Oscars 2019: 13 Biggest Acting Snubs
The REAL best performances of the year.
Every year it seems the Academy Award nominations are inherently a little disappointing.
This isn't a slight against the Academy, it's just a fact. There are so many great movies made each year that it is literally impossible for them to honor all of the ones that are deserving of it. This year was made all the more difficult by the fact that 2018 was an incredibly stellar year for film.
With so many excellent films and performances and only five slots available for nominations, a whole lot of truly incredible performances got left out in the cold, for better or worse. From shockingly-excellent comeback performances from former stars, to breakthrough performances from young performers who are just getting started, to performances that changed the entire way audiences thought and felt about the given performer.
These were the best performances of 2018 that weren't nominated for an Oscar but absolutely should have been.
13. Jamie Lee Curtis (Halloween)
After decades away from the franchise, Jamie Lee Curtis returned to the town of Haddonfield and the role of Laurie Strode to deliver what was, unquestionably, her best performance ever as the character and also her finest acting turn in at least two decades.
Curtis took full advantage of the new film's retcons, distancing herself from the more trite and familial aspects that had defined her relationship to Michael in prior films. She instead leans heavily into the new concept, painting Laurie as a woman scarred by an act of random malicious violence forty years ago who has been attempting to cope with a fractured psyche ever since. She proves once again why she's the definitive Scream Queen, fully-investing herself in the sequences of suspense and delivering some of the best material for reaction shots of any actress this year.
But the parts of her performance where Curtis truly shines are in the quieter moments, such as her emotional breakdown at dinner with her family or the subsequent shot of her contemplating running into on-coming traffic. She works wonders here, managing to condense the entire forty years' worth of story into single frames and selling Laurie's grief and pain in these heartbreaking vignettes.
12. Ryan Gosling/Claire Foy (First Man)
For one reason or another, this just wasn't Damien Chazelle's year at the Academy Awards.
After becoming the youngest director in history to win Best Director for La La Land a few years back and that film subsequently sweeping a good half of the awards, many were predicting that his follow-up, First Man, would achieve a similar level of Oscar glory. Yet, things went strangely quiet on First Man after its premiere in October and it wound up essentially getting snubbed altogether, aside from a few well-deserved Sound and Visual Effects nods.
Perhaps the biggest casualty of all of this though is the one-two powerhouse duo of lead performances the film featured. Ryan Gosling and Claire Foy as Neil Armstrong and Janet Armstrong, respectively, anchored this film in brutal emotion and pain. Gosling's stoic performance was the definition of restrained, playing a long-game that led to cracks slowly emerging in his stone-face over the course of the film. This led to every release of pain, such as his sobbing at the funeral of his daughter or his final confrontation with Janet before leaving, feeling gargantuan and affecting.
Meanwhile, Foy plays Janet as a character desperately trying to keep the disparate pieces of her family's life together even as it is all seemingly falling apart. She gets great showy moments, such as the immortal "You're a bunch of boys playing with balsa wood!" but also some incredibly impactful quieter moments, such as the scene where Neil leaves her at a funeral and she has to get a ride home from their friends, keeping up the facade that everything is okay all the while.
11. Lily James (Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again)
The #LilyJamesOscarCampaign rages on.
If you had told me a year ago that the Mamma Mia! sequel was going to wind up being one of the biggest and best surprises of 2018, I would have called you a liar. But here we are.
Despite all of the odds being stacked very much against it (the first film having already used all of ABBA's most iconic songs, having to find an actress to replace Meryl Streep as a younger version of her character, the fact that the first film in-and-of-itself is a patchwork of a movie that essentially gets by on charm alone, etc.), Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again managed to not only be a more-than-worthy sequel that surpassed the original by leaps and bounds, it was a genuinely great film in its own right.
A huge part of this comes down to the fact that Lily James pulled off the impossible. Twenty-one-time Oscar-nominated actress Meryl Streep does not exactly leave small shoes to fill, yet Lily James' performance as the young Donna Sheridan manages to actually outdo Meryl Streep's own from the first film.
Whereas Streep was essentially a side-character/narrative device in the first film, James' iteration of the character is the tried-and-true lead of the sequel and James is endearing, infectiously joyful, and capable of delivering emotional gut-punches when necessary. Moments like her one-take monologue in the boat to Sam are remarkable in how honest and raw they feel, with James showing off more range in this single shot than the majority of performances did this past year.
