How Warner Bros Can Fix The DC Extended Universe

Take a page out of Marvel's book. For your sake.

By Danny Meegan /

The troubled history of the (unofficially-titled) DC Extended Universe is one of the most fascinating entertainment stories of the past few years.

Advertisement

After a promising start with 2013's Man Of Steel, thinks quickly went downhill with the critically maligned duo of Batman V Superman and Suicide Squad, and while Wonder Woman was able to restore some credibility to the DCEU, the messy Justice League only reaffirmed its position as one of the lesser superhero cinematic universes.

On the plus side, now that Justice League has been and gone - and the first "phase" of the DCEU has come to a close - Warner Bros has an opportunity to evaluate the current state of its comic-book movie output, planning a course-correction for the DCEU to last over the next couple of years.

The studio is in a precarious position - having not exactly earned the trust of moviegoers and critics - but with a bit of patience and some careful planning, there's no reason the DCEU can't one day compete with the far-more successful Marvel Cinematic Universe.

But there's a lot of work to be done before that day becomes a reality.

7. Adopt Marvel Studios' Hierarchy Model

Now, to be absolutely fair to Warner Bros, they've already started making some promising behind-the-scenes changes in the wake of Justice League's disastrous box-office takings.

Advertisement

A few days into 2018, the studio hired Walter Hamada - the man who helped oversee the successful Conjuring cinematic universe - to replace Jon Berg as head of DC film production, and just recently, DC Entertainment's Geoff Johns stepped down from his executive role and moved to a more hands-on, creative position.

Both these moves have ensured that some of the people responsible for the DCEU's mess, like Berg and Johns, have less power, with Hamada being the one who will decide how DC Films operates going forward.

Of course, Hamada will still have to answer to the higher-ups at Warner Bros, but hopefully, they allow him as much creative freedom as Disney's execs offer Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige.

2016 Getty Images

Disney trusts Feige greatly and they basically let him do whatever he likes, and the results speak for themselves; his guiding hand has brought the MCU an unprecedented level of success.

Why? Because there aren't a dozen different men in suits reaching into his movies and changing them as they see fit. This is currently the DCEU's biggest issue.

Only time will tell if Hamada is as talented as Feige, but allowing him to map out the future of the DCEU - with little interference - can only make it feel more cohesive than it currently does. Plus, with Hamada's filmography including the excellent Conjuring cinematic universe, he's already proven he has a knack for, or at least an understanding of, universe-building.

Inevitably, fans would accuse DC of "copying" their rival, but as long as the movies are awesome... who cares?

6. Allow Filmmakers Creative Freedom (But Don't Forget To Guide Them)

With most DCEU movies, Warner Bros has failed to strike the perfect balance between studio interference and a director's vision, consistently leaning too heavily in one direction or the other.

Advertisement

Emboldened by the success of Christoper Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy (but weirdly, not phased by the failure of Green Lantern), the studio just let Zack Snyder and his writers do whatever the hell they wanted with Man Of Steel and BvS, and while the former movie worked out well enough, the latter was a colossal disaster that was poorly received by critics and most fans, as well as disappointing at the box-office.

RottenTomatoes

This stumble scared the studio - and rightly so - but rather than keeping their heads and being a bit more careful with their upcoming projects, they lost the plot, editing Suicide Squad into an unrecognisable mess and absolutely butchering Justice League (Warner Bros CEO Kevin Tsujihara famously demanded the film be under two hours, when the full, scripted story was almost certainly much longer than that).

Only Wonder Woman seems to have found the perfect recipe for Warner Bros, and with as bad as their track record is, they need to switch things up.

What they should be doing is allowing Hamada to map out his slate and develop an over-arching plan that links each movie together, in a big way or a small way. With this framework in place, he can bring in exciting filmmakers and allow them to make the movies they want to make, guiding them in the right direction but ultimately leaving them to their own devices.

