in The Phantom Menace), although he was still a world away from what the character would end up being. Had things gone differently in Lucas' mind on the day of the rewrite we could very easily ended up with a Darth Vader not called Darth Vader at all.
The second draft merged the two characters, marking the earliest recognisable appearance of the Vader we all know and fear. But there was one distinct difference; he was hardly in the film. Appearing only in the opening where he fights Deak (see the blue lightsaber) and again in the spacefighter finale.
3. He Died At The End Of A New Hope
Anakin Skywalker is such an essential part of the Star Wars saga we know today but that wasn't always the case; back in the early drafts the Vader-Valorum portmanteau was going to die at the end of Star Wars. A minor Imperial with some Force powers, his role was essentially to expand the scope of Force sensitives, which his very presence did.
As a secondary villain, however, it was logical for him to die before the end credits roll. Some of this idea stuck in the film itself; Vader's escape is based entirely on luck, with a TIE Fighter pilot (and not Han's blasters) sending him flying from the soon to be destroyed Death Star.
It goes without saying killing Vader at this point would have altered the direction of the saga completely from what we know. Even when he decided to spare Darth, Lucas had already been thinking of taking the saga away from family politics to something more galactic.
But one, out of the blue idea changed his mind...
2. He Wasn't Lukes Father Until The Second Draft Of Empire
Darth Vader is allegedly Dutch for dark father (it's not actually - dark is donker). But don't let that fool you into thinking Lucas had that whopping, universe-altering twist planned all along; he fact that Darth Vader is actually Anakin Skywalker, Luke's father, wasn't dreamt up until the second draft of The Empire Strikes Back.
Looking at earlier versions of A New Hope it's obviously made up on the fly; Annikin Skywalker (née Starkiller) and Vader are two distinct characters in all drafts of the first film, while when you ignore the sloppy retconning ("from a certain point of view") even the finished movie points away from it. There were even scenes shot for the first Star Wars that, had they been included, would've made no sense; the scene of Red Leader talking to Luke added into the Special Editions originally had some discussion of his father cut.
When that idea was created suddenly there were two Star Wars timelines; the one where Vader kills Anakin and the one where Vader is Anakin. The former, alternate saga would have been a wildly different beast, with the story of Luke less emotionally wrought and more typical, while Vader would be far from the three dimensional villain he became. It's this timeline where the previously mentioned of killing off Vader came from.
1. No Mask
Vader's mask is by far the most iconic element of the character, making the deep breaths feel almost superfluous. Which is why it's surprising that it wasn't a key part of character until well into the screenplay process.
When Ralph McQuarrie realised Vader was travelling from one ship to another in the opening he suggested to Lucas he should wear a breathing mask. It's logical, but it got the director's mind running. Soon he wanted this minor character in his movie more, bumping Vader's role to be a more prevalent threat.
Soon realising just how alluring the respirator was, Lucas eventually decided to have the mask (initially included just for that scene) a permanent robotic suit. Before the mask was added, the plan was to just have whichever actor was cast's face out in the open, with the character potentially sporting some samurai-inspired armour.
Not only would this have made Vader immediately less intimidating, it would have made the subsequent Skywalker twist impossible to pull off, not to mention dating the film more; even today Vader seems futuristic. Neutering the character in its absence, the lack of mask would have given us a less menacing villain and would have in turn weakened the films effect.
The helmet wouldn't have just led to a completely different Vader, but a completely different Star Wars.
Do you love Darth Vader as much as we do? Know any more alternate possibilities of how he could have turned out? Join the discussion in the comment section below.