8 Ways Heath Ledger’s Joker Almost Turned Out Completely Different

It was all part of the plan.

By Alex Leadbeater /

Advertisement

Heath Ledger's Joker has, in the years since The Dark Knight, proved so good the Oscars had to restructure the Best Picture award and become an undisputed icon, an emblem of how superhero cinema can go so far beyond men in silly costumes stage fighting. The scrawled on make-up, the Tom Waits-inflected voice and all the subtle little tics you only pick up on when watching the film for the thirtieth time; it's a beautiful meeting of actor and material so completely realised it transcends the hype.

Of course, the now-definitive screen Clown Prince of Crime didn't just walk into Gotham fully formed. Ledger invested months in fully immersing himself in the character, starting before the Nolan brothers had even finished the script, shaping the character in as fundamental ways as the writers. Naturally that means quite a lot changed in the time between the first tease at the end of Batman Begins and mask removal at The Dark Knight, with an entirely different version of the character at points possible.

Advertisement

The origins of the character himself are purposely vague, but thanks to interviews with Christopher Nolan, David S. Goyer and the late man himself, a picture of where Joker the performance came from can be painted. And it's a crazy one.

8. He'd Have Been A Recurring Villain

Warner Bros. Pictures

This kinda goes without saying, but Heath Ledger's death totally changed the plans for the Joker. Rather than just the defining glue of one of the best movies of the 21st Century, he could have been the overarching villain of the greatest movie franchise ever.

Advertisement

Now, Christopher Nolan famously doesn't plan ahead, never looking beyond the release of the movie he's currently working on. This enables his undivided focus on the matter at hand and leads to totally complete films that don't invest inordinate time into setting up a sequel (something far too prevalent in modern blockbuster cinema). It also means any plans for a third Batman film were, at the time of Ledger's death, vague at best. It took him a few years, and the production of a whole other film, to even consider making The Dark Knight Rises.

Still, it's clear from the second film of the trilogy that any subsequent movie, whether or not directed by Nolan, would have featured a returning Joker. Nothing in The Dark Knight was changed to accommodate Ledger's passing, meaning his ambiguous capture in the final moments was purposely keeping the door open. What exactly his role in events would have been is obviously unknown (it likely wouldn't have been anything as expansive as Bane's hostage crisis), but it'd have probably kicked off with him manipulating events from Arkham (not dissimilar to the rumoured plans for Jared Leto's take in Suicide Squad).

Advertisement

7. Nolan's Joker Almost Went Up Against A Batman Played By Heath Ledger

Warner Bros. Pictures

The Joker wasn't the first time Heath Ledger had come into contact with Christopher Nolan or Batman. When the then-up-and-coming director's total restart of the Caped Crusader was still in pre-production, Ledger was approached to play Bruce Wayne, but turned it down in pretty resolute terms, quoted as saying, "I would never take a part in a superhero film."

Advertisement

That could be exaggeration on Nolan's part, but it's not inconceivable rising star Ledger would want to keep out of the super hero circuit. Remember that this was a time when the genre had only a couple of respectable contemporary entries (X-Men and Spider-Man were the only notable hits) and the franchise itself was still marred by the all round failure of Batman & Robin. Taking on an important part of such a film would at best see you forever typecast in genre films, at worst completely kill your career.

The film that changed all that was Batman Begins, a grown-up, realistic take that used its funny page-originated characters to explore real-world issues and relatable emotions. Beating the likes of Robert Downey, Jr. and Samuel L. Jackson to the bandwagon, Heath Ledger contacted Nolan cold about playing the Joker in the sequel shortly after the movie hit.

Advertisement

Obviously that turned out magically, but there's still fun to be had thinking how Ledger would have done Bats. Just imagine how even more psychotically wounded Bruce Wayne could have looked.

6. The Original Plan Was To Do A Version Closer To The Killing Joke

Warner Bros.

The most defining post-Silver Age Joker story is The Killing Joke (although the recent Death Of The Family is a close second), Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's expose on the Clown Prince of Crime that still manages to make waves decades after first publication thanks to the ongoing question of whether Batman actually kills the Joker at the end.

Advertisement

When he first started talking about a Batman sequel starring the Joker, Nolan repeatedly stated the one-shot was going to be a key influence. While there's certainly elements present throughout, particularly the evaluation of the never-ending clash between the criminal and vigilante, in the finished film it's pretty slight. This isn't just Nolan being typically loose with an adaptation - he actually changed his approach. Once the film was actually in the bag, the biggest inspiration was now cited the very first appearances from the character in Batman.

That's a significant shift and one of the biggest tease to what the Joker could have been. And, like many great things to do with The Dark Knight, the reason it changed leads back to Ledger. The thing most out of kilter with The Killing Joke is rooted in Joker's mannerisms, which suggests that as the actor developed his distinct version of the character, the script adjusted to fit him.

Advertisement

5. He Wasn't Always Going To Be Played By Heath Ledger

Open Road Films

The Joker card at the end of Batman Begins was less a tease to a sequel (remember, Nolan doesn't think that far ahead) and more a symbol of where the reboot had left the hero - in the real world and ready for the more well-known adventures to begin (the League of Assassins are so obscure their name was changed to Shadows and nobody noticed)

Advertisement

Still, even ten years ago the internet was ready to dive on any and all easter eggs that had potential plot implications, so you can bet that one shot was one of the most dissected from the film. Everyone took it as proof positive a sequel (Batman Continues?) would feature a new, realistic version of the mad clown (read: no dancing to Prince). And who would be the man under the make-up? Well, according to reports at the time, none other than Sean Penn.