Get ready for another Marvel comparison, but this is exactly how the MCU does it. Feige knows where he wants to be in a few years time, and as long as his filmmakers steer towards that goal, they can do as they please. This has brought us gems like Black Panther and Guardians Of The Galaxy, movies that are very clearly products of smart directors who had the freedom to express themselves.

When it all comes down to it, the DCEU just needs great movies, and this model has proven to be an effective one for tentpole filmmaking.

5. Stop Announcing Release Dates So Early...

In October 2014, DC Entertainment officially announced a slate of ten movies, starting with BvS in 2016 and concluding with Green Lantern in 2020.

Advertisement

The first four of these have been released, but looking at the rest of them, it's abundantly clear that these movies were announced before the studio had any real confidence that they'd actually be made.

2018 was supposed to bring us a Flash standalone movie, 2019 a sequel to Justice League, and 2020 Cyborg and Green Lantern spinoffs - none of which will happen.

DCComics.com

It's not a bad thing to announce dates ahead of time - the blockbuster scene is very competitive, and staking out a piece of land for your movie is essential - but it becomes bad when these dates are only announced to please shareholders, and the actual movies quickly fade into development hell.

The Flash has been in development for so long (and its director has changed so often) that it's hard to get excited for it anymore, while the apparent cancellation of Justice League 2 and the inevitable lack of a Cyborg movie only shows that Warner Bros has as little confidence in the DCEU as moviegoers do. Green Lantern may still make its date, but even that's a long shot.

It's just embarrassing, and makes Warner Bros and the DCEU look amateurish. The studio needs to start locking in dates either when they've made sufficient behind-the-scenes progress on a project (e.g. hiring a director and having a script) or when they have a surefire, stick-to-your-guns plan for their next phase of movies.

And they should never, never announce release dates six years in advance. Too much can go wrong in that time.

Fortunately, Hamada has already started being more careful with release date announcements, and this needs to continue. Don't promise something there's a chance you might not deliver.

4. ...And Stop "Developing" SO Many Projects

Does anybody know for sure how many solo Joker movies are in development? Four? Five? How many of those will actually be connected to the other DCEU movies? Why are similar movies like Birds Of Prey and Gotham City Sirens both being discussed at once? What about that proposed Harley/Joker movie?

Advertisement

Piggybacking off our last point, Warner Bros is also notorious for putting a ridiculous amount of comic-book projects into development, most of which - if we're being realistic - will never actually get made.

Earlier this year, we ran through all 21(!) DC movies that Warner Bros were reportedly working on at the time, and since then, that number has only grown. Why tease fans with stuff that'll never happen? Why make promises that you can't keep? Why confuse moviegoers and pundits with so much information and so many movies that are impossible to keep track of?

revengeofthefans.com/Mario-Francisco Robles

For us fans, it's frustrating and downright annoying, and again, it makes Warner Bros look like amateurs. Do they actually know what they're doing? Or are they randomly chucking a bunch of characters at the wall and seeing what sticks? It feels like the latter.

So, Warner Bros: please make yourselves seem stronger, more careful, and smarter. Only put projects into development that you're fully sure of and committed to making, ones that fit within your plan for the DCEU's future. If you seem confident, we can have some confidence in you in return.

Of course, it's okay to tweak these projects as you go - altering the script, swapping characters in and out of movies, that sort of thing - but when half of those 21 in-development movies aren't even going to make it past the scripting phase, what's the point in getting fans' hopes up for no reason?

3. Keep The Good, And Slowly Phase Out The Bad

There's been a lot of talk around the possibility of Warner Bros cancelling the current iteration of the DCEU and starting afresh with a brand new one. However, that doesn't seem right, and it doesn't seem like the studio will do that anyway.

Advertisement

For one, they're not going to just abandon Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman, considering she's their only beacon of hope right now. Plus, outright cancelling the DCEU would only make them look cowardly, and make no mistake, studio executives do not like to admit when they're wrong.

Also... there's just too much good within the DCEU to completely dismiss it. Sure, it hasn't been success story after success story, but there are glimmers of light within all that darkness. There are still plenty of redeemable qualities Warner Bros can cling to.

