Prometheus 2: 10 Lessons It Must Learn In Order To Succeed

Or, how Ridley Scott can avoid dropping the ball a second time.

By Andrew Dilks /

Last month Ridley Scott's 2016 "mystery project" was finally revealed - after a lot of speculation on movie forums, 20th Century Fox announced that the film in question will be the sequel to Prometheus, with Noomi Rapace and Michael Fassbender reprising their roles of Dr. Elizabeth Shaw and David. The announcement immediately reopened the can of worms regarding the merits of Prometheus (something which this article will be guilty of doing in a moment), a movie which has stirred up no end of debate since its release. Is it a cinematic masterpiece or a hugely wasted opportunity to really flesh out the Alien mythology? Or is it - more plausibly - something in between; a decent science fiction film based on a much-loved franchise that's as entertaining as it is over-ambitious? To many, Prometheus felt like a project in which the makers - aware of the great expectations the movie had - couldn't quite decide which direction to take it. The end result, while visually impressive (if there's one thing Ridley Scott understands, it's how to make good-looking movies) ultimately feels disjointed and somewhat derivative. The following list covers some of the shortcomings of Prometheus and considers what the sequel can learn from them in order to deliver a more coherent, engaging and ultimately more successful movie.

10. Use The Technology Plausibly

Starting off with a bit of nitpicking, but nevertheless a point which takes away something of the authenticity which Scott and his production designers otherwise execute very effectively throughout the film - the sense that the future world envisioned is a logical one with plausible technology which the characters use appropriately. The most obvious point in Prometheus where the use of technology becomes counter-intuitive is in the scene where geologist Fifield (Sean Harris) maps the interior of the structure using his "pups" only for the very same character to get lost a short while later - all despite the fact that only moments before the captain of the ship was watching them on a map of his own. It's a case of ill-considered writing more interested in getting to the next key moment than it is concerned with plausibility. Hopefully the sequel will create a logically consistent approach to how this technology can be used and by whom - although all that said, this minor criticism of Prometheus pales in comparison to Gravity, in which a character who clearly has virtually no technical understanding of space travel inexplicably manages to fire up the re-entry vehicle in an abandoned Chinese space station.

9. Tighten The Dialogue

There's not a great deal that's wrong with any of the acting in Prometheus: the cast perform perfectly well - if hardly entering into the realm of award-winning territory - and do the best with the material they've been given. It's just a shame that the material could've done with a considerable amount of tightening up. From clichéd existential musings which might as well be the tag lines for the posters or trailer "moments" ("How far would you be willing to go, to get your answers? What would you be willing to do?" ... "Anything and everything.") to the references to "faith" scattered liberally throughout, coming across as snippets of a conversation between theology students, a lot of the exchanges seem to represent the lowest common denominator in the audience, rather than the presumably intelligent characters speaking them. Elsewhere, much of the dialogue feels like its primary function is to deliver exposition, while cheesy and incongruous banter between crew members facing imminent death adds to the B-movie feel. Given that Prometheus 2 isn't due out until 2016 it means that there's more than enough time to iron out the kinks which marred the first movie. With a bit of luck they'll take the advice of Michael Fassbender, who said in an interview last year, "I don't want them to rush it. It takes time to write a script." And if they're going to improve the dialogue, it'd make sense for them to spend a bit more time developing the people those lines are intended for...

8. Make The Characters More Believable

For saying that the crew of the Prometheus are supposed to have been selected for their scientific expertise, many of them behave completely out of character, committing acts which seem to point towards the fact that the writer has little understanding of the roles these characters are supposed to play. The most obvious example of this problem is the geologist Milburn (Rafe Spall), by turns terrified of an Engineer's severed head and desperate to return to the ship, then moments later enamoured with a very much alive alien snake which he tries to pet, with predictably deadly consequences. The fact that the entire mission appears to be predicated on Shaw's whim - choosing to base her confidence in the mission on faith rather than reason - confirms just how anti-scientific these scientists really are. This boils down to the overuse of stock characters, where disposable secondary characters are padded out with standard issue personality quirks and central characters embody broad archetypes. Since Prometheus 2 only has Shaw and David as its starting point it has the advantage of starting on a blank canvas upon which to continue the story. Perhaps the next time around they'll introduce characters who are more rounded, nuanced and, well, human - like, for instance, Ellen Ripley...

7. Plug In The Plot Holes

We've already covered here at What Culture some of the major questions which the sequel needs to answer, and while some of these were deliberately open-ended ideas designed to get the audience wondering, others were basic plot holes which could have been avoided. It's not uncommon for Hollywood movies to be full of enough plot holes to sink a ship, but Prometheus seems to have more than its fair share. Often, these feel like aspects the filmmakers have given up on caring about making sense, more intent on delivering "cinematic moments" than explaining the causes behind them. While audiences are often willing to suspend their disbelief when watching what is ostensibly a piece of entertainment, there's a fine line between pushing credibility to the limit and over-stretching the boundaries of believability. Since Prometheus begins with a lot of questions and ended with even more unanswered questions, at least the sequel is in a position where it can make good on its set up and give the audience some answers. We're not expecting them to come up with a coherent answer to the nature of existence (which is the timeless question the first movie poses) but addressing some of the loose ends would be a nice way to kick things off.