10. Tom Cruise (Mission: Impossible - Fallout)
Tom Cruise has somehow never won an Oscar. He's been nominated three times (for Born on the Fourth of July, Jerry Maguire, and Magnolia) but has never won. This seems odd, given that Cruise has quite literally been risking life-and-limb for decades now for the sheer sake of our entertainment.
And Mission: Impossible - Fallout certainly features its fair share of that. In pushing the possibilities of stuntwork to their very limits, the team behind Fallout crafted some of the most thrilling action setpieces of the last decade, all of which were done with Cruise squarely at the center of them.
Beyond that though, Fallout also sees Cruise pushing the emotional center of his performance as Ethan Hunt farther than he ever has before. The narrative of Fallout centers on the ramifications of all of Hunt's choices and Cruise's performance knocks this out of the park. He deepens Hunt's characterization in ways both big and small, introducing distinct shades of grey to a character who once seemed like such a straight-man.
Personalized setpieces such as his run across London or the multi-stage chase sequence through France allow Cruise to show off his versatile performance physically, both literally in his physical abilities and also in how he has mastered the art of giving audiences a window into his character's mind with the smallest of facial tics. But the quieter moments, like his waking from a nightmare of losing all his loved ones because of his own choices, are where Cruise's refined and restrained performance really shines.
9. Emily Blunt/Ben Whishaw (Mary Poppins Returns)
It's kind of insane that Emily Blunt didn't get a nomination of some sort this year, considering that several prognosticators were predicting that she could have easily gotten both a Best Actress nom for Mary Poppins Returns and a Best Supporting Actress nom for A Quiet Place. The snub for her work in Poppins, though, is outright ludicrous.
From the moment Blunt enters the picture (in a very supercalifragilisticexpialidocious kind of way) she is Mary Poppins. For a role that has been so defined by Julie Andrews' Oscar-winning performance for over five decades now, it is utterly remarkable just how thoroughly Blunt is able to not only channel Mary Poppins but outright disappear within the character. She gets a few more outright emotional beats than Andrews did in the first film and Blunt knocks them out of the park, with her performance of Where the Lost Things Go and her final bittersweet goodbye being especially high water marks.
And while Blunt is obviously the big draw here, it's also a shame that Ben Whishaw's incredible performance as the grown-up Michael Banks didn't get more Oscar love either. In a comparatively short amount of time, Whishaw is able to completely sell Michael's tragic arc and make it the beating heart of the film. His hushed and intimate performance of A Conversation is heartbreaking in its vulnerability.
8. Natalie Portman/Gina Rodriguez (Annihilation)
Released all the way back in February of 2018, Alex Garland's Annihilation was all-but-buried by Paramount upon release. The distributor sold off the international rights to Netflix and didn't put hardly any money into advertising the sci-fi film. While this may have adversely affected the film's initial box-office take, it luckily has not stopped film fans from discovering it for themselves and realizing just how incredible of a film it is.
While Annihilation could have easily been nominated in any number of categories (from technical aspects to Garland's direction, this thing is astonishing) one of the biggest crimes is that there was no love for Natalie Portman's lead performance as Lena or Gina Rodriguez's head-turning supporting turn as Anya.
For Portman, the snub is doubly malicious as she also could have very easily been nominated for her so-bonkers-it's-brilliant performance in Vox Lux. As Lena, Portman gives a distant and layered performance, one that actively enhances the film and the thematic subtext Garland is weaving. It's a staggering accomplishment that allows for the climax's introspection to be absolutely devastating.
Rodriguez on the other hand swings for the fences as Anya in a way that few beyond fans of her work on the underappreciated Jane the Virgin could have predicted. As a member of the team who loses her mind midway through the journey, Rodriguez sinks her teeth into the meaty role with vigor and delivers one of the best supporting turns of the whole year.
7. Elsie Fisher (Eighth Grade)
Bo Burnham's Eighth Grade is a sometimes hysterical, sometimes haunting film that serves as a perfect encapsulation of not only what its like to be a teenager on the cusp of adulthood in the modern world but also just what its like to feel perpetually trapped in adolescence.
