Al Pacino: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

By Hugh Firth /

Al Pacino is one of the few actors in the world today who can legitimately lay claim to being amongst the best. The list of films is ferocious taking in true classics such as the first two Godfather films, Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon, Scarface and Glengarry Glen Ross. Even those slightly lower down the list are still better than most firing on all cylinders with great films such as Insomnia, Donnie Brasco and Carlito's Way. He is a true modern great. Recently, though, similar to his old sparring partner Robert De Niro, he has made some awful films too. Why this is is hard to work out but he consciously decided to appear in Jack and Jill, Gigli and S1m0ne. Oh, and that Sky TV advert. My God. That Sky TV advert. Through it all though, he has a true legacy of great films and even though the subtleties in his performances might have been overtaken by 'speak quiet till the end of the line and then shout the last WORD' acting, there is no denying the brilliance in most of his work. To be fair to him, whittling down five great films was significantly harder than finding five ones that sucked because, to be honest, although his recent work isn't great, there aren't too many monumental misfires. So, without further ado, and to celebrate restored re-release in UK cinemas of The Godfather Part II, here are five awesome performances and five that sucked. As with this column every Friday, there are major spoilers below...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Lt. Vincent Hanna - Heat

A modern crime classic. This brooding piece plays out against the neon hue of Los Angeles as career criminal Neil McCauley (Robert De Niro) takes down one last job under the watchful eye of broken cop Vincent Hanna (Al Pacino). This film definitely falls into the 'shouting' part of Pacino's canon but here, with the livewire Hanna, it really works. He is supposed to be the opposite to De Niro's quiet, pensive McCauley. He is supposed to be a big, intimidating personality. He is a very different leader of men than the gang leader. To that end, Pacino's work here is finely judged and when it comes to the brilliant coffee shop confrontation, both men are finally stripped bare and Hanna's bravado is finally stripped away and a frightened lonely man is all that is left. In a film full of complex characters it is Pacino's Hanna that is the most difficult to understand and yet two moments sum him up. The first is the conversation with his wife Justine (Diane Venora) where he explains he has to remain 'I got to hold on to my angst, I preserve it, because I need it. It keeps me sharp. On the edge. Where I gotta be.' The second moment is the final image of Hanna holding McCauley's hand as the latter slowly dies. Both wishing for something more. Both not wanting to let go.

4. Frank Serpico - Serpico

If The Godfather films cemented Pacino as one to watch, Serpico placed him on the pinnacle as a consummate young actor. His performance as Frank Serpico, who goes from fresh-faced young police recruit to hippy agitator, is a joy to watch. The film tells of the titular cop as he is promoted to plainclothes police work. Here he discovers the police corruption and brutality that is an everyday occurrence. When he decides to expose his colleagues, he is harassed to the point of excess which not causes problems with his love-life but also with his life as a whole. Then, one night, he is shot in the face. It is then that he decides he will testify against the force and take on the corruption that has poisoned the NYPD. Not only is this one of Pacino's best performances, it is also one of Sidney Lumet's best films. The seventies shot drama is easily an equal to other cop films of the era like The French Connection but, in Frank Serpico, we have a character with real heart and a desire to do what is right. It's also great to see Pacino playing Frank later in life almost as a polar opposite to Michael Corleone, scruffy and determined to uphold the law.

3. Tony Montana - Scarface

Tony Montana has become one of the most influential gangster characters in modern cinema and Pacino's take on it, at a stage in his career when he was just beginning to suffer his first run of poor form following the trio of misfires Bobby Deerfield, Cruising and Author! Author!, briefly threw him back into the spotlight. It could be argued that this is where the crazy, shouting persona began to grow in Pacino that has since become his stereotype, but here it is a thing of manic beauty. Montana is almost like the bastard flipside on Michael Corleone. Montana, a Cuban assassin, is first seen being interviewed by faceless Miami border officials. He is relaxed and confident, their questions can't faze him. As he begins to move up the ladder of power, however, taking down Robert Loggia's Frank Lopez and stealing his girlfriend, Michelle Pfeiffer, Tony gets drunk on power and makes the biggest mistake of all by ignoring the first rule of drug-dealing, 'don't get high on your own supply'. In his drug-addled state he crosses drug overlord Alejandro Sosa and pays the ultimate price in a violent stand-off in his mansion. The film plays like a piece of bloody, high opera and, to that extent, manages to let the viewer accept the manic energy and ridiculousness of it all. Pacino is a whirling dervish at the centre though. All moments pass through his masterful performance. Yes. Tony is over-the-top but that's the point of the film, that excess will destroy you. You get sucked into Tony's word so much that you are genuinely surprised he has some morals when he refuses to allow and mother and child to be assassinated. From his Cuban accent and eighties clothes to his brilliant restaurant speech ('say hello to the bad guy') this is Pacino at his most excessive and brilliant.

