How Odin Lost His Eye

Because knowledge comes at a cost.

By Andrew Pollard /

Whereas so many comic book characters were created completely from the minds of a Stan Lee, a Jack Kirby, a Chris Claremont, a Frank Miller, or a Neil Gaiman, certain heroes and villains have their origins very much rooted in established lore.

Advertisement

Whether that lore is real life or fiction, many a character has pulled inspiration from elsewhere. And in the realms of comic books, few characters have been as influenced by existing material as Thor and his supporting players. The Thunder God is a famed figure of Norse mythology, and so too are a large portion of the people who help make up his world of Asgard and beyond.

One prime example of a character laced in Norse tradition is that of Thor's father, Odin.

Odin is a legendary warrior king who has played a pivotal part in the history of Thor across a variety of mediums, and one of the key traits of Odin is the unmissable fact that this ruler has only one eye. Just how he lost his right eye, that's a question to which the answer has certain caveats to it.

With that in mind, here is the real story behind Odin and his missing eye...

7. In Norse Mythology

Like so many characters associated with the comic book world of Thor, Odin of course is a character whose roots and origins are based around Norse mythology.

Advertisement

In said mythology, Odin was a wise, battle-hardened warrior and god who was forever on a quest for knowledge and understanding. As part of his ongoing quest to better himself, he at one point ended up at Mimir's Well at the base of the world tree Yggdrasil.

There, Odin's quest was to take a drink from this well. You see, the water in this well had given Mimir the sort cosmic of wisdom that had made him one of the most knowledgeable beings in existence.

To earn a swig of this most sought-after H2O, Mimir needed Odin to make his own personal sacrifice. And in case you hadn't guessed where this was going by now, that sacrifice was one of Odin's eyes.

Ultimately making the decision that an eye wasn't as valuable to him as the knowledge offered up by Mimir's Well, Odin went and gouged out one of his peepers. A man of his word, Mimir swiftly gave Odin a horn full of water in return.

This was just one of many ways in which the Odin of Norse mythology pushed himself to gain understanding of the world around him, with other examples being a nine-day fast from all food and drink, and the eerie idea to be hanged.

6. The American God

While the version of Odin which instantly comes to mind for many will be either the Marvel Comics character or his Marvel Cinematic Universe incarnation, Neil Gaiman's American Gods also put its own spin on Odin.

Advertisement

Gaiman has previous with Odin, mind, for he introduced the character into his legendary Sandman title. In Sandman, Odin was largely similar to the incarnation seen in Norse mythology, bar for a slightly more mischievous side that saw him sharing a similar mindset to Loki at times.

In Gaiman's American Gods, however, he provided a version of Odin who was a little changed up from that Norse god. That version would be the Mr. Wednesday character, who has subsequently been portrayed by Ian McShane in Amazon's adaptation of American Gods. Where as the Sandman Odin had a mildly questionable edge, Mr. Wednesday was a full-on conman desperate to pit other all-mighty beings against one another.

The word Wednesday is "onsdag" in Swedish, with Old Norse language having "onsdag" as loosely translated to Odin's Day. In American Gods, it's never specified just how Mr. Wednesday has lost his eye, but we do know that he has replaced that lost eye with a glass replacement that's a slightly different shade to his other eye.

5. The Journey Of The MCU's Odin

The Marvel Cinematic Universe's spin on Odin was famously played by Sir Anthony Hopkins, with Hopkins' King of Asgard appearing in three MCU offerings that ultimately culminated in his death in 2017's Thor: Ragnarok.

Advertisement

A strong but fair king, this depiction of Odin had him as the long-time ruler of Asgard. A warrior who was trying his best to prepare his throne for his natural successor, Hopkins' Odin was a man who put ruthlessness above sentiment - as shown by his treatment of Chris Hemsworth's Thor in that first film.

Remember, the whole reason why the God of Thunder ended up on Earth in the first place is due to being banished by Odin for his arrogance. After Thor had soured the truce and peace between Asgardians and the Frost Giants, his father decided that the only suitable punishment for this behaviour was to banish Thor to Earth to prove that he truly was worthy to replace Odin as the leader of Asgard.

As Odin himself put it in that original 2011 movie, "I have sacrificed much to achieve peace. So, too, must a new generation sacrifice to maintain that peace."

