Don Cheadle: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Miles Ahead or lagging behind...?

By Simon Gallagher /

Sony Pictures Classic

Don Cheadle is a strangely difficult talent to define. While he's starred in the lead of some great films and caught awards attention for his finest work, he never seems to be talked about in truly A grade terms. He's an intriguing character actor whose CV is a broad, many-headed beast that speaks of range and bravery and sadly not enough chances to lead his own projects.

Advertisement

As he ages, Cheadle has expressed his growing comfort behind the camera rather than in front of it, and while he clearly has stories to tell and a well-crafted phrasebook of experience to draw from, he is still a hugely watchable talent. To have him leave acting behind altogether to concentrate on more directing gigs like Miles Ahead would be a travesty.

Over the years he's played superheroes and human heroes; offered balance, brilliance and surrealism and run the full gamut from porn star to jazz musician and dentist and everything in between. And in most cases he's done so charitably and without stealing scenes, which says a lot about his commitment to the craft of acting.

Advertisement

With Cheadle's Miles Davis passion project - which he also directed - hitting cinemas in the UK today, now is the perfect time to evaluate where it sits on the actor's personal Awful to Awesome scale...

5 Awesome Performances

5. James Rhodes - Iron Man 3 (2013)

Marvel Studios

Despite the well-publicised failings of Iron Man 2 (they're all comparative really, but they're still pertinent), the addition of Shane Black to the follow-up was a genius move. Not only did it re-establish the right tone (without compromising the central premise of Tony Stark suffering PTSD and guilt), it also refocused the bromance between Iron Man and Rhodey.

Advertisement

Rather than being a glorified sidekick, War Machine is promoted thanks to Black's penchant for buddy cop movies. He's an anchor and offers balance to Stark's wilder side, and while he's not in it as much as his partner, Rhodey is a far more rounded character and a better written presence than he was in either of the previous films. The smarter role also gives Cheadle something to actually do, rather than hiding behind the metal face mask fighting an army of impostor robots as he did in the second.

it's just a shame that come the Avengers movies, Rhodey is relegated back to being the slightly douchey best friend freeloader who looks like walking cannon fodder.

Advertisement

4. Alan Johnson - Reign Over Me (2007)

Columbia Pictures

If anyone else was in the title role, the heart-breaking, gut-wrenching drama of Reign Over Me would be legitimately adored. As it is, the tender, affectionate tale of loss, redemption and friendship is classed solely as That Adam Sandler 9/11 film by people with tiny minds and limited imagination.

Advertisement

Putting aside the casually silly conceit that Cheadle's dentist keeps getting propositioned for blowjobs by a patient, his performance is another that succeeds because it offers some much needed balance. Alongside Sandler's most volatile performance, Cheadle is a picture of reservation and restraint, quietly weighing up his own problems against the vast mess of Sandler's Charlie's life.

Those problems might be cliched, but it is to Cheadle's eternal credit that his performance transcends the material's limits to make the role entirely worthwhile. He's not swallowed up in someone else's story, he's the driver of it.

Advertisement

Yes, the film is exploitative of emotional material, but the story-telling is great and the central relationship between Cheadle and Sandler is charming, believable and feels substantial.

3. Buck Swope - Boogie Nights (1997)

New Line Cinema

If it wasn't for Samuel L Jackson, Don Cheadle would never have even played Buck Swope. The infamous shouter was apparently sent the script initially and dismissed it outright, leaving the road open for Cheadle to swoop in (after Juliann Moore vouched for Paul Thomas Anderson).

Advertisement

His reward was one of Boogie Nights' most stable characters: Buck is aspirational, despite his long and illustrious porn career. He's the antithesis of Dirk Diggler (again, Cheadle plays a character offering balance), seeking a way out of porn and into his dream of a simple life. And while he could have been painted as a naive fool, there is some self-awareness and some sadness to Cheadle's performance that gives Swope surprising complexity and depth.

The scene when he is denied a loan because of his professional past is startlingly good, and the idea that Swope is never able to exist comfortably in his own skin is basically the entire premise of the film. The fact that he gets a happy ending is great, but you do still get the sense that he's still just playing a part: it's only when his child is born and in that exchange with the banker that you get a real, pure sense of who he is.

Advertisement

2. Miles Davis - Miles Ahead (2016)

Sony Pictures Classic

All too often, actors like Cheadle are relegated to dependable supporting roles or interesting character performances and kept somewhat away from the leads for no fathomable reason. If there's to be a single lesson taken away from his exceptional performance as musical legend Miles Davis, it should be that that thinking needs to be addressed.

Advertisement

Cheadle is vastly better than the rest of the film, towering over the framing in a way that actually pulls the liberally fictional biopic away from Lifetime TV territory. He brings a surreal edge to the performance, which seems more invested with capturing the spirit of the man rather than capturing a wholly authentic picture of him.

His directing leaves a little to be desired, as he struggles to reconcile so many balls in the air, but as a performance, Cheadle's Davis is a tour de force, as unconventional as it is eminently watchable. And there is definitely something to be said of capturing the magic of a myth as well as simply mirroring the man.

Advertisement

1. Paul Rusesabagina - Hotel Rwanda (2004)

Lionsgate

In stark contrast to Miles Ahead, Cheadle's haunting, brilliant performance in Hotel Rwanda is a masterpiece of few brush strokes. It is a story of superheroic scale and devastation told in jarringly human terms, as the world implodes around hotel manager Paul Rusesabagina who tries incredibly hard to rebuild it as it falls.