2. Sonny Wortzik - Dog Day Afternoon

What a film and what a performance. To be honest, this film is packed with great work from all involved and yet Pacino still manages to stand out as Sonny Wortzik. Pacino was in a period of his career almost unparalleled by any actor before or since. Everything he touched turned to gold and only Robert De Niro could come close. Based on real events, the film tells of Sonny and his best friend Sal (the towering John Cazale €“ an actor who could have ruled Hollywood were it not for his premature death) as they rob a bank. This is no mere robbery though as Sonny is trying to fund a sex-change operation for his wife Leon (Chris Sarandon €“ again, brilliant). What starts out as a small news story grows as the press lay siege and Sonny leads the baying crowd in a chant of 'Attica! Attica!'. Finally, as the FBI lead proceedings, they are taken to the airport to escape before Sal is shot and Sonny finally arrested. The relationship between Pacino and Cazale is the real heart of this film and plays on a parallel to their work in the first two Godfather films. Yet again, Pacino plays a character so different from the ones that made him famous, almost turning in a comedy role before the depth of realisation hits the audience of Sonny's sadness and desperation. The docu-drama feel is heightened not only through the performances but by the lack of a soundtrack making the tension, as it cranks up, an element driven by the ensemble cast. A brilliant, brilliant film.

1. Michael Corleone - The Godfather Trilogy

What else was going to be number one?! You might ask why the trilogy when the third is a poor relation of the golden-plated first two parts? Well, even in the series closer, Pacino's work is still immense and through all three films he gives us one of the longest, most detailed characterisations we're yet to see in cinema. The fall of Michael Corleone (as the film might be called) is an incredible piece of acting work to watch. As he goes from fresh-faced war veteran to cold-hearted mob boss, the life and colour drains from his eyes to the point where, at the defining moment of his life, the punishment of his brother Fredo, they are mere black shells. Surrounded by one of the best ensemble casts ever assembled for a series of films (Pacino, De Niro, Brando, Caan, Keaton, Duvall, Shire, Cazale) it is Michael who begins as the heart of the piece before he greys and ages into the sad, cardigan wearing old man who can't escape his past. Pacino almost says more in his silences than any lines of dialogue but, again, it is the relationship which Fredo which 'breaks out heart' and Michael, looking out of the boat house window is as haunting an image as we're ever going to see. A five-star performance in a five-star classic. Now on to the sucked...

... And 5 Performances That Sucked

5. Rooster - Righteous Kill

Well, everything Heat was, Righteous Kill isn't. The excitement was quite up there with 1995 levels but audiences were keen to see the two greatest actors of their generation share some serious screen time. What we got though was, well, average. It was just another cop film. Nothing more, and that's why it makes the list. Pacino could have delivered on a barnstorming scale but both he and De Niro sleepwalk through the film. The film opens with De Niro's 'Turk' confessing to the Poetry Boy killings, a murderer who leaves short poems with his victims which include morally repugnant characters such as acquitted rapists, assaulting priests and drug dealers. As time proceeds however, Turk discovers that the murderer is in fact his friend and partner of thirty years, Rooster (Pacino). The ending shows Turk's earlier confessions was no more than a red herring as he was being forced to read Rooster's diary before an eventual fire-fight that sees Pacino grounded and dying. If this starred two average actors, it would have been a perfectly acceptable piece of DVD cop trash but to see two greats 'phone it in' is such a shame. Also, moving from Michael Mann to John Avnet clearly didn't get their juices flowing and Pacino, in particular, seems to be just going through the motions. Why these two signed up for such a weak script, no one will know. All we can be thankful for is that it's looking likely the two will reunite for Martin Scorcese's The Irishman next year with Pacino as Jimmy Hoffa.

