Dan Aykroyd: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked
Bustin' makes him feel good.
If there was any justice in the world, Dan Aykroyd would have been the subject of a special Awesome/Sucked column years ago when Ghostbusters 3 was made, starring the entire original cast and passing the torch to a new generation. Sadly, thanks in part to the lack of a suitable script and Bill Murray's unwillingness to play ball, the relentless march of time robbed us of that opportunity.
And now, Aykroyd qualifies almost by accident. He has a cameo in the new Ghostbusters film, having praised it to the high heavens (in the most transparent case of sycophancy ever seen): an unintentional booby prize that by no means reflects on the quality of the reboot. But talk about distracting.
Of course, Aykroyd is a lot more than a Ghostbuster. He's been a Blues Brother, a Conehead, a super secret Indiana Jones cameo and one of the most enduringly popular Saturday Night alumni ever. And all that despite making a frankly stunning number of terrible movies. He's just very lucky that his early output (between SNL and the mid-90s) was so consistently watchable (even when it wasn't the best).
Firstly, the performances that made Aykroyd the comedy movie legend he is...
5. Roman Craig - The Great Outdoors (1988)
Traditionally, The Great Outdoors is considered a good John Candy film, and while it's true that the late, great star is a fundamentally definitive presence, his success depends on the charitable balance offered by Aykroyd.
Dodging his usual nice guy/charming outsider shtick, Aykroyd here is in full douche-bag mode, playing Candy's incredibly dislikable in-law, driven by greed, arrogance and the appearance of power. He's a yuppy villain, and he's thoroughly detestable - and thus thoroughly successful - and his chemistry with the perpetually adorable Candy is great.
Outrageously, the film is not universally loved, with accusations that its lack of innovation or an important message in some way compromises its ability to entertain. It's ludicrous: The Great Outdoors is a disposable comedy based on a great character dynamic, and it is as funny and as memorable as Candy's other more celebrated work.
4. Louis Winthorpe III - Trading Places (1983)
While there is some politicised thoughtfulness on class difference in The Great Outdoors, it's never as open or as blatant as the brilliant, barbed capitalist criticism of Trading Places. And while the film is memorably populated with pantomime villains and caricatures, and presided over by the colourful energy of Eddie Murphy, it is owned by a spell-binding performance of human decay by Aykroyd.
The film is basically a yuppy Christmas Carol - or at least it has that sort of capitalist nightmare at its heart - as we watch Aykroyd's Winthorpe be casually destroyed by his poisonous pay-masters on a bet. As he goes from Prince to Pauper, and initially loses the plot, it's great to watch Aykroyd shift from smug superiority (not in itself enough to make him a villain) to dead eyed nihilism and right through to heroic redemption.
Obviously, there are problematic moments (like him blacking up towards the climax), but this was a case of two SNL MVPs sparring successfully to create comedy lightning in a bottle that still endures today.
3. Dr. Raymond Stantz - Ghostbusters (1984)
It's pretty easy to forget Aykroyd's role in Ghostbusters in the face of the other characters around him. He's not quite the straight man (Egon), or the skeptic (Winston) and he can't hope to compete with the acerbic cynicism and scene-stealing wit of Bill Murray, but his role is the most important. Because he's the audience's way in.
He might be an expert - meaning there is fundamental distance between him and the audience - but his excitement and naive enthusiasm ultimately makes him the most sympathetic character. That's why it's him who accidentally summons the Stay Puft and why he is castigated for not saying yes when asked if he's a God. He's basically the everyman and the easiest one to root for.
It also helps that he's hilarious, quietly picking up less flashy gags as Bill Murray attempts to make it all about him. Perhaps that's why it was Stantz and not Venkman who was invited back for that auspicious cameo in Casper...
2. Elwood J. Blues - The Blues Brothers (1980)
The BLues Brothers movie shouldn't have worked. Seriously, when do sketch show skits turn into feature films that are fully formed, improve on the characters and are that magically thing - funny? If you're trying to answer that genuinely, the answer is stunningly rarely.
Even more impressively, The Blues Brothers weren't exactly the most narratively appropriate characters to adapt out, but thanks to Aykroyd's writing and John Landis' direction, the result of this supremely weird film was surprisingly successful. It's not just a cult gem, it's actually a legitimately great comedy - one of the best of the '80s in fact.
20 years later, he'd revive the character for an unthinkable, misguided sequel, but the less we say about that the better.
1. Grocer - Grosse Pointe Blank (1997)
It's a great tragedy that Grosse Pointe Blank will probably never be considered in the great pantheon of Dan Aykroyd's best movies. A good deal of that probably comes down to the fact that it came outside of his most successful 1980s period, and that it's very much John Cusack's movie.
But Aykroyd is an absolute joy to watch in GBP - a magnificent bastard of a supervillain with a Terminator boxy hairstyle, Jack Nicholson eyebrows and an enormous capacity for pantomime malevolence. He's clearly also having a lot of fun too, revelling in spitting venom and being the most cartoonish element in an otherwise grounded story. And it's precisely because of his difference to Blank's attempted "normal" life that he works so well - it's almost like he's been ripped from a Shane Black movie.