Going forward, it's important that they understand what currently works, and what doesn't. Think of Aquaman and the upcoming slate of movies as a soft reboot, of sorts, one where all the terrible crap has been axed and the positive stuff remains.

Jesse Eisenberg's Lex Luthor, Steppenwolf, the Parademons, and the whole Knightmare/Darkseid angle can all be forgotten about and ignored, and stuff like the bloated, muddled scripts, movies that lack their own flavour and identity, and abysmal editing all need to be fixed.

Warner Bros.

On the other hand, Wonder Woman should be and will be a prominent figure going forward. DC movies typically have memorable music, so this shouldn't change. Henry Cavill is finally playing the Superman many of us wanted, so keep him around too. Dwayne Johnson is also onboard as Black Adam, and that definitely can't hurt.

The point is, the DCEU isn't rotten to the core, and there's no point in throwing it all out when there's still plenty worth exploiting.

2. Further Utilise DC Comics' Lesser-Known Characters

On the surface, BvS seemed like a guaranteed one billion dollar hit, but surprisingly, it fell over $100 million short. This proved that audiences won't flock to a poor movie just because it's got some famous characters slapped across the poster, and in fact, since the DCEU's inception, its "biggest" characters - Bats and Supes - haven't clicked with the masses in the same way that previous iterations of the characters have.

Advertisement

DC Comics boasts a gigantic roster of intriguing characters, spanning almost 100 years of entertainment. With the DCEU's big hitters underperforming - and Marvel proving that even lesser-known characters can work on the big screen - why not dive into that well?

Bringing more obscure characters into the DCEU would have several benefits. For one, it would give audiences something different and fresh, and that curiosity factor could drive more interest. Crazier and more unique characters also afford filmmakers the opportunity to make their movies more distinctive, a big improvement over the DCEU's generally soulless fare.

Remember, Marvel built the MCU on the back of B and C-list characters. In 2008, nobody cared about Iron Man or Thor, and now they're the biggest heroes in the world. In contrast, the DCEU will be nearly six years old before we get its first truly "risky" movie with Aquaman later this year. That's insane, especially considering the MCU was doing that from day one.

These movies have to be good, mind you - there's no use just being different, as Suicide Squad proved - because the DCEU really needs a Black Panther, an Ant-Man or a Guardians to cement itself as an exciting franchise. Hopefully, Aquaman, Shazam, or New Gods can deliver on that front.

1. Control The Narrative, And Don't Let Rumours Do The Talking

As previously mentioned, Warner Bros and DC have so many projects in various stages of development that it's stupidly hard to keep track of them all. DC Films is a tornado of rumours, what-ifs, delays, behind-the-scenes shake-ups and broken promises, and it should not be as confusing as it is.

Advertisement

Let's run through just a handful of the current question marks surrounding the DCEU: Ben Affleck's status as Batman, and whether or not he'll be recast; which damn Joker movie will get made, and which connects to the DCEU; what's going on with the Flash movie; why Suicide Squad 2 keeps getting pushed back; when we'll see The Rock as Black Adam, considering his casting was announced in 2014; where the hell Man Of Steel 2 is; what the DCEU is building up to, like the MCU built to Infinity War; and what happened to Justice League Dark?

Warner Bros apparently don't have a firm grasp on any of their projects, or the news surrounding them, and it's damn frustrating.

So why don't they clear up the confusion, and tell us what's going on with all of their movies? Release monthly news bulletins, or build a dedicated DC Films news website. Hold regular fan and press events to tease upcoming projects. If Ben Affleck is being wishy-washy about his Batman future, grow some balls and fire him, hire an actor who actually has passion for the part, and proudly announce it to the world.

The short version: get people excited, instead of leaving them in the dark and making them annoyed.

Warner Bros isn't adequately controlling the flow of information released to the public, which makes it hard to gauge what's true, and what's not. It would help the DCEU's perception greatly if the fans and the filmmakers were all on the same page.

Advertisement