When The Hobbit became a prequel trilogy everyone waited with bated breath for a Star Wars-esque let down. An Unexpected Journey kicked things off very similar to The Phantom Menace; a plodding start met with general dissatisfaction, but fan love. And, in true Menace fashion, slowly those fans turned against the film, to the point where everyone went into The Desolation Of The Smaug wondering just how bad it was going to be. Now reactions (if not Smaugs temper or the box office) are calming down, people's thoughts are in. And the general consensus is rightly that while this suffers from some of the same issues as before, overall the film is an awful lot of fun; with a more consistent tone and pacing, this is a much more assured bringing of Tolkiens small scale Hobbit into Jacksons epic Middle Earth. But the damage from the first part is done and many scorned fans were quick to condemn the film. Fair play to them for voicing their distaste, but so many of the criticisms seem off. Instead of worthy criticisms (its overly long, has too much filler and has questionable CGI) theres picky looks at poor physics and the indestructible heroes, which never seemed to matter in The Lord Of The Rings trilogy. To me it just looks like people are struggling to get off the hating bandwagon and are trying to grab onto what they can. Im not saying Desolation Of Smaug is perfect, far from it, but its certainly impressed some haters of the first film (like myself), which is a pretty impressive feat. And there's more to enjoy than what's there in a first, quickly paved viewing. Here are eleven things in The Desolation Of Smaug you probably missed. Spoilers for The Desolation Of Smaug, as well as strong theorising on its sequel, There And Back Again, are present throughout.
10. Peter Jacksons Cameos Continue
Peter Jackson loves his cameos, doesnt he? His distinct, almost Hobbit-y look makes him instantly recognisable in his various guises in a way we havent seen with such recurrence since Alfred Hitchcock. A Rohanian spear thrower, arrow targeted pirate and a dragon fleeing dwarf, (and, outside of Middle Earth, a policeman stabbing Santa, King Kong aiming pilot and unsuspecting tramp), his most noticable appearance came in Fellowship, where he plays a carrot chomping resident of Bree. And its that role he reprises in Desolation. The films Bree opening, a welcome tone setter that, unlike later parts feels totally in service of this single film, kicks off with Jackson slumping across screen with the signature carrot. Certainly obvious for those aware of this tradition, to the general audience it comes across as general set up. Its made more self indulgent (or cool, depending on how you feel about this sort of thing) as the scene goes on; Katie Jackson, Peters daughter, who also appeared in the original trilogy as various cute (thats actually how shes credited) children plays The Prancing Ponys barmaid, Betsy Butterbur.
9. No More Misty Mountains Cold
Although the dishwashing song was a bizarre carry over from the book, I have to say I did enjoy the dwarves singing The Misty Mountains. Not only does Richard Armitage have a good voice on him, but hearing it slowly evolve into the dwarves trademark theme gave a nice edge to their actions, especially when the film up to that point had relied on a lot of Rings music. Like any good soundtrack piece a quick tempo change can turn it into something completely different and I was more than happy to let it become a motif of the trilogy. So imagine the disappointment when the song doesn't make even the slightest return in the sequel. There were so many moments when the dwarves were getting into scrapes where it would have been incredibly welcome, but instead there was a cover much less memorable. Other recurring themes from The Lord Of The Rings made their little appearances, which makes this all the more peculiar. The conspiracy theorist in me thinks it could be an attempt to distance the film from the disappointment of An Unexpected Journey, but thatd be incredibly misplaced; Howard Shores theme was one of the saving graces of the film. Maybe it was just something simpler, like the fact wed left the eponymous range behind. Although that doesn't lessen the disappointment.
9. Everyone Was Forced To Miss This Awesome Orc
A fair criticism of The Hobbit is the over reliance on CGI. Effects extravaganzas can work (as Gravity showed), but with these films the technology too far it just looks a little fake (and that's not even touching on the HFR issue), a particular let down after how well traditional and modern methods were so masterfully melded in The Lord Of The Rings. This whole issue has been personified by The Desolation Of Smaug. Bolg, the original antagonist in The Hobbit sat out An Unexpected Journey thanks to his resurrected father Azog taking over dwarf chasing duties. Now, with the Necromancer wanting Azog for some overarching reason, old Bolgy gets to lead the chase. When we finally get to see Jackson's interpretation of the Tolkien character, it's a little bit of a let down; he's just another cool looking, but clearly CGI model. What's worse is that there was an actual, physical Bolg on set. Seen above and played by Conan Stevens (who stupidly left the role of Gregor Clegane in Game Of Thrones for this), it's subsequently been replaced by the film version, probably so the design jars less with Azog. You have to question why they even bothered switched the characters (and, looking Number 6, they almost didn't). The old version of Bolg is still in the trilogy in a small capacity though; there's a split second shot of him during the Moria fight in the first film.
