Iron Man 4: 10 Things That Must Happen

Wedding bells, new suits, and a demon in a bottle, namely...

By Tom Baker /

Last week we got the news we'd all been dreading: Iron Man 4 is not happening. At least, not according to Robert Downey Jr, who you could probably count as a credible source. When asked about a possible further entry in the incredibly successful superhero franchise, RDJ rather bluntly replied "there isn't one in the pipe. No, there€™s no plan for a fourth Iron Man." Well, that's it. The dream is over. The man who made Marvel Studios what it is doesn't have much interest in carrying on his own series (he is still signed on for the next couple of Avengers movies). For the time being, anyway. That might be the current party line - and it's unlikely, what with non-disclosure agreements up the woo-wah, Downey Jr was speaking out of turn - but, well, money talks. Iron Man 3 made a record-breaking $1.2 billion, which is obviously the sort of success that Marvel would want to replicate. $1.2 billion is a lot of money. If we had a sure-fire way of making that much money, we'd definitely do it. And we've not seen a safer bet than a forth Iron Man film, especially considering the surprising quality of the last film. As blunt and definitive as the horse's mouth was, there's still a chance that Iron Man 4 could happen in the future. In which case, we have a least of demands. Or expectations. That sounds a little less like we're holding Marvel to ransom. The first three films set the template for the modern superhero movie, and have been the high water mark for that genre so far. To keep up that level of quality, to please the hardcore fans and casual audience alike, these are ten things that must happen in a hypothetical Iron Man 4.

10. References To Extremis

Iron Man was the Patient Zero of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The nascent film studio's first inklings of a huge, interlocking bunch of franchises came in the big screen adventures of Tony Stark, which did something that Hollywood blockbuster series rarely do: actually established some in-universe continuity. So in Iron Man 2, references to the events in the previous film weren't just winks and nods to audience members who'd actually bothered to watch it; instead, you had the sense these characters were actual people with actual histories and everything they did mattered. So Iron Man 2 further developed Tony and Pepper's relationship and the government's relationship with a rich dude having a fly war suit, and Iron Man 3 dealt with the PTSD-like fallout of the character's involvement in Avengers. Which means that, considering Extremis was such a big deal in that third film, to have it completely absent from the fourth would not only be annoying, but also not in keeping with the rest of the series. And consistency is what Marvel Studios is all about. The technological virus has cropped up in the comics a few times since its debut - sometimes as the focus of storylines, sometimes just incidental - and we'd be disappointed if Iron Man 4 didn't follow suit.

9. Pepper And Tony Get Married

So far each of the Iron Man films has climaxed with some sort of big personal or professional development for Tony Stark. The first movie ended with him admitting he was Iron Man; the second with Pepper resigning as CEO of Stark Industries; the third with all the Iron Man suits being destroyed as a sign of Tony's devotion to Pepper, along with the long-awaited removal of shrapnel from his heart. Again, if they're going to carry on the series in the same fashion, then Iron Man 4's going to need a similar moment of emotional catharsis and real growth, another aspect of the franchise which sets it apart from other, lesser blockbusters where stasis in the name of the game. Honestly, unless they're going to keep repeating themselves, the only place we can see them going after the first three is by closing out Iron Man 4 with the wedding between Pepper and Tony. Or, if they'd like to continue playing with expectations, they might do something completely different: if Shane Black's on board again especially, we can see Marvel throwing us all a curve ball by substituting the schmaltzy wedding finales of Temple Of The Crystal Skull et al by opening the film with the pair returning from the church, or their honeymoon, or something. Considering the messy personal life of Tony Stark is part of what makes the character so compelling, having him deal with the added challenge of marriage would be pretty fun.

8. Expanding The World

Obviously we loved Captain America: The Winter Soldier - because everybody in their right mind/with a penchant for eyeliner and longing looks adored The Winter Soldier - but one of the more difficult parts to get our heads around was all the fault of Marvel's genius world-building. Thanks to those interlocking bunch of franchises which culminated in all the superheroes teaming up for Avengers, we had to ask: where were the rest of those superheroes when Cap was being hunted by SHIELD/HYDRA? There was one offhanded remark about Tony Stark and Stephen Strange, and the appearance of Black Widow and Nick Fury helped place the film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but otherwise? Nada. It was a problem Thor: The Dark World had, too (well, that film had a lot of problems, but this isn't the time nor place). Iron Man 3 made allowances for the MCU with the Avengers PTSD and the cute post-credits scene with Tony and Bruce Banner - who isn't that kind of doctor - but we'd like to see the expanding Marvel universe given a little more deference than just a couple of lines and veiled references for fanboys to pick up on. Not necessarily a full-blown crossover, but something like you'd get in the comics: characters being consulted on their specialities, swinging by in the background etc. Especially considering by the time Iron Man 4 gets made (if it gets made) we'll have had the Netflix Defenders series, and it's possible Doctor Strange and Ant-Man will be out by then too.

