Gemini Man Review: 4 Ups & 6 Downs

A fascinating disaster.

By Jack Pooley /

Paramount Pictures

It's incredibly rare that a $140 million Will Smith-starring tentpole movie arrives with such little hype, but indeed, there's been precious little buzz - positive, anyway - about the ambitious sci-fi actioner Gemini Man, helmed by Oscar-winning director Ang Lee.

Advertisement

There has been curiosity, at least, about the film's intriguing concept - a present-day Will Smith battling a younger clone of himself - as well as Lee's attempt to push cinematic boundaries by shooting the film at 120 fps.

Ultimately, though, Gemini Man really isn't worth much fuss at all, and despite the clear effort on Lee's part to give audiences a unique experience, it's one that's by turns bland and weird rather than fresh and exhilarating.

Advertisement

Early reviews are largely negative so far, rightly lamenting its utter lack of imagination as scripted, as well as the rather unconvincing aspects of its lavish production.

It's not the one-star trainwreck you might've been expecting and gets a few points for being so fascinatingly bizarre, but it's certainly a career low-point for just about everyone involved...

Advertisement

Downs...

6. The High Frame-Rate Is Distracting

Paramount Pictures

Ang Lee shot Gemini Man digitally at 120 frames-per-second, just as he did with his previous film Billy Lynn's Long Halftime Walk, in the hope of giving audiences a more immersive and visually engaging experience.

Advertisement

At most locations the film is "only" being presented at 60 fps, but the high frame-rate (HFR) format is sure to prove massively divisive with audiences regardless, because the ultra-smooth image is so far divorced from what people are used to seeing.

Many consider HFR to recreate the "realistic" aesthetic of a soap opera or TV news report, which many viewers find jarring compared to the usual cinematic 24 fps, especially in a movie as outlandish as this.

Advertisement

Ultimately, even though HFR does lend the material much more visual detail, the distraction isn't worth the scattered benefits, especially when it causes some of the CGI-assisted action beats to look unnaturally jerky.

There is a novelty appeal to seeing an A-lister like Will Smith in 60 fps, but after the HFR versions of The Hobbit movies and Billy Lynn both fell flat with audiences, it's surprising that Lee or any movie studio actually agreed to give it yet another whirl.

Advertisement

5. The Hilariously Awful Script

Paramount Pictures

After listening to more than a few lines of dialogue from this film, you won't be surprised to learn that various versions of the script have been around for over 20 years, constantly re-written while Hollywood waited for digital de-aging technology to catch up to its vision.

Advertisement

Yet even with the many, many rewrites, the film for the most part feels like a naff high-concept action-thriller ripped straight from the mid-90s, with its outrageously cornball dialogue, shameless amount of exposition and lame "humour."

Though the cast sure is trying to make it work, it's embarrassing that anyone would greenlight a script so lazy and rough around the edges, in terms of its plot, characters and, worst of all, the spoken word.

Advertisement

Moreover, that Will Smith was swayed by such dreck is all the more baffling - not that he's always proven himself the best judge of a project, mind.

4. Benedict Wong Is Totally Wasted

Paramount Pictures

Benedict Wong plays the main supporting character in the movie, Baron, Henry Brogan's (Smith) former colleague who is drafted in to help bring down Brogan's younger clone.

Advertisement

And though Wong does about as well with the material as can be expected, he's basically relegated to cringe-worthy, corny comic relief for the most part.

Given the dramatic range Wong has demonstrated over his many years as an actor, it's a shame to see him used so cynically here, clearly hoping to coast on his visibility in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Advertisement

Though he gets a decent amount of screen time throughout the film, precious little of it is actually memorable, and the ultimate arc his character takes is...not good.

3. The Dull Action Sequences

Paramount Pictures

You'd think that with the movie's unique presentation, Lee would really want to push the action as far as he possibly could, and yet, the overwhelming majority of the action sequences are totally bland and forgettable.

Advertisement

It doesn't help that most of the coverage is annoyingly tight and claustrophobic rather than letting the 3D HFR format soak in clear, crisp wides, and Lee makes the baffling decision to stage much of the action in dark lighting conditions.

Despite Lee proving with Life of Pi his ability to craft jaw-dropping set-pieces, almost everything here feels totally stock and generic, while lacking the flair fans of Lee's typically expect.

Advertisement

2. The Inconsistent Pacing & Tone

Paramount Pictures

Gemini Man is totally all over the place as a blockbuster, and never more than in terms of its pacing and its tone.