6. Lay Off The Clichés

On a basic level much of the dialogue and characterization already mentioned falls into this category, but by far the biggest offending scene is the revelation that Weyland (Guy Pierce, pointlessly cast as an old man) is actually Vickers' (Chalize Theron) father. Vickers seems to be there to cover the "evil corporation" base (another popular cliché these days) but the relationship reveal seems completely out of place and, given that neither character has been padded out beyond a basic stereotype, it has almost no impact on the audience. It feels like a plot development thrown in simply for the sake of it. With a bit more thought, the sequel will avoid such scenes and appreciate that they only pay off when the audience has invested in the characters. After all, audiences are generally too savvy these days, and either see them coming a mile off or can spot when they've been shoehorned in by a lazy writer. And speaking of shoehorning in "moments"...

5. Don't Shoehorn In Alien Franchise 'Moments'

If you're going to include moments which reference previous installments of the series, it's advisable to do it with a degree of subtlety. Prometheus isn't too concerned with this approach, and the Cesarian scene comes across as the obligatory chest-bursting homage everyone was expecting. It's certainly handled very well, but as technically proficient as it is the feeling that a scene of this kind was inevitable is inescapable. Even more audaciously, the entire first act - from the arrival on the planet to the discovery of the pods - feels like a remake of Alien. Other obvious franchise nods include David's severed head, which plays as a riff on the finale to Aliens in which Bishop gets torn apart by the queen alien, and the closing scene, as the traditional-looking alien we're all familiar with emerges from the dead body of the Engineer - it's the kind of reveal we've already seen in the series, and comes across as a lazy way to end the movie. These nods feel like products of studio executives shoehorned in just to satisfy fans. Prometheus 2 would do well to either embrace the essence of the previous films entirely and take them to new heights or forge its own path.

4. Ease Up On The Copying

Besides reworking aspects from the Alien franchise, Prometheus also borrows elements from other sci-fi films - while it's inevitable that there's some signs of inspiration in a film of this kind, Prometheus demonstrates a few glaring examples which its sequel would do well to tone down. Did using a flamethrower on a mutating crew member remind anyone of John Carpenter's The Thing? Other comparisons relating to visual style, themes and characterisation can be made with sci-fi movies and franchises including Star Trek, Contact, Leviathan, 2001: A Space Odyssey, Mission to Mars, A.I. and The X-Files, whether intentional or otherwise. By the same token it plays on genre conventions and tropes too often, and the culmination of this is a film that sometimes feels generic. A film like Cabin in the Woods succeeds because it's knowingly taking swipes at and subverts genre expectations and rules; Prometheus, with its ambitious origin of humanity scope and questions of faith versus reason, would have been far more effective if it were less derivative and knowingly referential, and instead focused on being more original.

3. Improve The Pacing

The first act might be a carbon copy of the opening act in Alien but perhaps this is also why it works so well, with moments of tension building up to release that draws the audience in. Unfortunately, this principle is unevenly applied throughout the rest of Prometheus. The final act is where the pacing issues really start to show, with a rushed finale which seems more bothered with cramming in the remaining ideas the filmmakers had and forcing a grand finale into the screenplay than it is with making any real sense. It's a classic cinematic case of over-egging the pudding while throwing in a deus ex machina - the conveniently timed reveal of the giant squid fetus monster which saves Shaw from the engineer - to wrap up the action. Since Prometheus has already established the universe the sequel won't have to spend so much time setting things up, allowing the filmmakers to structure a story which can be moved forward at greater leisure without trying to cram too much in to a short space of time.

2. Scale Back The "Big Ideas"

It's all very well drawing on mythology, ancient history and religious symbolism to try and give a story more philosophical weight, but unfortunately Prometheus sets much of this up too superficially, as if it exists simply to get the audience to sit there scratching their heads in confusion, rather than actually pondering broader implications. The ancient alien aspect is explained with a cursory scene comparing ancient tablets which feels like an excerpt from an episode of the Discovery Channel's Ancient Aliens series (although that would no doubt avoid the schoolboy error of an expert describing Sumer, Mesapotamia and Babylonia as "unconnected" cultures), while the religious symbolism is so heavy-handed throughout the film - from the captain setting up a Christmas tree upon arrival to Shaw clinging to her cross and the motif of the virgin birth flipped on its head - that few viewers could have failed to grasp the unsubtle faith versus science conflict Shaw's character is faced with. Prometheus feels as if it doesn't quite know what to do with all these ideas - or indeed, which one to focus on. The sequel should settle on one that it is able to explain coherently - one which casts aside the red herrings and apparent MacGuffins and delivers a solid mythology.

1. Focus In On A Good Idea

This final lesson in a sense sums up everything about Prometheus which relegated it from a potential masterpiece to a flawed piece of entertainment, while at the same time outlining the broader problem with huge budget blockbusters which revisit much-loved and highly profitable franchises - even those with a name like Ridley Scott attached to them. That problem is a lack of focus. The lack of focus in Prometheus is the primary lesson the sequel can learn from, and given that the first movie ends with a set-up that wipes much of the slate clean, there is no reason why Scott and his collaborators can't avoid the same mistakes. Rather than introducing another round of generic stock characters to dispose of (for instance, predictably copying off Aliens next time around and introducing a team of military guys) perhaps a smaller addition of well-rounded characters whom the audience doesn't just sit there waiting to be killed would make the story around them richer and more engaging. The suggestion that Prometheus 2 will feature multiple David's has certainly been met with a lot of enthusiasm on the internet and the concept could work well, but a word of caution is needed - after all, Agent Smith was one of the best things about The Matrix, and the sequel's "multiple Smiths" approach was one of the laziest aspects of the film. More isn't necessarily better, and if they do choose to go down that route in Prometheus 2, let's hope they use the premise to throw up some interesting narrative twists and moral dilemmas while focusing on a tighter plot. That way, it could become the truly great film the original - a noble effort in many respects - struggled to attain. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.