Advertisement

Cheadle's frantic, almost hopeful performance is the perfect foil to the film's sense of outrage. Though it doesn't really push the agenda too much, Hotel Rwanda stands as a monument to Western shame in the Rwanda genocides told through the eyes of a horribly normal man.

His Rusesabagina is a picture of decency, and a lesson in retaining humanity in unthinkable conditions, enduring impossible gut-punches with poise and determination to just keep on keeping on. And in that stubborn humanity is the film's most haunting image: of Cheadle sanctifying himself with a gun to his head.

Advertisement

And now on to Cheadle's performances that weren't quite so brilliant...

5 That Sucked

5. Clarence "Tango" Butler - Brooklyn's Finest (2009)

Overture Films

Despite boasting an incredibly gifted cast and some basically intriguing stories - a cop on the verge of retirement, another bent by corruption and a third pushed too deep into cover and questioning his loyalties - Antoine Fuqua's Brooklyn's Finest far from lives up to its name.

Advertisement

It's dull and insipid at times; derivative and uninspired at others, and it feels like little more than an exercise in exploring cliches.

Cheadle's deep cover cop is an interesting figure, and his relationship with Wesley Snipes' con is similarly promising, the execution is too lacking in imagination and too quick to peel back the layers suggesting every authority is a front for rampant racism and corruption. And worst of all, Cheadle just seems bored and painfully unsuited to the character - like he's just wearing the wrong clothes and acting the part too consciously.

Advertisement

For someone who's supposed to be under cover, that's fatally distracting.

4. Luke Graham - Mission To Mars (2000)

Buena Vista Pictures

Brian De Palma might be considered a genius in some circles but there's no getting around the fact that his Mission To Mars is not fit either for purpose or to have his good name attached to it.

Advertisement

Clearly enamoured by the idea of crafting something stunning looking set in space, De Palma ignored the fact that the screenplay was woeful and the incontrovertible truth that it would never be anything other than a poor sci-fi. That must be why he spent so much time making certain parts of it look beautiful while neglecting the other hugely important elements like story-telling and characters in a way that is almost criminal.

Cheadle plays a lone survivor abandoned on Mars after a mission goes south who sustains himself using the produce of a greenhouse... Wait... Isn't that The Martian? Sadly, his grizzled, oddly briefly deranged loner is nothing like the brilliant Mark Watney though. After years living in constant fear that he's about to die, Cheadle's survivor somehow gets over his lunacy in a matter of moments and it just doesn't ring true at all. Much like the rest of the film, actually.

Advertisement

3. Henri Moore - After The Sunset (2004)

New Line Cinema

If you ever wondered whether Don Cheadle would be a good fit for a Bahamas gangster tied up in a zany plan by a "retired" thief and his long-term FBI adversary to steal a giant diamond, the answer is no.

Advertisement

Lost in a movie that feels more like an extended advertisement for the tropical paradise it was filmed in, Cheadle is as wasted as Pierce Brosnan and Woody Harrelson as the grifter and his boy in blue. It really doesn't help that the script is diabolical, or that the story is flat out lunatic, but Cheadle sticks out like a sore thumb - a case of a talented square peg being shoe-horned into a round hole.

It's not funny, nor thrilling, nor particularly clever, and it seems to position itself as an Oceans Eleven-like slick caper without delivering on anything but the surface gloss. The best thing that can be said about it is that the only people who will love it will probably discover it entirely accidentally.

Advertisement

But at least Cheadle and the rest of the cast got a lovely looking holiday out of it.

2. James Rhodes - Iron Man 2

Marvel Studios

There's no denying the fact that Cheadle's casting in the wake of the Terrence Howard debacle was a smart idea - he was an interesting character actor with a strong track record after all - but the film he debuted in was not the right fit.

Advertisement

Rather than the buddy cop bromance he shared with Robert Downey Jr in the follow up, the Iron Man 2 version of Rhodey is more like the egotistical, unlikable douche-bag who appears in Avengers: Age Of Ultron. He's an undercooked, distracting element in a film already chock full of them and quite why anyone thought that restrained, charming Don Cheadle was the right fit for a slightly obnoxious fly boy is beyond baffling.

His performance - like the film's threat - feels fatally inauthentic, like we're watching a video game with no real stakes, and the film could have ploughed on without him, or any of the villains, or indeed much of the plot. All play second fiddle to Tony's issues, and none are anywhere near as rewarding.

Advertisement

1. Basher Tarr - The Oceans Trilogy (2001-07)

Warner Bros.

When the first Ocean's Eleven came out, it was hard to tell what exactly Don Cheadle was trying to achieve with his accent: if it was consciously designed to be terrible, then he did a remarkably good job. His lilting cockney, which frequently took trips around Greater London and then across the Atlantic at times too, was a comical mess that was surely intentional.

Advertisement

Sadly not - Cheadle had initially wanted to play the role American, so you can probably forgive him for not really committing to the performance of an accent he clearly had no experience with. But why he wasn't just pushed into the background for the sequels is beyond stupid: even when Eddie Izzard appears to play basically the same role with a better accent, Tarr abides. It's only when he gets a chance to play an American character that he sounds anything like a real human.

But it's not just the accent that hurts here: Cheadle is so ill at ease with that part of the performance that the rest of it comes across as jarring and incomplete. Like a rough draft he intended to add some of his usual charm to at a later date.

Advertisement

Which of Don Cheadle's performances do you think deserve to be classed as his best and his worst? Share your picks below in the comments thread.