4. Starkman - Gigli

Why? Just...why? Pacino goes through the motions (noticing a pattern here) in an awful, truly offensive film. It's perhaps easy to see why Pacino might have signed up because Martin Brest, the man who directed him to an Oscar in Scent of a Woman, also directed this but, Al, read your scripts first. Coming at the low that was 'Bennifer', the films centres around Larry Gigli (Ben Affleck) who is made to kidnap the mentally disabled son of a federal prosecutor to stop Starkman (Pacino) being sent to prison. The mob boss doesn't trust Larry to do the job well so sends lesbian hard-nut Ricki (Jennifer Lopez) after him to oversee the job. Then Gigli turns her because he's, you know, Ben Affleck, and Ricki's lover slashes her wrists because, you know, it's Jennifer Lopez. And Al Pacino sits and shouts because, well, that's what he does now. I feel dirty after writing that plot synopsis. I hope you're all happy now. Anyway, it's almost as if Pacino is pretending he's not even in this movie because he thinks if he shouts loud enough we'll forget his grey wig and crappy suits. Look at how terrifying Pacino is as Michael Corleone, even when standing in silence. Now look at his Starkman as he shouts and stomps. It's not even a fair fight is it?!

3. John Milton - The Devil's Advocate

And now, the pinnacle of Pacino's 'shouty shouty' performances. I know a lot of people like this film for the trashy schlock horror that it is but I'm sure they're only saying that because of Keanu and Theron's arses going hell for leather in the sex scene. It is a poor film and not one to be placed alongside De Niro's egg-peeling Devil in Angel Heart. Incredibly, this film came between Donnie Brasco and The Insider, two great films that showcased Pacino's ageing talent. This film is just the out of date tuna between two slices of freshly baked bread. Keanu Reeves stars as a lawyer (yes, I know) who is hired by Milton, Chadwick & Waters' John Milton (with a name like that he can be trusted, yeah?!). He moves his young wife Mary Ann (Charlize Theron) to New York but the two being to find strange goings-on both in the court room and in their own minds as Milton's demonic deeds and despots take over. More synopsis could be given but bar the fact that Pacino is the Devil and Kevin's father, I'll just say €“ it's all a bloody dream. Good. Now you don't have to watch it. As opposed to some films in this top five, it does at least look as though Pacino is having fun...it's just that none of the audience is. It is only Theron that gets away with anything with an affecting performance as a woman on the edge. It's a shame that she surrounded by 'loud angry man' and 'empty head boy'. No wonder she decided to play Aileen Wuornos in Monster.

2. Tom Dobb - Revolution

Pacino had had a few ups and downs since the turn of the eighties but even in such damp squibs as Bobby Deerfield and Author! Author!, he still turned in good work in average films. Cruising, although controversial and not the best film of anyone involved, is still an interesting piece to watch, almost as if Pacino had been cast in a downbeat version of Stallone's Cobra. It was with Revolution though that everything fell apart and Pacino 'retired' for four years before returning with the excellent Sea of Love. It tells the story of Tom Dobb who is forced to fight in the American Revolutionary War. Soon, his son is captured by the evil British soldiers including Donald Sutherland's Sergeant Major Peasy. Eventually Dobb fights for the freedom of the colonies all the while searching for his son. And that's pretty much it. It cost $28million and made...$346,761. That's more interesting than the plot. The funniest thing about this film is that Pacino stars alongside Sid Owen (Ricky!!!) and Dexter Fletcher as his son at different ages. Pacino's performance, however, is seriously misjudged and, basically, he is severely miscast as Dobb. It could have been his Gladiator or Braveheart, in actual fact it was a huge flop and became his Ishtar.

1. As Himself - Jack And Jill

The most depressing film on this list. By a country mile. Not only is it Adam Sandler at his most annoying but we also find he's 'done an Eddie Murphy' by playing more than one character AND he's dragged one the best actors of his generation down into the cess pool too. Jack is an advertising executive who has to try and get Al Pacino in a Dunkin' Donuts commercial. Jill is his annoying sister who is just, well, awful. Pacino, obviously, falls for Jill (Sandler in drag remember) and agrees to the advert if he gets a date with her (because that's how Oscar winners conduct their deals). He then tries to win her over dressed as the Man of La Mancha (obviously) before Jill (Sandler in drag) turns him down. We then see Pacino in the advert as he calls himself Dunkaccino and has a bit of a rap (this is an Oscar winner remember and not Sandler in drag). Similar to Gigli, this film is just offensively bad. Even with Sandler's American fan-base, it's incredible that his grossed over $100,000,000 worldwide. Pacino, though, should be dragged through the streets for this self-referential piece of rubbish. Taking the mickey out of yourself is fine if the script is good but this is not and Pacino must, must, must have known that. It's like watching that rubbish Sky advert but for ninety minutes. The only worthwhile thing is Pacino's reaction to the advert where he says, "Every copy of this must be destroyed. No-one can ever see it." We'll assume this was secret footage to a private screening Pacino had of this film.