Reported by Batman On Film, Penn was offered the role, although in retrospect that seems a bit exaggerated - that Warner Bros. were already casting goes against how Ledger got the part. Still, like most rumours, it probably comes from a seed of truth - Warner probably wanted the Oscar-winner for the role, but were overpowered by a creatively in control Nolan.

Advertisement

Penn was certainly a popular choice for the part, the subject of a mobilised fan campaign (turn down your screen brightness before clicking that link), which likely only made the strong initial backlash against Ledger stronger.

4. The Marketing Was Changed After Ledger Died

Warner Bros. Pictures

Promotional ARGs (Alternate Reality Games) that give fans a mostly-online experience of their favourite movies and TV shows have somewhat fallen out of fashion in recent years, but in the late-noughties they were all the rage. Even more questions were raised by The Lost Experience, Cloverfield amped up its mystery monster to painful levels of hype by detailing a battle between big oil and eco-protestors and, best of all, The Dark Knight brought the preamble to the Batman sequel to vivid life.

Advertisement

The Dark Knight ARG was ridiculously complex, kicking off at Comic-Con 2007 and, over the next year, leading the more obsessively-inclined fans through the schemes of the Joker, Harvey Dent's campaign trail and Gordon's attempts to bring down the Clown Prince of Crime.

Incredibly fun at the time, looking back there's a noticeable shift in focus about halfway through, with the Joker becoming less prominent in events. Obviously this was a sudden change brought about in reaction to Ledger's death, which, while probably over-sensitive in retrospect, makes sense given how high profile it was.

Advertisement

This tact spilled over into the film's more mainstream marketing; had Ledger not died, it's likely his Joker would have been as prominent on posters and the like as Batman. In the end, however, it didn't matter too much - once the film hit he was all anyone was talking about.

3. There Was Talk Of A Posthumeous Cameo In The Dark Knight Rises

Warner Bros. Pictures

As the Joker was, of course, still alive at the end of The Dark Knight, all through the production of The Dark Knight Rises there was speculation about whether there'd be some appearance from him.

Advertisement

The question looming even bigger than that was how it could be achieved in a manner respectful to Ledger. Recasting such an iconic role was out of the question (in any case, no one would dare take it on) and using CGI and previously unused footage would feel tacky, while the often rumoured easter egg of his cell, complete with scrawled gibberish on the wall, would too easily pull the audience out of the disparate plot.

It would be ridiculous to think that Nolan didn't consider each and every one of those ideas at some point in pre-production. Thankfully he understood quickly that even a small cameo would have greatly altered the legacy of Ledger's character. Nolan purposely gave Joker no backstory, having him appear a fully formed menace to greater increase his horror, and having him disappear under similarly mysterious terms makes him somewhat mythical. Knowing what happened to him, even it's as simple as being locked up for life, would negate the character's impact and give him some undeserved finality.

Advertisement

Although the film was totally Joker-free (and rightly so), the same can't be said of the novelisation. In a throwaway mention, it's revealed Joker is the sole inmate of Arkham, a strange concept, but one that explains why he's not tearing up Gotham in the film's latter half.

2. He Was Supposed To Make A Big Point About Batman's One Rule

Warner Bros. Pictures

Batman doesn't kill, but he will purposely crash a train and leave someone inside, throw someone off a building and shoot at a truck until it veers off the road. In the eyes of a damaged orphan, that's not killing apparently.

Advertisement

That's one of the biggest question marks over Nolan's films, with Bats obliquely breaking his one rule with very shaky justification. Now, it is fleetingly addressed during Joker's interrogation in The Dark Knight, but across the series it's generally just hoped you won't notice the contradictions.

Originally, however, that was going to be a major plot device. Not saving Ra's al Ghul at the end of Batman Begins was to provide a moral dilemma for the character and be a key part of Joker's case against the hero.

Advertisement

You see, following the origin story, David S. Goyer had a two-movie arc involving the Joker and Two-Face mapped out. This fell by the wayside at some point during pre-production, with only very broad ideas (the characters, some of the momentum) crossing over into the finished film. What became The Dark Knight would have ended with a conflicted Batman going against his instincts and letting Joker live, sending him off to Arkham. That's similar to the finished film in terms of where it leaves the characters, but it goes a very different route to get there - sparing the clown was going to be a big deal.

The finished film isn't really lacking in Joker tearing up Batman mentally - the only difference is that in the early draft he was targeting the Batman visage, rather than the more human side underneath.

Advertisement

1. He Was Going To Scar Harvey Dent When On Trial In The Third Film

Warner Bros. Pictures

One of the big differences between Goyer's original plan and the final story is that Harvey Dent doesn't go through his hideous transformation until the third movie, in something that now reads as a mash-up of the villain's comic book origins and the version of events seen in The Dark Knight. After being captured at the end of film two, film three would see Joker on trial, during which he douses Dent with acid, sending the DA into a downward spiral and becoming Two-Face.

Advertisement

Although it's much more in-line with the comics, having the dethroning at the hands of the Joker means that the overarching impact - he's unveiling Gotham's dark heart - is similar to The Dark Knight's warehouse explosion.

A two-parter clearly doesn't fit with Nolan's sensibilities, so it'd be easy to conclude that the planned story was simply compounded down into one film, but the courtroom setting (which is homaged with Dent's introduction in the film proper) reveals the early script was very different from the finished movie.

Advertisement

And that seems like a good thing. Having Joker involved in Two-Face's origin so obliquely is the sort of happenstance meddling that dominated the earlier movies (Two-Face killed Dick Grayson's family, really?), something that really goes against how forward thinking The Dark Knight, and Heath Ledger's Joker in particular, was.

Were there any other ways Heath Ledger's Joker almost turned out differently? Share them down in the comments.

Advertisement