Blair Witch Review: 7 Ups And 3 Downs

Now with 50% more corner standing.

By Alex Leadbeater /

Lionsgate

The original Blair Witch Project may no longer be quite lauded as a horror classic (even if it probably should), but its impact on film culture is indelible: it's the Psycho of found footage and the "is it real?" marketing became a template for viral campaigns in the internet age. That's quite a legacy; a belated follow-up could be the Mad Max: Fury Road of horror and still have comparatively little impact. And that's if you can get past the cynicism about doing a late-in-the-day sequel anyway.

Advertisement

This combined fear is likely the cause for the film's big marketing gambit - it spent most of its life under the title The Woods, only revealed to be part of an existing franchise at Comic-Con in July. That gave, if only for a fleeting moment, Blair Witch as much hype as it's predecessor; people got interested in the film based on its own merits, so when they slapped the brand on it the reaction was excitement rather than cynicism.

Of course, hype tactics, especially one so big as this, are primarily there to get bums in seats. Keeping them there on the edge is another matter.

Advertisement

So, does Blair Witch succeed or is it just like all the other resurrected horror icons? Thankfully, it's the former. Like most strong directors going into the bosom of a franchise there's some feeling of restriction to Adam Wingard's latest, but pure terror still works its way through the trees (along with some sly social commentary). Here's seven Ups and three Downs from Blair Witch.

Ups:

7. It's Scary (Especially At The End)

Lionsgate

Putting aside the hype, Blair Witch was always going to be fighting an uphill battle care of some of the most hyperbolic trailer quotes imaginable; the teaser for "The Woods" had an assortment of lines from trusted genre publications calling it a "new beginning" and "one of the scariest films ever made". While that sure stirs up excitement, it doesn't really help the film, creating unreal expectations and opening it right up for instantaneous mocking.

Advertisement

Thankfully, Blair Witch is scary. Sickeningly so in fact. Adam Wingard's proven gifted at playing horror conventions knowingly over his previous features, but here he plays it so straight that the built-up results are nothing short of chilling.

The final twenty minutes in particular are unbearably intense. As the characters unwittingly stumbled to near-certain doom, the tension mounts and by the time we reach what is clearly the final location (you'll know it when you see it), I was frozen in place, unable to breathe, let alone move. It's pure, unadulterated terror, and, whatever issues there may be in presentation, this is the stuff of Burkittsville dreams.

Advertisement

6. It's Got A Millennial Attitude

Lionsgate

The horror is all the more effective because it comes after an oddly humorous first half. The characters, who all have broad but distinct personalities, are constantly wisecracking and using jokey disbelief as a cover for the mounting fear that's gradually consuming them. Yes, there's a lot of jokes in Blair Witch. A very noticeable lot.

Advertisement

But of course, these are millennials, so what did you expect? The first movie followed Gen X-ers pumped full of pretentiousness and dreams of success. This one has a bunch of students doing a project because they have to. As such, the reactions to the emerging horror are more knee-jerk - this batch opt to turn back much easier - and they cope with all hell breaking loose it with all the self-awareness a generation raised on the internet would.

At points the characters can be a bit annoying, the sort of film students who would be exhausting to spend too much time with, but as with the original that's kinda the point. The aim is realism, not likability, and in reality these are the sort of people who'd end up in this situation.

Advertisement

5. It Seriously Expands The Mythology

Lionsgate

While the potential of a wide-release snuff film tricked a few people, what really gave The Blair Witch Project its elevated status was its method of delivery of answers. Talks of witchcraft and corner-loving serial killers were peppered through the intro and briefly paid off later on, but to get a real idea of what was going on took hours on the dial-up internet reading into the viral marketing, and even then a resolute solution was hard to come by.

Advertisement

The mythology was a defining element for so many fans, and gave the movie a strange allure for everyone else. So it's very exciting that Wingard takes ahold of that mythology, expands it greatly, and yet still has it feel cohesive.

There's a backstory built up for the Blair Witch that increases her menace and contextualises things like Rustin Parr, those stick sculptures and the original trio's disappearance. Yes, that's right: it provides all the pieces to resolutely answer what exactly happened at the end of the original. And it does it well.

Advertisement

4. The Shooting Methods Are Novel

Lionsgate

Blair Witch is set in 2014, and as such has a lot of 2014 tech in it; drones, earpiece cameras, GPS readers, you get the picture. At first that seems worrying; a drone is going to allow unreal sweeping shots and earpiece cameras are a lazy way to fall back on effortless POV shots. However, as the movie gets going there's a real effort made to use these for different effects; the drone's a way to convey the dense forest, while the earpieces remove the characters knowledge of being filmed.

Advertisement

There's some really subtle tricks in there, with so much action unsettlingly happening to the side of shot and different camera quality building through the film to instinctively tell you what recording we're currently viewing. It's an inch forward rather than a leap, but Wingard's found plenty of fertile ground in found footage.

However while the captured footage may be, this film actually isn't scrappy. In fact, it's carefully curated; as the opening text says, this was "assembled", and there's definitely points where the editing is in-universe obviously making a point, especially with the long gaps between beats made to draw out the worry. Things come to a head in big conversations, where there's so many cameras we're jumping perspective every second. The result is dizzying, and with the disorientation Wingard's making an astute point about our constantly-recorded lives and how much has changed - in reality and cinema - since the original.