8. The Whole Women Dwarf Joke Gets Deeper
One thing in The Hobbit that is still incredibly overlooked almost six hours in are the individuals of the dwarf company. Aside from Thorin, Kili and Balin none of the others have any rounded character; Bombur is fat, Bofur is Irish etc. Its such a issue that its not until half an hour into Desolation Of Smaug that film-only fans finally learn Gloin is actually Gimlis father. The moments a massive wink to the fans that rivals Jacksons carrot (and much broader), but it also has something that has become an incredibly odd running gag over the past ten years. In my list of easter eggs in the previous film I pointed out how some of the women in Dale had some pretty notable sideburns, hearkening back to that one brief scene in The Two Towers where Gimli goes off on one about how hairy dwarf women are. Well, after Desolation Of Smaug that whole spiel seems to strike closer to home; before the aforementioned father reveal Legolas mistakes Glions wife for a man. Jackson probably thought the joke was funny enough to have a second go around, but suddenly that throwaway scene ten years ago becomes a major touchstone between the two trilogies.
7. Legolas Is Older Than His Father
In last years list I pointed out how the mostly absent Thranduil, set to make a bigger impact this year, was in fact Legolas father. Im torn as to what extent whether that needs repeating because the interaction was so brief and un-fatherly that, beyond their similar hair, newbies to the story would be forgiven (to some degree) for not realising it. Even with elf action taking up a disproportionate amount of the story, there wasnt much time spent on the actual politics of the woodland elves. Of course with the whole treasure grabbing/orc fighting to come in There And Back Again it'll step up next year, with the Tauriel-Kili thing pulling Legolas out of his Daddy's boy rut leading to fans theorising therell be some elvish turncoats in the Battle Of The Five Armies. Now that would make the relationship interesting. In the meantime, well have to make do with that brief glimpse of Thranduils scarred face and this bizarre fact; Lee Pace is a spry thirty four compared to Orlando Bloom at thirty six, meaning Legolas is, in the real world at least, older than his father. Crazy, although I still dont think it justifies the horrible CGI aging.
6. In The Trailer, Not In The Movie
Scenes being in a trailer, but not making it all the way to the final film is surprisingly common, but with The Hobbit its noteworthy because theres that inescapable feeling that whatever scene it is will make its way into the extended directors cut. The first trailer for An Unexpected Journey came before it was decided to turn two stretched movies into three, so naturally some bits of it were only finally seen in The Desolation Of Smaug. But in amongst the woefully premature tease of Gandalfs solo quest there were shots of Bilbo in Rivendell that we didnt get to see until the Extended Edition. The Desolation Of Smaug didnt break from tradition. The one shot of Azog (who's presence is severely toned down in the film) in the trailer didn't make it into the final feature, although its questionable if thisll ever be in any version. Assumingly set during the barrel escape, this scene seems to come from an alternate plan for the story with Azog, instead of Bolg, chasing down the barrel riding dwarves; did the film originally not have suit-cum-CGI orc at all? There's also a few scenes that hadn't quite gone through the CGI wringer when we first saw then, but to avoid dragon my feet, I'll come to them later.
5. The Original Ending
Theres an alternate reality where weve just finished Guillermo Del Toros Hobbit duology. Along with the Beatles Lord Of The Rings (yes, that was almost a thing), its a fascinating failed Middle Earth film, made all the more intriguing because the finished product were now experiencing is questionably close to what might have been. Youd hope Del Toro would have taken a more practical approach (even Pacific Rim had a few puppets thrown in), but the real wish is films with more self justification. And, as revealed by Jackson in a recent interview, the proposed ending of An Unexpected Journey (Part 1 of 2) would have done just that. The credits would have originally rolled just after the barrel sequence, with Bards silhouette, instead of Smaugs eye, leading to a year of speculation. It makes a lot of sense really. All of the meandering adventure vignettes are within the confines of one, fun story, while the dragon and epic Lord Of The Rings scale is bridged in the other. Not to mention theres a sort of cliffhanger that helps build Bard as a big presence, but also feels like a full stop in the story, rather than Desolations sudden open end.