Advertisement

For starters, despite its reasonable 117-minute runtime, this thing takes a long time to get going, with the clone plot not introduced until the end of the first act, and it's almost the half-way point before the whole "CGI Will Smith" angle really comes into play.

If the first half is a slow, dull slog, the second is a frantic rush to the finish line, with neither proving particularly satisfying.

Advertisement

The tone also fleets from absurd self-seriousness to cartoonish ridiculousness on a whim, and audiences likely won't know when they're supposed to laugh and when they've supposed to be actually invested in what's taking place.

Again these are weird mistakes for Lee to be making, but at least in the pacing stakes, he was responsible for 2003's exhaustingly overlong Hulk, so there is a precedent.

Advertisement

1. The Outrageously Bad Ending

Paramount

No spoilers here of course, but the film's ending sure is wild. It is at this point that Gemini Man basically stops trying to pretend it can be taken seriously in any way and just drives itself enthusiastically off a cliff.

Advertisement

The film's final moments deliver up the one-two punch of a ridiculous additional plot twist and a CGI-slathered scene so hideous the only response is to laugh.

In the very least, the end of the movie is probably the most memorable part, if only because of how truly, weirdly bad it is. You'll see, if you bother to watch it that is.

Advertisement

But while Gemini Man certainly isn't a good piece of cinema, it's not without its merits. Here's what worked...

Ups...

4. Will Smith & Mary Elizabeth Winstead's Solid Performances

Paramount Pictures

No matter the film's many issues, it's hard to knock the clear effort Will Smith and Mary Elizabeth Winstead have put into their lead roles.

Advertisement

Smith lends the horribly-written drama about as much gravitas as one could possibly expect, and his CGI-assisted performance as a younger version of himself feels distinctly different from an emotional perspective.

Winstead is meanwhile effortlessly charming as his new pal Danny, enjoying easy chemistry with Smith, and one of the script's few smart decisions is that it doesn't even try to contrive a romantic relationship between the two.

Advertisement

They're clearly trying to prop up the dreck material, and considering some of the woeful dialogue they're forced to spit out, they more-or-less come out with their dignity in tact, which is quite the achievement.

3. There's ONE Decent Set-Piece

Paramount Pictures

Though the majority of the film's action sequences aren't up to much, there is a single set-piece mid-way through the movie that's absolutely worth watching (if probably on Netflix or YouTube in four months' time).

Advertisement

The scene in question is a prolonged shootout and motorcycle chase between the two Henrys, with the scene boasting by far the most kinetic editing and creative shot selections of the entire movie.

It's also the one scene where the use of HRF is somewhat effective: a gorgeous shot of older Henry riding his motorcycle down a narrow alleyway has an additional clarity due to the higher frame rate, and it's a breathtaking moment.

Advertisement

It's a totally ridiculous scene, for sure, with the younger Henry basically using motorcycles as weapons to launch at his older self, but it's the closest the film ever gets to being fully in touch with its own silliness - and exciting to watch at the same time.

2. The 3D Presentation Is Worth Seeing

Paramount Pictures

So much has been said about Gemini Man's HFR style that the fact it's also presented in 3D has largely been ignored. But to Lee's credit, the 3D on offer is actually relatively decent, having been shot natively in the format to ensure the maximum visual fidelity.

Advertisement

Lee doesn't go overboard trying to make objects pop out of the screen, but 3D is used well to discern between different planes of depth and movement.

There are even moments where it combines dizzyingly with the HFR: a late-film shootout sees machine-gun fire whizzing around our heroes, and the 3D HFR combo makes it seem decidedly more frenetic than a conventional 2D film ever could.

Advertisement

Of course, the problem is that all of the movie's 3D screenings are accompanied by HFR, which is so often a distracting counter-weight to the immersive 3D.

All things considered if you're going to see the movie in cinemas at all, you may as well see it in the version Lee intended, peculiar though it is.

Advertisement

1. CGI Will Smith Is Surprisingly Decent...Mostly

Paramount Pictures

Though the trailers didn't do a great job of selling the digital Will Smith, for the most part Lee makes it work relatively well in the final film, sensibly confining the character to low-light and pulling the camera back when he is required to emote.

Advertisement

Given how garish these de-aged characters can look, especially when they're a focal point of the movie, this is a pretty solid effort. The technology still isn't where it needs to be for pure photo-realism, but it vaults over the uncanny valley more often than not.

There is one scene featuring the CGI Smith that Lee misguidedly shoots in broad daylight, however, and the results are both hideous and hilarious. Considering how this element could've easily sunk the film if it wasn't done well, though, Lee mostly gets away with it.

Advertisement

Basically, it's the least of the film's problems.