Advertisement

3. It Still Doesn't Show That Much

Lionsgate

Not to get too on the soapbox about the original, but not having the budget to properly show the witch (or anything for that matter) was its biggest strength. It made it feel real, because, quite simply, you wouldn't shot everything unbeknowingly plot essential. Heck, it's implied everything goes to sh*t because Heather picks up a stick figure, something we never see and only learn in a single line. This makes it stand out from all later found footage films, totally lacking the polish, structure and payoff of a standard narrative.

Advertisement

Blair Witch does explain more and, as I'll look at in Downs, tries to provide a less randomised ploy, but crucially it maintains the rule of not showing everything and keeping you guessing. Yes, we do see more things, but the film is still incredibly restrained in those beats, with any exposition or showy glimpse fleeting and only playing into the character's wider confusion.

Within this there's also an extension of the ethics of found footage, with documentarian Lisa filming some of the terrors even after decency's point, being told explicitly that she's going too far.

Advertisement

2. The Woods

Lionsgate

Lionsgate could have used any fake title they wanted for Blair Witch, but wound up going with the incredibly bland "The Woods", which is about as dry as an autumnal leaf. It did fit with Wingard's previous - You're Next had some verve, but The Guest was very much a genre teasing title - but now knowing it was all a cover it seems like a missed opportunity.

Advertisement

That is until you consider how much a part those woods play in the film. They're not just the key connective tissue to the original, but an oppressive presence trapping the heroes. It'd be customary to say they're a "character", but really it's more apt to describe them as the film's monster's "weapon".

The thick, green leaves (this is set at the other end of the calendar to the first) become symbols of the unknown, in torch light gnarled fingers trying to pull you off the beaten path. One kill scene using falling trees, and the existential dread comes from the felled canopy is suffocating.

Advertisement

1. It's The Good Kind Of Legacy-quel

Lionsgate

As the legacy-quel craze has become seemingly the only way to make a late-in-the-day sequel in modern Hollywood (unless you're Ghostbusters), they've been divided into three categories; lazy redos (Independence Day: Resurgence), lazy-but-fun redos (Jurassic Park) and redos that have something more to say (Star Wars: The Force Awakens, Creed). Thankfully, Blair Witch is (mostly - as always, I'll get to that) in the latter camp.

Advertisement

In some ways it's surprising that this is a legacy-quel at all - you'd expect something a bit more novel after that marketing - but Wingard works his usual genre cliché twist magic and the result is a top level one.

What's important to remember when approaching this new subset of movies is that they can't just coast on nostalgia. Yes, a film of this type should include plenty of references for the fans, but it needs to also have its own, unique forward momentum, taking itself in new directions and also serving as a standalone flick, which is exactly what Blair Witch does; the expanded mythology certainly shows the former, and trust me when I say it can work by itself.

Advertisement

But, like the film's camping trip, it isn't a total success. Let's take a look at the film's Downs.

Downs:

3. It Becomes A Bit Too Repetitive

Lionsgate

Of course, a requisite part of a legacy-quel is that the film acts as a stealth remake, and if there's an element that Blair Witch struggles with, it's that.

Advertisement

The plot beats are unsettlingly similar to the first - documentary set-up, pratting about in the woods, creeping worry, all out panic etc. - which doesn't work in something pitched on being spontaneous. There's definitely elements in the new mythology that allow Wingard to present something of a twist on the beats, but it does begin to feel like this is going onto autopilot.

Sometimes the movie redoes so heavily that it stops making proper sense. At one point the characters discover that, after a day of walking through the woods, they're back at the previous night's campsite. We do get the expected millennial response, but it's still cheapened by directly coming out of the original's book of tricks. There's not even a recognition this is the same problem Heather and co. faced, which, given the recording's importance, just doesn't ring true.

Advertisement

2. The Middle Section Is Confused

Lionsgate

Blair Witch is a major studio movie trying to look like a scrappy "real" film, and where it can't quite replicate the shock factor of reality (or even the original) is in the actual telling of the story. Wingard tries to insert some narrative structure into proceedings, while at the same time wanting to keep a sense of unpredictability, two things that don't gel.

Advertisement

It's too counterintuitive and in the second act things begin to feel a lot more box ticky than they have any right to. It's a series of creepy vignettes, all ordered seemingly at random yet too comfortably placed, and while there's fun moments in there, the editing, with cross-cutting and little pause, mean many fall flat.

Faked realism is a hard thing to pull off for sure, although given how adept Wingard is in translating the other elements, and how skilful his convention busting narratives have been in the past, it feels like a major mis-step.

Advertisement

1. Jump Scare Fake-Outs

Lionsgate

My least favourite thing in all of cinema - not just horror, the entire medium - is jump scare fake-outs. Cattle prod jolts aren't all that fun in general, but there's at least a few standout cases where they really made things more tense. However, those ones where you think it's the ghost/monster/killer but is instead just a cat/bird/dumb friend (delete as most annoyingly applicable) have never worked, only serving to release all the built-up tension and give audiences a chance to laugh in the face of horror.

Advertisement

I can respect Wingard for trying to use them to show the characters' increased paranoia, but most of the ones he executes (and he does far too many) don't work and only exhaust the audience. Many of them are localised in that middle section too, so it's not easy to see why some people may fall out of favour with the film before it really picks itself up for the finale.

Blair Witch is in cinemas from 15th September.

Advertisement