4. The Love Triangle Wasn't In The Film Until Last Year
One of the more contentious additions to The Hobbit has been the burgeoning relationship between dwarf Kili and Elf Tauriel. Not a complete surprise after An Unexpected Journey's Extended Edition had Kili eying up the other species in Rivendell, it's angered some fans who've dismissed it as elaborate fan fiction. What you don't want to happen is for the hate to become directed at Evangeline Lily's Tauriel. While she may not be in the original book, she's a welcome addition in an otherwise completely male world and, most importantly, wasn't always envisioned as a love interest. The whole subplot of the couple (Taurili, Kiliel?) was added to the film a year after principal photography and came about only at the request of the studio; Hollywood still struggles with the concept of women either not in relationships or pining for a man. This shouldn't be too much of a surprise. Both Arwen and Eowyn, who became well defined characters in The Lord Of The Rings films after being brushed over in the books, both ended up in relationships by Return Of The King's end. It's just a shame we had what was assumedly a subplot of Legolas' unrequited affections was axed in place of something more pedestrian.
3. Stephen Colbert (Of All People) Has A Cameo
One thing The Hobbit has inadvertently done is bring a lot of devout Tolkien fans out of the woodwork. Everyone loved The Lord Of The Fans, fan and non-fan alike, but the sheer division of this trilogy has led to many wearing their love of Middle Earth (or at least strong feelings for what is after all a childrens book) as a badge of honour. How else could you defend liking such a visually splendous, but narratively defunct film? Some fans, however, never made any secrets of their affections. Perhaps not incredibly well known outside of American, Stephen Colbert has become an important face in US politics, with his satirical The Colbert Report (in which he plays a right wing version of himself) growing to the point where hes been rumoured as a Presidential candidate. But on top of that, hes also a very open Tolkien nerd. The Colbert Report has plenty of moments where he goes off on one about Middle Earth (the highlights are a two part clash with James Franco), so its a nice payoff that he has a little cameo in The Desolation Of Smaug. Hidden to the extent you need to be on the lookout to have a hope of spotting him, he plays a one-eyed of the spy who forms part of the chain tracking Bard.
2. Is The Arkenstone A Silmaril?
Its an ongoing discussion amongst Tolkien fans that looks set to never get an answer; is the Arkenstone, the gem that gives the right to rule Erebor, actually a Silmaril? If youre thinking you might have missed a moment with that last object, dont worry. The Silmarils are present only in Tolkiens posthumously published Silmarillion, for which Jackson doesnt have the rights to. Three jewels that prove essential to the epic tome, the Silmarils glow with their own light and (there being so few of them) caused an awful lot of conflict in the early Ages of Middle Earth before disappearing from knowledge. The important thing here is the self-produced glow, something that makes the Arkenstone so immediately identifiable on screen, leading to some fans suggesting the prophesied resurgence of the Silmarils came in the form of the Heart of the Mountain. But this is all book work; whats this got to do with the film? Well in The Hobbit Trilogy the Arkenstones powers have been upped, with a suggestion it was actually the stones influence, rather than dwarf greed, that led to Thror's complacancy, which ties into some of the Silmarils more supernatural elements. But, in a move similar to the blue wizards mentioned last year, thats as far as Jackson can go; he cant invoke the actual name because he doesnt have the rights.
1. That, My Lad, Was A (Different) Dragon
One of the most tantalising elements of The Fellowship Of The Ring was the all too brief glimpses of Gollum. Always bathed in shadow, it obviously helped build suspense for his proper introduction in The Two Towers, but also hid the series ongoing production; the look of the character, particularly his heavily Serkis-influenced face, was yet to be finalised and animated. This naturally led to some inconsistencies between the look in Fellowship and the later two films, but no one cared because it was freaking Gollum. After plenty of tail, finger, eye and kite teasing in An Unexpected Journey, people were quick to draw parallels between the treatment of Smaug and Gollum, although given The Hobbits intense production I imagine few thought thered be the same design differences. Yet thats exactly what weve got. Throughout principal production of the trilogy Jackson had no idea how his dragon would look; its size, shape and pretty much everything else were all up for grabs, which is evidenced in the films; the dragon that bursts into Erebor has four legs, which prove particularly useful at swatting dwarves, while the one Bilbo uncovers only has two legs and armed wings. And on a more picky, effects based level, compare Smaugs eye at the end of the first Hobbit to what is in the film and its abundantly clear theres been a step up in quality. Were not elves were bound to have missed something. Do you have any more cool facts and easter eggs about The Desolation Of Smaug? Air them, along with any opinions on the film, down in the comments.