Burnham's writing and direction are incredibly impressive, but none of it wouldn't have been even half as effective if not for the performance of Elsie Fisher. From the first moment we see her in her home-made YouTube video that opens the film, Fisher imbues Kayla with this openness and child-like sense of joy that feels completely genuine.
She's just a child and part of what makes the film so compelling is watching her go on this journey of self-discovery in which the world around her seems to be constantly trying to break her down and belittle her. This leads to moments like the side-splittingly hysterical attempt at sexual discovery with the banana-incident or what is perhaps the most cringe-inducing late-night car ride ever put to film.
It all culminates in Kayla and her father (played by the also incredibly excellent Josh Hamilton) having an intimate fireside chat about how much he loves her. It's a moment so small, yet it feels so big because Fisher's astounding performance sells it so well.
6. Toni Collette/Alex Wolff (Hereditary)
In a year full of excellent horror films, Ari Aster's Hereditary was perhaps the most highly acclaimed of them all, earning rave reviews and almost immediately sparking a rallying cry for Toni Collette to earn an Oscar nomination for her performance.
And it's easy to see why. The film takes her character, Annie, on one helluva journey and Collette manages to nail every stop along the way from a fairly normal person to a Paimon-possessed meat-puppet. Most interestingly though is her performance amidst the madness that makes up the bulk of the film's runtime, as she desperately attempts to hold it together in increasingly dire circumstances. The dinner table scene is horrifying to watch and not for the typical horror move reasons. It's because of the sheer tension in the room and the way that Collette is able to suck all of the oxygen out of the scene with the single line of "I never wanted to be your mother".
Her all-around remarkable craft and dedication to the role pays off in spades and should have easily earned her a nom. But the quieter and stranger choice from the film would have to be Alex Wolff's performance as her son, Peter. Wolff's performance sees his character dealing with his own form of escalating madness, but his standout moment comes just after the accidental death of his sister. Aster keeps the camera on Wolff and just allows him to just react for several minutes and the results are absolutely gut-wrenching.
5. Hugh Grant (Paddington 2)
Hugh Grant is perhaps one of the most reliable commodities in all of Tinseltown. For decades now, whether the film he's performing in is any good or not, Grant has consistently delivered performances characterized by charm, wit, and likability. Which is why it is such a genuine thrill to see him turn his entire legacy on its head (and skewer it in the process) with his performance as Phoenix Buchanan in Paul King's ever-delightful Paddington 2.
The fact that Paddington 2 wasn't nominated in several categories should be a federal offense, but let's let that slide here to focus on Grant's insanely great performance. In the film, Buchanan is a once-revered actor who has now been so belittled as to star in dog food commercials. In an attempt to regain the public's affection and respect, Buchanan seeks out a treasure with which he could fund his one-man play. In attempting to do so, he also comes into conflict with Paddington, ultimately framing him for theft and putting him in jail.
Grant jumps into the role's more nefarious nature with vigor and is clearly having a ball ripping into overly-vain actors and, in essence, his own career. It gets so meta that Buchanan even has Grant's actual headshots hanging up around his house. But even as Grant hams it up, he's also delivering the best performance of his career. Moments such as Buchanan finding Mr. and Mrs. Brown snooping around his house see him giving a layered and powerful performance, becoming one of 2018's best big-screen baddies in the process.
4. KiKi Layne/Stephan James (If Beale Street Could Talk)
It is a genuine tragedy that Barry Jenkins' sublimely crafted If Beale Street Could Talk did not unanimously sweep the Oscar nominations. From Jenkins direction, to James Laxton's cinematography, to the sound mixing and editing, everything about this film is mindbogglingly great. But the greatest credit of all goes to the film's two leads; KiKi Layne as Tish and Stephan James as Fonny.
The narrative of the film puts these two characters through the absolute ringer, constantly imposing new seemingly-insurmountable struggles upon them. In such a narrative, it is all too easy to lose sight of what was the heart of the story in the first place, their love story, and instead get bogged down in the glumness of it all.
Jenkins' film instead consistently chooses to focus on the joy and happiness of these two characters, and thanks to its non-linear structure and Layne and James' performances, this choice works ridiculously well.