Speaking of sacrifice and Frost Giants, that nicely dovetails into...

4. The Fight That Cost Odin His Eye

Opting to step away from some of the more traditional elements of Norse mythology, the MCU's interpretation of Odin sought to give a different reason for Odin only having one eye.

Advertisement

Rather than the long-established Norse rationale of Odin sacrificing his eye at Mirmir's Well in exchange for 'true wisdom', the 2011 Thor movie revealed Odin's backstory during its first act.

There, audiences saw how this version of Odin had lost his right eye in battle. That particular battle took place in Tønsberg, Norway back in 965 AD, and was part of Asgard's ongoing war against Laufey and the Frost Giants of Jotunheim - with King Odin standing up to stop Laufey from capturing the Nine Realms.

Odin and his Asgardian army would obviously win that battle and the larger war, but Odin lost his right eye in the process. In addition to that loss though, Odin actually gained a son during that battle. That son being Laufey's offspring Loki, who had been left alone to perish.

While the MCU Odin - like the majority of other versions of Odin - was left with just one eye, another iteration of Odin so nearly lost both of his eyes...

3. The God Of War

The God of War video game series is nothing short of stunning. And while Kratos is so often the focal point and draw-in point of the franchise for gamers, one other fun element of the 2018 God of War release is the presence of Odin.

Advertisement

Despite being mentioned and seen in picture form, Odin never actually turns up in the game - yet his story is one that still manages to be told.

With the traditional look associated with Odin - complete with a missing eye - the God of War spin on the character so nearly lost both of his eyes.

As the story goes with this version of the character, it was actually Mimir who came to Odin this time out. Bringing his Mystic Well of Knowledge along with him, Mimir encourages Odin to feast on the well's contents. In this instance, the well is laced with a ludicrous number of magic mushrooms.

Even though he may be a god, that didn't stop Odin trippin' out in a major way. And by major way, that means that the visions he saw gave him the urge to pull out both of his eyes. Mimir actually stepped in to stop Odin after he'd yanked out one eye, but this was all part of a plan from Mimir to have Odin be under his control.

By the time all was said and done though, Odin would eventually turn the tables - removing one of Mimir's eyes and torturing him.

2. The Comic Book Odin

While the God of Thunder, Thor, was introduced to the comic book world in Journey into Mystery #86, Odin would join his son just six months later in November 1962's Journey into Mystery #86.

Advertisement

The son of one of the very first Asgardians - that being Bor - Odin became the ruler of Asgard not long after he and his two brothers defeated the fire demon Surtur. Those brothers would be lost during that fight, with Odin taking on his siblings' powers at that time.

Skipping ahead, there was the classic love story of all-powerful warrior meets all-powerful goddess, has a child, then brings that son to Asgard to be raised by his actual wife. Yes, Frigga is not the birth mother of Thor. Instead, Odin went off to make a baby with the goddess Gaea. Then again, the various comic book iterations of Odin have long established him as a womaniser who admits that he has more children than he can remember.

Anyway, back to that pesky eye.

In the standard canon of Marvel Comics, Odin's eye loss did again occur courtesy of his truth for knowledge. Just this time out, there was a twist.

1. The True Cost Of Knowledge

Despite his womanising ways and carefree approach to fathering children left, right, and centre, Odin was never anything less than a true warrior and protector of Asgard.

Advertisement

Throughout the years, the Allfather stepped up to the plate to bat away threats from the likes of Surtur, the Absorbing Man, the Celestials, and of course Loki. But it was the threat of the world-ending Ragnarok that saw Odin lose one of his peepers in the world of Marvel Comics.

Yet again, the loss of this eye involved Mimir, and yet again the loss was as part of Odin's quest for knowledge. This time out though, Odin was seeking the wisdom to stop Ragnarok from happening. As always seems to be the case with Mimir, the cost for this information and insight was one of Odin's eyes. And in a bizarre twist, that removed eye would become a sentient being all of its own - complete with all of the memories held by Odin.

Even after this though, there was a spell where Odin was often drawn on the page as having two eyes.

While Odin was successful in being able to halt Ragnarok, that cataclysmic world-ending occurrence was only delayed. To the point where years later it took Odin's son, Thor,, sacrificing both of his eyes to the Well of Mimir in order to obtain the knowledge to put a permanent halt to the threat of Ragnarok.

Advertisement