7. Fallout From Avengers: Age Of Ultron

We'd be very surprised if the plot of Ant-Man €“ which involves another genius billionaire inventor who exists in the Marvel Cinematic Universe €“ doesn't get referred to by or otherwise involve Tony Stark in some way. We'd also be surprised if the second Avengers film, Age Of Ultron, doesn't in some way play into a possible Iron Man 4. In the comic books the original Ant-Man, Hank Pym, is responsible for the titular tyrannical robot the superheroes have to team up to defeat (he wasn't meant to be evil, it was an accident, honest!). In one of the biggest divergences from the source material to date, the big screen adaptation of the Ultron story will have Tony Stark responsible. Woops. Nice one, Iron Man. It makes thematic sense for the self-destructive Stark to, well, be responsible for the possible literal destruction of himself and his Avenging team mates. Rumour has it the hyper-intelligent android will come about as a potential replacement for Iron Man, what with Tony apparently hanging up the shellhead at the end of the third film; so, when we get around to an Iron Man 4, we imagine that Ultron will be the reason for him returning to active superhero duty. We also imagine a greater fallout than from the first Avengers, since the enemy they face this time will be all Tony Stark's fault €“ he'll be distrusted by not only the public but also his friends. That's gonna be, like, double PTSD or something.

6. Vision

Speaking of Age Of Ultron and speculation on such, the Vision totally has to be in Iron Man 4? The android member of the Avengers is to be placed by English actor Paul Bettany, who actually already has a role in the MCU: he's been the voice of Tony Stark's personal Artificial Intelligence computer program, JARVIS (short for Just a Rather Very Intelligent System). So far Bettany's appearances as JARVIS have been a fun Easter egg for eagle-eared movie fans, but with Age Of Ultron he'll be upgraded to an actual star, a full-fledge member of the Avengers. Presumably, anyway. We suppose there's a chance he'll just be the team's long-suffering butler, which is what the all-too-human Jarvis of the comic books got up to. More likely, however, is he'll be the same Vision of the comics: an android created by Ultron to infiltrate the Avengers and destroy them from the inside. Which doesn't actually pan out, since this new robot turns out quite nice, and eventually winds up marrying the Scarlet Witch. Just as Ultron will be casting a shadow over Iron Man 4 so should the Vision, since he's the creation of Tony Stark's creation. We'd even like if there was a new spin on the buddy cop dynamic between Tony and his pal James Rhodes, with the Vision throwing a spanner in the works as Tony Stark's new sidekick, who doesn't question his methods or criticise him quite so often. We like rooting for the underdog, too, so we're just hopeful Bettany which actually get to appear on-screen in an Iron Man film at some point.

5. A Bigger Role For Rhodey

We kid, but it would actually suck if James Rhodes got shunted to the sidelines in Iron Man 4. It's the sort of thing that a Hollywood studio would do, but Marvel still have a chance to prove our instincts wrong. Over the course of the first three films Rhodey went from...well, he went from Terrence Howard to Don Cheadle for a start - not a believable evolution, but a welcome one - and his character developed from stuffy Army veteran and Stark's BFF to a guy borrowing one of his suits to War Machine (latterly Iron Patriot), the official superhero of the US military. He's a fun counterpoint to the wild, abrasive Stark and, considering he was hijacked by the bad guys in Iron Man 3, we'd like Rhodey to transcend his status as a plot-point and become a major player himself. Of course, Iron Man 4 might not happen if Robert Downey Jr is to be believed. At least, not an Iron Man 4 starring him. There have been times that Tony Stark has ducked out of the Iron Man role himself in the past, but the comic books didn't stop €“ he just subbed in James Rhodes to take his place in the meantime. Which means that, if RDJ really does turn down another Iron Man film proper, there's always the option of upgrading Don Cheadle to leading man status and having the former War Machine headline a movie. Which isn't unprecedented in cinema history (see: the Bourne film starring someone other than Jason Bourne, every Bond movie), and we love Rhodey, and we love Cheadle, and seriously, how good would a War Machine film be?

4. Less (Or More?) Suits

Chances are that won't happen, however. Marvel Studios aren't as risk-averse as a lot of their fellow Hollywood giants - as evidenced by their readiness to make weird, obscure titles like Guardians Of The Galaxy into movies - but they'll still wanna try their best to cling onto Robert Downey Jr. He's not only a huge star, but also somewhat totemic for Marvel, since he was the star of their first proper hit as an independent studio. Well, relatively independent. But definitely not a relative hit, since the first film made a cool $600 million, and box office receipts have only gone up with each instalment. So, chances are, if and when an Iron Man 4 happens, it'll star Robert Downey Jr. It pretty much has to at this point. But what will he be wearing...? We see it going either one of two ways. The standard for Iron Man movies so far has been introducing an upgrade to the titular armour with each film - or possibly multiple upgrades in each film - culminating in Tony summoning a whole army of different Iron Man suits to help him defeat Aldrich Killian at the end of the third movie. They were fun, weren't they? Except they all got blown up. So we see Iron Man 4 continuing in that tradition, with Tony boasting a special armour for any conceivable scenario (also good for merchandising opportunities), or else paring things down a little with a single suit of armour. Perhaps even the modern innovation of the armour which forms itself around Stark on a molecular level, rather than a traditional robotic "suit" he puts on. That would be rad.

