The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug - 5 Elements It Nailed (And 1 That Failed)

Aside from one issue, Peter Jackson's latest is also arguably his finest Middle Earth movie...

By Ryan N. Glenn /

Peter Jackson clearly has a knack for engaging his target audience with an engrossing adventure: first with The Lord Of The Rings trilogy and now with a three-part adaptation of The Hobbit, Peter has become a legend in the fantasy genre and an icon in terms of making direct adaptations of a given source material. While the troubles of making The Lord Of The Rings have passed, it would seem that times have become easier with The Hobbit's production (ignoring initial outrage that the book would be extended into three parts.) Boasting three new films based off a 315+ page book - and Tolkien's extended mythology - Peter Jackson now looks to tell the middle chapter of his new trilogy with The Desolation of Smaug, a direct continuation of An Unexpected Journey and what is perhaps one of the finest movies set in Middle Earth to date. An Unexpected Journey had its problems - mostly thanks to the aesthetics, and the ravages of ageing - but in the end An Unexpected Journey won hearts over thanks to a close attention to detail and its pervading love for Tolkien's grand work. The Desolation Of Smaug looks to accomplish that same goal, playing the part of a sequel while also contending with the criticisms that An Unexpected Journey faced and making them work in the trilogy's second outing. The Desolation Of Smaug is, without question, Jackson's finest trip to Middle Earth after The Return Of The King. Everything that was wrong with An Unexpected Journey has been lifted in the middle chapter, with tighter storytelling, much more variance in action, and a more believable and refined 48FPS "High Frame Rate" thanks to some incredible 3D effects. There are so many things to love about the film, and so few things to hate about it, to the extent that the bloated run-time feels like a breeze It is in fact such an entertaining and delightful film that it took some serious thinking and close scrutiny to detect any problems, which there is one of particular, and even then, the problem is hardly fatal. It should be pointed out that this article gives away crucial plot points and pacing details, so a spoiler alert is in effect. Please proceed with caution.

5. The Improved-Upon 48FPS And Outstanding Use Of 3D

Peter Jackson's decision to apply new filming techniques for An Unexpected Journey was not a bad one when it was first announced - innovation, after all, is to be encouraged. Looking into this "High Frame Rate" technique, which marked the first time of its use in a widescreen format, I was intrigued at how its use would effect the film, especially in a 3D format. Although the final result was worth the price of admission, it left a lot to be desired thanks to the quick edits and the smoke and mirrors effect, where it was so painfully obvious that certain elements were CG and not practical. The Desolation of Smaug plays the same card with smoke and mirrors, but makes up for it with better edits and a tighter pace. And after seeing An Unexpected Journey again in 3D and watching it at 48FPS, it's almost a melding effect where you become used to the fast pace and crystal clear visual quality of both films. It's a truly remarkable effect on the eyes where we see the film played in a fast motion (almost like it's running at 60FPS in a video game), but in actuality it's not affecting the running time nor is it hurting the pace. But it's the 3D effects that deserve the most focus, somewhat inevitably, and it's hard to be disappointed by the end result: filmed in 3D with Red Epic cameras, both films thus far have shown off their excellence in using 3D. This time out, the film does far more with 3D, providing more close up, in-your-face moments that will undoubtedly make some people jump. Nearly every scene utilizes the 3D in an intelligent way, and the later segments of the Dwarves traversing Erebor and Bilbo interacting with Smaug absolutely floors, and are worth the increased ticket price alone.

4. The Increased Amount Of Action

An Unexpected Journey took its time introducing to us the vast amount of characters and setting up its narrative, and of the running time of 169 minutes, more time was spent with dialogue and getting to the action itself. But when the action showed up, boy was it captivating: thanks in part to the 3D the action stood out, and even in a 2D format the action is still a joy. The Desolation Of Smaug plays a different card, increasing the action scenes tenfold and introducing inventive ways to use the 3D at the same time. Each bit of action in this film easily upscales all of the action scenes from An Unexpected Journey, in some cases even in the original three LOTR films. The hotly anticipated barrel sequence is one of the most engaging action scenarios of 2013, bar none: even in 2D I could watch that scene all day long, extended or not. And then of course there are the Mirkwood spider sequence, and the climactic sequence where the pace hits its apex at Erebor when Smaug appears and steals his scenes entirely. Even the criticised decision to bring back Legolas added more action elements, and channelled the higher-octane spirit and pace of the original trilogy. It's al part and parcel of setting up a trilogy: the original trilogy had the same experience, with The Fellowship Of The Ring pursuing a more sophisticated method in introducing characters and pushing action to the back burner, then The Two Towers looked to introduce the beginning stages of the action before The Return Of The King went full-blood with epic action sequences. In this case, An Unexpected Journey was the build-up, The Desolation Of Smaug started the action, and There And Back Again will hopefully reach that same fever pitch as The Return Of The King.