Everything else in the film - the humanist existentialism, the characters, the writing, the wit - is all perfect, but it wouldn't work without a villain like Aykroyd to sell the enduring threat of Blank's dangerous job. And we owe a lot for that.
And now on to the ones that sucked...
5. Max Beasly - Unconditional Love (2003)
It's always a fairly damning indication of a film's quality when the studio behind it postpone it for almost four years then premiere it on TV and dump its release in direct-to-DVD land. Watching Unconditional Love, it's entirely justified that New Line Cinema did it, though.
In the "comic murder mystery", Aykroyd plays a deeply uninteresting character - the husband of Kathy Bates who leaves her (no doubt partly because of her ridiculous obsession with the least believable Tom Jones clone ever in Jonathan Pryce). That - and the murder of Pryce's pop star - send her on a journey of renewed self-discovery.
There are some fun ideas, but the execution is hopeless and muddled and you're left wondering when there's going to be some jokes. Particularly when it comes to Aykroyd, who is painfully wasted and could have been replaced with any sad-sack comedian of any quality. That's not the kind of job he should have been taking even in 2003.
4. Ellis Fielding - Loose Cannons! (1990)
Whenever anyone questions the assertion that there is a buddy cop movie for every taste and sensibility, point them towards Loose Cannons! which spices up the premise needlessly with a little Hitler intrigue.
The buddy cop elements are entirely by the book, and in no way terrible. Gene Hackman was born to play perpetually annoyed, grizzled veterans with a teak-tough exterior, and Aykroyd is believable as his dorky, emotionally unstable forensic expert partner. That was enough to sell a film really, but from there it all spirals into ridiculousness.
Aykroyd's character does impersonations - Goofy, Captain Kirk, Roadrunner - when he's uncomfortable, which he inevitably is as their central case involves a porno starring Adolf Hitler. Yep, seriously. It sounds bonkers, but strangely, the pace is laboured, the jokes don't really come and if it weren't for some of his later film choices, you'd think this was easily Aykroyd's most embarrassing professional memory.
3. Dad - Loser (2000)
2000 really wasn't the greatest year for the Dan Aykroyd fan club: he'd rubbed salt into the wounds of anyone complaining about a Blues Brothers sequel by making it terrible, and he also appeared in one of the most unremarkable teen comedies of all time. That it came at the height of the genre, starred American Pie's Jason Biggs and was backed up by the supreme excellence of Wheatus' "Teenage Dirtbag" makes it all the worse.
Loser is an absolute abomination, and definitive proof - if ever it were needed - that nobody should ever allow David Spade and Andy Dick to work on the same project. It is utterly, painfully unfunny, offering no new riff on the teen comedy movie, and the entire thing - including Dan Aykroyd's entirely pointless supporting role as "Dad" - is upstaged horribly by Biggs' improbable, ridiculous curtains.
He only turns up for a short amount of screen time, but Loser is another case of Aykroyd wasting his comic legacy for walk-ons and supporting roles that are distantly beneath him.
2. Pa Tex - North (1994)
There are people who will tell you that North doesn't deserve the bashing it got from the likes of Roger Ebert; that it deserves secondary appraisal and a more open mind. Those people are morons who should be stripped of their opinion privilege.
It's a comedy without jokes, a Rob Reiner film without his characteristic humanist appeal, and a supposedly heart-warming family tale without sympathy, heart, imagination or appeal. The premise is nasty and vindictive and Aykroyd's part - of a garish Texan looking to replace his dead son with North - should have offered balance and a commentary on a deeply sympathetic tragedy. Instead, you can't feel anything but abject disdain for him: he's a cartoon who probably deserved to have his life ruined, and the sooner he's off screen the better.
Unfortunately, he's then replaced by a succession of racial stereotypes and terribly written caricatures who force themselves through jokes that never work towards a resolution that really isn't worth the effort to get to.
1. Yogi Bear - Yogi Bear (2010)
I was willing to forgive Aykroyd for his various walk on parts and his annoying association with Adam Sandler films (in which he played the same character multiple times). I was even willing to forgive him for The Blues Brothers 2000, which a lot of people simply aren't, but I absolutely draw the line at his association with Yogi Bear.
It's almost like he looked at the travesty that was Bill Murray's work on the Garfield movies and decided that not only could he do better at ruining his legacy, he would do so in a way that made it impossible to forgive him.
Yogi Bear would have been fine with an impersonator doing the voice, given that it was clearly aimed at the child of childish audience who don't care for intellect or jokes of substance (or success). Instead, they called in an all-star vocal cast to be utterly swallowed up in an awful script, and Aykroyd basically sounds like he's doing a terrible impression of Yogi all the way through the dull as dishwater plot. Hardly one for the ages.
How would you rank Dan Aykroyd's best and worst films? Offer your suggestions below in the comments thread.