30 Days of Night and Hard Candy director David Slade was attached to the Fox property, even claiming the Daredevil script was "amazing." But, alas, Slade fell through as he got more and more pressing work and the project seemed dead in the water, once again, after going through two to three more screenwriters. So, where does that leave us, now? Daredevil is a hot commodity at a studio bent on continually expanding their cinematic universe. But as many fans have stated, it would be difficult for Daredevil to fit into this Avengers universe (despite becoming one recently in the comic world). So, what should Marvel do? Take the property on its own two legs and work it within the confines of its own trilogy or universe? Use Daredevil as a character to open up to another, different, more realistic and gritty universe featuring the likes of The Punisher and Moon Knight? Here are some ideas for what Marvel Studios can do, who they can cast, and some good starting points for the Daredevil cinematic universe...
Advertisement
Stand-Alone vs. Combined Universe
Let's be completely honest here. Daredevil, as fantastic as the character is, wouldn't have much to do on the Avengers team. He's a street level fighter who's massively sensitive to sound. Had he been in the end scene of The Avengers fighting along side the team, he would have spent the majority of the time on his knees with his hands to his ears in pain at the explosions, screaming, and gunfire. Cosmic war is not his element. And that's perfectly fine. Not every character needs to be like that. When it comes to Matt Murdock, he's a prime example of a hero whose alias is less important than the man himself. Batman overshadows Bruce Wayne. The Hulk overshadows Banner. Clark Kent is just a ruse for the true icon of Superman. But Matt Murdock is Murdock before Daredevil. Writers like Stan Lee, Frank Miller, Ed Brubaker, Kevin Smith, Brian Bendis, and Mark Waid have explored that extensively. He's a renegade, extremely adept martial artist and gymnast, but that's all second fiddle to his psychology as the lawyer seeking order in the chaos of both a professional and private life. Which leads us to the fact that unlike the majority of superheroes, Matt Murdock actually has a full-time job. Batman is rich. Iron Man is rich. Bruce Banner is a scientist always on the run, Reed Richards is a scientist always making...stuff. But none of them are actually employed. Sure, Peter Parker takes pictures for The Daily Bugle and Clark Kent is a reporter, but Matt Murdock is one of the few heroes to actually have to worry about paying the bills with a steady, demanding job (the only other one I can think of off the top of my head is Barry Allen's Flash, who is a forensic scientist). Which means that his work is imperative to his life and story. A Daredevil movie should be a bit of a legal drama, as well. It would definitely put a new spin on the superhero genre. But that means we spend adequate time not exploring the realms of roof-jumping herodom. And I, personally, don't find that possible with Daredevil being committed into the current Marvel Cinematic Universe. Let him get his own breathing room without being swamped with lawsuits because of the Hulk's destruction in Harlem.
Story Lines and Comic Runs
Being that this film is no longer associated to the Mark Steven Johnson film from 2003 with Fox, we have a good ol'fashioned reboot on our hands. So, what run should we start off with? With Slade attached, we were going to get Frank Miller's Born Again, which remains the definitive Daredevil tale of this day. It's spectacularly written, illustrated, and executed and I couldn't recommend it more to a comic lover. And I'm ecstatic that it hasn't been brought to screen yet. The issue with putting a story like Born Again up is that it requires tons and tons of back story to be fully effective. It's the tale of Daredevil's identity being put into his mortal enemy's hands by Karen Page, his ex-girlfriend and love of his life. While we saw The Kingpin in the 2003 film (played by the late Michael Clarke Duncan), Karen was practically no where to be found (admittedly, she is in the director's cut of the film for about two minutes). Born Again is a conclusion, not a starting point. So, I'd recommend Miller's The Man Without Fear run, obviously, minus the Elektra subplot (Marvel Studios does not own her character). Miller's run, or they could take the film in a completely new direction, giving it a Daredevil: Noir feel from the 1930s or take Carnahan's direction as the 1970s upbringing, using TMWF as its crux. Other great story-lines could include Daredevil: Redemption, which would be a legal drama before an action film, or adapting Mark Waid's current run with an origin story. Steer clear from Born Again for a while. It's too similar to The Dark Knight Rises and wouldn't make any sense to start off. Of course, you could also go with my full-length feature script. I'm quite proud of it.
Tone
Daredevil can work with almost any take. He's easily a combination of Batman, Iron Man, and Spider-Man. While lots of people want the new film to be explicitly adult, mature, dark, and gritty, the fact is that he can be just as effective in an Iron Man-esque universe, wit, charm, and romance included. It's one thing the 2003 film got very right. It was able to be incredibly serious and dark while having that fun spark to it as well. It never took itself so seriously that it forgot its identity. That doesn't mean I forgot about the horrid playground scene. I know that in the script I produced, I tried to level it as a combination of the tone in Iron Man and Batman Begins. It's something you'll find in Mark Waid's current endeavors with the Man Without Fear. There were tons of fears that Daredevil moving to Marvel Studios meant it would become a lot like an action-adventure version of an episode of Franklin & Bash, which wouldn't necessarily be detrimental to the character as long as it's well-written and executed respectfully. While Daredevil deals with sensationally thematic elements (drug use on the streets, prostitution, extreme violence), he's also quite the ladies man (having slept with Elektra, Black Widow, and Black Cat, thank you very much) which leads the film into Spider-Man romance territory. And that's a good thing, to be able to market your movie to everyone. It's important to realize Daredevil works on almost all cylinders. Don't restrict him. Have fun with what you're producing, filmmakers.
Casting
Casting is always difficult for a superhero film, because so many actors could fit. I, personally, find these actors to be the best for the roles (despite the fact that some of them are a bit too old for my own script). Nikolaj Coster-Waldau for Matt Murdock. He's got the look, the acting chops, and isn't too well-known to be altogether distracting in the final product. I feel like he could bring an incredibly human side to Matt Murdock, something that many fan-casters forget when they're writing up their fantasy ensemble. Other fan-favorites include Ryan Gosling, Michael C. Hall, Jake Gyllenhaal, and Bradley Cooper. Carey Mulligan for Karen Page. Soft, sweet, simple, and powerful, Mulligan could really bring a new sensibility to this character that hasn't adequately been explored on screen yet. Other power players include Charlize Theron, Julie Bowen, Katrina Bowden, Imogen Poots, and Elizabeth Banks. Val Kilmer for The Kingpin. I see James Gandolfini and John Goodman get thrown around a lot; and while they're fantastic actors, I personally see Kilmer really driving it home in the role. While Michale Clarke Duncan provided a titan of a threat, some perspective shooting could really lead to Kilmer being a massive challenge to Daredevil; something hehas to be. Patton Oswalt for Foggy Nelson. I love Jon Favreau's Foggy from the 2003 movie, and I think Oswalt could really take off in this role. Other options include Jason Segal and Seth MacFarlane. David Tennant for Bullseye. Now, it might seem off at first, but I see Bullseye being just as calculatingly evil and excruciating mentally as he is physically. Jason Statham is a favorite for the role, but I don't see him adequately portraying Bullseye when the punches aren't being thrown. I'd love to see Tennant's take on the character, bringing a real, eerily human aspect to the world's greatest assassin. Billy Bob Thornton for Ben Urich. He looks the part, the man can act, and I really can't think of anyone better for the role (though most people want Bryan Cranston). John Cusack could throw in an interesting performance, as well.
Conclusion
So, what do you think? What plans do you hope are in store for Daredevil now that he's under the Marvel Studios roof? What stories would you like to see played out? What actors would you like to see in portrayal? And how do you feel about a stand-alone universe? Let's just all agree on one thing: Daredevil needs to get back into cinemas.