3. Putting Thorin In The Limelight

If there's anything An Unexpected Journey did excellently, it was introducing Richard Armitage's Thorin: in the book he played the part as both forceful leader and spirited member of the Dwarves, with the same happy attitude as the rest but still applying his leadership skills whenever possible. For his film adaptation, Thorin is much more serious and dedicated to his task, forsaking any comedic portrayals and leaning more towards a brooding personality that fits the film's themes perfectly. The Hobbit's sequel puts Thorin and his goals in a higher position on the totem pole. His primary objective (along with the rest of his company) is still to retake Erebor from Smaug while avoiding Azog's hunting parties at the same time, but now he's branching off to other matters that are more economical and political this time around. When his company reach Lake-town, Thorin feels obligated to lend assistance, in the hope of reciprocation. As descendants of Dale (the former town desolated by Smaug), he promises to share Erebor's treasures, helping them get back to the lives they desire and deserve. For a dwarf who seeks to reclaim what was once lost years ago, Thorin throws his greed aside, and shows the first signs of being a true king. However, he still burns for the Arkenstone, Erebor's most important treasure. Near the end, when the Dwarves have reached Erebor, Thorin reveals his desperation of recovering the Arkenstone in the name of his homeland, and after sending Bilbo to recover the magnificent gem and having him retrieve it from Smaug, Thorin shows a flash of anger when asking Bilbo if he has the stone, without concern for the hobbit's well-being. In some senses Thorin's relationship with the Arkenstone is almost identical to Bilbo's relationship with the One Ring, with Bilbo's first signs of his obsession occurring in Mirkwood during his encounter with the spiders. It makes for an interesting additional element to Thorin, and it will be exciting to see how There And Back Again further evolves his character.

2. Smaug

Obviously the biggest selling point for the film is the great Smaug himself. Thanks to the impeccable vocal and motion capture performance by Benedict Cumberbatch, Peter Jackson took an important piece of Tolkien's fiction and made him work on a level that arguably only he could have accomplished. What we get is a complete CG representation of Smaug in all his glory, confronting Bilbo and the Dwarves inside Erebor, grand-standing dialogue between the dragon and Bilbo, and a chase sequence involving the Dwarf company that adds a wonderful climactic note to the movie. The sheer anticipation of seeing him after all the trekking through Middle Earth is met with the reward of one of the coolest, most visually appealing introductions in recent memory. And seeing him in full astonishing 3D is nothing short of amazing. Weta Digital packed all of their experience in designing Smaug; after all the intricacies in the Lord of the Rings trilogy, they've gathered enough knowledge to pay their homage to Tolkien in full, and Smaug is one of their absolute masterpieces. Smaug's just such an impressive piece of visual entertainment and an even more impressive character, supplementing ruminative visions of what is to come while providing his own nonpareil personality in ways that have us, as the audience, root for this potentially threatening and deadly antagonist. While Smaug may appear to be the film's selling point to most, the next element for The Desolation Of Smaug is surely something none of us saw coming within a dragon's lifetime....

1. Ending On A Monumental Cliffhanger

Despite being likely to attract both controversy and praise, the ending to The Desolation Of Smaug is, by all accounts, the most rewarding aspect to the film and perhaps one the greatest decisions Peter Jackson has ever made. What makes this ending so rewarding is how it ends: just as it seems Thorin, Bilbo, and company have dispatched Smaug in a flood of molten gold, the nearly invincible wyrm breaks loose of both his golden prison and Erebor and makes for Esgaroth, living up to his promises towards Bilbo that he looks to make the citizens of Laketown suffer, declaring "I am fire....I am death." As Smaug flies into the distance to unleash hell, Bilbo is seen scurrying to the ruins of the Erebor's entrance, asking to himself, "What have we done?". Cut to credits and a black screen made all the blacker by the shock and awe of the spectacle we just witnessed. What better way to end a middle chapter than at that point? Peter Jackson and his production crew have usually run into trouble finding a stopping point for each film, even back when production on the Lord Of The Rings began. How do they divide three whole books into three whole films? How do you split key events up? Such is the case with The Hobbit, but with only one book that is barely over 315 pages being divided into three more films, the task of creating a gripping narrative that is both fresh and familiar was even more daunting, but both films so far have ended in exactly the right place. In this case, the ending gives Smaug more screen time in the third film, even if it is limited to the opening sequence. It also leaves us pondering a number of issues: what of Gandalf being trapped at Dol Guldur and the Orc armies heading for the Lonely Mountain? What of Legolas chasing after Bolg? What of Kili and Tauriel, even if it is a bit of a forced romance? Does Bilbo really possess the Arkenstone? There are so many plot points left unanswered, but that is exactly as it should be to build excitement for the final film. And now on to the one major issue that ruined The Desolation Of Smaug's perfect score...

The Major Problem: The Addition Of An Unneeded Romance

Quite possibly one of Peter Jackson's most awkward decisions in filmmaking, and maybe even Philippa Boyens as some blame in this, was developing a romantic relationship between Kili and Tauriel. Let it be known that Tauriel is an original creation for The Desolation Of Smaug and its sequel coming out next December, since she never appeared in the book, nor the Appendices, which of course means that this relationship never happened, and Kili never had an emotional bearing in the book. So the scriptwriters decided it would be a great idea to develop Kili a little more by not only creating a new character who bears some resemblance to Liv Tyler's Arwen, but having them develop a relationship over the course of the film. Now I love Kili and find him to be one of the more entertaining dwarves of the bunch, and I understand Tauriel as a character in the scheme of things, but what I don't understand is their relationship. Is it really even needed? Not really, it just feels like an excuse to carry over the romanticism between Aragorn and Arwen into a book that never really had that connection in the first place. And although the running time is vindicated this time around, the whole scenario between Kili and Tauriel could have been replaced with more action or interactions between Bilbo and Smaug, maybe even more time for Gandalf and Radagast. How do you guys feel? Do you agree with any of the mentioned aspects of The Desolation Of Smaug? Are there any other elements that you found particularly annoying or unwanted? Your comments are always appreciated and opinions welcome.