3. An Interesting Villain

Iron Man wasn't the most popular or well-known character for Marvel to launch their independent productions with, but he did have one thing that set him apart from all other superheroes: he's a genuinely interesting, well-developed character. He isn't perfect. He has foibles. He was vices. He's ultimately heroic, but his motivations are sometimes muddy. That's more we can say for Thor. It's also more than we can say for any of the villains that Tony Stark has been put up against thus far, each of whom has been some variation on the Evil Corporate Suited guy who takes the phrase "hostile takeover" entirely too literally. With hilarious results! By which we mean, violent results with lots of explosions. The sub-villains tend to be a lot more fun - Mickey Rourke's characteristically eccentric Whiplash, for example, and we're still reeling from the bait-and-switch of Ben Kingsley's Mandarin in Iron Man 3 - but the principal antagonist? So boring, so predictable, so like everything we've seen before in every other blockbuster. They're rich dudes who want to take over the world because they're rich dudes, and rich dudes tend to be pretty greedy. They also have the resources to try and take over the world, as a result of the rich dudeness, so it makes sense you'd pitch them against a superhero who uses his rich dudeness for good instead. But it's been played out. Bring us something a little more interesting, something different, and possibly a totally new creation for Iron Man to do battle with for his fourth big screen outing (since, to be fair, most of the classic bad guys he fights in the comics are either rich dudes or, well, the Mandarin proper).

2. The Return Of Shane Black

Iron Man 3 was far better than the third film in a bloated, multi-million dollar franchise had any right being. Instead of settling into a tired formula, trotting out familiar characters and situations to appease fans who liked it the first two times around, it did something new with the series. It was also hilarious, immensely charming, and thoroughly idiosyncratic (we defy you to think of a weirder opening to a Hollywood blockbuster than Blue by Eiffel 65). The already unique tone of the series had been set by Jon Favreau in the first two instalments, but he departed to direct the ill-fated Cowboys And Aliens. In his stead was Shane Black, the genius scriptwriter of every great buddy cop film from Lethal Weapon to Last Action Hero. And the guy who tells the joke in Predator. His trademark sense of humour and penchant for the self-referential was a perfect fit for Iron Man - and Robert Downey Jr in particular, with whom he collaborated on his directorial debut, Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang. Black made his mark in Hollywood by refusing to work within the system's restraints, something which (ironically) greatly appealed to the big studios, who paid top dollar for his scripts and made them into huge-budget behemoths. It worked with Iron Man 3, too, which includes amazingly subversive things like the Mandarin reveal and Tony Stark being openly dismissive of an orphaned child who, in lesser films, would be a naïve innocent that reminds the hero why he's a hero. It's this sort of genuine innovation, invention, and sharp humour that Iron Man 4 needs to beat the odds and be far better than the fourth film in a bloated, multi-million dollar franchise has any right being. Plus, having Black on board will probably help coax back RDJ...

1. Demon In A Bottle

Black had actually been involved with the Iron Man series since the second film, advising Robert Downey Jr and Jon Favreau on the particulars of the second film's script; specifically, its handling of Tony Stark's burgeoning alcoholism. Faverau planned to introduce Iron Man's infamous drinking problem as a result of the effects of revealing his identity to the world, Pepper Potts getting a boyfriend that wasn't him, and sadness at being old. Black suggested they model Stark on Robert Oppenheimer, who became depressed with being "the destroyer of worlds" after working on the Manhattan Project. It was an approach that worked, and did a good job at setting the third film up as a straight adaptation of the classic Demon In A Bottle storyline from the comics, the definitive Iron Man arc. Demon In A Bottle sees Tony tipping over into being fully dependant on alcohol, as a result of the various stresses and strains in his life (including, but by no means limited to, another of those attempted "hostile takeovers" of Stark Industries), both in and out of the suit. It was a surprisingly humane and realistic depiction of alcoholism - allowing for some requisite superhero comic histrionics - and helped re-define a character who had somewhat lost his way, and had lacked a defining hook for years. The big screen Iron Man never really needed that sort of re-focus, however, which is probably why Black decided to abandon the plans to bring Demon In A Bottle to the big screen with the third film, and just have fun instead. And it was fun! We can't doubt his decision. But, really, enough dilly-dallying €“ people have been discussing Demon In A Bottle's adaptation ever since the first Iron Man film was announced. Now's the time to do it. We already know Tony's gotta have double PTSD after Age Of Ultron and, with friends and allies alike turning on him, it would make sense for him to turn to drink. If that doesn't sound insensitive. It'd also be an interesting, dramatic turn for a huge franchise to take, especially given RDJ's own past with substance abuse. It would be daring, brave, and really cool. All things that have worked out well for the Iron Man films so far, so why not for the fourth?