For proof as to why these two both deserved some Oscar love, one need look no further than the handful of scenes they share divided by the glass partitions of prison. Specifically, the scene in which Fonny briefly loses his cool and snaps on Tish, saying he doesn't know how much longer he can survive in prison. In a scene with so few words, the anger within Fonny is palpable and the sadness and subsequent grief that consumes Tish is powerfully present without her having to say a single line. It's brutally effective and clearly demonstrates why these two deserved noms.
3. Joaquin Phoenix (You Were Never Really Here)
Phoenix re-cemented his status as one of the bravest and most daring performers in Hollywood this past year with an all-around unconventional yet engrossingly effective lead performance in Lynne Ramsay's You Were Never Really Here.
The film is a beautiful bit of cinematic poetry, opting to consistently allow its audience to meditate in the meaning of the thematically-charged visuals rather than beating them over the head with exposition. Ramsay's directorial choices and brave and perfectly utilize Phoenix's unique abilities.
Playing Joe as a PTSD-addled veteran, Phoenix's performance is solemn and reserved, with him only getting a handful of lines of dialogue throughout the whole film. Yet he conveys so much through his physicality alone. Phoenix gained weight for the performance and result is a hulking husk of a man who is able to tell say more with a single movement of his shoulder than most screenwriters can in several pages.
For this writer's money's worth, Phoenix's most impressive bit of acting in the whole film comes near the end when he discovers that Nina has escaped on her own, slitting Williams' throat. Phoenix breaks down, tearing off his shirt and fully releases the overwhelming rage and sadness that has been repressed within his entire performance and it is alarmingly resonant.
2. Tilda Swinton/Dakota Johnson (Suspiria)
The only person on this list who could have actually been nominated for multiple roles within the same film, Tilda Switnon's not one, not two, but three different performances in Luca Guadagnino's Suspiria showed off precisely why her name is so revered in cinematic circles.
Playing Madame Blanc, Dr. Jozef Klemperer, and Helena Markos herself, Swinton spans the entire spectrum of performances. As Blanc, her performance is restrained and distant, intentionally painting her as a loving-yet-difficult mother figure for the entire company. As Klemperer, Switnon completely disappears behind some equally Oscar-worthy make-up and becomes the beating heart of the film through emotional beats such as Klemperer's reunion with his long-dead wife or the reaction shots Swinton is able to make oh-so-effective during the finale, even as she is underneath all of the prosthetics.
And though her time as Markos may be comparatively brief, she chews the scenery with all the intensity of a rabid creature, delivering some of the film's most iconic lines and moments. She does all of this while, again, being submerged under pounds of prosthetics and being entirely unrecognizable.
While Swinton's range of performances makes her the obvious choice, the leading lady herself, Dakota Johnson, was just as deserving of some Oscar love. As Susie Bannion, Johnson gives a subtle-yet-powerful performance that sells one of the most surprising and bold character arcs of the year. The Susie we start the film with and the Susie we end the film with are two very different characters, yet Johnson's remarkable performance keeps us so anchored in her throughout the entire film that the transformation feels completely earned.
1. Nic Cage (Mandy)
Last but certainly not least is the living legend himself, Mr. Nicolas Cage.
After years spent essentially appearing exclusively in straight-to-the-bargain-bin DVDs, Cage had an unbelievably great year in 2018 from a glorious cameo in Teen Titans Go! to the Movies to his scene-stealing performance as Spider-Noir in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse. But the real crowning jewel of his year was his performance in Panos Cosmatos' Mandy, which was not just his best performance of the year, it was his best performance in decades.
Cosmatos' vibrant and off-kilter film is fantastical in every way, creating an environment and aesthetic in which Cage is able to go completely off the rails and yet still feel completely at home within the film. And boy, does he go off the rails.
Moments like the long-take just after Mandy's death, as Cage's Red comes to grips with it in the bathroom, are pure unfiltered Cage madness at its absolute best. Similarly, the subsequent scene of him attempting to explain what he's hunting to Bill Duke's character and delivering the line "They were weirdo, hippie-types, whole bunch of 'em. And then there was some muscle - it didn't make any sense. There were bikers, and gnarly psychos, and... crazy evil!" in the kind of instantly unforgettable way that only Cage can.
It was a gonzo, swing-for-the-fences kind of performance that just worked in every way imaginable, as Cage dug deep within himself and reached depths he had not even visited in years.
What do you think were the biggest acting snubs this year? Let us know down in the comments.